<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
I mean you no offense, but anybody who can say anything "inarguably and absolutely" with respect to AT/NT and Teletrade photographs has lost quite a bit of credibility with me...Mike >>
Mike,
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Doug >>
Doug,
I don't see anybody agreeing with you, but I'll sit patiently by and wait for them....
That being said, I just have a tough time when anybody, expert or not, speaks with such certainty. The way I read your posts, you are portraying your subjective opinion as fact and dismissing all alternative opinons as ingorant -- a big mistake in my book, even if you are right.
Take care...Mike >>
Mike,
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Thanks,
Doug >>
Doug,
How well did that $1M payroll work in this case?
The only assessment your $1M payroll gave was in market acceptability -- TPGs make no factual representation of NT or AT.
They are providing a subjective opinion -- just like you. It says nothing as to the TRUE nature of this coin, despite your convincing yourself otherwise....Mike >>
Mike,
As I stated, every company makes mistakes. By implication, TPGs are giving factual representation of NT. Otherwise, they would not bodybag coins with the label of "QT or AT". Their subjective opionion is a group opinion of experts with hundreds of years of combined experience. Let's be practical Mike. I'm afraid you are a bit cynical in your judgements here.
The coin is undeniably and incontrovertibly NT. Period. End of Story.
<<< Yawn...the lack of substance in your argument bores me...please refrain from speaking.
Doug >>>
LOLOL, just as I would have thought your answer to my inquiries would be uofa.......no experience, no one to back you up, no nothing except a delusional inflated ego. In reality, you wouldn't know an AT from NT Peace dollar if it hit you upside the head uofa, but your posts do have that certain entertainment value
<< <i><<< Yawn...the lack of substance in your argument bores me...please refrain from speaking.
Doug >>>
LOLOL, just as I would have thought your answer to my inquiries would be uofa.......no experience, no one to back you up, no nothing except a delusional inflated ego. In reality, you wouldn't know an AT from NT Peace dollar if it hit you upside the head uofa, but your posts do have that certain entertainment value >>
<sigh> Please, again, try not to speak - you add nothing of value to this discussion. I have challenged you to prove your previous allegations, and all you have are personal barbs...hey, here's an idea - try stamps!
As I stated, every company makes mistakes. By implication, TPGs are giving factual representation of NT. Otherwise, they would not bodybag coins with the label of "QT or AT". Their subjective opionion is a group opinion of experts with hundreds of years of combined experience. Let's be practical Mike. I'm afraid you are a bit cynical in your judgements here.
The coin is undeniably and incontrovertibly NT. Period. End of Story.
Doug >>
But that's just it, Doug -- you've bought into it. The IMPLICATION is that they are representing their coins as NT, when the FACTS are quite different. Would it change your mind if NGC were made aware of the ATed coins going into their holders -- the who and how -- and yet the known-AT coins continue to holder? Would you like to see more examples of recolored coins in NGC plastic to be convinced?
I'm sorry if my disdain for implied half-truths and the misrepresentation of opinion as fact gets the best of me -- I'm working on that.
Take care...Mike
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
I have an idea for you uofa, why don't you start a thread and poll here claiming yourself to be an expert on toned coins and see how many of the people here who actually know a thing or two about toned coins agrees with you.
I'd really like to see what some people here think about your self proclaimed "expert" qualifications like TDN, Hadleydog, Coingame2000, ArtR, Legend, Coinguy1, Gemtone65, Bestclsr1, Sunnywood, Bajjerfan, TomB, etc.
<< <i><<<I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter>>>
Please do not bunch me in with your expert advice on a instant recognition of an image.
To be even 90% sure on this issue, the coin must be seen in person in order to establish if it meets certain criteria.
i.e.;
According to PCGS's book Coin Grading and Counterfeit Detection, the following are other indications of artificial toning:
1)The toning floats on the surface of the coin rather than having depth and being bonded to the metal.
2)The toning occurs over hairlines or other marks.
3)The toning exhibits bright "crayon" colors.
4)The toning has a yellow-brown, smoky appearance, indicating it was caused by cigarette or cigar smoke.
How can you possibly even pick out 2 out of 3 by looking at a internet picture. ludicrist >>
Hey Wooden Nickel,
How did I bunch you into my expert advice...please explain exactly where I mentioned you as agreeing with me.
You are correct, I see no appearance of the PCGS Counterfeit signs in the pictures - thank you for your supporting statement. But if you still disagree with the toning, take me up on my open wager and let's see who is right? <again, more silence>...Doug
<< <i>I have an idea for you uofa, why don't you start a thread and poll here claiming yourself to be an expert on toned coins and see how many of the people here who actually know a thing or two about toned coins agrees with you.
I'd really like to see what some people here think about your self proclaimed "expert" qualifications like TDN, Hadleydog, Coingame2000, ArtR, Legend, Coinguy1, Gemtone65, Bestclsr1, Sunnywood, Bajjerfan, TomB, etc. >>
Why don't you just PM them yourself and see what they say. I do not deal in the stratosphere that TDN and Legend deal in regarding toners and they don't concentrate on them. Neither does Coinguy1, but the rest are toning experts from what I can see. So ask those remaining folks and report your results here - and then make a public apology to me when the vast majority of those folks agree with my assessment of the coin and my assessment of my abilities as an expert...but somehow, I don't think I will hear again from you on that subject, as it would take you to swallow a huge portion of ego to admit when you're wrong.
<< <i>But if you still disagree with the toning, take me up on my open wager and let's see who is right? <again, more silence>...Doug >>
I don't necessarily agree or disagree, but I will put up $250 towards purchase and grading of this coin as per the terms you defined earlier. Any other takers?...Mike
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
Uofa, actually, I have already spoken with a few people here who know a thing or two about you and your coins in the past, and I don't really think you'd like know what actual knowledgeable people think.....trust me, LOLOL.
The FACT is you're just a weekend Ebay hacker with maybe a couple years experience in dealing in B coins, and a self inflated ego that is laughable, case closed. Bye.
