<< <i><<There are coins an expert can absolutely tell are AT from an image. There are coins an expert can not make a call, based on an image. And then, there are coins like this one, where an expert can tell beyond a shadow of a doubt they are NT from an image...this is one of them>>
Doug, if you can tell that coin is "beyond a shadow of a doubt" NT from the images, then you are apparently 1) far more expert than just about all of the rest of us here, and 2) unlike just about everyone else, capable of knowing from images, with certainty, what a coin looks like in person, even though you haven't seen it in hand.
Sorry, but the chances of any one person being that much superior to everyone else in those respects are extremely remote. >>
Mark,
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
Doug >>
Meant to ask this last night, what guild is this you mention?
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
<< <i><<There are coins an expert can absolutely tell are AT from an image. There are coins an expert can not make a call, based on an image. And then, there are coins like this one, where an expert can tell beyond a shadow of a doubt they are NT from an image...this is one of them>>
Doug, if you can tell that coin is "beyond a shadow of a doubt" NT from the images, then you are apparently 1) far more expert than just about all of the rest of us here, and 2) unlike just about everyone else, capable of knowing from images, with certainty, what a coin looks like in person, even though you haven't seen it in hand.
Sorry, but the chances of any one person being that much superior to everyone else in those respects are extremely remote. >>
Mark,
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
Doug >>
Meant to ask this last night, what guild is this you mention? >>
<< <i><<There are coins an expert can absolutely tell are AT from an image. There are coins an expert can not make a call, based on an image. And then, there are coins like this one, where an expert can tell beyond a shadow of a doubt they are NT from an image...this is one of them>>
Doug, if you can tell that coin is "beyond a shadow of a doubt" NT from the images, then you are apparently 1) far more expert than just about all of the rest of us here, and 2) unlike just about everyone else, capable of knowing from images, with certainty, what a coin looks like in person, even though you haven't seen it in hand.
Sorry, but the chances of any one person being that much superior to everyone else in those respects are extremely remote. >>
Mark,
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
Doug >>
Meant to ask this last night, what guild is this you mention? >>
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Thanks,
Doug >>>
Just curious..........are these the same "grading and toning experts at NGC" who graded and holdered the famous Anaconda Peace dollar as well as many, many other bad Peace dollars I've seen in NGC holders over the years? If that is the basis for your so-called compelling position, you had better learn something before you make these rediculous posts.
One of your members was spouting off on the Coin Universe Forum Board hosted by PCGS last night...about his prowess as an authenticator of NT coins. In doing so, he did not make many friends by claiming to be a self proclaimed expert on the subject, nor did he represent this "guild" as he/she put it, with much professionalism.
If you all are as arrogant as this member was in the CU Forum, then there is no place for me in this organization.
Doug, as usual, you have provided nothing in the way of support. I believe, despite your word, that the coin is probably one of yours, either now, or one you sold and guaranteed it was genuine. You have had many coins for sale on E-bay, and probably Teletrade. You have had some coins that were obviously AT on E-bay, as I was informed so by the past owners of the coins.
You offer a challenge to prove the coin is real. Fair game. I hope someone takes you up on your offer. There are several people offering money to prove UFOs and ghosts are fake/real. Why do they make the offers? FREE publicity!!!! For you, this is BAD publicity. I have never bid, and never will bid on any coins of yours. Some toned coins that are AT I have bought because they are pretty. BUT, I bought them knowing they are AT and at an AT price. They will never be for sale at any auction. I will sell them to another coin collector and let him/her know they are AT before they buy them if I ever sell them. AND, as a side note, I only have 8 of them. They are three Ike's sold as PKOK coins on E-bay, and a 1971 proof set I bought on E-bay from a fellow board member. The set was sold as real for over $350. It was returned when the buyer informed the seller it was obviously AT and the case was broken open, toned, and reglued together. Bad glue job too. I bought the same set for $25. ANACONDA did the right thing and stepped up to the plate when his coin was proved AT. Will you do the same?
I have real rainbow toned Peace dollars, some slabbed, some not. I have seen many for sale and was told how some were made to hide the fact that the coin was cleaned. The dealers did this to recoup some money from their mistake, NOT to heap a big reward. Now it has grown to be a BIG profit game for those that can get the coins past the graders. I, like many here, won't play the guessing game, is it AT/NT with our money. Most of the real toned coins are either dark or muted colors. Peace dollars DON'T tone the same as Morgans and will not be as bright. If you see one, it's PROBABLY fake!
I do not call myself an expert. I say the coin is AT. That's my opinion. I will say for certain that I am 100% sure of my opinion. I am certain without a doubt that it's my opinion. No one can argue with that. But, I don't know for sure if the coin's AT, I just think it is. BUT, I am 100% sure I have an opinion. Why don't you quit while you're behind? Ray
You only live life once, enjoy it like it's your last day. It just MIGHT be!
One of your members was spouting off on the Coin Universe Forum Board hosted by PCGS last night...about his prowess as an authenticator of NT coins. In doing so, he did not make many friends by claiming to be a self proclaimed expert on the subject, nor did he represent this "guild" as he/she put it, with much professionalism.
If you all are as arrogant as this member was in the CU Forum, then there is no place for me in this organization.
Thanks for the heads up. >>
That sounds like an unprovoked and unfair jab at the other members of the TCCS, a number of whom are almost certainly not arrogant.
Why not send them a link to this thread, invite them to discuss the coin in a polite manner and ask them to comment on Doug's posts in which he stated <<Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning.>> and <<......I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.>>?
<<That sounds like an unprovoked and unfair jab at the other members of the TCCS, a number of whom are almost certainly not arrogant.>>
no, it was provoked and it did not mean that they were arrogant, it was mearly a question, "If you all are as arrogant as this member was in the CU Forum"
If someone is going to represent a guild, the other members need to know exactly how that member is portrayed outside that organization.
