@Bullsitter said:
Who would have thought that the BIG10 would be left out 2 years in a row?
I think the committee made a bigger comment about the SEC v. other conferences by putting UGA at #5 ahead of conference champion OSU. I realize at least one person will call that SEC bias but whatever you call it a committee of people whose opinion actually matters thinks it.
And Nostradamus Navarro nailed it back on Oct 28 lol
Nailed the initial rankings with LSU jumping ND and nailed the final 4 as well.
Irish play in my backyard so won't have to miss work or travel for that one.
Looking forward to it.
GO IRISH!!
@thenavarro said:
I don't actively participate much on these boards anymore, but I still pop into this thread every other week or so as I always enjoyed seeing the passion of the posters here and I like to read the banter. There is no better sport on the planet to me than college football.
I've spent a significant portion of my Fall so far commuting to the Notre Dame games from Texas. I'll typically take one of my friends or my daughter or wife, and I take time along the way to meet with some of my internet friends along the journies. Next two excursions will be for the FSU game at Notre Dame, and for the game against Syracuse at Yankee Stadium. I've never been inside Yankee Stadium, so I'm really looking forward to that one.
I've been pretty satisfied with the season to date. Parity everywhere, but so far, my team has escaped unscathed.
The QB switch to Book after the 3rd game, has given Irish fans hope that the team can get into the playoffs and let the chips fall where they may. Any week could derail the train, like all but 3 other Division 1 FBS schools have learned this season, but for now, it keeps on going down the rails.
With the 1st rankings that matter coming down the pipe in a couple of days, this is how I THINK the top four will be Tuesday night:
1) Alabama
2) Clemson
3) LSU
4) Notre Dame
This is how I think the top four should be as of now:
1) Alabama
2) Clemson
3) Notre Dame
4) Michigan
And here is my prediction on how the final 4 will end up at regular season's end whether it is right, wrong, or indifferent:
1) Alabama
2) Clemson
3) Notre Dame
4) Oklahoma
Good luck to your respective squads along the way except for the ones that play ND.
I'd love to see a television special where Joel Klatt sits on one side of the room and the thirteen committee members sit on the other. Give Joel an hour to tear them apart at the seams for their hypocrisy. That is a playoff match up I'd pay to see.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
After my team getting screwed out of a national championship for the fourth time in seven years. I've about had enough of this committee espn influenced fraud. This year Ohio State has had better wins than Georgia, Clemson AND Oklahoma. Big ten was the best conference last year going 14-6 against the non conference power five. And one of the 2 best conferences this year going 3-1 against the BIG 12. Buckeyes also play in probably the toughest division in college football. Yet the idiots on this committee pick Oklahoma. Oklahoma LOST to their rival. Buckeyes BEAT THEIR RIVAL BY 23 POINTS. MICHIGAN is a better team than Texas. Oklahoma A team that has no chance against Bama. OSU got robbed AGAIN by this fraud committee. Will be boycotting playoffs again. This committee is a joke. Until it expands this isnt worth watching. They keep excluding the 1 team that can best saban. I REFUSE to watch the rose bowl and wish the whole team would boycott the game in protest. I declare Ohio State the 2018 national champions. They deserve it. They have the best QB in the nation that put on 62 against the number 1 defense. And won the title game by 21 points. A team ND only beat by 10 and only beat Michigan by 7. Notre Dame hasn't beaten the Buckeyes since 1936. And I don't need to hear the dumb excuse that WELL THEY LOST TO PURDUE BY ALOT. That's only one game. The haters came up with a different excuse when they got left out in 2015 when they were riding on a 23 game winning streak, defending champions and their only blemish was a 3 point loss in the final seconds. AND NEVER trailed in any of their games .The truth is about the only way the Buckeyes can win it all anymore is if they go undefeated. And then im sure the haters will find excuses to KEEP them out. Buckeyes are the most hated team in the country. I don't care who wins in the playoffs, its all a sham.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
@garnettstyle said:
After my team getting screwed out of a national championship for the fourth time in seven years. I've about had enough of this committee espn influenced fraud. This year Ohio State has had better wins than Georgia, Clemson AND Oklahoma. Big ten was the best conference last year going 14-6 against the non conference power five. And one of the 2 best conferences this year going 3-1 against the BIG 12. Buckeyes also play in probably the toughest division in college football. Yet the idiots on this committee pick Oklahoma. Oklahoma LOST to their rival. Buckeyes BEAT THEIR RIVAL BY 23 POINTS. MICHIGAN is a better team than Texas. Oklahoma A team that has no chance against Bama. OSU got robbed AGAIN by this fraud committee. Will be boycotting playoffs again. This committee is a joke. Until it expands this isnt worth watching. They keep excluding the 1 team that can best saban. I REFUSE to watch the rose bowl and wish the whole team would boycott the game in protest. I declare Ohio State the 2018 national champions. They deserve it. They have the best QB in the nation that put on 62 against the number 1 defense. And won the title game by 21 points. A team ND only beat by 10 and only beat Michigan by 7. Notre Dame hasn't beaten the Buckeyes since 1936. And I don't need to hear the dumb excuse that WELL THEY LOST TO PURDUE BY ALOT. That's only one game. The haters came up with a different excuse when they got left out in 2015 when they were riding on a 23 game winning streak, defending champions and their only blemish was a 3 point loss in the final seconds. AND NEVER trailed in any of their games .The truth is about the only way the Buckeyes can win it all anymore is if they go undefeated. And then im sure the haters will find excuses to KEEP them out. Buckeyes are the most hated team in the country. I don't care who wins in the playoffs, its all a sham.
