veryfine--thanks. I bought it raw and figured it was a 35 just like you. We are both wrong!
newbarberguy and dogwood-----I was scratching my head too. I didn't get that 96-O and I offered an opinion on the 93-S newbarberguy commented on. While we are the subject of 96-O, I'll post the one I did score years ago
<< <i>Tombr, I would place that 11-D at VF-20...I have an 05-S that has similar wear and that's the grade I got from PCGS...am I right?
Oh, also...you thief! Where did you get such a nice looking 96-O? >>
Tombr - based on the wear on the left facing wing - you have an XF 40. Newbarberguy - look at the coin again - see the lead-feather - see the seperation ?
BTW, Tombr, that is a great looking 96-O. On that we agree.
Mike Hayes ~~~~~~~~~~~~ Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
Mike, I don't agree that it's an XF-40...and I think my subjective grade of VF-20 was hasty and is a little low. We're getting into seams here but the only grade left would be VF-30--but I've never seen a PCGS grade of VF-30. My comments are based only on a lowly two years of experience in trying to judge these mid-grade Barber halves...so if there are any lurkers out there please don't be influenced by my coin-grading ability...but will leave it up to Tombr...only his hairdresser (if he has one--cuz I don't) knows for sure! Dave
Dave, the 11-D graded XF40. I thought the reverse was XF40 hands down (as Mike ponited out about the feathers) and the obverse was VF30 or so, net VF35. PCGS thought different. You'll always have minor disagreements in grading. I'm just glad it didn't come back Genuine
The 96-O is a VF30 which I agree with. I got it from
Here's my 13-S. Its VF20 for comparison.
Here's a VF25 1902-O
And a VF35 1908-O
A XF45 1910-P
There you go Dave, a VF20, VF25, VF30 (96-O), VF35, XF40 (11-D) and a XF45 if you would like to compare all the grades from VF20 to XF45. I don't own anything higher than XF45.
MFH, can you take over the grading examples from here up
Tombr, I'm "learn-ed" now! I wouldn't have guessed XF-40 but then again I tend to look at the right wing span...may be because the "O" variety is a little less pronounced. I'm humbled and learn-ed. Thanks for the lesson (bowing to the great MuhammadaBarber).
That's a great looking 05-S - and looks like a strong XF 45.
Joe,
I've commented on the 1912 Quarter and a nice looking coin. I found it very interesting that your images look nowhere near the Heritage images. Heritage's images show a much more heavily toned coin. Your images showed a close up of the coin. Regardless, its a very nice type coin for your set.
Tom,
I'm still shaking my head how - in such a short amount of time - you have so greatly improved your images. Mark's book on photography was a worthwhile investment. Great job and looking forward to see all of your coins reimaged on your Registry Set soon.
Mike Hayes ~~~~~~~~~~~~ Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
Thanks tombr! I was more along the lines of Newbarberguy. I'm thinking I better regrade some of my halves posted on the BST before I sell any more of them
<< <i>Thanks tombr! I was more along the lines of Newbarberguy. I'm thinking I better regrade some of my halves posted on the BST before I sell any more of them >>
I was offered a very nice 1914-D quarter in 58 this afternoon. It was steep, IMHO , but after I kicked it around awhile, I decided to bite the bullet and get it. To my chagrin, it was sold while I was on the proverbial fence.
Mike Hayes ~~~~~~~~~~~~ Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
Nice to see some great circulated midgrade coins! I'll echo great imaging, Tom, you have really got the hang of it now. I still struggle to get the lighting/white balance just as the coin is in hand.
Dave (newbarberguy) don't feel bad about PCGS grading, they are all over the place in VF20-XF40.
I have received some nice coins from a fellow forum member, but they are not imaged yet and Greg (Mr. Breeze), led me to this one in Richmond last September. Because of my accident I haven't had time/ etc to image it until today.
PCGS says XF40, and I agree with them on this. line under LIBERTY and full Right (facing) eagle feather lines to edge. Sorry Tom, the 11 D is a SWEET coin, but VF30-35.
Don
Do your best to avoid circular arguments, as it will help you reason better, because better reasoning is often a result of avoiding circular arguments.
Glad to hear you're up and around - been wondering how you're doing.
Nice 14-S - and a solid 40, IMHO. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The 11-D is almost as nice but IMHO - again - I still think it makes the grade.
