Official NFL HOF autograph set thread???

gregm13

What did you submit? I'm still waiting on my orders...both a 25 card PSA/DNA and modern which contained another 20+ auto'd cards. BTW, the first of my all time auto'd sets is live....it's the all Time Dolphins auto'd set. I've requested similiar sets for the All Time Rushers, QB, Receivers, Defense, 75th Anniversary Team, Future HOF modern and Future HOF senior.

Will you collect any of those sets?

Greg M.

Reese3333

I submitted:

Arnie Herber-02 Legendary Cut
Vince Lombardi-02 Legendary Cut
Ken Strong-02 Legendary Cut
Bronko Nagurski-02 F/X Cut
Sammy Baugh-01 Donruss Classics
Jim Brown=01 SOTT
Joe Montana-01 Legends
Steve Van Buren- 04 Fleer GOTG
Walter Payton-Inkredible
Joe Namath-01 Legends

I would definitely be working on some of those sets. I should just about have everyone on the 75th Ann. Set. I am always picking up Senior and Modern autos. Some of those other sets would be fun to start as well.

gregm13

<< <i>I submitted:

Arnie Herber-02 Legendary Cut
Vince Lombardi-02 Legendary Cut
Ken Strong-02 Legendary Cut
Bronko Nagurski-02 F/X Cut
Sammy Baugh-01 Donruss Classics
Jim Brown=01 SOTT
Joe Montana-01 Legends
Steve Van Buren- 04 Fleer GOTG
Walter Payton-Inkredible
Joe Namath-01 Legends

I would definitely be working on some of those sets. I should just about have everyone on the 75th Ann. Set. I am always picking up Senior and Modern autos. Some of those other sets would be fun to start as well. >>



Reese,

Nice lot of cards that you submitted....you must have a lot of money invested in that submission!

Greg M.

jradke4

reese.

would love to see a scan of the herber!!

jay

Reese3333

No problem Jay,

I will try and find a scan of it on my hard drive. If not, I will have to wait until the 5 day special pops.

jradke4

as you can imagne since i am a big packer fan the herber and lambeau are the two that i am after the most. i hope i can get a shot at one of them in the near future.

Reese3333

Found it, here it is:

Fabfrank

Nice Herber card Reese. Do you know if that card is numbered?

Reese3333

According to beckett, there are #25. There is no serial number though.

gregm13

<< <i>According to beckett, there are #25. There is no serial number though. >>



Reese,

You just have to rub in the Arnie Herber don't ya

Greg M.

gregm13

Is anyone interested in a PSA 9 Doug Atkins 2004 UD Legends certified auto for $25 dlvd? I also have a nice auto'd Emmitt Thomas for $30 dlvd.

Greg M.

Reese3333

<< <i>Reese,

You just have to rub in the Arnie Herber don't ya

Greg M. >>



I wasn't trying to I promise

Fabfrank

Greg- PM sent

gregm13

<< <i>Greg- PM sent >>



PM back at ya!

Greg M.

Reese3333

I got my tall boy order back from the group sub on Saturday

Thanks Greg!

Reese3333

Grades Popped!!! I am bummed about some of these (Lombardi and Nagurski should be 10's), but the Herber makes me VERY happy!!!!

1 09047843 2001 SP AUTHENTIC JBr JIM BROWN SIGN OF THE TIMES 8
2 09047844 2001 DONRUSS CLASSICS 199 SAMMY BAUGH SIGNIFICANT SIGNATURES 7
3 09047845 2001 U.D. LEGENDS JM JOE MONTANA AUTOGRAPH 8
4 09047846 GBASV GOLD BORDER AUTOGRAPH 7
5 09047847 2002 SP LEGENDARY CUTS LC-KS KEN STRONG CUT SIGNATURE 10
6 09047848 2002 SP LEGENDARY CUTS LC-AH ARNIE HERBER CUT SIGNATURE 10
7 09047849 2002 SP LEGENDARY CUTS LC-VL VINCE LOMBARDI CUT SIGNATURE 8
8 09047850 2001 U.D. ROOKIE F/X LC-BN BRONKO NAGURSKI LEGENDARY CUTS-AUTOGRAPH 9
9 09047851 1999 UPPER DECK RETRO WPAR WALTER PAYTON AUTOGRAPH 8
10 09047852 2001 U.D. LEGENDS JN JOE NAMATH AUTOGRAPH 8

Date Received: 12/26/2007
Date of Grades Posted: 01/02/2008
Date Shipped: No Date Specified

LEDFOOT

Hey guys need a little help,

I need:

1999 Century Legends Epic Signatures Jerry Rice and Troy Aikman


Thanks

Paul

Fabfrank

Reese- Great grades. Are any available or are they going into your set?