@garnettstyle said:
After my team getting screwed out of a national championship for the fourth time in seven years. I've about had enough of this committee espn influenced fraud. This year Ohio State has had better wins than Georgia, Clemson AND Oklahoma. Big ten was the best conference last year going 14-6 against the non conference power five. And one of the 2 best conferences this year going 3-1 against the BIG 12. Buckeyes also play in probably the toughest division in college football. Yet the idiots on this committee pick Oklahoma. Oklahoma LOST to their rival. Buckeyes BEAT THEIR RIVAL BY 23 POINTS. MICHIGAN is a better team than Texas. Oklahoma A team that has no chance against Bama. OSU got robbed AGAIN by this fraud committee. Will be boycotting playoffs again. This committee is a joke. Until it expands this isnt worth watching. They keep excluding the 1 team that can best saban. I REFUSE to watch the rose bowl and wish the whole team would boycott the game in protest. I declare Ohio State the 2018 national champions. They deserve it. They have the best QB in the nation that put on 62 against the number 1 defense. And won the title game by 21 points. A team ND only beat by 10 and only beat Michigan by 7. Notre Dame hasn't beaten the Buckeyes since 1936. And I don't need to hear the dumb excuse that WELL THEY LOST TO PURDUE BY ALOT. That's only one game. The haters came up with a different excuse when they got left out in 2015 when they were riding on a 23 game winning streak, defending champions and their only blemish was a 3 point loss in the final seconds. AND NEVER trailed in any of their games .The truth is about the only way the Buckeyes can win it all anymore is if they go undefeated. And then im sure the haters will find excuses to KEEP them out. Buckeyes are the most hated team in the country. I don't care who wins in the playoffs, its all a sham.
It's important to remember that Ohio also gave up 51 to Maryland and only a blown 2pt conversion kept that from being a loss. That HAD to have influenced the committee, I would think.
I would have picked Oklahoma over Ohio as well but certainly would not have been the travesty to pick Ohio that picking Georgia would have been.
I knew after the Purdue game the Buckeyes had no chance. They finished strong enough to be mentioned but not good enough to be selected. If somehow they would have gotten in I would not apologize. At the same time I have no complaints. I would like to see the Playoffs go to at least 8 teams. The five major conference Champs and three at large teams. There are at least two teams not in that would not be favorites but have a reasonable shot at winning it all. BTW in 2015 the Buckeyes were screwed over big time, IMHO.
Buckeyes get screwed almost every year. Seriously what does the conference have to do to get any respect? Last year they went 7-1 in the bowl games and then crickets.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPION IS INCLUDED
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
@garnettstyle said:
After my team getting screwed out of a national championship for the fourth time in seven years. I've about had enough of this committee espn influenced fraud. This year Ohio State has had better wins than Georgia, Clemson AND Oklahoma. Big ten was the best conference last year going 14-6 against the non conference power five. And one of the 2 best conferences this year going 3-1 against the BIG 12. Buckeyes also play in probably the toughest division in college football. Yet the idiots on this committee pick Oklahoma. Oklahoma LOST to their rival. Buckeyes BEAT THEIR RIVAL BY 23 POINTS. MICHIGAN is a better team than Texas. Oklahoma A team that has no chance against Bama. OSU got robbed AGAIN by this fraud committee. Will be boycotting playoffs again. This committee is a joke. Until it expands this isnt worth watching. They keep excluding the 1 team that can best saban. I REFUSE to watch the rose bowl and wish the whole team would boycott the game in protest. I declare Ohio State the 2018 national champions. They deserve it. They have the best QB in the nation that put on 62 against the number 1 defense. And won the title game by 21 points. A team ND only beat by 10 and only beat Michigan by 7. Notre Dame hasn't beaten the Buckeyes since 1936. And I don't need to hear the dumb excuse that WELL THEY LOST TO PURDUE BY ALOT. That's only one game. The haters came up with a different excuse when they got left out in 2015 when they were riding on a 23 game winning streak, defending champions and their only blemish was a 3 point loss in the final seconds. AND NEVER trailed in any of their games .The truth is about the only way the Buckeyes can win it all anymore is if they go undefeated. And then im sure the haters will find excuses to KEEP them out. Buckeyes are the most hated team in the country. I don't care who wins in the playoffs, its all a sham.
It's important to remember that Ohio also gave up 51 to Maryland and only a blown 2pt conversion kept that from being a loss. That HAD to have influenced the committee, I would think.
I would have picked Oklahoma over Ohio as well but certainly would not have been the travesty to pick Ohio that picking Georgia would have been.
OKLAHOMA beat nobody. texas lost to maryland
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
@garnettstyle said:
After my team getting screwed out of a national championship for the fourth time in seven years. I've about had enough of this committee espn influenced fraud. This year Ohio State has had better wins than Georgia, Clemson AND Oklahoma. Big ten was the best conference last year going 14-6 against the non conference power five. And one of the 2 best conferences this year going 3-1 against the BIG 12. Buckeyes also play in probably the toughest division in college football. Yet the idiots on this committee pick Oklahoma. Oklahoma LOST to their rival. Buckeyes BEAT THEIR RIVAL BY 23 POINTS. MICHIGAN is a better team than Texas. Oklahoma A team that has no chance against Bama. OSU got robbed AGAIN by this fraud committee. Will be boycotting playoffs again. This committee is a joke. Until it expands this isnt worth watching. They keep excluding the 1 team that can best saban. I REFUSE to watch the rose bowl and wish the whole team would boycott the game in protest. I declare Ohio State the 2018 national champions. They deserve it. They have the best QB in the nation that put on 62 against the number 1 defense. And won the title game by 21 points. A team ND only beat by 10 and only beat Michigan by 7. Notre Dame hasn't beaten the Buckeyes since 1936. And I don't need to hear the dumb excuse that WELL THEY LOST TO PURDUE BY ALOT. That's only one game. The haters came up with a different excuse when they got left out in 2015 when they were riding on a 23 game winning streak, defending champions and their only blemish was a 3 point loss in the final seconds. AND NEVER trailed in any of their games .The truth is about the only way the Buckeyes can win it all anymore is if they go undefeated. And then im sure the haters will find excuses to KEEP them out. Buckeyes are the most hated team in the country. I don't care who wins in the playoffs, its all a sham.