Regardless - great to see more postings here.
Noone has bothered to do anymore guessing. I've just upgraded another coin and found a newp as well. Anymore guesses ? I'd like to award the Dale Friend catalog to a Half Dollar collector. [ signed by Dale, himself ].
BTW, its not the 1914-D Quarter in PCGS 58 that another collector was selling ... I hemmed and hawed too long [ a half hour ] and he sold it to another collector. Yes, I could have kicked myself in the arse.
Happy Hunting.
Mike Hayes ~~~~~~~~~~~~ Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
You Barber guys got me start looking for original Halves and quarters about 3-4 months ago. So I sent my lil' mini collection that I started to PCGS. Nothing major or all that tough but at least I only got one Bagged! I have been looking for eye appeal no matter the grade, just had to be original.....not an easy task! ANyway, thought I'd share my grades. I'll post some pics when they come back! What a great thread!! I hope to contribute in the future! Barbers are kinda addicting!
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade 1 1 12979611 6534 1915-S 50C US F12 2 1 12979612 6525 1912-D 50C US F12 3 1 12979613 6492 1902 50C US VF25 4 1 12979614 6517 1909-O 50C US VG10 5 1 12979615 6520 1910-S 50C US VF20 6 1 12979616 6509 1907-D 50C US AU50 7 1 12979617 6492 1902 50C US AU50 8 1 12979618 6516 1909 50C US AU55 9 1 12979619 6503 1905-S 50C US XF40 10 1 12979620 6529 1913-S 50C US Genuine (92 - Cleaned) 11 1 12979621 6489 1901 50C US AU58 12 1 12979622 5671 1915-D 25C US AU58 13 1 12979623 5619 1898 25C US AU55 14 1 12979624 5601 1892 25C US AU53 15 1 12979625 6147 1827/6 50C US XF45 16 1 12979626 6611 1941 50C US MS65 17 1 12979627 6621 1944 50C US MS65 18 1 12979628 86658 1951 50C US MS64FL 19 1 12979629 6655 1949-S 50C US MS65 20 1 12979630 7248 1897-O $1 US AU55 Total Items: 20 Date Received: 1/15/2009
I just received my grade for a duplicate 1894-S Quarter - once I get the TrueView images - I'll post them along with the sellers images.
I also received an upgrade for one of my sets - will post it once I hear some answers to my last "Contest" - to win an autographed copy of Dale Friend's Heritage Auction Catalog.
Holeinone1972 - Thank you for posting your beautiful 1894 Quarter !!
Manorcourtman - Looking forward to your images !!
Mike Hayes ~~~~~~~~~~~~ Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
<< <i>While at the FUN Show, I picked up a couple of copies of a specialized edition of Dale Friend's Collection.
I had Dale autograph one for myself [ Thank You, Dale, for the kind words ] and another with just his signiture.
I will be happy to give the second copy away to anyone - who has already posted to this Thread - if they can name the next coin I will add to any of my Barber Collections:
[ ie: Liberty Head Nickels; Dimes; Quarters and Half Dollars ]
Even I can't guess which coin will be upgraded - obviously, none of my AU 58's or MS coins will be on the list - but there are alot of AU 53's & 55's that are on my want list in 58 or finer, and there are alot of missing registered coins in the Nickel and Dime Collections.
So...look over my Registry sets...see what fits the criteria for my upgrade-list and make a guess - multiple guesses are okay. Obviously, the first correct guess is automatically the winner...
Please remember, this "contest" is for anyone who has already posted to this Thread
This Thread is too large for the casual Barber Collector - and alot of collectors don't want to wade thru almost 3000 posts - can't blame them really - so I don't think we'll be seeing any new names posted on replys.
This should be good for a laugh - regardless - as I mentioned, I don't even know what is in store for my collection. [ I have added so many upgrades recently - I'm going to have to "cool my jets" for awhile !! ]
... and what's a Barber Post without an image ?
here's a quick random pick...
which is also one of my favorite coins !! Thanks again, BFJ !! >>
... just getting my little contest back on the forefront.... !!
Mike Hayes ~~~~~~~~~~~~ Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
<< <i>One of the upgrades I have been searching for - an 1894-S - and although raw this coin looks AU 58 to me. I don't have it in hand as yet - so I can't say with any certainty that it'll holder at all. It was worth a shot IMHO.