Reese3333

Thanks Frank,

These are all going to my set for now. At some point I will be upgrading some of them though.

gregm13

<< <i>Grades Popped!!! I am bummed about some of these (Lombardi and Nagurski should be 10's), but the Herber makes me VERY happy!!!!

1 09047843 2001 SP AUTHENTIC JBr JIM BROWN SIGN OF THE TIMES 8
2 09047844 2001 DONRUSS CLASSICS 199 SAMMY BAUGH SIGNIFICANT SIGNATURES 7
3 09047845 2001 U.D. LEGENDS JM JOE MONTANA AUTOGRAPH 8
4 09047846 GBASV GOLD BORDER AUTOGRAPH 7
5 09047847 2002 SP LEGENDARY CUTS LC-KS KEN STRONG CUT SIGNATURE 10
6 09047848 2002 SP LEGENDARY CUTS LC-AH ARNIE HERBER CUT SIGNATURE 10
7 09047849 2002 SP LEGENDARY CUTS LC-VL VINCE LOMBARDI CUT SIGNATURE 8
8 09047850 2001 U.D. ROOKIE F/X LC-BN BRONKO NAGURSKI LEGENDARY CUTS-AUTOGRAPH 9
9 09047851 1999 UPPER DECK RETRO WPAR WALTER PAYTON AUTOGRAPH 8
10 09047852 2001 U.D. LEGENDS JN JOE NAMATH AUTOGRAPH 8

Date Received: 12/26/2007
Date of Grades Posted: 01/02/2008
Date Shipped: No Date Specified >>



Great cards Reese - congrats. Have you sent the Edwards in yet?

Greg M.

Reese3333

I've got the box ready to go. I am hoping to get in the mail tomorrow morning.

This is what I am sending to PSA/DNA:

51 Bowman Tom Fears
55 Topps AA Mel Hein
55 Topps AA Ken Strong
55 Topps AA Turk Edwards
56 Topps Crazylegs Hirsch
56 Topps Charley Conerly
63 Topps Ernie Stautner
75 Topps Emmitt Thomas
75 Topps Jim Tyrer
77 Touchdown Bulldog Turner
90 Proset George Young
90 Swell Paul Brown
90 Swell Weeb Ewbank

Reese3333

Anyone know anything about these? I was just curious about the checklist. I think these may be the WORST I've seen. What are they thinking???

gregm13

<< <i>Anyone know anything about these? I was just curious about the checklist. I think these may be the WORST I've seen. What are they thinking???



>>



God - are those AWEFUL!! I wouldn't pay 10 cents for any of those. Why would you put a card inside of a card? I'd prefer the older cards...

Greg M.

Reese3333

The Bulldog Turner is a BIN for $800

I looked at some completed auctions, and they aren't selling for much. Most of the guys I have seen are all still living. I would think that there must be some significant signatures in the product, or people wouldn't be busting it, right????

IMeddie

Reese,

I hope there are better autos that the ones you posted. They are UGLY.

Todd

Reese3333

Yeah, they are bad. I will get them out of my photobucket account so we don't have to look at the anymore!


Good news!!! I was able to get back $580 of the $650 back from the Steve Owen autograph. I had to file a chargeback with my credit card because the seller would keep finding excuses as to why he could not to send my refund, after promising it on several different occasions. I have to file with Paypal for the rest, but probably will not be able to get it back since it has been 45 days since the transaction.

gregm13

Reese,

What did you only get $580 of the $650 back? Why not the whole amount?

Let's make sure to blacklist the seller. What was hi name again....georgeallen40?

Regards,

Greg M.

Reese3333

The remaining $62.81 was paid with a paypal balance. I have contacted paypal about a dispute, but it has been 45 days and it won't let me. I have emailed them and have not been able to get a response. I may be out the $62.

The seller was Georgeallen40. He promised to issue my refund immediately after I sent the card back to him. The day he recieves the card, he emails me saying that he now can't refund me for 2 weeks. I wait the two weeks, and now he says it will be a month until he has the money. He promised to list things for sale to cover my refund, and of course he never had anything listed for sale. I tried to work with him, but he stopped returning my emails. It was a terrible transaction and horrible experience to go through. Thank God I paid with my credit card and was able to recover most of the refund.

jradke4

Hi all, I was able to pick up a Wayne Millner Fleer HOF auto the other day. Another one down, now less than 10% to go.

Reese3333

Nice pickup Jay!