It's important to remember that Ohio also gave up 51 to Maryland and only a blown 2pt conversion kept that from being a loss. That HAD to have influenced the committee, I would think.
I guess you and the committee missed this BLOWN 2 pt conversion.
I'm sure garnett will call the Strength of Schedule "fake news"...Sort of makes all those B10 is the toughest conference this season arguments look silly.
As for the non-conference record, you have to look at the quality of those wins and losses. Presumably the 2nd best team in the B10 - NW - went 0-3 out of conference and lost to two nobodies. NW lost by 3 at Michigan - the 2nd best team in the B10 East - and ran the table against the rest of the B10 teams it played. By Garnett's home/away logic that means NW would have won by 2 touchdowns if the game had been played at Ryan Field. Yet the same team that was beating a supposedly elite Michigan 17-0 in the 2nd quarter lost to Akron & Duke the two weeks prior.
Last year the B10 did great in bowl games but the SEC had the two best teams in the country. Your entire argument his year for the B10 focuses on your irrational belief that you have two great teams (OSU & Michigan).
The B10 will get a bowl win when OSU crushes Washington but OSU should be playing Georgia. I would have wanted to see Penn State playing LSU instead of an overrated Kentucky as well as Michigan playing Georgia or LSU. The best teams in the B10 should be playing the best teams from the SEC and be seeded appropriately if any bragging rights will be determined. It is no different than in head to head team competitions where a coach puts his worst player against the best from the other side in order to shift the rest of the matches to an advantage for his team.
It would be great if the B10 and SEC would schedule conference wide head to head each year like conferences do in college basketball.
LOL SEC did not have the two best teams in the country. The 2 best teams were Ohio State and Wisconsin. OSU was spanking everyone and playing their best football late in the season. Wisconsin went 13-1. Bama played nobody and did not deserve a playoff spot. The whole system is rigged and everyone with half a brain knows it.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
The last 4 years of the playoffs the BIG10 has only sent 2 teams out of 16
Those 2 teams, OSU and MSU were clobbered 69-0. No wonder they weren't invited, they are boring.
Bullsitter, will you agree that probably anyone who went instead of OSU and MSU during that period probably would have suffered the same fate?? maybe even worse. going in and facing Alabama as the Number Four seed in the past half-decade hasn't been easy. to that end and following your logic it might be that the "Committee" is trying to find the best competition for that game. it is a bitter pill to swallow in saying that the 'Tide has been tough during that period, there just should be a more objective, reasoned and systematic way to field these four Teams.
by virtue of their records, numbers 1-3 have shown they are above everyone else but not really that much above. playing early games against whipping boys is silly. it is a sad fact that the Committee positions Teams to achieve a pre-determined objective, having them ready lower in the rankings in case something unexpected happens.
the biggest thing about this year which just didn't seem proper was Notre Dame. think about it, all the other Teams in reasonable contention for a playoff spot --- Alabama, Clemson, Georgia, Oklahoma and Ohio State --- weren't so much playing to get in, they were playing to STAY in. Georgia in particular suffered because of that. I seriously doubt there is any scenario we could imagine which would have left Notre Dame at Number Five.
there is something wrong with that, I wonder how it will be fixed.
@garnettstyle said:
After my team getting screwed out of a national championship for the fourth time in seven years. I've about had enough of this committee espn influenced fraud. This year Ohio State has had better wins than Georgia, Clemson AND Oklahoma. Big ten was the best conference last year going 14-6 against the non conference power five. And one of the 2 best conferences this year going 3-1 against the BIG 12. Buckeyes also play in probably the toughest division in college football. Yet the idiots on this committee pick Oklahoma. Oklahoma LOST to their rival. Buckeyes BEAT THEIR RIVAL BY 23 POINTS. MICHIGAN is a better team than Texas. Oklahoma A team that has no chance against Bama. OSU got robbed AGAIN by this fraud committee. Will be boycotting playoffs again. This committee is a joke. Until it expands this isnt worth watching. They keep excluding the 1 team that can best saban. I REFUSE to watch the rose bowl and wish the whole team would boycott the game in protest. I declare Ohio State the 2018 national champions. They deserve it. They have the best QB in the nation that put on 62 against the number 1 defense. And won the title game by 21 points. A team ND only beat by 10 and only beat Michigan by 7. Notre Dame hasn't beaten the Buckeyes since 1936. And I don't need to hear the dumb excuse that WELL THEY LOST TO PURDUE BY ALOT. That's only one game. The haters came up with a different excuse when they got left out in 2015 when they were riding on a 23 game winning streak, defending champions and their only blemish was a 3 point loss in the final seconds. AND NEVER trailed in any of their games .The truth is about the only way the Buckeyes can win it all anymore is if they go undefeated. And then im sure the haters will find excuses to KEEP them out. Buckeyes are the most hated team in the country. I don't care who wins in the playoffs, its all a sham.
It's important to remember that Ohio also gave up 51 to Maryland and only a blown 2pt conversion kept that from being a loss. That HAD to have influenced the committee, I would think.
I guess you and the committee missed this BLOWN 2 pt conversion.
Yeah, having a defender knock down a pass in a rivalry game is absolutely the same thing as a quarterback air mailing a wide open throw. You nailed it.