Dragon, I challenge you to list who you talked to and what their comments were! Arbitrary statements without support are meaningless, just like the rest of your thread contributions to date.
<< <i>I have learned in my experiences and travels that you in fact cannot beat a broken drum. >>
Huh? I think you've bitten down on one too many wooden nickels, my friend.
Doug >>
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~`` No, I was just kinda wondering just how you tip an image on a monitor in order to reveal these characteristics:
1)The toning floats on the surface of the coin rather than having depth and being bonded to the metal.
2)The toning occurs over hairlines or other marks.
<< <i>But if you still disagree with the toning, take me up on my open wager and let's see who is right? <again, more silence>...Doug >>
I don't necessarily agree or disagree, but I will put up $250 towards purchase and grading of this coin as per the terms you defined earlier. Any other takers?...Mike >>
Mike, don't throw your money away - trust me (and NGC) on this one! But, if you gather enough, I guess I will take the dough!
<< <i>I have learned in my experiences and travels that you in fact cannot beat a broken drum. >>
Huh? I think you've bitten down on one too many wooden nickels, my friend.
Doug >>
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~`` No, I was just kinda wondering just how you tip an image on a monitor in order to reveal these characteristics:
1)The toning floats on the surface of the coin rather than having depth and being bonded to the metal.
2)The toning occurs over hairlines or other marks. >>
The list you are referring to detects AT coins...it does not determine NT coins...there is a difference.
You people here are so negative about these beautiful and highly valuable works of art. It took great talent to make these trashures and offer them up for your shillings and dollars on eBay / teletrade. Can't you just accept the expert opinions of those who are kind enough to offer them? If it's on sale on the net, certified in an NGC slab, and endorsed by the PhD's of toning, isn't that good enough?
Just bid these Coins up to the sky. That way, the kind sellers can make even more available for one and all.
What would you do with your money anyhow? Buy a car or something?
Interesting thread -I like it but think 80% chance NT
my concerns are if the red is purple then probably bad a couple locations that go straight to red the light area if green than probably bad
this thread helps explain why coin colorists will be around for a long time
if someone can take a $30 coin and add color so that Doug is willing to pay $500 for it because he is sure it is NT, they do not need to make many a month to make a good living
I am not a lawyer but if someone sells a coin that has been played with ( colored, whizzed, plated, lasered, puttied, smoked, dipped, MS70'd, etc) and sells it as is, is there fraud involved? if so why?
I have nothing to add in terms of toning expertise, but I am notably impressed by Doug's confidence. I hope that he is correct. Alas, like many other such arguments, we on the forum will never have resolution of this one.
<< <i>but I am notably impressed by Doug's confidence. >>
Looks like this one went on well into the night. I too am impressed with his confidence, however, one must understand where my lack of confidence comes from. I own what has been confirmed by many to be an AT half cent. Confirmed by some of the expert dealers mentioned in this thread. And low and behold, the coin can be traced back to another well known so called toning expert. I guess when we say toning expert around here there is a fine line between those who tone coins, and those who are capable of determining whether a coin is AT or NT with certainty.
I just wanted to give Doug an opportunity to step up to the plate and act like an expert should. Like presenting facts as to his determination. I guess the toning expert handbook must list as number 1 with bold type: Be evasive at all times and keep repeating with authority that a coin is NT and people will pay huge sums of money making us all rich.
<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
I mean you no offense, but anybody who can say anything "inarguably and absolutely" with respect to AT/NT and Teletrade photographs has lost quite a bit of credibility with me...Mike >>
Mike,
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Doug >>
Doug,
I don't see anybody agreeing with you, but I'll sit patiently by and wait for them....
That being said, I just have a tough time when anybody, expert or not, speaks with such certainty. The way I read your posts, you are portraying your subjective opinion as fact and dismissing all alternative opinons as ingorant -- a big mistake in my book, even if you are right.
Take care...Mike >>
Mike,
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Thanks,
Doug >>
Doug,
How well did that $1M payroll work in this case?
The only assessment your $1M payroll gave was in market acceptability -- TPGs make no factual representation of NT or AT.
They are providing a subjective opinion -- just like you. It says nothing as to the TRUE nature of this coin, despite your convincing yourself otherwise....Mike >>
Mike,
As I stated, every company makes mistakes. By implication, TPGs are giving factual representation of NT. Otherwise, they would not bodybag coins with the label of "QT or AT". Their subjective opionion is a group opinion of experts with hundreds of years of combined experience. Let's be practical Mike. I'm afraid you are a bit cynical in your judgements here.
The coin is undeniably and incontrovertibly NT. Period. End of Story.
Doug >>
Doug, the grading company's aren't "giving factual representation of NT" - they are providing OPINIONS, a number of which are incorrect. And in most cases, even they wouldn't be so recklessly bold in those OPINIONS, as you have acted in this thread.
On another matter, if/when a team of three graders (or even four graders, for that matter) examines a coin, no grading team that I know of, or would want to deal with, has "hundreds of years of combined experience".
Hopefully, you are just having some fun here and don't need the giant spoonful (or entire medicine bottle) of humility that it appears you do.
<< <i>but I am notably impressed by Doug's confidence. >>
Looks like this one went on well into the night. I too am impressed with his confidence, however, one must understand where my lack of confidence comes from. I own what has been confirmed by many to be an AT half cent. Confirmed by some of the expert dealers mentioned in this thread. And low and behold, the coin can be traced back to another well known so called toning expert. I guess when we say toning expert around here there is a fine line between those who tone coins, and those who are capable of determining whether a coin is AT or NT with certainty.
I just wanted to give Doug an opportunity to step up to the plate and act like an expert should. Like presenting facts as to his determination. I guess the toning expert handbook must list as number 1 with bold type: Be evasive at all times and keep repeating with authority that a coin is NT and people will pay huge sums of money making us all rich. >>
I can only conclude, having been a party to these discussions in the past, that between absolutely AT and absolutely NT there is a large gray area. People will draw their line between the two at various points along the spectrum. For some people, the NT group of coins will be larger and for others, the AT group of coins will be larger.