Did you all see that the HOF Football Any Medium set has been added in the Autographs section on the registry. I have tried three times to add my cards, and still haven't been able to add anything!

jradke4

Reese,

I have seen that set up for almost a month. I havent tried adding any cards yet though. I wonder if they exclude cards though they say any medium. I doubt that, but it also might take them awhile to get the cards added to the set that you want to add. Like if you have a rare auto'd card for this set it can take a day or two before they enter in the info to allow you to add the card.

Jay

gregm13

<< <i>Hi all, I was able to pick up a Wayne Millner Fleer HOF auto the other day. Another one down, now less than 10% to go. >>



Jay,

Congrats on the Millner - another one down. How much did you pay?

Regards,

Greg M.

SooperDave

I think the new NFL autograph registry any medium requires that the signatures be graded so a card with an authenticated auto is not accepted

jradke4

<< <i>

<< <i>Hi all, I was able to pick up a Wayne Millner Fleer HOF auto the other day. Another one down, now less than 10% to go. >>



Jay,

Congrats on the Millner - another one down. How much did you pay?

Regards,

Greg M. >>



I paid enough. It was from Jack.

Reese3333

<< <i>I think the new NFL autograph registry any medium requires that the signatures be graded so a card with an authenticated auto is not accepted >>



That would explain it. Thanks Sooperdave!

Reese

SooperDave

Question for you autograph guys. If you have a PSA authenticated signature and you want to have the auto graded all you have to pay for is the grading fees ...right?
Thanks
Superdave

Reese3333

Just added a bunch of scans for my set. The cards will no pics I am still waiting on from PSA.

Please check it out!


Reese's HOF Auto Set

obusek99

I have a redemption card for a John Hannah auto card from Press Pass Legends. Anyone interested? Only thing I ask in return is a card as well, not even a good one, I just like getting crap in the mail. PM if interested.

gregm13

<< <i>I think the new NFL autograph registry any medium requires that the signatures be graded so a card with an authenticated auto is not accepted >>



I really wish that PSA would grade the autograph on slabbed cards. I would much prefer the auto'd card registry to be based upon the quality of the autograph rather than the card.

Regards,

Greg M.

gregm13

<< <i>I have a redemption card for a John Hannah auto card from Press Pass Legends. Anyone interested? Only thing I ask in return is a card as well, not even a good one, I just like getting crap in the mail. PM if interested. >>



What are you interested in? I have tons of autographed cards to trade. Let me know what player or team you're looking for.

Regards,

Greg M.

obusek99

I want it to be a surprise, so surprise me, anything. Creased and beaten I don't care.

Reese3333

Is anyone looking for Johnny "Blood" McNally? Condition wise its not great, but he is pretty tough. This is first one I've seen where he signed on the front.



1974 Fleer McNally Auto

Reese3333

I just got my order back from PSA and added scans of Herber (signature looks much better than the scan) , Lombardi, Nagurski,...

I am not really sure what to do with this one. This card was signed by George Allen. I tried to add it to the registry, and was told that since Allen's name was not listed on the flip, I could not add it. I was told to send it back as a "Mech Error." I sent it at the end of November, and included a note of what needed to be done and also the email from the customer service rep explaining the problem. I was very unhappy yesterday when I opened the package and the problem had NOT been fixed. Does anyone know what I should do now? Has anyone had to send a mech error back more than once to be fixed? Anyone know who I can contact to assure it will be fixed?

jradke4

any see the thorpe auto thats up on ebay. seller wont take paypal though!!! yet at the bottom it says seller perferred as a paypal option.

thorpe

Reese3333

Last one sold for $13,500. I wonder how high this one will go?

jradke4

i would bet that it wont get that high if he isnt taking paypal. why would you send an bank MO for that amount.

Reese3333

You're right! I didn't even notice that. His feedback is pretty good though. I tried to read the description, but it started making me sick...

jradke4

nothing wrong with his feedback at all. but who would send out a MO for that price. with things the way they are right now with problems with high interest loans you never know what someone might do. not that i think he is trying anything, just to make that clear. but i would never send anyone that type of cash as a MO.

Reese3333

The Thorpe ended for $5700. It looks like some others were concerned as well with the listing.

Reese3333

The National Treasure's checklist finally came out. I think the only one on the list that was previously impossible is George Trafton.

All Decade Cuts:
1 Red Grange - Chicago Bears 40
2 Jim Thorpe - Canton Bulldogs 1
3 Ernie Nevers - Chicago Cardinals 21
4 Ed Healy - Chicago Bears 22
5 George Trafton - Chicago Bears 67
6 Dan Fortmann - Chicago Bears 21
7 Mel Hein - New York Giants 61
8 Earl "Dutch" Clark - Detroit Lions 30
9 Arnie Herber - Green Bay Packers 6
10 Cliff Battles - Washington Redskins 41
11 Ken Strong - New York Giants 40
12 Dante Lavelli - Cleveland Browns 25
13 George Connor - Chicago Bears 70
14 Sammy Baugh - Washington Redskins 50
15 Sid Luckman - Chicago Bears 42
16 Bob Waterfield - Los Angeles Rams 39
17 Byron "Whizzer" White - Pittsburgh Steelers 16
18 Alex Wojciechowicz - Detroit Lions 36
19 Tony Canadeo - Green Bay Packers 100
20 Charley Trippi - Chicago Cardinals 50
21 Clyde "Bulldog" Turner - Chicago Bears 100
23 Marion Motley - Cleveland Browns 14
24 Pete Pihos - Philadelphia Eagles 32
25 George McAfee - Chicago Bears 56
26 Raymond Berry - Baltimore Colts 50
27 Tom Fears - Los Angeles Rams 6
28 Elroy “Crazylegs” Hirsch - Los Angeles Rams 15
29 Rosey Brown - New York Giants 50
31 Chuck Bednarik - Philadelphia Eagles 25
32 Ernie Stautner - Pittsburgh Steelers 100
33 Otto Graham - Cleveland Browns 100
35 Norm Van Brocklin - Los Angeles Rams 6
36 Ollie Matson - Los Angeles Rams 21
37 Hugh McElhenny - San Francisco 49ers 50
38 Lenny Moore - Baltimore Colts 59
39 Lou Groza - Cleveland Browns 10
40 Leo Nomellini - San Francisco 49ers 4
41 Sam Huff - New York Giants 1
42 Dick "Night Train" Lane - Detroit Lions 32
46 John Mackey - Baltimore Colts 8
48 Sonny Jurgensen - Washington Redskins 25
49 Bart Starr - Green Bay Packers 29
50 Johnny Unitas - Baltimore Colts 19
51 Paul Hornung - Green Bay Packers 50
52 Leroy Kelly - Cleveland Browns 9
53 Gale Sayers - Chicago Bears 59
54 Jim Brown - Cleveland Browns 25
55 Deacon Jones - Los Angeles Rams 50
57 Dick Butkus - Chicago Bears 10
58 Ray Nitschke - Green Bay Packers 19
59 Lem Barney - Detroit Lions 10
60 Paul Warfield - Cleveland Browns 10
62 Larry Little - Miami Dolphins 1
64 Ken Stabler - Oakland Raiders 10
65 Roger Staubach - Dallas Cowboys 15
66 Earl Campbell - Houston Oilers 50
67 Franco Harris - Pittsburgh Steelers 50
68 Walter Payton - Chicago Bears 34
69 Jack Youngblood - Los Angeles Rams 5
70 Joe Greene - Pittsburgh Steelers 15
72 Alan Page - Minnesota Vikings 25
73 Mike Webster - Pittsburgh Steelers 11
74 Ted Hendricks - Oakland Raiders 10
75 Jack Lambert - Pittsburgh Steelers 25
79 Steve Largent - Seattle Seahawks 50
80 James Lofton - Green Bay Packers 30
81 Kellen Winslow - San Diego Chargers 15
82 Ozzie Newsome - Cleveland Browns 50
83 Joe Montana - San Francisco 49ers 25
84 Dan Fouts - San Diego Chargers 25
85 Eric Dickerson - Los Angeles Rams 60
87 John Riggins - Washington Redskins 25
90 Mike Singletary - Chicago Bears 50
94 Michael Irvin - Dallas Cowboys 10
95 John Elway - Denver Broncos 25
96 Brett Favre - Green Bay Packers 21
97 Barry Sanders - Detroit Lions 25
100 Thurman Thomas - Buffalo Bills 15