@garnettstyle said:
After my team getting screwed out of a national championship for the fourth time in seven years. I've about had enough of this committee espn influenced fraud. This year Ohio State has had better wins than Georgia, Clemson AND Oklahoma. Big ten was the best conference last year going 14-6 against the non conference power five. And one of the 2 best conferences this year going 3-1 against the BIG 12. Buckeyes also play in probably the toughest division in college football. Yet the idiots on this committee pick Oklahoma. Oklahoma LOST to their rival. Buckeyes BEAT THEIR RIVAL BY 23 POINTS. MICHIGAN is a better team than Texas. Oklahoma A team that has no chance against Bama. OSU got robbed AGAIN by this fraud committee. Will be boycotting playoffs again. This committee is a joke. Until it expands this isnt worth watching. They keep excluding the 1 team that can best saban. I REFUSE to watch the rose bowl and wish the whole team would boycott the game in protest. I declare Ohio State the 2018 national champions. They deserve it. They have the best QB in the nation that put on 62 against the number 1 defense. And won the title game by 21 points. A team ND only beat by 10 and only beat Michigan by 7. Notre Dame hasn't beaten the Buckeyes since 1936. And I don't need to hear the dumb excuse that WELL THEY LOST TO PURDUE BY ALOT. That's only one game. The haters came up with a different excuse when they got left out in 2015 when they were riding on a 23 game winning streak, defending champions and their only blemish was a 3 point loss in the final seconds. AND NEVER trailed in any of their games .The truth is about the only way the Buckeyes can win it all anymore is if they go undefeated. And then im sure the haters will find excuses to KEEP them out. Buckeyes are the most hated team in the country. I don't care who wins in the playoffs, its all a sham.
It's important to remember that Ohio also gave up 51 to Maryland and only a blown 2pt conversion kept that from being a loss. That HAD to have influenced the committee, I would think.
I guess you and the committee missed this BLOWN 2 pt conversion.
Yeah, having a defender knock down a pass in a rivalry game is absolutely the same thing as a quarterback air mailing a wide open throw. You nailed it.
LOL the Oklahoma state receiver was WIDE OPEN. But the QB threw the ball about 6 ft too short. Oklahoma state should've won that game.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
I expect Oklahoma to have a small lead or be very close after the first half. Alabama will turn it on the second half and on to the Championship Game. Notre Dame will be exposed and embarrassed by Clemson.
Oklahoma is one of the few teams that has a winning record against us. I think it'll be like the Georgia game.
We just need to run the dang ball and the clock.
@galaxy27 said:
Meyer retiring after the Rose Bowl
I do not think anybody is surprised by this. Well maybe one person but everybody else knew it was happening. Too bad. Great coach. Ethics are questionable but I would say most successful coaches have questionable ethics. Even the great Coach Wooden badly abused the system back in the day.
@garnettstyle said:
Haskins has proven in the big games that he is the best QB in the country. 499 yards passing tonight. 17 td passes in the last three games. No question OSU deserves the fourth spot spanking NW by 3 td's. ND only beat NW by 10.
@garnettstyle said:
After my team getting screwed out of a national championship for the fourth time in seven years. I've about had enough of this committee espn influenced fraud. This year Ohio State has had better wins than Georgia, Clemson AND Oklahoma. Big ten was the best conference last year going 14-6 against the non conference power five. And one of the 2 best conferences this year going 3-1 against the BIG 12. Buckeyes also play in probably the toughest division in college football. Yet the idiots on this committee pick Oklahoma. Oklahoma LOST to their rival. Buckeyes BEAT THEIR RIVAL BY 23 POINTS. MICHIGAN is a better team than Texas. Oklahoma A team that has no chance against Bama. OSU got robbed AGAIN by this fraud committee. Will be boycotting playoffs again. This committee is a joke. Until it expands this isnt worth watching. They keep excluding the 1 team that can best saban. I REFUSE to watch the rose bowl and wish the whole team would boycott the game in protest. I declare Ohio State the 2018 national champions. They deserve it. They have the best QB in the nation that put on 62 against the number 1 defense. And won the title game by 21 points. A team ND only beat by 10 and only beat Michigan by 7. Notre Dame hasn't beaten the Buckeyes since 1936. And I don't need to hear the dumb excuse that WELL THEY LOST TO PURDUE BY ALOT. That's only one game. The haters came up with a different excuse when they got left out in 2015 when they were riding on a 23 game winning streak, defending champions and their only blemish was a 3 point loss in the final seconds. AND NEVER trailed in any of their games .The truth is about the only way the Buckeyes can win it all anymore is if they go undefeated. And then im sure the haters will find excuses to KEEP them out. Buckeyes are the most hated team in the country. I don't care who wins in the playoffs, its all a sham.
Meyer has the best record against top 5 opponents in history. That's why the sec biased committee kept the Buckeyes out of the playoffs most years. This year, like most any other year, were the team that had that best shot at knocking out the Tide. Oklahoma? LOL They have yet to win a playoff game.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
Urban Meyer Leaves Ohio State With One of the Most Remarkable Head Coaching Records in Football History.
Coaching in 218 games and winning 186 of them, Urban Meyer's .853 win percentage is one of the highest ever. He won three national titles (just one of 16 college football coaches to accomplish this feat) at two different universities, including his most recent at Ohio State in 2014. Meyer was 11-3 in the 14 bowl games he coached, and will be favored to win his 15th and first Rose Bowl.
Urban Meyer was an amazing 26-2 in his career against his rivals. Absolutely unparalleled in college football!!!
Urban Meyer won seven conference titles at Utah, Florida, and Ohio State combined
Meyer had by far the highest winning percentage of any active coach with over ten years of head coaching experience
Meyer's teams finished their seasons ranked in the top five eight times during his career
Meyer never posted a record worse than 8-5 (Florida, 2010)
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
Agreed. I guess it is nice when 12-1 is a terribly disappointing year. Only the Buckeyes and Alabama consider a one loss season to be a disappointment. Everyone else considers that a great season.
@garnettstyle said:
Urban Meyer Leaves Ohio State With One of the Most Remarkable Head Coaching Records in Football History.
Coaching in 218 games and winning 186 of them, Urban Meyer's .853 win percentage is one of the highest ever. He won three national titles (just one of 16 college football coaches to accomplish this feat) at two different universities, including his most recent at Ohio State in 2014. Meyer was 11-3 in the 14 bowl games he coached, and will be favored to win his 15th and first Rose Bowl.