I have also noticed that some members of the Toned Coin Posse (if you will) will come out of the woodwork and defend some very suspect coins (to my untrained eye) and argue the point to death.
I have come to accept all of the above as part of the landscape of the AT/NT debate.
<< <i>will you please educate us on what exactly you see and don't see in the image that makes this " Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT"? >>
Knowing the reasoning behind an opinion helps us all learn.
-Amanda >>
Well, I like to learn on a coin-by-coin basis. Generalizing can confuse me sometimes. When I have a particular coin and someone tell me why something is so on that coin, I can understand that. I, and many others here want to learn to distinguish AT from NT. Explaining the reasoning behind a position helps everyone.
-Amanda >>
On this thread, Amanda, as always, impresses the heck out of me with her maturity and her succinct, calm and polite statement. That her post has not been answered tells me everything I need to know. Rob
Modern dollars are like children - before you know it they'll be all grown up.....
-- "I can only conclude, having been a party to these discussions in the past, that between absolutely AT and absolutely NT there is a large gray area. People will draw their line between the two at various points along the spectrum. For some people, the NT group of coins will be larger and for others, the AT group of coins will be larger." --
Absolutely true. I'd add only that the gray area exists in large part because we can't even reach a consensus on working definitions of NT and AT.
Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Years of experience, wide recognition of competancy by my collegues and fellow toning enthusiasts, high percentage of submission success to PCGS and NGC with regard to NT - basically the same qualifications as other professional numismatists in the hobby as a whole - I just happen to know this niche' as an expert.
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Damn, even I was fooled. Anaconda's pics make the coins colors appear genuine and gototoninghell's pics are always obviously AT. I am sure Anaconda's pics more properly represent the coin AND it is in an NGC holder.
... if NGC is slabbing $10,000+ coins...could really shake the market values badly.
Doug
------------------------- You're in good company Doug...
"There's an old saying in Tennessee — I know it's in Texas, probably in Tennessee — that says, fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you can't get fooled again." —President George W. Bush, Nashville, Tenn., Sept. 17, 2002
Just in time, too --- things were getting kind of dull around here --- you can get only so much mileage out of the "20th Anniversary / First Strike" game.
This was the 9th response from ElmerFusterpuck's question "1922 Peace Dollar - makes me wonder...NT or AT?"
uofa1285 Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Suddenly we are all idiots, so the question is asked:
will you please educate us on what exactly you see and don't see in the image that makes this " Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT"? ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Every answer to this question was evasive, vague, twisted, turned, and the poster attempted to burry these bold unfounded statements, even coming up with this one:
uofa1285 am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainier NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ uofa stood alone on this one...statements that he needed no more than an internet image to determine 100% how the surface of a coin has reacted in an unknown environment. (artificially or naturally...uofa could do it " inarguably and absolutely" because of the claim to be an expert in the field ) ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I would like to see a coroner who is an expert in the field of medicine and who has performed 100’s of autopsies get on these boards, show him some pictures of slabbed stiffs who have passed away of natural causes and to explain to us how this person passed away. I’m sure they could not even be sure that the representation body in the image is even deceased, much less tell us how they died.
My point being, you cannot be 100% sure just because a toned coin is holdered by Third Party, and it is being offered in a coin auction house and that the image “looks right“...these facts alone do not support 100% conclusions. It doesn't matter if everyone thinks the coins is more or less natural in every aspect...when a gorilla gets up and pounds his chest and says "It is NT and everyone get behind me because I'm a self proclaimed expert" well, your going to have resistance.
It quickly became apparent that once again it was futile to argue with yet another self proclaimed expert in the field of Numismatics...it's really a shame that novice people have to be exposed to such actions as his.
<< <i>but I am notably impressed by Doug's confidence. >>
Looks like this one went on well into the night. I too am impressed with his confidence, however, one must understand where my lack of confidence comes from. I own what has been confirmed by many to be an AT half cent. Confirmed by some of the expert dealers mentioned in this thread. And low and behold, the coin can be traced back to another well known so called toning expert. I guess when we say toning expert around here there is a fine line between those who tone coins, and those who are capable of determining whether a coin is AT or NT with certainty.
I just wanted to give Doug an opportunity to step up to the plate and act like an expert should. Like presenting facts as to his determination. I guess the toning expert handbook must list as number 1 with bold type: Be evasive at all times and keep repeating with authority that a coin is NT and people will pay huge sums of money making us all rich. >>
I can only conclude, having been a party to these discussions in the past, that between absolutely AT and absolutely NT there is a large gray area. People will draw their line between the two at various points along the spectrum. For some people, the NT group of coins will be larger and for others, the AT group of coins will be larger.
I have also noticed that some members of the Toned Coin Posse (if you will) will come out of the woodwork and defend some very suspect coins (to my untrained eye) and argue the point to death.
I have come to accept all of the above as part of the landscape of the AT/NT debate.
(Oh, BTW, 100 ) >>
RYK, the issue at hand in my eyes is the lack of 'grey area'.
To say a coin is definately, inarguably, 100% naturally toned without having the coin in your posession for it's lifetime is a foolish statement. There is no grey area according to a certain board member(as far as this coin goes) and that's what bothers me. As mentioned before by Mark, there are numerous graders who would not be as straightforward/flat-footed/unwavering with their opinions/convictions on such coins. It should always be remembered that TPGs aren't necissarily grading what's naturally toned. They're assessing/grading what's Market Acceptable.
-D
"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it."
-Aristotle
Dum loquimur fugerit invida aetas. Carpe diem quam minimum credula postero.
Most experts in various fields that I have met along the way do not call themselves "experts". It is usually a title bestowed on someone else.
(Actually, in medical circles, an expert can be loosely defined as the guy/gal from out of town wearing a tie and carrying with him/her a Power point presentation. )
<< <i>(Actually, in medical circles, an expert can be loosely defined as the guy/gal from out of town wearing a tie and carrying with him/her a Power point presentation. ) >>
RYK, that person, if from at least 50 miles out of town, can be called "a consultant".