Coin arrived 12-15-08; looks better than I had hoped for; I see no reason it won't holder as an AU 58 !! >>
Well, I sent this coin into PCGS raw while I was at FUN and requested TrueView images. Last night my grade was made available but there was no image - yet. It should be up soon. I'll add the new images once I receive them... anyone care to make a stab at the grade ?
Mike Hayes ~~~~~~~~~~~~ Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
I've heard the collector coins are doing well too, but I think the supply is drying up at the moment-----at least in the Halves. My usual hunting grounds haven't been as fertile recently.
I've heard the collector coins are doing well too, but I think the supply is drying up at the moment-----at least in the Halves. My usual hunting grounds haven't been as fertile recently. >>
I'll say. Had a curiosity bid on a 1901-o quarter in PCGS XF45 on eBay that went for $512. Not moon money but indicative of a strong market for tough original well graded Barbers. It's still early in this economic downturn but certain things just feel strong.
Here's a relative newp. Ex NGC 45
We're all born MS70. I'm about a Fine 15 right now.
Quite an expensive coin KK. It's hard to tell from the image how it really looks. But as far as wear, I think the obverse is XF-45, reverse is AU-55. Probably in an AU-53 holder if it was submitted a few times.
<< <i>Quite an expensive coin KK. It's hard to tell from the image how it really looks. But as far as wear, I think the obverse is XF-45, reverse is AU-55. Probably in an AU-53 holder if it was submitted a few times. >>
It is expensive but its the KEY to the series. I like the reverse a lot but the obverse imho does not appear to be all there for the assigned grade. Maybe it was "net" graded
<< <i>After 1872 posts on this Mega Thread and on the occasion of completing my Barber Quarter collection with the addition of a very choice 1901-S in PCGS AU 55 , I thought I'd add it here as well as getting it eventually buried in the thread.
Edit: 2/17/09:
This coin is currently at HLRC; I traded it towards an 1892-O Micro O PCGS MS 63 with a Green Bean - CAC Sticker. - EX: Peter Shireman - [ whose influenece made me realize that this is truly a very special coin.]
You have my word that this 1901-S Quarter is a very solid AU 55 . Its reverse has AU 58 detail, IMHO, and although the obverse has been discussed as an AU 53, however, I feel the obverse does qualify as an AU 55. The reverse absolutely carries this coin in its grade of AU 55. I have been offered a number of 01-S quarters, and this one was the best match to my collection. I have decided to only have AU 58's to MS coins in this set.
BTW, HLRC's price is substantially lower than what I originally paid for this coin. Yes, I took it on the chin on this trade however I think I stole the 1892-O MIcro O Half. Its all a matter of give and take. Right, Harry ?
Edited to add the old NGC holdered images:
To the next owner of this coin, enjoy it, you won't find its equal in AU for many decades. >>
Mike Hayes ~~~~~~~~~~~~ Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
Went to the Lakeland Florida Coin Show today...75-100 dealers/sellers or so...not a bad turn out. There were other events going on within the complex so there was lots of traffic at the Convention Center and at the coin show. Saw lots of raw Barber halves but most were in the G-F range and a few in VF and XF...and for the first time saw a number of PCGS slabbed Barber Halves. One dealer had a half dozen slabbed Barber Halves in the MS 61-64 range...another dealer had a couple of AU's and VF's. To my surprise, one dealer actually had an 1892-P PCGS XF-45...which I hurriedly acquired since it filled a hole in my collection...first time I've ever come across a slabbed XF-45 there...and have been going twice a year for the past few years.
To my surprise though, some dealers responded quite negatively when I asked if they had an certified Barber Halves...one dealer was somewhat rude when I asked and replied "What's wrong, can't you grade your own coins? I don't need a TPG to grade my coins that's why I don't have or sell slabbed coins." I didn't reply or argue with the guy...just assumed he was ignorant and decided to let him wallow in his own ignorance. Some other dealers scowled when I told them I was specifically looking for PCGS slabbed coins. I don't know if anyone else has ever gotten responses like that...perhaps it's just that they were small time dealers/collectors from rural Florida. I have to say though that most of the dealers were courteous and helpful...but it only takes a few rotten eggs to spoil what was overall, a pleasant way to spend a Saturday afternoon.
