Although final mintages for the five (5) 1964-D versions are not yet listed, each now shows as NOT IN STOCK. Can this be the end of the Morgan mintage and what does Dan have in store for us with the already stunning 1917 Peace "broken sword" ?????
@jessewvu said:
Maybe it would be nice to make some more from burnished eagles for the rest of us schmucks that didn't get one.
This is all part of the fun with Carr offerings. And I'm not just saying that because I got one. I get it, if I didn't I'd be a touch bummed too but when you do it's awesome. And another bus always comes along. He's always doing fun things.
Regarding the Broken Sword Peace dollars, Dan told me by email that he would likely release a matte version but the a proof like version wasn't likely due to technical difficulties
@drfish said:
Regarding the Broken Sword Peace dollars, Dan told me by email that he would likely release a matte version but the a proof like version wasn't likely due to technical difficulties
I could see this due to the Broken Sword field surface which is concave and quite beautiful. The die would have to be polished to have a flat field for a proof like.
@drfish said:
Regarding the Broken Sword Peace dollars, Dan told me by email that he would likely release a matte version but the a proof like version wasn't likely due to technical difficulties
I could see this due to the Broken Sword field surface which is concave and quite beautiful. The die would have to be polished to have a flat field for a proof like.
I disagree. You can certainly have a proof or proof-like look on a concave surface... just a couple of years ago we had the Baseball Hall of Fame coins that were much more concave and those came in proof.
@drfish said:
Regarding the Broken Sword Peace dollars, Dan told me by email that he would likely release a matte version but the a proof like version wasn't likely due to technical difficulties
I could see this due to the Broken Sword field surface which is concave and quite beautiful. The die would have to be polished to have a flat field for a proof like.
I disagree. You can certainly have a proof or proof-like look on a concave surface... just a couple of years ago we had the Baseball Hall of Fame coins that were much more concave and those came in proof.
To be more accurate, I should have said that it would be harder to do a concave surface if the polishing equipment for a concave surface isn't readily available. I'm assuming that the polishing equipment is different for a flat vs. concave surface and that the equipment for a concave surface is less readily available.
I don't think mirrored fields will look all that great on a peace dollar. Now a matte, well, I just heard my wallet shed another tear and it will probably have an all out panic attack once they're released
Who wants to start a Dan Carr price guide? Not me but someone should
mark
Walker Proof Digital Album Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
I've been thinking that with the continuing talk of the down market, Dan's pieces are one of the bright areas in the hobby where prices and demand seems to continue to go up. The pieces are very well executed and have a growing following. For new collectors, I would actually recommend buying select pieces at issue prices to protect from paying too much tuition up front.
I'd like to see a 2021 Peace HR in gold...if the Mint doesn't do one. A Peace centennial silver round would be nice and consistent with other products.
@HalfStrike said:
The gold St. Gaudens would be nice, maybe we could supply the coins and pay him the price for striking them.
A high-relief would be awesome.
Dan's Confederate double eagles were ones where you could supply your own double eagle.
I've been wondering if this approach would work better for other higher priced coins.
I would readily supply a gold coin for overstriking. the delay would be with finding a suitable one at auction or for sale at a reasonable price.
i think he could do a high relief on any gold St. Gaudens coin, the ones he just released were done that way. I notice they came out much cleaner as the strike went deeper into the surface.
Here is a quick scan of mine with certificate. It looks just like the image on the web site. As far as I know they are all identified only as 'matte finish'.
Wonder if Dan is going to release the eight pieces that were struck with clashed dies ????
@CascadeChris said:
Since I'm a variety hunter and really hate filling holes etc I've been thinking of selling off my albums, aside the near full Morgan and peace, and all the random slabs and stuff I accumulated when I was a novice and focus exclusively on cherrypicking while trying to complete a full Carr collection. One of every overstrike and original he has produced while getting new ones as they come out. That should be quite the challenge. Am I crazy lol.
please keep us updated on your attempt to buy one of every strike and original he has produced !
@CascadeChris said:
Since I'm a variety hunter and really hate filling holes etc I've been thinking of selling off my albums, aside the near full Morgan and peace, and all the random slabs and stuff I accumulated when I was a novice and focus exclusively on cherrypicking while trying to complete a full Carr collection. One of every overstrike and original he has produced while getting new ones as they come out. That should be quite the challenge. Am I crazy lol.
please keep us updated on your attempt to buy one of every strike and original he has produced !
Well that might be way too lofty a goal as a lot are super low mintage or not even released or super expensive but when I can pick up something I don't have I will. And I probably won't go after different finishes unless it's a series I really like.
Hey 40, just curious if you got that walker / ASE on eBay for $750 as I know you like his pieces that are multi-struck.