Edited for typo.
An authorized PCGS dealer, and a contributor to the Red Book.
With the idiotic and laughable comments from our self proclaimed "expert" on Peace dollar toning aside, and after viewing many thousands of toned and mostly untoned Peace dollars over the past 25 yrs. or so, the first thing I usually look at is the colors themselves and their intensity with vivid colors as well as various shades of blue generally being the first giveaway.
Many people may not realize that for many of the AT'd Peace dollars out there, the coin doc will start with a coin that is already toned to some degree and enhance the coin which may make the work less noticable. In addition, most professionally done AT'd Peace dollars I've seen were done in darker shades of opaque color to attempt to mask problems on the coin, and not done to make the coin a 'monster toner', with the exception of some of the silly coins seen offered on Ebay.
If you view the thousands of past Peace dollar lots on Heritages auction archives you will notice the majority of natural colored Peace dollars are generally toned in uneven and/or splotchy shades of various golds, browns, and rust type colors from album or roll storage and sometimes seen less then vivid crescents of subdued rainbow color around the rims. Less often seen natural colors can also be various shades of lighter green and deep cherry red but these are few and far between in my experiences. Due to their method of manufacture and planchet preperation Peace dollars do not lend themselves to generally aquiring bright or vivid color or the various shapes and patterns of mint bag toned Morgan dollars, and various shades of either powder or deep cobalt blue are usually a big red flag on Peace dollars.
In addition, NGC in my experiences has a rather poor track record for holdering Peace dollars with artificial color either in whole or part, and it should never be assumed that a Peace dollar is good because it's in an NGC holder IMO.
Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Years of experience, wide recognition of competancy by my collegues and fellow toning enthusiasts, high percentage of submission success to PCGS and NGC with regard to NT - basically the same qualifications as other professional numismatists in the hobby as a whole - I just happen to know this niche' as an expert.
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Damn, even I was fooled. Anaconda's pics make the coins colors appear genuine and gototoninghell's pics are always obviously AT. I am sure Anaconda's pics more properly represent the coin AND it is in an NGC holder.
... if NGC is slabbing $10,000+ coins...could really shake the market values badly.
Doug
------------------------- You're in good company Doug...
"There's an old saying in Tennessee — I know it's in Texas, probably in Tennessee — that says, fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you can't get fooled again." —President George W. Bush, Nashville, Tenn., Sept. 17, 2002 >>
Thanks for digging that up. A few other quotes to be read:
"Because even the experts can never be 100% certain that a product is exactly what they initially believe it to be! "
"This was not at all obvious to most toning experts, based on Anaconda's pictures combined with the NGC holder. "
Doug, I must join in the chorus and express my disappointment in your argument. You've talked down to numerous posters while answering NO question on how you can judge THIS COIN to be naturally toned. Fact is, I've never had a Teletrade coin look like the picture, and color most certainly can't be judged unless it is the most obvious of patterns (such as a simple, bag-toned crescent). Additionally, you hold NGC in such a regard as to be the be-all, end-all decider. I question numerous coins slabbed by NGC, as well as PCGS and ANACS, and even YOU were fooled by the holder just a few months ago. Oh, how soon we forget.
Collectors get stuck with crap because they forget to look at the coin, and buy the plastic instead. It doesn't help when the most persuasive argument an "expert" can make is that other experts, in this case the NGC graders, must be right. There's really no other way to say it than "put up, or shut up."
<< <i>Many people may not realize that for many of the AT'd Peace dollars out there, the coin doc will start with a coin that is already toned to some degree and enhance the coin which may make the work less noticable >>
I felt this is worth quoting from Dragon's post. Also it really doesn't just apply to Peace Dollars. I've seen many times on this board folks take a NT qualifier like let's say pull-away toning at the date and say no question NT. Somewhere else can be enhanced on the coin. Look at the whole coin and determine what makes sense is what I go by.
BTW, notice he mentions the "blue."
Please... Save The Stories, Just Answer My Questions, And Tell Me How Much!!!!!
Peace dollars are not my specialty by any means, but if I look at this coin, and for a moment ignore the fact its in a top tier holder, I don't like it. I'd lean towards NT. The colors just don't look like what I've seen toned peace dollars look like. To bright on teh yellow orange and reds, and the color progression does not look right. I'd expect to see a more natural progression towards the edges of the coin... it does look like the colors on a couple of known AT peace dollars I have... The fact that it is in a holder does not sway me. My gut tells me AT, so I would not buy the coin. If I am wrong, so be it, but I would not take the risk. At the end of the day, we don't always get a real answer on these, but I think it would be dangerous to be 100% sure based on the photo, especially on this coin. Just my 2 cents
<< <i>Many people may not realize that for many of the AT'd Peace dollars out there, the coin doc will start with a coin that is already toned to some degree and enhance the coin which may make the work less noticable >>
I felt this is worth quoting from Dragon's post. Also it really doesn't just apply to Peace Dollars. I've seen many times on this board folks take a NT qualifier like let's say pull-away toning at the date and say no question NT. Somewhere else can be enhanced on the coin. Look at the whole coin and determine what makes sense is what I go by.
BTW, notice he mentions the "blue." >>
Stman, I almost commented on Dragon's post and the good information it provided. But I refrained, as I was under the impression that facts (as opposed to proclamations without foundation) had no place in this thread.
Comments
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
I mean you no offense, but anybody who can say anything "inarguably and absolutely" with respect to AT/NT and Teletrade photographs has lost quite a bit of credibility with me...Mike >>
Mike,
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Doug >>
Doug,
I don't see anybody agreeing with you, but I'll sit patiently by and wait for them....
That being said, I just have a tough time when anybody, expert or not, speaks with such certainty. The way I read your posts, you are portraying your subjective opinion as fact and dismissing all alternative opinons as ingorant -- a big mistake in my book, even if you are right.
Take care...Mike >>
Mike,
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Thanks,
Doug >>
Doug,
How well did that $1M payroll work in this case?