If this e-mail does not peak their interest as to what was said...they do not need and invitation.
The diplomacy ended when the person representing the guild ended it by his arrogance.
<< <i><<That sounds like an unprovoked and unfair jab at the other members of the TCCS, a number of whom are almost certainly not arrogant.>>
no, it was provoked and it did not mean that they were arrogant, it was mearly a question, "If you all are as arrogant as this member was in the CU Forum"
If someone is going to represent a guild, the other members need to know exactly how that member is portrayed outside that organization.
If this e-mail does not peak their interest as to what was said...they do not need and invitation.
The diplomacy ended when the person representing the guild ended it by his arrogance. >>
FWIW, I read your e-mail as Mark did and agree with him. The point is, I believe, that uofa does not speak for the guild, so the wording of the note was strong given what transpired...Mike
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
It doesn't have the sound of a question "WoodenNickel"....it would certainly come across to most as a jab at TCCS member whether intended or imagined....but let me digress and get to the bottom of the brew ha ha here since I am one of the aforementioned (Albeit Junior) founding members of the TCCS. When I initially saw this coin posted across the pond my gut instinct said Market Acceptable since I had seen quite a few peace dollars with similar colors and toning patterns in other TPG holders. With that said I think the colors should come into question even though they don't scream AT to me in any way shape or form. I think it is a good idea for all of us to question but not label coins that have A-typical color and or toning patterns. The problem is....over here they get labeled right off the bat as AT from folks that have zero information or knowledge of the subject. I don't know if this coin is AT or NT from the image but I can see the colors and toning pattern fairly well so if Doug feels he can see enough to give it a 100% seal of approval then I am ok with that......but that is certainly his opinion. I would also submit that their are probably others in the TCCS that would indeed agree with his assessment but I personally prefer to see a coin in hand before leverage the full weight of my opinion on a coin.
Doug is not a villain here and I will not crucify him for trying to step up and represent our guild...if that's what you want to call it. I think each TCCS members has in someway done that to an extent in the past.....this was just and example of a more public display. Yes we tend to stick together when it comes to toned coin opinions and education.......as the combined knowledge of our "guild" has decades and decades of experience on the subject matter. Doug is welcome to his opinion and I would certainly consider him an asset to our organization.......but I think each of us are entitled to our own opinions and mine differs slightly from Doug's. There is no harm in that and I don't want this to appear to be dissention in the ranks so to speak.......it simply means that everyone has their own opinions and the goal in expressing those opinions is to help educate others. If Doug's blanket statement that the coin is 100% NT cause other collectors to take a closer look and educate themselves then I think it's good for the hobby as a whole
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Thanks,
Doug >>>
Just curious..........are these the same "grading and toning experts at NGC" who graded and holdered the famous Anaconda Peace dollar as well as many, many other bad Peace dollars I've seen in NGC holders over the years? If that is the basis for your so-called compelling position, you had better learn something before you make these rediculous posts. >>
<< <i><<That sounds like an unprovoked and unfair jab at the other members of the TCCS, a number of whom are almost certainly not arrogant.>>
FWIW, I read your e-mail as Mark did and agree with him. The point is, I believe, that uofa does not speak for the guild, so the wording of the note was strong given what transpired...Mike >>
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ These are uofa words and I quote:
Mark,
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
Doug
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ uofa is aligning other members of TCCS with his statements!
Also: I quote uofa again:
Yawn...the lack of substance in your argument bores me...please refrain from speaking.
Doug ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ if this is NOT arrogance please explain what the context of this message is then?
<< <i><<That sounds like an unprovoked and unfair jab at the other members of the TCCS, a number of whom are almost certainly not arrogant.>>
FWIW, I read your e-mail as Mark did and agree with him. The point is, I believe, that uofa does not speak for the guild, so the wording of the note was strong given what transpired...Mike >>
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ These are uofa words and I quote:
Mark,
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
Doug
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ uofa is aligning other members of TCCS with his statements! >>
Doug might believe that he is representing the other members of TCCS (in his views) but that doesn't necessarily make it so. And, unless or until they speak to others the way he did, they don't deserve to be found guilty of sharing his attitude. As an example, Shane just posted a not-unexpectedly informed and gentlemanly response here.
<< <i>It doesn't have the sound of a question "WoodenNickel"....it would certainly come across to most as a jab at TCCS member whether intended or imagined....but let me digress and get to the bottom of the brew ha ha here since I am one of the aforementioned (Albeit Junior) founding members of the TCCS. When I initially saw this coin posted across the pond my gut instinct said Market Acceptable since I had seen quite a few peace dollars with similar colors and toning patterns in other TPG holders. With that said I think the colors should come into question even though they don't scream AT to me in any way shape or form. I think it is a good idea for all of us to question but not label coins that have A-typical color and or toning patterns. The problem is....over here they get labeled right off the bat as AT from folks that have zero information or knowledge of the subject. I don't know if this coin is AT or NT from the image but I can see the colors and toning pattern fairly well so if Doug feels he can see enough to give it a 100% seal of approval then I am ok with that......but that is certainly his opinion. I would also submit that their are probably others in the TCCS that would indeed agree with his assessment but I personally prefer to see a coin in hand before leverage the full weight of my opinion on a coin.
Doug is not a villain here and I will not crucify him for trying to step up and represent our guild...if that's what you want to call it. I think each TCCS members has in someway done that to an extent in the past.....this was just and example of a more public display. Yes we tend to stick together when it comes to toned coin opinions and education.......as the combined knowledge of our "guild" has decades and decades of experience on the subject matter. Doug is welcome to his opinion and I would certainly consider him an asset to our organization.......but I think each of us are entitled to our own opinions and mine differs slightly from Doug's. There is no harm in that and I don't want this to appear to be dissention in the ranks so to speak.......it simply means that everyone has their own opinions and the goal in expressing those opinions is to help educate others. If Doug's blanket statement that the coin is 100% NT cause other collectors to take a closer look and educate themselves then I think it's good for the hobby as a whole >>
Shane,
If I'm reading this right, it's safe to say that:
a1) You do not agree with Doug's assessment on the coin when he said "Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning."