Urban Meyer was an amazing 26-2 in his career against his rivals. Absolutely unparalleled in college football!!!
Urban Meyer won seven conference titles at Utah, Florida, and Ohio State combined
Meyer had by far the highest winning percentage of any active coach with over ten years of head coaching experience
Meyer's teams finished their seasons ranked in the top five eight times during his career
Meyer never posted a record worse than 8-5 (Florida, 2010)
That's some very good stats on Meyer. The winning percentage is off the charts. Top 5 rankings are strong.
How come he only won 1 National Championship at OSU?
2012 Not permitted to play in a bowl game because of transgressions that had nothing to do with Meyer. Finished season undefeated and would probably have faced Notre Dame for the Championship and also probably the favorite.
2015 Never trailed in any game the entire year except for one loss on the games final play. Not selected for the playoffs. Good chance they would have been favored to win it all or close to it.
2018 Not selected. No complaints. However if they were in they would have as good a chance as anyone except for Alabama.
@Brick said:
2012 Not permitted to play in a bowl game because of transgressions that had nothing to do with Meyer. Finished season undefeated and would probably have faced Notre Dame for the Championship and also probably the favorite.
2015 Never trailed in any game the entire year except for one loss on the games final play. Not selected for the playoffs. Good chance they would have been favored to win it all or close to it.
2018 Not selected. No complaints. However if they were in they would have as good a chance as anyone except for Alabama.
I don't recall what the deal was in 2015. Was it unfair that they weren't selected?
2015 was only unfair if you are a rabid OSU supporter.
Alabama - 12-1 SEC champions lost by one score at home to ranked Mississippi St
Clemson - 13-0 ACC champions, undefeated in regular season
Michigan St - 12-1 B10 champions, beat OSU head to head, only lost by 1 point at Nebraska
Oklahoma - 11-1 Big12 champions, lost by one score to Texas on a neutral field
MSU lost to Alabama 38-0 in the CFP semi-finals.
There were no sliders in the playoffs that year and no legitimate argument to be made for OSU other than that they should get an automatic spot in the playoffs because they were the defending national champions. I think if the SEC or Big12 champion had two losses that year instead of one OSU would have been selected.
OSU has a much more legitimate gripe this year. When there is nothing to really distinguish between two 1 loss conference champions, one side is going to be upset. OSU quit in their loss to Purdue and that ended up being the deciding factor. I would have preferred to see OSU in the playoffs even with their loss to Purdue as I think they are more talented and better coached than Oklahoma, but I can't really complain about the CFP committee's decision.
@fergie23 said:
2015 was only unfair if you are a rabid OSU supporter.
Alabama - 12-1 SEC champions lost by one score at home to ranked Mississippi St
Clemson - 13-0 ACC champions, undefeated in regular season
Michigan St - 12-1 B10 champions, beat OSU head to head, only lost by 1 point at Nebraska
Oklahoma - 11-1 Big12 champions, lost by one score to Texas on a neutral field
MSU lost to Alabama 38-0 in the CFP semi-finals.
There were no sliders in the playoffs that year and no legitimate argument to be made for OSU other than that they should get an automatic spot in the playoffs because they were the defending national champions. I think if the SEC or Big12 champion had two losses that year instead of one OSU would have been selected.
OSU has a much more legitimate gripe this year. When there is nothing to really distinguish between two 1 loss conference champions, one side is going to be upset. OSU quit in their loss to Purdue and that ended up being the deciding factor. I would have preferred to see OSU in the playoffs even with their loss to Purdue as I think they are more talented and better coached than Oklahoma, but I can't really complain about the CFP committee's decision.
Robb
That is interesting. Like many years 5 worthy teams but can only pick 4 so someone will always feel left out but if you lose your conference championship game hard to be too upset. Sort of like if you get your butt smoked by Iowa or Purdue. It sucks but losing those games gives the committee an excuse to pick somebody else.
for the top Teams a loss is devastating, especially towards the end of the season. an early loss can be overcome and a Team can "prove" that it was a fluke and get it, not so 2-3 games before the season's end, and especially not so in the Championship Games.
that has always perplexed me. the pressure to be perfect is staggering.
RE: the Ohio State loss to MSU was one of Urban Meyer's biggest failures. with the Offense they had he allowed the Spartans to limit the field of play to 15 yards and never changed what he did.
@garnettstyle said:
Urban Meyer Leaves Ohio State With One of the Most Remarkable Head Coaching Records in Football History.
Coaching in 218 games and winning 186 of them, Urban Meyer's .853 win percentage is one of the highest ever. He won three national titles (just one of 16 college football coaches to accomplish this feat) at two different universities, including his most recent at Ohio State in 2014. Meyer was 11-3 in the 14 bowl games he coached, and will be favored to win his 15th and first Rose Bowl.
Urban Meyer was an amazing 26-2 in his career against his rivals. Absolutely unparalleled in college football!!!
Urban Meyer won seven conference titles at Utah, Florida, and Ohio State combined
Meyer had by far the highest winning percentage of any active coach with over ten years of head coaching experience
Meyer's teams finished their seasons ranked in the top five eight times during his career
Meyer never posted a record worse than 8-5 (Florida, 2010)
I said on another forum that Meyer has a case as the greatest college football coach of all-time. He & Saban are head & shoulders above everybody - yes, everybody. It's so much harder to win at the highest level year in and year out now. You can't put 200 guys on scholarship like you could in the 50s.
Saban has more national titles but most of his success has come at one school. When you include more than just their "most successful school", Meyer catches up - fast. Either Florida or Ohio is Meyer's 2nd-most success tenure at a school. Both blow away Saban's LSU tenure. After that, it's Utah for Meyer vs MSU for Saban. Not even the same galaxy. After that, it's BGSU for Meyer vs Toledo for Saban. Again, not even close.
As Garnettstyle mentioned, Meyer has had multiple national title-level teams that didn't even get a chance to play for the title. Unbeaten team at Ohio - no bowl game at all. Unbeaten Utah team, didn't get to play for a title. A 1-loss Florida team and two 1-loss Ohio teams also didn't play for the title.