@CascadeChris said:
Since I'm a variety hunter and really hate filling holes etc I've been thinking of selling off my albums, aside the near full Morgan and peace, and all the random slabs and stuff I accumulated when I was a novice and focus exclusively on cherrypicking while trying to complete a full Carr collection. One of every overstrike and original he has produced while getting new ones as they come out. That should be quite the challenge. Am I crazy lol.
please keep us updated on your attempt to buy one of every strike and original he has produced !
Well that might be way too lofty a goal as a lot are super low mintage or not even released or super expensive but when I can pick up something I don't have I will. And I probably won't go after different finishes unless it's a series I really like.
Hey 40, just curious if you got that walker / ASE on eBay for $750 as I know you like his pieces that are multi-struck.
no not me ! I prefer his fantasy date over strikes ! few years back I started at top of fantasy date page and bought two of everything its been a hard and costly road ! I do have a new double strike I will be posting soon
@CascadeChris said:
Since I'm a variety hunter and really hate filling holes etc I've been thinking of selling off my albums, aside the near full Morgan and peace, and all the random slabs and stuff I accumulated when I was a novice and focus exclusively on cherrypicking while trying to complete a full Carr collection. One of every overstrike and original he has produced while getting new ones as they come out. That should be quite the challenge. Am I crazy lol.
please keep us updated on your attempt to buy one of every strike and original he has produced !
Well that might be way too lofty a goal as a lot are super low mintage or not even released or super expensive but when I can pick up something I don't have I will. And I probably won't go after different finishes unless it's a series I really like.
Hey 40, just curious if you got that walker / ASE on eBay for $750 as I know you like his pieces that are multi-struck.
no not me ! I prefer his fantasy date over strikes ! few years back I started at top of fantasy date page and bought two of everything its been a hard and costly road ! I do have a new double strike I will be posting soon
@Voyageur said:
Is anyone going to the ANA National Money Show in Orlando next week and who might be the best dealers to check with for some of Dan's work ??
Illini420 or Jay Robinson if they are going
mark
Walker Proof Digital Album Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
@Voyageur said:
Is anyone going to the ANA National Money Show in Orlando next week and who might be the best dealers to check with for some of Dan's work ??
Illini420 or Jay Robinson if they are going
mark
I won't be able to make the show and I don't think Mike(illini420) is but I would check with him here to be sure.
Not sure if either will be there but Jim Cauley(errors and more)
And jackpot gold and silver usually have some of Dans items.
Comments
Although final mintages for the five (5) 1964-D versions are not yet listed, each now shows as NOT IN STOCK. Can this be the end of the Morgan mintage and what does Dan have in store for us with the already stunning 1917 Peace "broken sword" ?????
Just received my peace dollar and '64 Morgan; beautiful!
Maybe it would be nice to make some more from burnished eagles for the rest of us schmucks that didn't get one.
Beautiful Dan- thanks! I'm starting to accumulate a nice little hoard of Carr creations- this is fun.
This is all part of the fun with Carr offerings. And I'm not just saying that because I got one. I get it, if I didn't I'd be a touch bummed too but when you do it's awesome. And another bus always comes along. He's always doing fun things.
After looking at the previous 64/65 Peace dollars, I'm guessing we'll see matte and proof-like versions for the 1917.
Successful BST transactions with forum members thebigeng, SPalladino, Zoidmeister, coin22lover, coinsarefun, jwitten, CommemKing.
PocketArt ~ You are breakin' my
with those images !
I Absolutely agree with CascadeChris and am very pleased to have one each of the 1964-D Morgan varieties.
COCollector may very well be correct and perhaps Dan will even create something "extra special" as well.
Regarding the Broken Sword Peace dollars, Dan told me by email that he would likely release a matte version but the a proof like version wasn't likely due to technical difficulties
I could see this due to the Broken Sword field surface which is concave and quite beautiful. The die would have to be polished to have a flat field for a proof like.
I disagree. You can certainly have a proof or proof-like look on a concave surface... just a couple of years ago we had the Baseball Hall of Fame coins that were much more concave and those came in proof.
Michael Kittle Rare Coins --- 1908-S Indian Head Cent Grading Set --- No. 1 1909 Mint Set --- Kittlecoins on Facebook --- Long Beach Table 448
Ah, but the matte on his '64 Peace dollars was by far the nicer (IMHO) and would be on for one of the '17s in matte also.
Well, just Love coins, period.
To be more accurate, I should have said that it would be harder to do a concave surface if the polishing equipment for a concave surface isn't readily available. I'm assuming that the polishing equipment is different for a flat vs. concave surface and that the equipment for a concave surface is less readily available.