-or-
a2) You don't know the first thing about natural toning.
-and-
b) Doug does not speak for the rest of the TCCS when he said "I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter" (although we've only heard from one member of the TCCS so Doug could be correct about the majority opinion).
In short, Doug expressed his opinion, and you, a founding member of the TCCS, do not agree. Correct?
Just want to be clear....Mike
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
Apparently, all one needs to know is "the first thing" about natural toning to be sure of the NT'edness of this sadly struck '22 P.
(I think you all had maybe moved on to the second or third things, which are probably what are confusing you!
BTW, am I the only person who noticed that it looks like they struck this poor thing in 1921?)
Anyhoo - I think if Doug wants to be an expert, we should all just let him be an expert! Can't we all just get along?
As I didn't see this until today, the inarguable coin has been rendered "unsold" and the reserve or whatever is no longer there.
Does smoeone remember how much they were hoping to get for this thing?
I stopped abrubtly and did not proceed, I find the following statements tackless and offensive.
Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely".
Doug
Your statement shows your inexperience in the toning field...but that's okay, we all have to learn somehow.
Doug
Please look those up and then we can talk semantics if you like.
Doug
Yawn...the lack of substance in your argument bores me...please refrain from speaking.
Doug
<sigh> Please, again, try not to speak - you add nothing of value to this discussion. I have challenged you to prove your previous allegations, and all you have are personal barbs...hey, here's an idea - try stamps!
Hey guys, as a fouding member of the TCCS boards let me start by saying I personally can't make the call between a good AT job and NT from a scan/image and be 100% positive................. anymore than I can accurately grade from the same format. Pictures can be decieving. My original comment on this piece was that I felt it was NT, but needed to see it in hand first to be sure. Peace dollars don't normally come nicely toned, so I am very suspect when I see one. Not to say they can't be NT and beautiful (ArtR has a beauty), but that would be the exception and not the rule. JMHO.
This is an interesting thread, for many of the wrong reasons, and one that I had not read until moments ago. Typically, I avoid threads that ask for the AT vs. NT decision because I have found, over time, that these threads have a tendancy to devolve into something that reflects less about education or experience and more about who can shout the loudest and longest.
Is the toning on this Peace dollar legitimate? I guess the answer to that question would hinge upon what one defines as natural or artificial toning and how one perceives the color, apparent depth and progression of toning and the likely storage method or other outside influence needed to produce the observed effect. A significant portion of that information is not available to me through my interpretation of the single set of images provided by TeleTrade and viewed on my factory default settings monitor.
Based entirely on the single set of images provided by TeleTrade I can quickly come to the conclusion that I do not like the aesthetics of the coin. Beyond that, I have more questions than answers. Is the reverse rim from 11:00 through 5:00 muted green? Is it vivid, pure emerald green? Is it a combination of green with underlying hints of violet or blue? Is the center of the eagle's back and right wing toned or slightly scuffed? If toned, is the toning more auburn or more blue? Is that light pink that I see at the top of the eagle's legs and shooting upwards from the reverse rim through the DO of DOLLAR? If pink, is that same color, though deeper, present directly in front of the eagle's neck and under its beak? How do the colors change when rotated? Are there flecks of toning beneath the toning visible in the image? If so, what colors are the flecks?
Simply put, I have not seen the coin in-hand, nor do I like the visual impact of the coin. I view all coins as if they were raw, regardless of certification company or grade, and I do not always agree with the TPGs. My disagreements span designated grade, decision to bag and exclude from certification, decision to openly net grade and decisions to certify and grade coins that I believe have been altered far too much. Therefore, I am not a TPGs best friend. However, based upon the imperfect and incomplete evidence of the single set of images, I can put forth a guess as to how I would interpret the coin. My opinion is that I would not buy this Peace dollar if raw, I would not buy this Peace dollar if certified and I am not at all convinced that the overall body of toning that this coin represents would be considered natural to me. The apparent pink, off-green, ubiquitous yellow and possible placement of blue disturb me as does the overall "feel" of the reverse image.
The TCCS discussion is somewhat tangential in my opinion, but I will address it since I am one of the folks who put up their own money to register, build and maintain the site as a public forum for discussion, sharing and education. A PCGS thread introducing the TCCS and listing the original members shows 13 folks listed. I don't know that I have seen any of the others post in this thread, I do not know their opinions of this coin and frankly an opinion on this coin without discussion as to how the opinion was obtained would mean little to me. However, I can emphatically state that those members of the TCCS whom I have had the pleasure to meet with in person have been inquisitive and honest when it comes to how coins might tone and if others believe the toning to be NT or AT regardless of who owned the coin in question. In my opinion, that is a positive attribute.
<< <i>Hey guys, as a fouding member of the TCCS boards let me start by saying I personally can't make the call between a good AT job and NT from a scan/image and be 100% positive................. anymore than I can accurately grade from the same format. Pictures can be decieving. My original comment on this piece was that I felt it was NT, but needed to see it in hand first to be sure. Peace dollars don't normally come nicely toned, so I am very suspect when I see one. Not to say they can't be NT and beautiful (ArtR has a beauty), but that would be the exception and not the rule. JMHO. >>
<< <i>I am not at all convinced that the overall body of toning that this coin represents would be considered natural to me. >>
Doug's slope just became much more slippery. For those keeping score at home, he's 0/3 with founding members thusfar....Mike
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
a1) You do not agree with Doug's assessment on the coin when he said "Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning."Correct.....in hand I might, but from the image I personally can't make or agree with that statement with 100% conviction.