The only assessment your $1M payroll gave was in market acceptability -- TPGs make no factual representation of NT or AT.
They are providing a subjective opinion -- just like you. It says nothing as to the TRUE nature of this coin, despite your convincing yourself otherwise....Mike >>
Mike,
As I stated, every company makes mistakes. By implication, TPGs are giving factual representation of NT. Otherwise, they would not bodybag coins with the label of "QT or AT". Their subjective opionion is a group opinion of experts with hundreds of years of combined experience. Let's be practical Mike. I'm afraid you are a bit cynical in your judgements here.
The coin is undeniably and incontrovertibly NT. Period. End of Story.
Doug
<< <i>I love how ngc is being touted as the final word when it comes to toned coins....
Name one other person or organization (besides PCGS) who one can better rely upon?
<silence>
Doug
Doug >>>
LOLOL, just as I would have thought your answer to my inquiries would be uofa.......no experience, no one to back you up, no nothing except a delusional inflated ego. In reality, you wouldn't know an AT from NT Peace dollar if it hit you upside the head uofa, but your posts do have that certain entertainment value
<< <i><<< Yawn...the lack of substance in your argument bores me...please refrain from speaking.
Doug >>>
LOLOL, just as I would have thought your answer to my inquiries would be uofa.......no experience, no one to back you up, no nothing except a delusional inflated ego. In reality, you wouldn't know an AT from NT Peace dollar if it hit you upside the head uofa, but your posts do have that certain entertainment value
<sigh> Please, again, try not to speak - you add nothing of value to this discussion. I have challenged you to prove your previous allegations, and all you have are personal barbs...hey, here's an idea - try stamps!
Doug
Please do not bunch me in with your expert advice on a instant recognition of an image.
To be even 90% sure on this issue, the coin must be seen in person in order to establish if it meets certain criteria.
i.e.;
According to PCGS's book Coin Grading and Counterfeit Detection, the following are other indications of artificial toning:
1)The toning floats on the surface of the coin rather than having depth and being bonded to the metal.
2)The toning occurs over hairlines or other marks.
3)The toning exhibits bright "crayon" colors.
4)The toning has a yellow-brown, smoky appearance, indicating it was caused by cigarette or cigar smoke.
How can you possibly even pick out 2 out of 3 by looking at a internet picture. ludicrist
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
<< <i>Holy crap- that's a huge asking price on that peace dollar.......
"Not Sold" -- Gee, I am shocked!!
<< <i>Mike,
As I stated, every company makes mistakes. By implication, TPGs are giving factual representation of NT. Otherwise, they would not bodybag coins with the label of "QT or AT". Their subjective opionion is a group opinion of experts with hundreds of years of combined experience. Let's be practical Mike. I'm afraid you are a bit cynical in your judgements here.
The coin is undeniably and incontrovertibly NT. Period. End of Story.
Doug >>
But that's just it, Doug -- you've bought into it. The IMPLICATION is that they are representing their coins as NT, when the FACTS are quite different. Would it change your mind if NGC were made aware of the ATed coins going into their holders -- the who and how -- and yet the known-AT coins continue to holder? Would you like to see more examples of recolored coins in NGC plastic to be convinced?
I'm sorry if my disdain for implied half-truths and the misrepresentation of opinion as fact gets the best of me -- I'm working on that.
Take care...Mike
I'd really like to see what some people here think about your self proclaimed "expert" qualifications like TDN, Hadleydog, Coingame2000, ArtR, Legend, Coinguy1, Gemtone65, Bestclsr1, Sunnywood, Bajjerfan, TomB, etc.
<< <i><<<I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter>>>
Please do not bunch me in with your expert advice on a instant recognition of an image.
To be even 90% sure on this issue, the coin must be seen in person in order to establish if it meets certain criteria.
i.e.;
According to PCGS's book Coin Grading and Counterfeit Detection, the following are other indications of artificial toning:
1)The toning floats on the surface of the coin rather than having depth and being bonded to the metal.
2)The toning occurs over hairlines or other marks.
3)The toning exhibits bright "crayon" colors.
4)The toning has a yellow-brown, smoky appearance, indicating it was caused by cigarette or cigar smoke.
How can you possibly even pick out 2 out of 3 by looking at a internet picture. ludicrist >>
Hey Wooden Nickel,
How did I bunch you into my expert advice...please explain exactly where I mentioned you as agreeing with me.
You are correct, I see no appearance of the PCGS Counterfeit signs in the pictures - thank you for your supporting statement. But if you still disagree with the toning, take me up on my open wager and let's see who is right? <again, more silence>...Doug
<< <i>I have an idea for you uofa, why don't you start a thread and poll here claiming yourself to be an expert on toned coins and see how many of the people here who actually know a thing or two about toned coins agrees with you.
I'd really like to see what some people here think about your self proclaimed "expert" qualifications like TDN, Hadleydog, Coingame2000, ArtR, Legend, Coinguy1, Gemtone65, Bestclsr1, Sunnywood, Bajjerfan, TomB, etc. >>
Why don't you just PM them yourself and see what they say. I do not deal in the stratosphere that TDN and Legend deal in regarding toners and they don't concentrate on them. Neither does Coinguy1, but the rest are toning experts from what I can see. So ask those remaining folks and report your results here - and then make a public apology to me when the vast majority of those folks agree with my assessment of the coin and my assessment of my abilities as an expert...but somehow, I don't think I will hear again from you on that subject, as it would take you to swallow a huge portion of ego to admit when you're wrong.
Doug
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
<< <i>But if you still disagree with the toning, take me up on my open wager and let's see who is right? <again, more silence>...Doug >>
I don't necessarily agree or disagree, but I will put up $250 towards purchase and grading of this coin as per the terms you defined earlier. Any other takers?...Mike
The FACT is you're just a weekend Ebay hacker with maybe a couple years experience in dealing in B coins, and a self inflated ego that is laughable, case closed. Bye.
<< <i>I have learned in my experiences and travels that you in fact cannot beat a broken drum. >>
Huh? I think you've bitten down on one too many wooden nickels, my friend.