This coin is awesome and has some beautiful lilac-colored toning on the lower part of the reverse and the upper part of the obverse, especially behind Liberty's head. Just can't get the lighting right to get a nice picture of the entire coin, but the above pics are my best first try. Will definitely be one of the stars of my 1909 Mint Set, if not THE star!!
I was at the Lakeland show on Friday. First time I made it over there. I did not see much at all in the way of the better date Barber halves in F-AU. Did see two dealers who had large selections of dates in G-F. Saw a couple of slabbed high end halves; proofs and 65+ coins. I figured if Mike H. had made the trip up, they'd be gone in a heart beat I did pick up a nice raw AU50+ 98P quarter for $75, which was a pretty good deal (no pics yet). Most of my funds were spent on a nice grouping of early date walkers and some type coins.
What do you do with an ebay seller that advertises an "original" coin but when you receive it, it looks like it has been "retoned"? I recieved a beautiful 1907-P in the mail today with an excellent mint strike but for the life of me, it looks like it has been "retoned". I'm not an expert but I'm no novice either...I think I've progressed beyond the casual collector at this point. It's a soft brown color on both the obv and rev...not similar to other coins that reflect a steel gray color. Although he advertised the coin as "original" I seriously have my doubts now. I will send to PCGS for grading but if it comes back as "retoned" I will go after the seller and demand a refund...any thoughts out there?
newbarberguy....lets see pix, but if you have a gut feeling about the coin, unless he has a 60 day return even if you pop it out of it's holder, I'd say make a call and stick with it.
tychojoe, keep them coming. Fine is tough as a grade set.
We're all born MS70. I'm about a Fine 15 right now.
Don't know what to say - I'd get in touch with the seller first - and as you're concerned about the originality of the coin - don't send it for for grading without the express knowledge of the seller - in case the delay in submitting the coin constitutes a violation of the sales agreement.
BTW, the 94-S Quarter imaged before came back as a Genuine - Cleaned. I didn't notice any patterned hairlines.
Technojoe,
Nice group of Fines !!
Mike Hayes ~~~~~~~~~~~~ Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
Comments
I fiinally got in the mood to take a picture. This is an 11-D I recently added to the harem. I found this date and mint hard to find too.
PCGS gave it a---------well how about a few guesses before I reveal it. NO cheating
<< <i>I was setup!
I fiinally got in the mood to take a picture. This is an 11-D I recently added to the harem. I found this date and mint hard to find too.
PCGS gave it a---------well how about a few guesses before I reveal it. NO cheating
VF-35?
Regardless of the assigned grade, that coin is soooooo nice.
newbarberguy and dogwood-----I was scratching my head too. I didn't get that 96-O and I offered an opinion on the 93-S newbarberguy commented on. While we are the subject of 96-O, I'll post the one I did score years ago
Oh, also...you thief! Where did you get such a nice looking 96-O?
<< <i>Tombr, I would place that 11-D at VF-20...I have an 05-S that has similar wear and that's the grade I got from PCGS...am I right?
Oh, also...you thief! Where did you get such a nice looking 96-O? >>
Tombr - based on the wear on the left facing wing - you have an XF 40.
Newbarberguy - look at the coin again - see the lead-feather - see the seperation ?
BTW, Tombr, that is a great looking 96-O. On that we agree.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
US and British coin collector, and creator of The Ultimate Chuck E. Cheese's and Showbiz Pizza Place Token & Ticket Guide
I don't agree that it's an XF-40...and I think my subjective grade of VF-20 was hasty and is a little low. We're getting into seams here but the only grade left would be VF-30--but I've never seen a PCGS grade of VF-30. My comments are based only on a lowly two years of experience in trying to judge these mid-grade Barber halves...so if there are any lurkers out there please don't be influenced by my coin-grading ability...but will leave it up to Tombr...only his hairdresser (if he has one--cuz I don't) knows for sure!
Dave
Dave, the 11-D graded XF40. I thought the reverse was XF40 hands down (as Mike ponited out about the feathers) and the obverse was VF30 or so, net VF35. PCGS thought different. You'll always have minor disagreements in grading. I'm just glad it didn't come back Genuine
The 96-O is a VF30 which I agree with. I got it from
Here's my 13-S. Its VF20 for comparison.