-or-
a2) You don't know the first thing about natural toning. I might not know the second thing about natural toning but I think I have gotten past first base.
-and-
b) Doug does not speak for the rest of the TCCS when he said "I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter" (although we've only heard from one member of the TCCS so Doug could be correct about the majority opinion). yes I think you nailed it....he stated almost every member so he still has a chance to be right since there are many others out there.
In short, Doug expressed his opinion, and you, a founding member of the TCCS, do not agree. Correct? I can't be 100% that I agree with this statement, but it might be a yes....how was the question stored?
Teletrade scans do not show the true color of coins -- the reds on that Peace Dollar have a pink cast that would make someone suspect AT -- however, in hand, the colors might be a truer red and indicate NT -- or they still may be pink -- who knows?
Bottom line, a coin like that needs to be seen in hand to make an informed assessment of the toning.
Here's another question:
Assuming the coin is NT, is this MS-63 1922 Peace Dollar a four figure coin? What do you think?
In my "less than expert" opinion, it would be a "B" toner worth $200 or so, and if one paid $500 or more for it, he/she would likely be buried at that level.
As a founding member of the TCCS,albeit my name was left off Rons original list,i could not make a determination of whether the coin is AT or NT without seeing it in my hand.That being said,i would say Doug is certainly entitled to his opinion,but i cant agree or disagree based on that image alone.Sunnywood and I have constantly stated,though he is ususlly much more eloquent than I am,that one can NOT get a true feel for in hand look OR grade from images alone.
Great coins are not cheap,and cheap coins are not great!
<<< Assuming the coin is NT, is this MS-63 1922 Peace Dollar a four figure coin? What do you think? >>>
Assuming it is, and that's a very BIG if just going from that pic IMO, it would be nowhere near a four figure coin IMO, not by a longshot. There are those people who incorrectly assume that ANY Peace dollar with some color is worth a big premium which is not true. There are plenty of crusty and otherwise unattractively toned Peace dollars out there, it's only the few and far between nice ones that are worth substantial premiums.
<<< In my "less than expert" opinion, it would be a "B" toner worth $200 or so, and if one paid $500 or more for it, he/she would likely be buried at that level. >>>
Correct. Even if real, at above 500.00 for a reverse toned MS63 like that, the buyer would die with that coin IMO unless he was able to locate a bigger fool.
<< <i>As a founding member of the TCCS,albeit my name was left off Rons original list,i could not make a determination of whether the coin is AT or NT without seeing it in my hand.That being said,i would say Doug is certainly entitled to his opinion,but i cant agree or disagree based on that image alone.Sunnywood and I have constantly stated,though he is ususlly much more eloquent than I am,that one can NOT get a true feel for in hand look OR grade from images alone. >>
That makes Doug 0/4.
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
It's NT, simply due to the fact that it's in a TPG slab. It's about as crystal clear as can be.
Seriously though, if a coin is hinging somewhere between obviously NT and probably NT, if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster.
<< <i>It's NT, simply due to the fact that it's in a TPG slab. It's about as crystal clear as can be.
Seriously though, if a coin is hinging somewhere between obviously NT and probably NT, if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
It's comforting that expert, jr. is able to hold the line while we await the return of expert....
<< <i>It's NT, simply due to the fact that it's in a TPG slab. It's about as crystal clear as can be.
Seriously though, if a coin is hinging somewhere between obviously NT and probably NT, if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
It's comforting that expert, jr. is able to hold the line while we await the return of expert.... >>
<< <i>It's NT, simply due to the fact that it's in a TPG slab. It's about as crystal clear as can be.
Seriously though, if a coin is hinging somewhere between obviously NT and probably NT, if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
I just passed on a $200,000 coin I could have used for my type set because I was fairly certain it was AT ... even tho it was in a top two holder.
To the extent that it is possible to judge anything from an image (and many of you know how much I have railed against judging color from images) .... the peace dollar in question appears to be NT to me, and I applaud uofa1282 for going out on a limb and saying so. However, in agreement with bestclser1, I will not pass final judgment without seeing the coin in hand. Incidentally, I always thought the infamous Anaconda peace dollar was AT, and I so stated at the time.
TDN, you mean that "modern crap" 1796 Bust dime you posted on TCCS? That was part of my old early type set, of which the half dime, dime and quarter were purchased by Legend a few years ago. (Yeah, thanks for telling me it was a dime LOL, shoulda known better from the obverse cud ... I didn't even recognize my own coin !!!)
Finally, a fun and controversial thread! I don't usually stir things up but when the Dragon-Lady person compared me to an Iraqi, that fired me up a bit.
MikeInFL - 0/4? man, you need to take some accounting classses! My count is at best 5/1 and at worst 2/2/2! Go back and do a recount (Bushmaster, Sunnywood, etc.) But, your cool with me since you don't attack personally.
Russ, I gots tuns of respekt for ya but I don't care what his/her background in toners is - the Lady-in-Drag(on) lost any credibility with me when he went with comparing me to an Iraqi War Criminal.
Hey, Dragoon, if your such an expert, take me up on my wager...no? You lack the courage of your convictions, sir/ma'am.
Raycyca - huh? Perhaps you should just observe.
TDN - I proclaimed to be "God's gift to toning"? You're confusing that with my proclomation to being "God's gift to women". Hey, that Kennedy is NT all day long - I guarantee it! Anyway, I'm not even in your collecting league so I will offer no insults to you, sir.
For the clear thinking posters who acknowledge this Peace dollar is 'most likely' NT, congrats for having the guts to opine to the bored group of cynical sharks that would rather call the collector's album half empty, instead of half filled.