Doug
Doug
<< <i>Uofa, is the Teletrade coin yours? >>
No, I like it but only for about $500 to $750, based on the pics.
Doug
<< <i>
<< <i>I have learned in my experiences and travels that you in fact cannot beat a broken drum. >>
Huh? I think you've bitten down on one too many wooden nickels, my friend.
Doug >>
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~``
No, I was just kinda wondering just how you tip an image on a monitor in order to reveal these characteristics:
1)The toning floats on the surface of the coin rather than having depth and being bonded to the metal.
2)The toning occurs over hairlines or other marks.
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
<< <i>
<< <i>But if you still disagree with the toning, take me up on my open wager and let's see who is right? <again, more silence>...Doug >>
I don't necessarily agree or disagree, but I will put up $250 towards purchase and grading of this coin as per the terms you defined earlier. Any other takers?...Mike >>
Mike, don't throw your money away - trust me (and NGC) on this one! But, if you gather enough, I guess I will take the dough!
Doug
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>I have learned in my experiences and travels that you in fact cannot beat a broken drum. >>
Huh? I think you've bitten down on one too many wooden nickels, my friend.
Doug >>
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~``
No, I was just kinda wondering just how you tip an image on a monitor in order to reveal these characteristics:
1)The toning floats on the surface of the coin rather than having depth and being bonded to the metal.
2)The toning occurs over hairlines or other marks. >>
The list you are referring to detects AT coins...it does not determine NT coins...there is a difference.
Doug
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
<< <i>That's exactly why you can't beat a broken drum...your drum is broken. >>
I am still lost on how your metaphor relates to my arguments but I guess that's why I can't sing.
Doug
This thread is almost uncomfortably laughable.
Check out my current listings: https://ebay.com/sch/khunt/m.html?_ipg=200&_sop=12&_rdc=1
Just bid these Coins up to the sky. That way, the kind sellers can make even more available for one and all.
What would you do with your money anyhow? Buy a car or something?
my concerns are if the red is purple then probably bad
a couple locations that go straight to red
the light area if green than probably bad
this thread helps explain why coin colorists will be around for a long time
if someone can take a $30 coin and add color so that Doug is willing to pay $500 for it because he is sure it is NT, they do not need to make many a month to make a good living
I am not a lawyer but if someone sells a coin that has been played with ( colored, whizzed, plated, lasered, puttied, smoked, dipped, MS70'd, etc) and sells it as is, is there fraud involved? if so why?
<< <i>but I am notably impressed by Doug's confidence. >>
Looks like this one went on well into the night. I too am impressed with his confidence, however, one must understand where my lack of confidence comes from. I own what has been confirmed by many to be an AT half cent. Confirmed by some of the expert dealers mentioned in this thread. And low and behold, the coin can be traced back to another well known so called toning expert. I guess when we say toning expert around here there is a fine line between those who tone coins, and those who are capable of determining whether a coin is AT or NT with certainty.
I just wanted to give Doug an opportunity to step up to the plate and act like an expert should. Like presenting facts as to his determination. I guess the toning expert handbook must list as number 1 with bold type: Be evasive at all times and keep repeating with authority that a coin is NT and people will pay huge sums of money making us all rich.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
I mean you no offense, but anybody who can say anything "inarguably and absolutely" with respect to AT/NT and Teletrade photographs has lost quite a bit of credibility with me...Mike >>
Mike,
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Doug >>
Doug,
I don't see anybody agreeing with you, but I'll sit patiently by and wait for them....
That being said, I just have a tough time when anybody, expert or not, speaks with such certainty. The way I read your posts, you are portraying your subjective opinion as fact and dismissing all alternative opinons as ingorant -- a big mistake in my book, even if you are right.
Take care...Mike >>
Mike,
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Thanks,
Doug >>
Doug,
How well did that $1M payroll work in this case?
The only assessment your $1M payroll gave was in market acceptability -- TPGs make no factual representation of NT or AT.
They are providing a subjective opinion -- just like you. It says nothing as to the TRUE nature of this coin, despite your convincing yourself otherwise....Mike >>
Mike,
As I stated, every company makes mistakes. By implication, TPGs are giving factual representation of NT. Otherwise, they would not bodybag coins with the label of "QT or AT". Their subjective opionion is a group opinion of experts with hundreds of years of combined experience. Let's be practical Mike. I'm afraid you are a bit cynical in your judgements here.
The coin is undeniably and incontrovertibly NT. Period. End of Story.
Doug >>
Doug, the grading company's aren't "giving factual representation of NT" - they are providing OPINIONS, a number of which are incorrect. And in most cases, even they wouldn't be so recklessly bold in those OPINIONS, as you have acted in this thread.
On another matter, if/when a team of three graders (or even four graders, for that matter) examines a coin, no grading team that I know of, or would want to deal with, has "hundreds of years of combined experience".
Hopefully, you are just having some fun here and don't need the giant spoonful (or entire medicine bottle) of humility that it appears you do.
<< <i>
<< <i>but I am notably impressed by Doug's confidence. >>
Looks like this one went on well into the night. I too am impressed with his confidence, however, one must understand where my lack of confidence comes from. I own what has been confirmed by many to be an AT half cent. Confirmed by some of the expert dealers mentioned in this thread. And low and behold, the coin can be traced back to another well known so called toning expert. I guess when we say toning expert around here there is a fine line between those who tone coins, and those who are capable of determining whether a coin is AT or NT with certainty.
I just wanted to give Doug an opportunity to step up to the plate and act like an expert should. Like presenting facts as to his determination. I guess the toning expert handbook must list as number 1 with bold type: Be evasive at all times and keep repeating with authority that a coin is NT and people will pay huge sums of money making us all rich. >>
I can only conclude, having been a party to these discussions in the past, that between absolutely AT and absolutely NT there is a large gray area. People will draw their line between the two at various points along the spectrum. For some people, the NT group of coins will be larger and for others, the AT group of coins will be larger.