Here's a VF25 1902-O
And a VF35 1908-O
A XF45 1910-P
There you go Dave, a VF20, VF25, VF30 (96-O), VF35, XF40 (11-D) and a XF45 if you would like to compare all the grades from VF20 to XF45.
I don't own anything higher than XF45.
MFH, can you take over the grading examples from here up
I'm "learn-ed" now! I wouldn't have guessed XF-40 but then again I tend to look at the right wing span...may be because the "O" variety is a little less pronounced. I'm humbled and learn-ed. Thanks for the lesson (bowing to the great MuhammadaBarber).
Dave,
That's a great looking 05-S - and looks like a strong XF 45.
Joe,
I've commented on the 1912 Quarter and a nice looking coin.
I found it very interesting that your images look nowhere near
the Heritage images. Heritage's images show a much more heavily
toned coin. Your images showed a close up of the coin. Regardless,
its a very nice type coin for your set.
Tom,
I'm still shaking my head how - in such a short amount of time - you
have so greatly improved your images. Mark's book on photography
was a worthwhile investment. Great job and looking forward to see
all of your coins reimaged on your Registry Set soon.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
I'm thinking I better regrade some of my halves posted on the BST before I sell any more of them
<< <i>Thanks tombr! I was more along the lines of Newbarberguy.
I'm thinking I better regrade some of my halves posted on the BST before I sell any more of them
I might sound repetitive, but got a VF - 1895-S ?
-----------------------------------------------------------
I was offered a very nice 1914-D quarter in 58 this afternoon.
It was steep, IMHO , but after I kicked it around awhile, I decided
to bite the bullet and get it. To my chagrin, it was sold while I was
on the proverbial fence.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
Dave (newbarberguy) don't feel bad about PCGS grading, they are all over the place in VF20-XF40.
I have received some nice coins from a fellow forum member, but they are not imaged yet and Greg (Mr. Breeze), led me to this one in Richmond last September. Because of my accident I haven't had time/ etc to image it until today.
PCGS says XF40, and I agree with them on this. line under LIBERTY and full Right (facing) eagle feather lines to edge. Sorry Tom, the 11 D is a SWEET coin, but VF30-35.
Don
I agree with you on the 11-D. I bought it raw. I was thinking VF-30/35 too. The obverse is a little weak. Grading is subjective though as we all know
Don,
Glad to hear you're up and around - been wondering how you're doing.
Nice 14-S - and a solid 40, IMHO.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The 11-D is almost as nice but IMHO - again - I still think it makes the grade.
Regardless - great to see more postings here.
Noone has bothered to do anymore guessing. I've just upgraded another coin
and found a newp as well. Anymore guesses ? I'd like to award the Dale Friend
catalog to a Half Dollar collector. [ signed by Dale, himself ].
BTW, its not the 1914-D Quarter in PCGS 58 that another collector was selling ...
I hemmed and hawed too long [ a half hour ] and he sold it to another collector.
Yes, I could have kicked myself in the arse.
Happy Hunting.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 12979611 6534 1915-S 50C US F12
2 1 12979612 6525 1912-D 50C US F12
3 1 12979613 6492 1902 50C US VF25
4 1 12979614 6517 1909-O 50C US VG10
5 1 12979615 6520 1910-S 50C US VF20
6 1 12979616 6509 1907-D 50C US AU50
7 1 12979617 6492 1902 50C US AU50
8 1 12979618 6516 1909 50C US AU55
9 1 12979619 6503 1905-S 50C US XF40
10 1 12979620 6529 1913-S 50C US Genuine (92 - Cleaned)
11 1 12979621 6489 1901 50C US AU58
12 1 12979622 5671 1915-D 25C US AU58
13 1 12979623 5619 1898 25C US AU55
14 1 12979624 5601 1892 25C US AU53
15 1 12979625 6147 1827/6 50C US XF45
16 1 12979626 6611 1941 50C US MS65
17 1 12979627 6621 1944 50C US MS65
18 1 12979628 86658 1951 50C US MS64FL
19 1 12979629 6655 1949-S 50C US MS65
20 1 12979630 7248 1897-O $1 US AU55
Total Items: 20
Date Received: 1/15/2009
once I get the TrueView images - I'll post them along with
the sellers images.