Doug
Edited to remove a bunch of blank lines below name and a couple of typos.
Wow! Come back after a day and see this thread has exploded like Fat B**stard OD'ing on Ex-Lax. Can't wait to see that coin go up for bid again. Actually, I'm vary wary of wild toned Peace Dollars in general, since I just not remember seeing them 10 years ago. Wild Morgans have been around as long as I remember (been collecting for 35 years).
The 'top-tier' TPGs have added value to the hobby, but having blind faith in them will get you screwed, if not now, for sure later.
Comments
<< <i>
<< <i><<There are coins an expert can absolutely tell are AT from an image. There are coins an expert can not make a call, based on an image. And then, there are coins like this one, where an expert can tell beyond a shadow of a doubt they are NT from an image...this is one of them>>
Doug, if you can tell that coin is "beyond a shadow of a doubt" NT from the images, then you are apparently 1) far more expert than just about all of the rest of us here, and 2) unlike just about everyone else, capable of knowing from images, with certainty, what a coin looks like in person, even though you haven't seen it in hand.
Sorry, but the chances of any one person being that much superior to everyone else in those respects are extremely remote. >>
Mark,
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
Doug >>
Meant to ask this last night, what guild is this you mention?
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i><<There are coins an expert can absolutely tell are AT from an image. There are coins an expert can not make a call, based on an image. And then, there are coins like this one, where an expert can tell beyond a shadow of a doubt they are NT from an image...this is one of them>>
Doug, if you can tell that coin is "beyond a shadow of a doubt" NT from the images, then you are apparently 1) far more expert than just about all of the rest of us here, and 2) unlike just about everyone else, capable of knowing from images, with certainty, what a coin looks like in person, even though you haven't seen it in hand.
Sorry, but the chances of any one person being that much superior to everyone else in those respects are extremely remote. >>
Mark,
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
Doug >>
Meant to ask this last night, what guild is this you mention? >>
See here - I think this is it, though I am not sure beyond a shadow of a doubt
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
R.I.P. Guilded Lilies
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i><<There are coins an expert can absolutely tell are AT from an image. There are coins an expert can not make a call, based on an image. And then, there are coins like this one, where an expert can tell beyond a shadow of a doubt they are NT from an image...this is one of them>>
Doug, if you can tell that coin is "beyond a shadow of a doubt" NT from the images, then you are apparently 1) far more expert than just about all of the rest of us here, and 2) unlike just about everyone else, capable of knowing from images, with certainty, what a coin looks like in person, even though you haven't seen it in hand.
Sorry, but the chances of any one person being that much superior to everyone else in those respects are extremely remote. >>
Mark,
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
Doug >>
Meant to ask this last night, what guild is this you mention? >>
See here - I think this is it, though I am not sure beyond a shadow of a doubt >>
That's odd, I see quite a few coins that I would call AT on the TCCS web site. Then again, I'm no expert.
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Thanks,
Doug >>>
Just curious..........are these the same "grading and toning experts at NGC" who graded and holdered the famous Anaconda Peace dollar as well as many, many other bad Peace dollars I've seen in NGC holders over the years? If that is the basis for your so-called compelling position, you had better learn something before you make these rediculous posts.
<< <i>That's odd, I see quite a few coins that I would call AT on the TCCS web site. Then again, I'm no expert.
I too wish I had the trained eyes of an expert.
-D
-Aristotle
Dum loquimur fugerit invida aetas. Carpe diem quam minimum credula postero.
-Horace
INFO@TONEDCOINS.ORG
One of your members was spouting off on the Coin Universe Forum Board hosted by PCGS last night...about his prowess as an authenticator of NT coins. In doing so, he did not make many friends by claiming to be a self proclaimed expert on the subject, nor did he represent this "guild" as he/she put it, with much professionalism.
If you all are as arrogant as this member was in the CU Forum, then there is no place for me in this organization.
Thanks for the heads up.
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
You offer a challenge to prove the coin is real. Fair game. I hope someone takes you up on your offer. There are several people offering money to prove UFOs and ghosts are fake/real. Why do they make the offers? FREE publicity!!!! For you, this is BAD publicity. I have never bid, and never will bid on any coins of yours. Some toned coins that are AT I have bought because they are pretty. BUT, I bought them knowing they are AT and at an AT price. They will never be for sale at any auction. I will sell them to another coin collector and let him/her know they are AT before they buy them if I ever sell them. AND, as a side note, I only have 8 of them. They are three Ike's sold as PKOK coins on E-bay, and a 1971 proof set I bought on E-bay from a fellow board member. The set was sold as real for over $350. It was returned when the buyer informed the seller it was obviously AT and the case was broken open, toned, and reglued together. Bad glue job too. I bought the same set for $25. ANACONDA did the right thing and stepped up to the plate when his coin was proved AT. Will you do the same?
I have real rainbow toned Peace dollars, some slabbed, some not. I have seen many for sale and was told how some were made to hide the fact that the coin was cleaned. The dealers did this to recoup some money from their mistake, NOT to heap a big reward. Now it has grown to be a BIG profit game for those that can get the coins past the graders. I, like many here, won't play the guessing game, is it AT/NT with our money. Most of the real toned coins are either dark or muted colors. Peace dollars DON'T tone the same as Morgans and will not be as bright. If you see one, it's PROBABLY fake!
I do not call myself an expert. I say the coin is AT. That's my opinion. I will say for certain that I am 100% sure of my opinion. I am certain without a doubt that it's my opinion. No one can argue with that. But, I don't know for sure if the coin's AT, I just think it is. BUT, I am 100% sure I have an opinion. Why don't you quit while you're behind? Ray
<< <i>e-mail sent to TCCS
INFO@TONEDCOINS.ORG
One of your members was spouting off on the Coin Universe Forum Board hosted by PCGS last night...about his prowess as an authenticator of NT coins. In doing so, he did not make many friends by claiming to be a self proclaimed expert on the subject, nor did he represent this "guild" as he/she put it, with much professionalism.