I have also noticed that some members of the Toned Coin Posse (if you will) will come out of the woodwork and defend some very suspect coins (to my untrained eye) and argue the point to death.
I have come to accept all of the above as part of the landscape of the AT/NT debate.
(Oh, BTW, 100
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>will you please educate us on what exactly you see and don't see in the image that makes this " Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT"? >>
Knowing the reasoning behind an opinion helps us all learn.
-Amanda >>
Well, I like to learn on a coin-by-coin basis. Generalizing can confuse me sometimes. When I have a particular coin and someone tell me why something is so on that coin, I can understand that. I, and many others here want to learn to distinguish AT from NT. Explaining the reasoning behind a position helps everyone.
-Amanda >>
On this thread, Amanda, as always, impresses the heck out of me with her maturity and her succinct, calm and polite statement. That her post has not been answered tells me everything I need to know. Rob
Questions about Ikes? Go to The IKE GROUP WEB SITE
Absolutely true. I'd add only that the gray area exists in large part because we can't even reach a consensus on working definitions of NT and AT.
It is neither Natural or Artificial
It is CT (chemically toned in a natural way or an unnatural way ) or TT (thermally toned) In my opinon, both are a detriment to MINT STATE condition.
I happen to agree with ME, and I am 100% certain.
Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug
______________________________________________________
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Doug
______________________________________________________
Years of experience, wide recognition of competancy by my collegues and fellow toning enthusiasts, high percentage of submission success to PCGS and NGC with regard to NT - basically the same qualifications as other professional numismatists in the hobby as a whole - I just happen to know this niche' as an expert.
Thanks for asking,
Doug
________________________________________________________
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Thanks,
Doug
**********************************************************************************************************
Wednesday February 15, 2006 10:41 PM
Damn, even I was fooled. Anaconda's pics make the coins colors appear genuine and gototoninghell's pics are always obviously AT. I am sure Anaconda's pics more properly represent the coin AND it is in an NGC holder.
... if NGC is slabbing $10,000+ coins...could really shake the market values badly.
Doug
-------------------------
You're in good company Doug...
"There's an old saying in Tennessee — I know it's in Texas, probably in Tennessee — that says, fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you can't get fooled again." —President George W. Bush, Nashville, Tenn., Sept. 17, 2002
PCGS, ANACS, & NGC Certified Coins on My Website.
Random Collector
www.marksmedals.com
Just in time, too --- things were getting kind of dull around here --- you can get only so much mileage out of the "20th Anniversary / First Strike" game.
and they're cold.
I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
Mary
Best Franklin Website
uofa1285
Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Suddenly we are all idiots, so the question is asked:
will you please educate us on what exactly you see and don't see in the image that makes this " Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT"?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Every answer to this question was evasive, vague, twisted, turned, and the poster attempted to burry these bold unfounded statements, even coming up with this one:
uofa1285
am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainier NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely".
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
uofa stood alone on this one...statements that he needed no more than an internet image to determine 100% how the surface of a coin has reacted in an unknown environment. (artificially or naturally...uofa could do it " inarguably and absolutely" because of the claim to be an expert in the field )
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I would like to see a coroner who is an expert in the field of medicine and who has performed 100’s of autopsies get on these boards, show him some pictures of slabbed stiffs who have passed away of natural causes and to explain to us how this person passed away. I’m sure they could not even be sure that the representation body in the image is even deceased, much less tell us how they died.
My point being, you cannot be 100% sure just because a toned coin is holdered by Third Party, and it is being offered in a coin auction house and that the image “looks right“...these facts alone do not support 100% conclusions. It doesn't matter if everyone thinks the coins is more or less natural in every aspect...when a gorilla gets up and pounds his chest and says "It is NT and everyone get behind me because I'm a self proclaimed expert" well, your going to have resistance.
It quickly became apparent that once again it was futile to argue with yet another self proclaimed expert in the field of Numismatics...it's really a shame that novice people have to be exposed to such actions as his.
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>but I am notably impressed by Doug's confidence. >>
Looks like this one went on well into the night. I too am impressed with his confidence, however, one must understand where my lack of confidence comes from. I own what has been confirmed by many to be an AT half cent. Confirmed by some of the expert dealers mentioned in this thread. And low and behold, the coin can be traced back to another well known so called toning expert. I guess when we say toning expert around here there is a fine line between those who tone coins, and those who are capable of determining whether a coin is AT or NT with certainty.
I just wanted to give Doug an opportunity to step up to the plate and act like an expert should. Like presenting facts as to his determination. I guess the toning expert handbook must list as number 1 with bold type: Be evasive at all times and keep repeating with authority that a coin is NT and people will pay huge sums of money making us all rich. >>
I can only conclude, having been a party to these discussions in the past, that between absolutely AT and absolutely NT there is a large gray area. People will draw their line between the two at various points along the spectrum. For some people, the NT group of coins will be larger and for others, the AT group of coins will be larger.
I have also noticed that some members of the Toned Coin Posse (if you will) will come out of the woodwork and defend some very suspect coins (to my untrained eye) and argue the point to death.
I have come to accept all of the above as part of the landscape of the AT/NT debate.
(Oh, BTW, 100
RYK, the issue at hand in my eyes is the lack of 'grey area'.
To say a coin is definately, inarguably, 100% naturally toned without having the coin in your posession for it's lifetime is a foolish statement. There is no grey area according to a certain board member(as far as this coin goes) and that's what bothers me. As mentioned before by Mark, there are numerous graders who would not be as straightforward/flat-footed/unwavering with their opinions/convictions on such coins. It should always be remembered that TPGs aren't necissarily grading what's naturally toned. They're assessing/grading what's Market Acceptable.
-D
-Aristotle
Dum loquimur fugerit invida aetas. Carpe diem quam minimum credula postero.
-Horace
<< <i>On this thread, Amanda, as always, impresses the heck out of me with her maturity and her succinct, calm and polite statement. >>
Thanks.
<< <i>That her post has not been answered tells me everything I need to know. Rob >>
-Amanda
I'm a YN working on a type set!