I also received an upgrade for one of my sets - will post
it once I hear some answers to my last "Contest" - to win
an autographed copy of Dale Friend's Heritage Auction Catalog.
Holeinone1972 - Thank you for posting your beautiful 1894 Quarter !!
Manorcourtman - Looking forward to your images !!
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
Boiler and Hayden,
Beautiful coins !!
Thanks for sharing them !
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
<< <i>While at the FUN Show, I picked up a couple of copies of
a specialized edition of Dale Friend's Collection.
I had Dale autograph one for myself
[ Thank You, Dale, for the kind words ]
and another with just his signiture.
I will be happy to give the second copy away to anyone - who has already
posted to this Thread - if they can name the next coin I will add to any of
my Barber Collections:
[ ie: Liberty Head Nickels; Dimes; Quarters and Half Dollars ]
Even I can't guess which coin will be upgraded -
obviously, none of my AU 58's or MS coins will be on the list -
but there are alot of AU 53's & 55's that are on my want list in 58 or finer,
and there are alot of missing registered coins in the Nickel and Dime Collections.
So...look over my Registry sets...see what fits the criteria for my upgrade-list
and make a guess - multiple guesses are okay. Obviously, the first correct
guess is automatically the winner...
Please remember, this "contest" is for anyone who has already posted to this Thread
This Thread is too large for the casual Barber Collector - and alot of collectors
don't want to wade thru almost 3000 posts - can't blame them really - so I don't think
we'll be seeing any new names posted on replys.
This should be good for a laugh - regardless - as I mentioned, I don't even know
what is in store for my collection. [ I have added so many upgrades recently - I'm
going to have to "cool my jets" for awhile !! ]
... and what's a Barber Post without an image ?
here's a quick random pick...
which is also one of my favorite coins !! Thanks again, BFJ !! >>
... just getting my little contest back on the forefront.... !!
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
<< <i>One of the upgrades I have been searching for - an 1894-S - and although raw
this coin looks AU 58 to me. I don't have it in hand as yet - so I can't say with any
certainty that it'll holder at all. It was worth a shot IMHO.
Coin arrived 12-15-08; looks better than I had hoped for; I see no reason it won't holder as an AU 58 !! >>
Well, I sent this coin into PCGS raw while I was at FUN and requested TrueView images.
Last night my grade was made available but there was no image - yet. It should be up soon.
I'll add the new images once I receive them... anyone care to make a stab at the grade ?
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
Here's something I had TrueViewed awhile ago - and can't remember if I ever posted it.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
I've heard the collector coins are doing well too, but I think the supply is drying up at the moment-----at least in the Halves. My usual hunting grounds haven't been as fertile recently.
<< <i>Now that's a NICE Barber
I've heard the collector coins are doing well too, but I think the supply is drying up at the moment-----at least in the Halves. My usual hunting grounds haven't been as fertile recently.
I'll say. Had a curiosity bid on a 1901-o quarter in PCGS XF45 on eBay that went for $512. Not moon money but indicative of a strong market for tough original well graded Barbers. It's still early in this economic downturn but certain things just feel strong.
Here's a relative newp. Ex NGC 45
My Ebay
1934-1958 RB Lincoln Short Set
NO cheating please
That's my old 01-S - Its in a PCGS 55 holder - and is currently listed at HLRC.
Harry's asking price is $38,500.
Edit to Add:
Look at Post # 2 of this thread !
ReEdit:
Its a solid 55 - no questions about it.
I traded it towards my new Micro O in 63.
I decided that I'd rather have a MS in my set.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
<< <i>Quite an expensive coin KK. It's hard to tell from the image how it really looks. But as far as wear, I think the obverse is XF-45, reverse is AU-55. Probably in an AU-53 holder if it was submitted a few times. >>
It is expensive but its the KEY to the series. I like the reverse a lot but the obverse imho does not appear to be all there for the assigned grade. Maybe it was "net" graded
Mike what say you since it was your coin?
KK
<< <i>New to my 1909 Mint Set
Very nice coin with a good strike
Sort of regret not pulling the trigger on it earlier, but glad it went to someone deserving
Michael Kittle Rare Coins --- 1908-S Indian Head Cent Grading Set --- No. 1 1909 Mint Set --- Kittlecoins on Facebook --- Long Beach Table 448
Forwarding this post as its now current again.