Historical Cuts
1 Benjamin Harrison - No Team 5
2 A.C. Goodyear - No Team 1
3 Adolph Coors Jr. - No Team 1
4 Alexander Cartwright - No Team 1
5 August Busch Jr. - No Team 1
6 Catherine Nimitz Lay - No Team 1
7 David Brinkley - No Team 1
8 Dick Moores - No Team 1
9 Hank Ketcham - No Team 1
10 Howard K. Smith - No Team 1
11 Ira Gershwin - No Team 1
12 J.H. Doolittle - No Team 1
13 Jack Dempsey - No Team 3
14 Jamie Wyeth - No Team 1
15 Jimmy Hoffa - No Team 2
16 John D. Ehrlichman - No Team 1
17 John Glenn - No Team 1
18 Kermit Roosevelt - No Team 3
19 Richard Nixon - No Team 2
20 Rocky Marciano - No Team 2
21 Rose F. Kennedy - No Team 1
22 Virgil "Gus" Grissom - No Team 2
23 Walter Cronkite - No Team 1
24 William Overgard - No Team 1
25 William Randolph Hearst Jr. - No Team 1
26 Gerald Ford - Michigan 1
27 Walter Payton - Chicago Bears 10
28 Tom Landry - Dallas Cowboys 1
29 Rosa Parks - TBD 1
30 Ronald Reagan - TBD 1
31 Jesse Owens - TBD 1
32 Joe Louis - TBD 1
33 Max Baer - TBD 1
34 Jack Sharkey - TBD 1
35 George Burns - TBD 1
36 Gracie Allen - TBD 1
37 Redd Foxx - TBD 1
38 Red Skelton - TBD 1
39 Bob Waterfield - Los Angeles Rams 5
40 Ernie Stautner - Pittsburgh Steelers 5
41 Hank Stram - Kansas City Chiefs 5
42 Johnny Unitas - Baltimore Colts 5
43 Paul Brown - Cleveland Browns 5
44 Doak Walker - Detroit Lions 5

Super Bowl Cuts
1 Bart Starr - Green Bay Packers 5
3 Joe Namath - New York Jets 25
4 Len Dawson - Kansas City Chiefs 50
6 Roger Staubach - Dallas Cowboys 29
10 Fran Tarkenton - Minnesota Vikings 25
11 Franco Harris - Pittsburgh Steelers 1
13 Tony Dorsett - Dallas Cowboys 50
14 Jack Lambert - Pittsburgh Steelers25
15 Franco Harris - Pittsburgh Steelers 1
17 Joe Montana - San Francisco 49ers10
18 John Riggins - Washington Redskins 25
19 Marcus Allen - Los Angeles Raiders 25
20 Joe Montana - San Francisco 49ers 10
21 Dan Marino - Miami Dolphins 25
23 Walter Payton - Chicago Bears 34
27 Joe Montana - San Francisco 49ers 5
29 Thurman Thomas - Buffalo Bills 15
30 Jim Kelly - Buffalo Bills 25
32 Michael Irvin - Dallas Cowboys 34
34 Steve Young - San Francisco 49ers 50
36 Brett Favre - Green Bay Packers 4
37 John Elway - Denver Broncos15
38 John Elway - Denver Broncos 15

Timeline Cuts
1 Jim Thorpe - Canton Bulldogs 1
2 Sid Luckman - Chicago Bears 35
6 Chuck Bednarik - Philadelphia Eagles 25
8 Dan Fouts - San Diego Chargers 25
10 Elroy “Crazylegs” Hirsch - Los Angeles Rams 10
11 Jack Youngblood - Los Angeles Rams 5
12 James Lofton - Green Bay Packers 30
15 Joe Greene - Pittsburgh Steelers 10
16 Joe Namath - New York Jets 25
18 Kellen Winslow - San Diego Chargers 10
20 Ken Strong - New York Giants 5
21 Larry Csonka - Miami Dolphins 1
24 Lou Groza - Cleveland Browns 14
26 Merlin Olsen - Los Angeles Rams 1
27 Ollie Matson - Los Angeles Rams 20
28 Jim Otto - Oakland Raiders 50
33 Sammy Baugh - Washington Redskins 50
35 Sonny Jurgensen - Washington Redskins 25
37 Thurman Thomas - Buffalo Bills 20
40 Tommy McDonald - Philadelphia Eagles 10
43 Bob Waterfield - Los Angeles Rams 100
44 Tom Fears - Los Angeles Rams 8
45 Dick "Night Train" Lane - Detroit Lions 40
47 Tom Landry - New York Giants 5
48 Norm Van Brocklin - Los Angeles Rams 1
49 Lance Alworth - San Diego Chargers 25
52 Alan Page - Minnesota Vikings 25
53 Bill Dudley - Pittsburgh Steelers 10
54 Billy Howton - Green Bay Packers 50
56 Michael Irvin - Dallas Cowboys 5
57 Jim Brown - Cleveland Browns 25
58 Barry Sanders - Detroit Lions 34
61 Brett Favre - Green Bay Packers 25
65 Reggie Bush - New Orleans Saints 50
71 Don Maynard - New York Jets 50
72 Jim Kelly - Buffalo Bills 25
74 Roger Staubach - Dallas Cowboys 15
75 Walter Payton - Chicago Bears 34