I don't know that I'd put Meyer at the top with Saban but it's really, really close.
@Brick said:
2012 Not permitted to play in a bowl game because of transgressions that had nothing to do with Meyer. Finished season undefeated and would probably have faced Notre Dame for the Championship and also probably the favorite.
2015 Never trailed in any game the entire year except for one loss on the games final play. Not selected for the playoffs. Good chance they would have been favored to win it all or close to it.
2018 Not selected. No complaints. However if they were in they would have as good a chance as anyone except for Alabama.
2017 team also should've been in the playoffs over Alabama who lost by two TD's against their rival and beat nobody.
Meyer had not one but TWO long winning streaks at OSU. The 2012 and 2013 teams were riding a 24 game win streak. 2014-2015 a 23 game win streak.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
Saban ran Meyer out of the SEC after Bama stomped him and Tebow. He knew he couldn't hang with Saban and the SEC so he faked heart problems and ran as fast as he could. He sat out a year and went to a cupcake conference, the BIG10. He knew he could win there because that league was weak.
Hey Garnett, wasn't OSU on probation for cheating in 2014? I remember something about that but wasn't sure about the years.
Some BIG10 fans like to twist stats and use "ifs" and "buts". I just state the facts Jack.
Yeah that "sterling" OSU resume in 2017, lost 31-16 to Oklahoma and lost 55 - 24 to Iowa. Win either of those games and OSU would have been in over Alabama. Garnett always whines about the CFP selection committee instead of placing the blame squarely on his team when they fail to get it done.
For those counting at home, the same 2017 Oklahoma that outclassed OSU on OSU's home field lost to Georgia in the CFP semifinals.
Also to note, the precedence to let in a 1 loss non-conference champion to the CFP was set in 2016 when the committee selected an OSU team, that didn't even play in the B10 championship game, over a 2 loss B10 champion Penn St. Penn State even beat OSU head to head that season. OSU then got wiped off the map by Clemson 31-0 in one of the most lopsided blowouts in CFP history - other two being Oregon over FSU 59-20 and Alabama over MSU 38-0.
If you look back, you will notice that Garnett was all about a 1 loss non-conference champion deserving to be in the CFP in 2016. He certainly changed his tune in 2017.
Comments
Who would have thought that the BIG10 would be left out 2 years in a row?
I think the committee made a bigger comment about the SEC v. other conferences by putting UGA at #5 ahead of conference champion OSU. I realize at least one person will call that SEC bias but whatever you call it a committee of people whose opinion actually matters thinks it.
And Nostradamus Navarro nailed it back on Oct 28 lol
Nailed the initial rankings with LSU jumping ND and nailed the final 4 as well.
Irish play in my backyard so won't have to miss work or travel for that one.
Looking forward to it.
GO IRISH!!
Some unexciting New Year's Six bowl games.
I liked the Alabama-GA game yesterday.
Was watching the Ohio-NW game and saw this - froze the screen and took a pic - IMO priceless.
How the hell did they get those seats!
I'd love to see a television special where Joel Klatt sits on one side of the room and the thirteen committee members sit on the other. Give Joel an hour to tear them apart at the seams for their hypocrisy. That is a playoff match up I'd pay to see.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
After my team getting screwed out of a national championship for the fourth time in seven years. I've about had enough of this committee espn influenced fraud. This year Ohio State has had better wins than Georgia, Clemson AND Oklahoma. Big ten was the best conference last year going 14-6 against the non conference power five. And one of the 2 best conferences this year going 3-1 against the BIG 12. Buckeyes also play in probably the toughest division in college football. Yet the idiots on this committee pick Oklahoma. Oklahoma LOST to their rival. Buckeyes BEAT THEIR RIVAL BY 23 POINTS. MICHIGAN is a better team than Texas. Oklahoma A team that has no chance against Bama. OSU got robbed AGAIN by this fraud committee. Will be boycotting playoffs again. This committee is a joke. Until it expands this isnt worth watching. They keep excluding the 1 team that can best saban. I REFUSE to watch the rose bowl and wish the whole team would boycott the game in protest. I declare Ohio State the 2018 national champions. They deserve it. They have the best QB in the nation that put on 62 against the number 1 defense. And won the title game by 21 points. A team ND only beat by 10 and only beat Michigan by 7. Notre Dame hasn't beaten the Buckeyes since 1936. And I don't need to hear the dumb excuse that WELL THEY LOST TO PURDUE BY ALOT. That's only one game. The haters came up with a different excuse when they got left out in 2015 when they were riding on a 23 game winning streak, defending champions and their only blemish was a 3 point loss in the final seconds. AND NEVER trailed in any of their games .The truth is about the only way the Buckeyes can win it all anymore is if they go undefeated. And then im sure the haters will find excuses to KEEP them out. Buckeyes are the most hated team in the country. I don't care who wins in the playoffs, its all a sham.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
the current system is flawed because people are involved.
espn.com/college-football/game/_/gameId/401013348
The committee didn't get it right because they didn't get the four best teams in. Ohio State would beat ND and Oklahoma.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
no surprise. SABAN wants no part of URBAN LOL.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
It's important to remember that Ohio also gave up 51 to Maryland and only a blown 2pt conversion kept that from being a loss. That HAD to have influenced the committee, I would think.
I would have picked Oklahoma over Ohio as well but certainly would not have been the travesty to pick Ohio that picking Georgia would have been.
I knew after the Purdue game the Buckeyes had no chance. They finished strong enough to be mentioned but not good enough to be selected. If somehow they would have gotten in I would not apologize. At the same time I have no complaints. I would like to see the Playoffs go to at least 8 teams. The five major conference Champs and three at large teams. There are at least two teams not in that would not be favorites but have a reasonable shot at winning it all. BTW in 2015 the Buckeyes were screwed over big time, IMHO.
http://www.unisquare.com/store/brick/
Ralph
Buckeyes get screwed almost every year. Seriously what does the conference have to do to get any respect? Last year they went 7-1 in the bowl games and then crickets.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPION IS INCLUDED
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
OKLAHOMA beat nobody. texas lost to maryland
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
Missouri beat Purdue, Purdue beat OSU.