<< <i>After 1872 posts on this Mega Thread and on the occasion of completing my Barber Quarter collection with the addition of a very choice 1901-S in PCGS AU 55 , I thought I'd add it here as well as getting it eventually buried in the thread.
Edit: 2/17/09:
This coin is currently at HLRC; I traded it towards an 1892-O Micro O PCGS MS 63 with a Green Bean - CAC Sticker. - EX: Peter Shireman - [ whose influenece made me realize that this is truly a very special coin.]
You have my word that this 1901-S Quarter is a very solid AU 55 . Its reverse has AU 58 detail, IMHO, and although the obverse has been discussed as an AU 53, however, I feel the obverse does qualify as an AU 55. The reverse absolutely carries this coin in its grade of AU 55. I have been offered a number of 01-S quarters, and this one was the best match to my collection. I have decided to only have AU 58's to MS coins in this set.
BTW, HLRC's price is substantially lower than what I originally paid for this coin. Yes, I took it on the chin on this trade however I think I stole the 1892-O MIcro O Half. Its all a matter of give and take. Right, Harry ?
Edited to add the old NGC holdered images:
To the next owner of this coin, enjoy it, you won't find its equal in AU for many decades. >>
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
Moving this Thread along...
Here's a newp for the Dime collection:
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
To my surprise though, some dealers responded quite negatively when I asked if they had an certified Barber Halves...one dealer was somewhat rude when I asked and replied "What's wrong, can't you grade your own coins? I don't need a TPG to grade my coins that's why I don't have or sell slabbed coins." I didn't reply or argue with the guy...just assumed he was ignorant and decided to let him wallow in his own ignorance. Some other dealers scowled when I told them I was specifically looking for PCGS slabbed coins. I don't know if anyone else has ever gotten responses like that...perhaps it's just that they were small time dealers/collectors from rural Florida. I have to say though that most of the dealers were courteous and helpful...but it only takes a few rotten eggs to spoil what was overall, a pleasant way to spend a Saturday afternoon.
and don't let the dealer's get to you, some were never taught how to treat a customer and some were never even taught any manners!
Let's see some pics of your XF45!
Michael Kittle Rare Coins --- 1908-S Indian Head Cent Grading Set --- No. 1 1909 Mint Set --- Kittlecoins on Facebook --- Long Beach Table 448
1909-O Barber Half PCGS MS65 (and CAC too) (ex. Friend)
This coin is awesome and has some beautiful lilac-colored toning on the lower part of the reverse and the upper part of the obverse, especially behind Liberty's head. Just can't get the lighting right to get a nice picture of the entire coin, but the above pics are my best first try. Will definitely be one of the stars of my 1909 Mint Set, if not THE star!!
Michael Kittle Rare Coins --- 1908-S Indian Head Cent Grading Set --- No. 1 1909 Mint Set --- Kittlecoins on Facebook --- Long Beach Table 448
http://www.ebay.com/sch/rs8199/m.html?_nkw=&_armrs=1&_ipg=&_from=
I gave some thought about going to Lakeland
but I had appointments today. Now I'm glad I
didn't drive up - its almost a 3 hr drive each way.
Mike - That's a very special 09-O half. I looked at
it while I was at FUN. Nice pick up !! Congrats !!
Rob - Sweet quarter - love the toning !!
Greg - Looking forward to see your new 98-P !!
Dennis - great looking 97-S quarter !
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
These are not a very good pictures (damn dimply plastic from ATS), but this came yesterday
“We are only their care-takers,” he posed, “if we take good care of them, then centuries from now they may still be here … ”
Todd - BHNC #242
Todd,
Beautiful V Nickel - love the color.
-------------------------------------------
My NEWP is too large to post - need to get it reduced.
Happy Hunting.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
tychojoe, keep them coming. Fine is tough as a grade set.
Don't know what to say - I'd get in touch with the seller first - and as you're
concerned about the originality of the coin - don't send it for for grading without
the express knowledge of the seller - in case the delay in submitting the coin
constitutes a violation of the sales agreement.
BTW, the 94-S Quarter imaged before came back as a Genuine - Cleaned. I didn't
notice any patterned hairlines.
Technojoe,
Nice group of Fines !!
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases