Options
NT or AT?
ElmerFusterpuck
Posts: 4,919 ✭✭✭✭✭
ElmerFusterpuck
Posts: 4,919 ✭✭✭✭✭
Comments
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>That is At all day and night long! >>
Too bad, results like that could make this AT thang catch on.
More surprising to me, a TT image that shows color.
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
<< <i>That is At all day and night long! >>
I'm not so sure on this one. Not an AT slam dunk and I'm on the fence. Would need to see in hand to get off on the AT or NT side.
looks as real as dlimb2 and pharmers avatars
would be surprised if it sells
Doug
Would like to see this one in hand first, but lean towards NT with very little premium for the color. JMHO.
<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
I mean you no offense, but anybody who can say anything "inarguably and absolutely" with respect to AT/NT and Teletrade photographs has lost quite a bit of credibility with me...Mike
<< <i>
<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
Nice counter argument and good points all...fool.
Doug
<< <i>
<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
I mean you no offense, but anybody who can say anything "inarguably and absolutely" with respect to AT/NT and Teletrade photographs has lost quite a bit of credibility with me...Mike >>
Mike,
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Doug
<< <i>I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT >>
Doug, what exactly are your qualifications. I have always wondered what it takes to call oneself an expert on the topic. Just curious.
As for no brainer, I disagree. The image is not conclusive IMO.
<< <i>I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT >>
Such a statement should never be said unless you've accompanied the coin at all times.
-Daniel
-Aristotle
Dum loquimur fugerit invida aetas. Carpe diem quam minimum credula postero.
-Horace
They call me "Pack the Ripper"
<< <i>
<< <i>I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT >>
Doug, what exactly are your qualifications. I have always wondered what it takes to call oneself an expert on the topic. Just curious.
As for no brainer, I disagree. The image is not conclusive IMO. >>
Years of experience, wide recognition of competancy by my collegues and fellow toning enthusiasts, high percentage of submission success to PCGS and NGC with regard to NT - basically the same qualifications as other professional numismatists in the hobby as a whole - I just happen to know this niche' as an expert.
Thanks for asking,
Doug
<< <i>
<< <i>I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT >>
Such a statement should never be said unless you've accompanied the coin at all times.
-Daniel >>
Your statement shows your inexperience in the toning field...but that's okay, we all have to learn somehow.
Doug
<< <i>Years of experience, wide recognition of competancy by my collegues and fellow toning enthusiasts, high percentage of submission success to PCGS and NGC with regard to NT - basically the same qualifications as other professional numismatists in the hobby as a whole - I just happen to know this niche' as an expert. >>
OK, now that we have established your basis for calling yourself an expert will you please educate us on what exactly you see and don't see in the image that makes this " Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT"?
<< <i>will you please educate us on what exactly you see and don't see in the image that makes this " Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT"? >>
Knowing the reasoning behind an opinion helps us all learn.
-Amanda
I'm a YN working on a type set!
My Buffalo Nickel Website Home of the Quirky Buffaloes Collection!
Proud member of the CUFYNA
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
I mean you no offense, but anybody who can say anything "inarguably and absolutely" with respect to AT/NT and Teletrade photographs has lost quite a bit of credibility with me...Mike >>
Mike,
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Doug >>
Doug,
I don't see anybody agreeing with you, but I'll sit patiently by and wait for them....
That being said, I just have a tough time when anybody, expert or not, speaks with such certainty. The way I read your posts, you are portraying your subjective opinion as fact and dismissing all alternative opinons as ingorant -- a big mistake in my book, even if you are right.
Take care...Mike
<< <i>
<< <i>Years of experience, wide recognition of competancy by my collegues and fellow toning enthusiasts, high percentage of submission success to PCGS and NGC with regard to NT - basically the same qualifications as other professional numismatists in the hobby as a whole - I just happen to know this niche' as an expert. >>
OK, now that we have established your basis for calling yourself an expert will you please educate us on what exactly you see and don't see in the image that makes this " Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT"? >>
I'll second this question.
Hard to determine much from an online auction pic also one way or the other.
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT >>
Such a statement should never be said unless you've accompanied the coin at all times.
-Daniel >>
Your statement shows your inexperience in the toning field...but that's okay, we all have to learn somehow.
Doug >>
Doug, I should be included in your "inexperience in the toning field" too, then, as I wouldn't say "this one is a no brainer NT" based upon the image. Nor would I say that about most any other coin, based upon images, alone.
I don't think you make your case any stronger/more convincing by speaking down to those who disagree with you, either. I had thought you were more polite than that.
<< <i>
<< <i>Years of experience, wide recognition of competancy by my collegues and fellow toning enthusiasts, high percentage of submission success to PCGS and NGC with regard to NT - basically the same qualifications as other professional numismatists in the hobby as a whole - I just happen to know this niche' as an expert. >>
OK, now that we have established your basis for calling yourself an expert will you please educate us on what exactly you see and don't see in the image that makes this " Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT"? >>
There are numerous threads in the CU archieves that detail out the NT progression of colors, the proper colors and the looks of what I see to be album/envelope toning. Please look those up and then we can talk semantics if you like.
Doug
<< <i>Years of experience, wide recognition of competancy by my collegues and fellow toning enthusiasts, high percentage of submission success to PCGS and NGC with regard to NT - basically the same qualifications as other professional numismatists in the hobby as a whole - I just happen to know this niche' as an expert. >>
I believe you forgot to add all the "worlds finest" you have owned. Just trying to help.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
I mean you no offense, but anybody who can say anything "inarguably and absolutely" with respect to AT/NT and Teletrade photographs has lost quite a bit of credibility with me...Mike >>
Mike,
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Doug >>
Doug,
I don't see anybody agreeing with you, but I'll sit patiently by and wait for them....
That being said, I just have a tough time when anybody, expert or not, speaks with such certainty. The way I read your posts, you are portraying your subjective opinion as fact and dismissing all alternative opinons as ingorant -- a big mistake in my book, even if you are right.
Take care...Mike >>
Mike,
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Thanks,
Doug
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Years of experience, wide recognition of competancy by my collegues and fellow toning enthusiasts, high percentage of submission success to PCGS and NGC with regard to NT - basically the same qualifications as other professional numismatists in the hobby as a whole - I just happen to know this niche' as an expert. >>
OK, now that we have established your basis for calling yourself an expert will you please educate us on what exactly you see and don't see in the image that makes this " Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT"? >>
I'll second this question.
Hard to determine much from an online auction pic also one way or the other. >>
The pictures are more than sufficient to determine NT without a doubt. This is almost as silly as arguing the BC toning. W.r.,
Doug
<< <i>
<< <i>Years of experience, wide recognition of competancy by my collegues and fellow toning enthusiasts, high percentage of submission success to PCGS and NGC with regard to NT - basically the same qualifications as other professional numismatists in the hobby as a whole - I just happen to know this niche' as an expert. >>
I believe you forgot to add all the "worlds finest" you have owned. Just trying to help.
EXCELLENT point Stman...I have owned many of the World's Finest toned coins - just ask me!
Doug
Doug >>>
LOLOLOLOLOL, damn, this thread gets more entertaining with every post.
Here on planet earth uofa, and based on some of the toned coins you've offered for sale as well as many of your amateurish & clueless statements here at CU, your comments are 100% laughable. But you just keep clicking your ruby slippers together and repeating to yourself ----- I am an expert, I am an expert, I am an expert, and I've traded AT'd coins on Ebay for 3 whole years now-------
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT >>
Such a statement should never be said unless you've accompanied the coin at all times.
-Daniel >>
Your statement shows your inexperience in the toning field...but that's okay, we all have to learn somehow.
Doug >>
Doug, I should be included in your "inexperience in the toning field" too, then, as I wouldn't say "this one is a no brainer NT" based upon the image. Nor would I say that about most any other coin, based upon images, alone.
I don't think you make your case any stronger/more convincing by speaking down to those who disagree with you, either. I had thought you were more polite than that. >>
Mark,
There are coins an expert can absolutely tell are AT from an image. There are coins an expert can not make a call, based on an image. And then, there are coins like this one, where an expert can tell beyond a shadow of a doubt they are NT from an image...this is one of them.
I was only rude to one person - that was only after he basically compared me to Sadam's Iraq and I thought that was a low blow that deserved a personal rebuke.
Doug
<< <i><<< am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Doug >>>
LOLOLOLOLOL, damn, this thread gets more entertaining with every post.
Here on planet earth uofa, and based on some of the toned coins you've offered for sale as well as many of your amateurish & clueless statements here at CU, your comments are 100% laughable. But you just keep clicking your ruby slippers together and repeating to yourself ----- I am an expert, I am an expert, I am an expert, and I've traded AT'd coins on Ebay for 3 whole years now-------
Okay Dragon, show me some of the toned coins I have offered for sale that I labeled as NT that were not so. Show me my amateurish and clueless statements on CU and other comments that are 100% laughable.
A fool's recourse to a losing argument is to stoop to personal attacks - that qualifies you as a Fool, Dragon. Not a personal attack, just a well known label for those who lack the debate skills using fact.
Doug
<< <i>I can tell that coin is NT even with my eyes closed.
Ummm, thanks for the endorsement...I think?
Doug
<< <i>
<< <i>I can tell that coin is NT even with my eyes closed.
Ummm, thanks for the endorsement...I think?
Doug >>
Doug, if you can tell that coin is "beyond a shadow of a doubt" NT from the images, then you are apparently 1) far more expert than just about all of the rest of us here, and 2) unlike just about everyone else, capable of knowing from images, with certainty, what a coin looks like in person, even though you haven't seen it in hand.
Sorry, but the chances of any one person being that much superior to everyone else in those respects are extremely remote.
<< <i>There are numerous threads in the CU archieves(sic) that detail out the NT progression of colors, the proper colors and the looks of what I see to be album/envelope toning. Please look those up and then we can talk semantics if you like. >>
Doug, pardon me for saying, your reply is BS. I'm well aware of the threads on the topic. I know quite a bit on the topic as well. I'm not interested in semantics, I'm interested in the coin image and exactly what specifics make this a no brainer in your opinion. Your evasive tactics are all too familiar and similar with so many of the other so-called experts who have a vested interest in this toning game. Just once I would like to see one of you experts step up to the plate and analyze the toning of an actual coin image and not talk in generalities. I happen to think this coin could very likely be NT. See my original post in the thread. But I would have to see the coin in hand as there is no way I could make such an absolute assertion from that image. So please take a couple of minutes to be specific. It could save you hours of replying to all the other bombs being tossed your way because of your failure to do so.
<< <i>
<< <i>will you please educate us on what exactly you see and don't see in the image that makes this " Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT"? >>
Knowing the reasoning behind an opinion helps us all learn.
-Amanda >>
Well, I like to learn on a coin-by-coin basis. Generalizing can confuse me sometimes. When I have a particular coin and someone tell me why something is so on that coin, I can understand that. I, and many others here want to learn to distinguish AT from NT. Explaining the reasoning behind a position helps everyone.
-Amanda
I'm a YN working on a type set!
My Buffalo Nickel Website Home of the Quirky Buffaloes Collection!
Proud member of the CUFYNA
Well, aside from the fact you're a legend in your own mind, you had at least 2-3 coins on Ebay that were not even close, but I'm sure you knew that already, right?
BTW uofa....... what in your mind qualifies someone as an "expert" as you claim yourself to be......buying and selling B toned dollars on Ebay for a couple years, is that it? How many hundreds of major shows and auctions have you attended, how many decades have you been intensely collecting or dealing in toned coins, have you ever even seen or opened an original bag of Morgan or Peace dollars, or firsthand witnessed a major hoard? And also please name here a few other industry "experts" (either dealers or collectors) who would also classify you as an expert in toned dollars.
Just for future reference, buying and selling so-so toned coins on Ebay and the BST board for a couple years doesn't make people an expert, or anything even close.
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
<< <i>
<< <i>I can tell that coin is NT even with my eyes closed.
Ummm, thanks for the endorsement...I think?
Doug >>
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
<< <i><<< Okay Dragon, show me some of the toned coins I have offered for sale that I labeled as NT that were not so. Show me my amateurish and clueless statements on CU and other comments that are 100% laughable. >>>
Well, aside from the fact you're a legend in your own mind, you had at least 2-3 coins on Ebay that were not even close, but I'm sure you knew that already, right?