So, an average SEC East team would beat OSU.
Good luck against Washington.
Nah, you know the Buckeyes would beat your team. They sure didn't look like the number one team in the country this past Saturday. URBAN OWNS NICKY
Get ready for another Clemson bama final. Bama will destroy Oklahoma. They don't have a pulse for a defense.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
I guess you and the committee missed this BLOWN 2 pt conversion.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
2017 - 2018 College football non-conference records against the POWER 5
Big 10 - 21-11
SEC - 19-15
BIG 12 - 12-14
PAC 12 - 10-13
ACC - 14-23
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
I'm sure garnett will call the Strength of Schedule "fake news"...Sort of makes all those B10 is the toughest conference this season arguments look silly.
As for the non-conference record, you have to look at the quality of those wins and losses. Presumably the 2nd best team in the B10 - NW - went 0-3 out of conference and lost to two nobodies. NW lost by 3 at Michigan - the 2nd best team in the B10 East - and ran the table against the rest of the B10 teams it played. By Garnett's home/away logic that means NW would have won by 2 touchdowns if the game had been played at Ryan Field. Yet the same team that was beating a supposedly elite Michigan 17-0 in the 2nd quarter lost to Akron & Duke the two weeks prior.
Last year the B10 did great in bowl games but the SEC had the two best teams in the country. Your entire argument his year for the B10 focuses on your irrational belief that you have two great teams (OSU & Michigan).
The B10 will get a bowl win when OSU crushes Washington but OSU should be playing Georgia. I would have wanted to see Penn State playing LSU instead of an overrated Kentucky as well as Michigan playing Georgia or LSU. The best teams in the B10 should be playing the best teams from the SEC and be seeded appropriately if any bragging rights will be determined. It is no different than in head to head team competitions where a coach puts his worst player against the best from the other side in order to shift the rest of the matches to an advantage for his team.
It would be great if the B10 and SEC would schedule conference wide head to head each year like conferences do in college basketball.
Robb
LOL SEC did not have the two best teams in the country. The 2 best teams were Ohio State and Wisconsin. OSU was spanking everyone and playing their best football late in the season. Wisconsin went 13-1. Bama played nobody and did not deserve a playoff spot. The whole system is rigged and everyone with half a brain knows it.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
Funny how fergie is already making excuses for sec teams if they lose the bowl games LOL.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
The last 4 years of the playoffs the BIG10 has only sent 2 teams out of 16
Those 2 teams, OSU and MSU were clobbered 69-0. No wonder they weren't invited, they are boring.
Bullsitter, will you agree that probably anyone who went instead of OSU and MSU during that period probably would have suffered the same fate?? maybe even worse. going in and facing Alabama as the Number Four seed in the past half-decade hasn't been easy. to that end and following your logic it might be that the "Committee" is trying to find the best competition for that game. it is a bitter pill to swallow in saying that the 'Tide has been tough during that period, there just should be a more objective, reasoned and systematic way to field these four Teams.
by virtue of their records, numbers 1-3 have shown they are above everyone else but not really that much above. playing early games against whipping boys is silly. it is a sad fact that the Committee positions Teams to achieve a pre-determined objective, having them ready lower in the rankings in case something unexpected happens.
the biggest thing about this year which just didn't seem proper was Notre Dame. think about it, all the other Teams in reasonable contention for a playoff spot --- Alabama, Clemson, Georgia, Oklahoma and Ohio State --- weren't so much playing to get in, they were playing to STAY in. Georgia in particular suffered because of that. I seriously doubt there is any scenario we could imagine which would have left Notre Dame at Number Five.
there is something wrong with that, I wonder how it will be fixed.
Yeah, having a defender knock down a pass in a rivalry game is absolutely the same thing as a quarterback air mailing a wide open throw. You nailed it.
LOL the Oklahoma state receiver was WIDE OPEN. But the QB threw the ball about 6 ft too short. Oklahoma state should've won that game.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
Meyer retiring after the Rose Bowl
I expect Oklahoma to have a small lead or be very close after the first half. Alabama will turn it on the second half and on to the Championship Game. Notre Dame will be exposed and embarrassed by Clemson.
http://www.unisquare.com/store/brick/
Ralph
Oklahoma is one of the few teams that has a winning record against us. I think it'll be like the Georgia game.
We just need to run the dang ball and the clock.
RTD, member of the SOS CLUB.
SOS stands for......Sons of Saban....
I do not think anybody is surprised by this. Well maybe one person but everybody else knew it was happening. Too bad. Great coach. Ethics are questionable but I would say most successful coaches have questionable ethics. Even the great Coach Wooden badly abused the system back in the day.
Apparently someone had some doubt.
Toughest division? ROFLMAO
Meyer has the best record against top 5 opponents in history. That's why the sec biased committee kept the Buckeyes out of the playoffs most years. This year, like most any other year, were the team that had that best shot at knocking out the Tide. Oklahoma? LOL They have yet to win a playoff game.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
Thank you, Urban.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
Urban Meyer Leaves Ohio State With One of the Most Remarkable Head Coaching Records in Football History.
Coaching in 218 games and winning 186 of them, Urban Meyer's .853 win percentage is one of the highest ever. He won three national titles (just one of 16 college football coaches to accomplish this feat) at two different universities, including his most recent at Ohio State in 2014. Meyer was 11-3 in the 14 bowl games he coached, and will be favored to win his 15th and first Rose Bowl.
Urban Meyer was an amazing 26-2 in his career against his rivals. Absolutely unparalleled in college football!!!