My Buffalo Nickel Website Home of the Quirky Buffaloes Collection!
Proud member of the CUFYNA
<< <i>I am an expert in the field >>
Self proclaimed experts. Gotta love 'em.
<< <i>
<< <i>I am an expert in the field >>
Self proclaimed experts. Gotta love 'em. >>
Most experts in various fields that I have met along the way do not call themselves "experts". It is usually a title bestowed on someone else.
(Actually, in medical circles, an expert can be loosely defined as the guy/gal from out of town wearing a tie and carrying with him/her a Power point presentation.
<< <i>(Actually, in medical circles, an expert can be loosely defined as the guy/gal from out of town wearing a tie and carrying with him/her a Power point presentation.
RYK, that person, if from at least 50 miles out of town, can be called "a consultant".
Edited for typo.
An authorized PCGS dealer, and a contributor to the Red Book.
VamGuy,
Man, that has to hurt!
Russ, NCNE
Many people may not realize that for many of the AT'd Peace dollars out there, the coin doc will start with a coin that is already toned to some degree and enhance the coin which may make the work less noticable. In addition, most professionally done AT'd Peace dollars I've seen were done in darker shades of opaque color to attempt to mask problems on the coin, and not done to make the coin a 'monster toner', with the exception of some of the silly coins seen offered on Ebay.
If you view the thousands of past Peace dollar lots on Heritages auction archives you will notice the majority of natural colored Peace dollars are generally toned in uneven and/or splotchy shades of various golds, browns, and rust type colors from album or roll storage and sometimes seen less then vivid crescents of subdued rainbow color around the rims. Less often seen natural colors can also be various shades of lighter green and deep cherry red but these are few and far between in my experiences. Due to their method of manufacture and planchet preperation Peace dollars do not lend themselves to generally aquiring bright or vivid color or the various shapes and patterns of mint bag toned Morgan dollars, and various shades of either powder or deep cobalt blue are usually a big red flag on Peace dollars.
In addition, NGC in my experiences has a rather poor track record for holdering Peace dollars with artificial color either in whole or part, and it should never be assumed that a Peace dollar is good because it's in an NGC holder IMO.
<< <i>Monday November 13, 2006 9:00 PM
Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug
______________________________________________________
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely". (No offense taken, BTW thanks).
Doug
______________________________________________________
Years of experience, wide recognition of competancy by my collegues and fellow toning enthusiasts, high percentage of submission success to PCGS and NGC with regard to NT - basically the same qualifications as other professional numismatists in the hobby as a whole - I just happen to know this niche' as an expert.
Thanks for asking,
Doug
________________________________________________________
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Thanks,
Doug
**********************************************************************************************************
Wednesday February 15, 2006 10:41 PM
Damn, even I was fooled. Anaconda's pics make the coins colors appear genuine and gototoninghell's pics are always obviously AT. I am sure Anaconda's pics more properly represent the coin AND it is in an NGC holder.
... if NGC is slabbing $10,000+ coins...could really shake the market values badly.
Doug
-------------------------
You're in good company Doug...
"There's an old saying in Tennessee — I know it's in Texas, probably in Tennessee — that says, fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you can't get fooled again." —President George W. Bush, Nashville, Tenn., Sept. 17, 2002
Thanks for digging that up. A few other quotes to be read:
"Because even the experts can never be 100% certain that a product is exactly what they initially believe it to be! "
"This was not at all obvious to most toning experts, based on Anaconda's pictures combined with the NGC holder. "
Doug, I must join in the chorus and express my disappointment in your argument. You've talked down to numerous posters while answering NO question on how you can judge THIS COIN to be naturally toned. Fact is, I've never had a Teletrade coin look like the picture, and color most certainly can't be judged unless it is the most obvious of patterns (such as a simple, bag-toned crescent). Additionally, you hold NGC in such a regard as to be the be-all, end-all decider. I question numerous coins slabbed by NGC, as well as PCGS and ANACS, and even YOU were fooled by the holder just a few months ago. Oh, how soon we forget.
Collectors get stuck with crap because they forget to look at the coin, and buy the plastic instead. It doesn't help when the most persuasive argument an "expert" can make is that other experts, in this case the NGC graders, must be right. There's really no other way to say it than "put up, or shut up."
Jeremy
<< <i>Many people may not realize that for many of the AT'd Peace dollars out there, the coin doc will start with a coin that is already toned to some degree and enhance the coin which may make the work less noticable >>
I felt this is worth quoting from Dragon's post. Also it really doesn't just apply to Peace Dollars. I've seen many times on this board folks take a NT qualifier like let's say pull-away toning at the date and say no question NT. Somewhere else can be enhanced on the coin. Look at the whole coin and determine what makes sense is what I go by.
BTW, notice he mentions the "blue."
it does look like the colors on a couple of known AT peace dollars I have...
The fact that it is in a holder does not sway me. My gut tells me AT, so I would not buy the coin. If I am wrong, so be it, but I would not take the risk. At the end of the day, we don't always get a real answer on these, but I think it would be dangerous to be 100% sure based on the photo, especially on this coin.
Just my 2 cents
<< <i>
<< <i>Many people may not realize that for many of the AT'd Peace dollars out there, the coin doc will start with a coin that is already toned to some degree and enhance the coin which may make the work less noticable >>
I felt this is worth quoting from Dragon's post. Also it really doesn't just apply to Peace Dollars. I've seen many times on this board folks take a NT qualifier like let's say pull-away toning at the date and say no question NT. Somewhere else can be enhanced on the coin. Look at the whole coin and determine what makes sense is what I go by.
BTW, notice he mentions the "blue." >>
Stman, I almost commented on Dragon's post and the good information it provided. But I refrained, as I was under the impression that facts (as opposed to proclamations without foundation) had no place in this thread.
Edited to add: where's that popcorn icon when you need it?
And "TCCS" refers I think to the Toned Coin Collectors Society.
An authorized PCGS dealer, and a contributor to the Red Book.