If you all are as arrogant as this member was in the CU Forum, then there is no place for me in this organization.
Thanks for the heads up. >>
That sounds like an unprovoked and unfair jab at the other members of the TCCS, a number of whom are almost certainly not arrogant.
Why not send them a link to this thread, invite them to discuss the coin in a polite manner and ask them to comment on Doug's posts in which he stated <<Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning.>> and <<......I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.>>?
no, it was provoked and it did not mean that they were arrogant, it was mearly a question, "If you all are as arrogant as this member was in the CU Forum"
If someone is going to represent a guild, the other members need to know exactly how that member is portrayed outside that organization.
If this e-mail does not peak their interest as to what was said...they do not need and invitation.
The diplomacy ended when the person representing the guild ended it by his arrogance.
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
<< <i><<That sounds like an unprovoked and unfair jab at the other members of the TCCS, a number of whom are almost certainly not arrogant.>>
no, it was provoked and it did not mean that they were arrogant, it was mearly a question, "If you all are as arrogant as this member was in the CU Forum"
If someone is going to represent a guild, the other members need to know exactly how that member is portrayed outside that organization.
If this e-mail does not peak their interest as to what was said...they do not need and invitation.
The diplomacy ended when the person representing the guild ended it by his arrogance. >>
FWIW, I read your e-mail as Mark did and agree with him. The point is, I believe, that uofa does not speak for the guild, so the wording of the note was strong given what transpired...Mike
Doug is not a villain here and I will not crucify him for trying to step up and represent our guild...if that's what you want to call it. I think each TCCS members has in someway done that to an extent in the past.....this was just and example of a more public display. Yes we tend to stick together when it comes to toned coin opinions and education.......as the combined knowledge of our "guild" has decades and decades of experience on the subject matter. Doug is welcome to his opinion and I would certainly consider him an asset to our organization.......but I think each of us are entitled to our own opinions and mine differs slightly from Doug's. There is no harm in that and I don't want this to appear to be dissention in the ranks so to speak.......it simply means that everyone has their own opinions and the goal in expressing those opinions is to help educate others. If Doug's blanket statement that the coin is 100% NT cause other collectors to take a closer look and educate themselves then I think it's good for the hobby as a whole
<< <i><<< Mike,
The alternative opinions are not offering factual evidence as to why they believe the coin to be AT. I have $1,000,000 payroll of grading and toning experts at NGC that agree with my assessment. I believe my position is the most compelling here.
Thanks,
Doug >>>
Just curious..........are these the same "grading and toning experts at NGC" who graded and holdered the famous Anaconda Peace dollar as well as many, many other bad Peace dollars I've seen in NGC holders over the years? If that is the basis for your so-called compelling position, you had better learn something before you make these rediculous posts. >>
And let's not even mention blue IHC's, OK?
Check out my current listings: https://ebay.com/sch/khunt/m.html?_ipg=200&_sop=12&_rdc=1
<< <i>Hard to take someone who proclaims to be God's gift to toning experts seriously when he has that Kennedy for an icon
It could be (far) worse. For example, he could have an obviously AT Trade dollar for his icon, instead.
<< <i>
<< <i><<That sounds like an unprovoked and unfair jab at the other members of the TCCS, a number of whom are almost certainly not arrogant.>>
FWIW, I read your e-mail as Mark did and agree with him. The point is, I believe, that uofa does not speak for the guild, so the wording of the note was strong given what transpired...Mike >>
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
These are uofa words and I quote:
Mark,
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
Doug
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
uofa is aligning other members of TCCS with his statements!
Also: I quote uofa again:
Yawn...the lack of substance in your argument bores me...please refrain from speaking.
Doug
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
if this is NOT arrogance please explain what the context of this message is then?
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i><<That sounds like an unprovoked and unfair jab at the other members of the TCCS, a number of whom are almost certainly not arrogant.>>
FWIW, I read your e-mail as Mark did and agree with him. The point is, I believe, that uofa does not speak for the guild, so the wording of the note was strong given what transpired...Mike >>
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
These are uofa words and I quote:
Mark,
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
Doug
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
uofa is aligning other members of TCCS with his statements! >>
Doug might believe that he is representing the other members of TCCS (in his views) but that doesn't necessarily make it so. And, unless or until they speak to others the way he did, they don't deserve to be found guilty of sharing his attitude. As an example, Shane just posted a not-unexpectedly informed and gentlemanly response here.
Who is this Mark?
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
<< <i>It doesn't have the sound of a question "WoodenNickel"....it would certainly come across to most as a jab at TCCS member whether intended or imagined....but let me digress and get to the bottom of the brew ha ha here since I am one of the aforementioned (Albeit Junior) founding members of the TCCS. When I initially saw this coin posted across the pond my gut instinct said Market Acceptable since I had seen quite a few peace dollars with similar colors and toning patterns in other TPG holders. With that said I think the colors should come into question even though they don't scream AT to me in any way shape or form. I think it is a good idea for all of us to question but not label coins that have A-typical color and or toning patterns. The problem is....over here they get labeled right off the bat as AT from folks that have zero information or knowledge of the subject. I don't know if this coin is AT or NT from the image but I can see the colors and toning pattern fairly well so if Doug feels he can see enough to give it a 100% seal of approval then I am ok with that......but that is certainly his opinion. I would also submit that their are probably others in the TCCS that would indeed agree with his assessment but I personally prefer to see a coin in hand before leverage the full weight of my opinion on a coin.