BTW uofa....... what in your mind qualifies someone as an "expert" as you claim yourself to be......buying and selling B toned dollars on Ebay for a couple years, is that it? How many hundreds of major shows and auctions have you attended, how many decades have you been intensely collecting or dealing in toned coins, have you ever even seen or opened an original bag of Morgan or Peace dollars, or firsthand witnessed a major hoard? And also please name here a few other industry "experts" (either dealers or collectors) who would also classify you as an expert in toned dollars.
Just for future reference, buying and selling so-so toned coins on Ebay and the BST board for a couple years doesn't make people an expert, or anything even close. >>
Yawn...the lack of substance in your argument bores me...please refrain from speaking.
Doug
<< <i>
<< <i>There are numerous threads in the CU archieves(sic) that detail out the NT progression of colors, the proper colors and the looks of what I see to be album/envelope toning. Please look those up and then we can talk semantics if you like. >>
Doug, pardon me for saying, your reply is BS. I'm well aware of the threads on the topic. I know quite a bit on the topic as well. I'm not interested in semantics, I'm interested in the coin image and exactly what specifics make this a no brainer in your opinion. Your evasive tactics are all too familiar and similar with so many of the other so-called experts who have a vested interest in this toning game. Just once I would like to see one of you experts step up to the plate and analyze the toning of an actual coin image and not talk in generalities. I happen to think this coin could very likely be NT. See my original post in the thread. But I would have to see the coin in hand as there is no way I could make such an absolute assertion from that image. So please take a couple of minutes to be specific. It could save you hours of replying to all the other bombs being tossed your way because of your failure to do so. >>
If you are well aware of the threads and know quite a bit about the topic, then you would have no choice but to agree with me. I am not being evasive. I just don't want to rehash what has more than adequetly been explained and proven in numbeous postings before. You don't need to see the coin in hand...the pics are enough, coupled with the NGC certification. They are the experts folks - get it? Sure, they miss 1/10,000 of one percent but every industry errors from time to time. No bombs are being tossed my way because there is no substance! They are like fire-cracker duds...just empty and disappointing.
Tell you what - I will buy the coin and make any one an open wager...We crack it out and submit it to NGC and PCGS one time each. If it grades both times, the loser pays for the coin and I keep it. If it body bags even once for AT, I will give the money it costs to buy the coin (and the coin) to the winner...any takers?
Doug
Edited to add the word "miss"
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
I mean you no offense, but anybody who can say anything "inarguably and absolutely" with respect to AT/NT and Teletrade photographs has lost quite a bit of credibility with me...Mike >>
Mike,
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Doug >>
Doug,
I don't see anybody agreeing with you, but I'll sit patiently by and wait for them....
That being said, I just have a tough time when anybody, expert or not, speaks with such certainty. The way I read your posts, you are portraying your subjective opinion as fact and dismissing all alternative opinons as ingorant -- a big mistake in my book, even if you are right.
Take care...Mike >>
Mike,
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Thanks,
Doug >>
Doug,
How well did that $1M payroll work in this case?
Or these cases?
The only assessment your $1M payroll gave was in market acceptability -- TPGs make no factual representation of NT or AT.
They are providing a subjective opinion -- just like you. It says nothing as to the TRUE nature of this coin, despite your convincing yourself otherwise....Mike
<< <i><<There are coins an expert can absolutely tell are AT from an image. There are coins an expert can not make a call, based on an image. And then, there are coins like this one, where an expert can tell beyond a shadow of a doubt they are NT from an image...this is one of them>>
Doug, if you can tell that coin is "beyond a shadow of a doubt" NT from the images, then you are apparently 1) far more expert than just about all of the rest of us here, and 2) unlike just about everyone else, capable of knowing from images, with certainty, what a coin looks like in person, even though you haven't seen it in hand.
Sorry, but the chances of any one person being that much superior to everyone else in those respects are extremely remote. >>
Mark,
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
Doug
<< <i>Ummm, thanks for the endorsement...I think?
Doug