I don't think mirrored fields will look all that great on a peace dollar. Now a matte, well, I just heard my wallet shed another tear and it will probably have an all out panic attack once they're released
Who wants to start a Dan Carr price guide? Not me but someone should
mark
Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
A price guide would be interesting.
I've been thinking that with the continuing talk of the down market, Dan's pieces are one of the bright areas in the hobby where prices and demand seems to continue to go up. The pieces are very well executed and have a growing following. For new collectors, I would actually recommend buying select pieces at issue prices to protect from paying too much tuition up front.
I like my 1964 die 6 peace proof like finish dollars 180 minted ! If he made 1964 peace dont know why he couldn't make 1917
It could go with the DcarrFacts pages
I'd like to see a 2021 Peace HR in gold...if the Mint doesn't do one. A Peace centennial silver round would be nice and consistent with other products.
I found the "S" mint mark on mine
INYNWHWeTrust-TexasNationals,ajaan,blu62vette
coinJP, Outhaul ,illini420,MICHAELDIXON, Fade to Black,epcjimi1,19Lyds,SNMAN,JerseyJoe, bigjpst, DMWJR , lordmarcovan, Weiss,Mfriday4962,UtahCoin,Downtown1974,pitboss,RichieURich,Bullsitter,JDsCoins,toyz4geo,jshaulis, mustanggt, SNMAN, MWallace, ms71
Where are these pages?
wishful thinking on my part
a fan may be able to start them with his permission
A 1906 St. Gaudens Double Eagle in high relief would be so nice.
"Facts pages" do exist. His production blog is here with mintage totals, production dates and issue prices...
http://www.moonlightmint.com/coin_catalog.htm
The gold St. Gaudens would be nice, maybe we could supply the coins and pay him the price for striking them.
A high-relief would be awesome.
Dan's Confederate double eagles were ones where you could supply your own double eagle.
I've been wondering if this approach would work better for other higher priced coins.
of course.
I was thinking more of putting all the mintages, images, dimensions, content, year etc. for each issue on a page or group of issues on a page
I would readily supply a gold coin for overstriking. the delay would be with finding a suitable one at auction or for sale at a reasonable price.
i think he could do a high relief on any gold St. Gaudens coin, the ones he just released were done that way. I notice they came out much cleaner as the strike went deeper into the surface.
Q: are all of the matte proof 64-D morgan overstrikes finished as pictured or are they all antiqued or ?
Here is a quick scan of mine with certificate. It looks just like the image on the web site. As far as I know they are all identified only as 'matte finish'.
Wonder if Dan is going to release the eight pieces that were struck with clashed dies ????
please keep us updated on your attempt to buy one of every strike and original he has produced !
Well that might be way too lofty a goal as a lot are super low mintage or not even released or super expensive but when I can pick up something I don't have I will. And I probably won't go after different finishes unless it's a series I really like.
Hey 40, just curious if you got that walker / ASE on eBay for $750 as I know you like his pieces that are multi-struck.
no not me ! I prefer his fantasy date over strikes ! few years back I started at top of fantasy date page and bought two of everything its been a hard and costly road ! I do have a new double strike I will be posting soon
Hmm. One of the buffalo nickels maybe?
Is anyone going to the ANA National Money Show in Orlando next week and who might be the best dealers to check with for some of Dan's work ??
Illini420 or Jay Robinson if they are going
mark
Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
Here's two quick images for your viewing pleasure. They came in last week.
I can see that the two coins have really different finishes.
1917 'High Grade', 1964-D 'Die pair 2, Proof Like'
Sugar magnolia blossoms blooming, heads all empty and I don't care ...
Amazing pictures!
Wow lance. Those pics are the cats meow!
Hope Dan waits a while before releasing anything new so we can all refill our pocket books !
No joke there, he could hurt a few with some big gold issues of this Peace Dollar!
Well, just Love coins, period.
I won't be able to make the show and I don't think Mike(illini420) is but I would check with him here to be sure.
Not sure if either will be there but Jim Cauley(errors and more)
And jackpot gold and silver usually have some of Dans items.
My Ebay Store
would it look as good in gold?
maybe a gold poof, but that'd show those lathe lines.
I've got faith in Dan improving the "lathe" effect soon. They don't seem to show in the 1/4 oz Clark, Gruber specimens as much.
Well, just Love coins, period.
I think it could look great in gold, especially the broken sword reverse.
uh.
I see he has essentially this already (with b/w drawings)
Yes.
Yes, I'm a moron.
Just another good day at the P.O.... Dan's 1964-D High Grade Finish, CLASHED, Die Pair 2 PL arrived today, and quickly too !