Doug is not a villain here and I will not crucify him for trying to step up and represent our guild...if that's what you want to call it. I think each TCCS members has in someway done that to an extent in the past.....this was just and example of a more public display. Yes we tend to stick together when it comes to toned coin opinions and education.......as the combined knowledge of our "guild" has decades and decades of experience on the subject matter. Doug is welcome to his opinion and I would certainly consider him an asset to our organization.......but I think each of us are entitled to our own opinions and mine differs slightly from Doug's. There is no harm in that and I don't want this to appear to be dissention in the ranks so to speak.......it simply means that everyone has their own opinions and the goal in expressing those opinions is to help educate others. If Doug's blanket statement that the coin is 100% NT cause other collectors to take a closer look and educate themselves then I think it's good for the hobby as a whole >>
Shane,
If I'm reading this right, it's safe to say that:
a1) You do not agree with Doug's assessment on the coin when he said "Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning."
-or-
a2) You don't know the first thing about natural toning.
-and-
b) Doug does not speak for the rest of the TCCS when he said "I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter" (although we've only heard from one member of the TCCS so Doug could be correct about the majority opinion).
In short, Doug expressed his opinion, and you, a founding member of the TCCS, do not agree. Correct?
Just want to be clear....Mike
<< <i>Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning. Wonderful coin but not worth quite that much.
Doug >>
Apparently, all one needs to know is "the first thing" about natural toning to be sure of the NT'edness of this sadly struck '22 P.
(I think you all had maybe moved on to the second or third things, which are probably what are confusing you!
BTW, am I the only person who noticed that it looks like they struck this poor thing in 1921?)
Anyhoo - I think if Doug wants to be an expert, we should all just let him be an expert! Can't we all just get along?
As I didn't see this until today, the inarguable coin has been rendered "unsold" and the reserve or whatever is no longer there.
Does smoeone remember how much they were hoping to get for this thing?
<< <i>It was around $1200 last I saw. >>
and they wanted more????
Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely".
Doug
Your statement shows your inexperience in the toning field...but that's okay, we all have to learn somehow.
Doug
Please look those up and then we can talk semantics if you like.
Doug
Yawn...the lack of substance in your argument bores me...please refrain from speaking.
Doug
<sigh> Please, again, try not to speak - you add nothing of value to this discussion. I have challenged you to prove your previous allegations, and all you have are personal barbs...hey, here's an idea - try stamps!
Doug
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
Spoken as a true Numismatist..thank you for your comment.
I am humbled.
~Woody~
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
Wether or not the coin was said to have been AT/NT is not reflected in the lenght of this thread, it's about chest pounding and the like.
All ethics and morality.
No one really opposed that it is indeed naturally toned, albiet maybe one, it's was how it was said in the context of the discussion that bothered me.
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
This statement doesn't now, nor has it ever sounded like Uofa was stating what he thought to be an opinion.
-D
-Aristotle
Dum loquimur fugerit invida aetas. Carpe diem quam minimum credula postero.
-Horace
Is the toning on this Peace dollar legitimate? I guess the answer to that question would hinge upon what one defines as natural or artificial toning and how one perceives the color, apparent depth and progression of toning and the likely storage method or other outside influence needed to produce the observed effect. A significant portion of that information is not available to me through my interpretation of the single set of images provided by TeleTrade and viewed on my factory default settings monitor.
Based entirely on the single set of images provided by TeleTrade I can quickly come to the conclusion that I do not like the aesthetics of the coin. Beyond that, I have more questions than answers. Is the reverse rim from 11:00 through 5:00 muted green? Is it vivid, pure emerald green? Is it a combination of green with underlying hints of violet or blue? Is the center of the eagle's back and right wing toned or slightly scuffed? If toned, is the toning more auburn or more blue? Is that light pink that I see at the top of the eagle's legs and shooting upwards from the reverse rim through the DO of DOLLAR? If pink, is that same color, though deeper, present directly in front of the eagle's neck and under its beak? How do the colors change when rotated? Are there flecks of toning beneath the toning visible in the image? If so, what colors are the flecks?
Simply put, I have not seen the coin in-hand, nor do I like the visual impact of the coin. I view all coins as if they were raw, regardless of certification company or grade, and I do not always agree with the TPGs. My disagreements span designated grade, decision to bag and exclude from certification, decision to openly net grade and decisions to certify and grade coins that I believe have been altered far too much. Therefore, I am not a TPGs best friend. However, based upon the imperfect and incomplete evidence of the single set of images, I can put forth a guess as to how I would interpret the coin. My opinion is that I would not buy this Peace dollar if raw, I would not buy this Peace dollar if certified and I am not at all convinced that the overall body of toning that this coin represents would be considered natural to me. The apparent pink, off-green, ubiquitous yellow and possible placement of blue disturb me as does the overall "feel" of the reverse image.
The TCCS discussion is somewhat tangential in my opinion, but I will address it since I am one of the folks who put up their own money to register, build and maintain the site as a public forum for discussion, sharing and education. A PCGS thread introducing the TCCS and listing the original members shows 13 folks listed. I don't know that I have seen any of the others post in this thread, I do not know their opinions of this coin and frankly an opinion on this coin without discussion as to how the opinion was obtained would mean little to me. However, I can emphatically state that those members of the TCCS whom I have had the pleasure to meet with in person have been inquisitive and honest when it comes to how coins might tone and if others believe the toning to be NT or AT regardless of who owned the coin in question. In my opinion, that is a positive attribute.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
<< <i>Hey guys, as a fouding member of the TCCS boards let me start by saying I personally can't make the call between a good AT job and NT from a scan/image and be 100% positive................. anymore than I can accurately grade from the same format. Pictures can be decieving. My original comment on this piece was that I felt it was NT, but needed to see it in hand first to be sure. Peace dollars don't normally come nicely toned, so I am very suspect when I see one. Not to say they can't be NT and beautiful (ArtR has a beauty), but that would be the exception and not the rule. JMHO. >>
<< <i>I am not at all convinced that the overall body of toning that this coin represents would be considered natural to me. >>
Doug's slope just became much more slippery. For those keeping score at home, he's 0/3 with founding members thusfar....Mike
<< <i>
<< <i>Hard to take someone who proclaims to be God's gift to toning experts seriously when he has that Kennedy for an icon
It could be (far) worse. For example, he could have an obviously AT Trade dollar for his icon, instead.