Urban Meyer won seven conference titles at Utah, Florida, and Ohio State combined
Meyer had by far the highest winning percentage of any active coach with over ten years of head coaching experience
Meyer's teams finished their seasons ranked in the top five eight times during his career
Meyer never posted a record worse than 8-5 (Florida, 2010)
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
Agreed. I guess it is nice when 12-1 is a terribly disappointing year. Only the Buckeyes and Alabama consider a one loss season to be a disappointment. Everyone else considers that a great season.
http://www.unisquare.com/store/brick/
Ralph
That's some very good stats on Meyer. The winning percentage is off the charts. Top 5 rankings are strong.
How come he only won 1 National Championship at OSU?
2012 Not permitted to play in a bowl game because of transgressions that had nothing to do with Meyer. Finished season undefeated and would probably have faced Notre Dame for the Championship and also probably the favorite.
2015 Never trailed in any game the entire year except for one loss on the games final play. Not selected for the playoffs. Good chance they would have been favored to win it all or close to it.
2018 Not selected. No complaints. However if they were in they would have as good a chance as anyone except for Alabama.
http://www.unisquare.com/store/brick/
Ralph
I don't recall what the deal was in 2015. Was it unfair that they weren't selected?
2015 was only unfair if you are a rabid OSU supporter.
Alabama - 12-1 SEC champions lost by one score at home to ranked Mississippi St
Clemson - 13-0 ACC champions, undefeated in regular season
Michigan St - 12-1 B10 champions, beat OSU head to head, only lost by 1 point at Nebraska
Oklahoma - 11-1 Big12 champions, lost by one score to Texas on a neutral field
MSU lost to Alabama 38-0 in the CFP semi-finals.
There were no sliders in the playoffs that year and no legitimate argument to be made for OSU other than that they should get an automatic spot in the playoffs because they were the defending national champions. I think if the SEC or Big12 champion had two losses that year instead of one OSU would have been selected.
OSU has a much more legitimate gripe this year. When there is nothing to really distinguish between two 1 loss conference champions, one side is going to be upset. OSU quit in their loss to Purdue and that ended up being the deciding factor. I would have preferred to see OSU in the playoffs even with their loss to Purdue as I think they are more talented and better coached than Oklahoma, but I can't really complain about the CFP committee's decision.
Robb
That is interesting. Like many years 5 worthy teams but can only pick 4 so someone will always feel left out but if you lose your conference championship game hard to be too upset. Sort of like if you get your butt smoked by Iowa or Purdue. It sucks but losing those games gives the committee an excuse to pick somebody else.
for the top Teams a loss is devastating, especially towards the end of the season. an early loss can be overcome and a Team can "prove" that it was a fluke and get it, not so 2-3 games before the season's end, and especially not so in the Championship Games.
that has always perplexed me. the pressure to be perfect is staggering.
RE: the Ohio State loss to MSU was one of Urban Meyer's biggest failures. with the Offense they had he allowed the Spartans to limit the field of play to 15 yards and never changed what he did.
I said on another forum that Meyer has a case as the greatest college football coach of all-time. He & Saban are head & shoulders above everybody - yes, everybody. It's so much harder to win at the highest level year in and year out now. You can't put 200 guys on scholarship like you could in the 50s.
Saban has more national titles but most of his success has come at one school. When you include more than just their "most successful school", Meyer catches up - fast. Either Florida or Ohio is Meyer's 2nd-most success tenure at a school. Both blow away Saban's LSU tenure. After that, it's Utah for Meyer vs MSU for Saban. Not even the same galaxy. After that, it's BGSU for Meyer vs Toledo for Saban. Again, not even close.
As Garnettstyle mentioned, Meyer has had multiple national title-level teams that didn't even get a chance to play for the title. Unbeaten team at Ohio - no bowl game at all. Unbeaten Utah team, didn't get to play for a title. A 1-loss Florida team and two 1-loss Ohio teams also didn't play for the title.
I don't know that I'd put Meyer at the top with Saban but it's really, really close.
This is what the first committee rankings looked like in 2014. Says it all why OSU has been snubbed 3 out of 5 years.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
2017 team also should've been in the playoffs over Alabama who lost by two TD's against their rival and beat nobody.
Meyer had not one but TWO long winning streaks at OSU. The 2012 and 2013 teams were riding a 24 game win streak. 2014-2015 a 23 game win streak.
IT CAN'T BE A TRUE PLAYOFF UNLESS THE BIG TEN CHAMPIONS ARE INCLUDED
Saban ran Meyer out of the SEC after Bama stomped him and Tebow. He knew he couldn't hang with Saban and the SEC so he faked heart problems and ran as fast as he could. He sat out a year and went to a cupcake conference, the BIG10. He knew he could win there because that league was weak.
Hey Garnett, wasn't OSU on probation for cheating in 2014? I remember something about that but wasn't sure about the years.
Some BIG10 fans like to twist stats and use "ifs" and "buts". I just state the facts Jack.
Yeah that "sterling" OSU resume in 2017, lost 31-16 to Oklahoma and lost 55 - 24 to Iowa. Win either of those games and OSU would have been in over Alabama. Garnett always whines about the CFP selection committee instead of placing the blame squarely on his team when they fail to get it done.
For those counting at home, the same 2017 Oklahoma that outclassed OSU on OSU's home field lost to Georgia in the CFP semifinals.
Also to note, the precedence to let in a 1 loss non-conference champion to the CFP was set in 2016 when the committee selected an OSU team, that didn't even play in the B10 championship game, over a 2 loss B10 champion Penn St. Penn State even beat OSU head to head that season. OSU then got wiped off the map by Clemson 31-0 in one of the most lopsided blowouts in CFP history - other two being Oregon over FSU 59-20 and Alabama over MSU 38-0.
If you look back, you will notice that Garnett was all about a 1 loss non-conference champion deserving to be in the CFP in 2016. He certainly changed his tune in 2017.
Robb