True ... but I don't make unequivocable pronouncements regarding toning off an image, do I?
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Hard to take someone who proclaims to be God's gift to toning experts seriously when he has that Kennedy for an icon
It could be (far) worse. For example, he could have an obviously AT Trade dollar for his icon, instead.
True ... but I don't make unequivocable pronouncements regarding toning off an image, do I?
You sir, are not an expert!
-D
-Aristotle
Dum loquimur fugerit invida aetas. Carpe diem quam minimum credula postero.
-Horace
<< <i>
Shane,
If I'm reading this right, it's safe to say that:
a1) You do not agree with Doug's assessment on the coin when he said "Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning." Correct.....in hand I might, but from the image I personally can't make or agree with that statement with 100% conviction.
-or-
a2) You don't know the first thing about natural toning. I might not know the second thing about natural toning but I think I have gotten past first base.
-and-
b) Doug does not speak for the rest of the TCCS when he said "I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter" (although we've only heard from one member of the TCCS so Doug could be correct about the majority opinion). yes I think you nailed it....he stated almost every member so he still has a chance to be right since there are many others out there.
In short, Doug expressed his opinion, and you, a founding member of the TCCS, do not agree. Correct? I can't be 100% that I agree with this statement, but it might be a yes....how was the question stored?
Just want to be clear....Mike >>
Bottom line, a coin like that needs to be seen in hand to make an informed assessment of the toning.
Here's another question:
Assuming the coin is NT, is this MS-63 1922 Peace Dollar a four figure coin? What do you think?
In my "less than expert" opinion, it would be a "B" toner worth $200 or so, and if one paid $500 or more for it, he/she would likely be buried at that level.
Assuming it is, and that's a very BIG if just going from that pic IMO, it would be nowhere near a four figure coin IMO, not by a longshot. There are those people who incorrectly assume that ANY Peace dollar with some color is worth a big premium which is not true. There are plenty of crusty and otherwise unattractively toned Peace dollars out there, it's only the few and far between nice ones that are worth substantial premiums.
<<< In my "less than expert" opinion, it would be a "B" toner worth $200 or so, and if one paid $500 or more for it, he/she would likely be buried at that level. >>>
Correct. Even if real, at above 500.00 for a reverse toned MS63 like that, the buyer would die with that coin IMO unless he was able to locate a bigger fool.
<< <i>As a founding member of the TCCS,albeit my name was left off Rons original list,i could not make a determination of whether the coin is AT or NT without seeing it in my hand.That being said,i would say Doug is certainly entitled to his opinion,but i cant agree or disagree based on that image alone.Sunnywood and I have constantly stated,though he is ususlly much more eloquent than I am,that one can NOT get a true feel for in hand look OR grade from images alone. >>
That makes Doug 0/4.
Seriously though, if a coin is hinging somewhere between obviously NT and probably NT, if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster.
<< <i>It's NT, simply due to the fact that it's in a TPG slab. It's about as crystal clear as can be.
Seriously though, if a coin is hinging somewhere between obviously NT and probably NT, if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster.
It's comforting that expert, jr. is able to hold the line while we await the return of expert....
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
<< <i>
<< <i>It's NT, simply due to the fact that it's in a TPG slab. It's about as crystal clear as can be.
Seriously though, if a coin is hinging somewhere between obviously NT and probably NT, if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster.
It's comforting that expert, jr. is able to hold the line while we await the return of expert.... >>
I would prefer, "Mr. Expert Jr." Thank you!
<< <i>It's NT, simply due to the fact that it's in a TPG slab. It's about as crystal clear as can be.
Seriously though, if a coin is hinging somewhere between obviously NT and probably NT, if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster.
I just passed on a $200,000 coin I could have used for my type set because I was fairly certain it was AT ... even tho it was in a top two holder.
<< <i>if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
That attitude is precisely why a lot of collectors get screwed, and buried in crap coins.
Russ, NCNE
TDN, you mean that "modern crap" 1796 Bust dime you posted on TCCS? That was part of my old early type set, of which the half dime, dime and quarter were purchased by Legend a few years ago. (Yeah, thanks for telling me it was a dime LOL, shoulda known better from the obverse cud ... I didn't even recognize my own coin !!!)
Best,
Sunnywood
Sunnywood's Rainbow-Toned Morgans (Retired)
Sunnywood's Barber Quarters (Retired)
MikeInFL - 0/4? man, you need to take some accounting classses! My count is at best 5/1 and at worst 2/2/2! Go back and do a recount (Bushmaster, Sunnywood, etc.) But, your cool with me since you don't attack personally.
Russ, I gots tuns of respekt for ya but I don't care what his/her background in toners is - the Lady-in-Drag(on) lost any credibility with me when he went with comparing me to an Iraqi War Criminal.
Hey, Dragoon, if your such an expert, take me up on my wager...no? You lack the courage of your convictions, sir/ma'am.
Raycyca - huh? Perhaps you should just observe.
TDN - I proclaimed to be "God's gift to toning"? You're confusing that with my proclomation to being "God's gift to women".
For the clear thinking posters who acknowledge this Peace dollar is 'most likely' NT, congrats for having the guts to opine to the bored group of cynical sharks that would rather call the collector's album half empty, instead of half filled.
Doug
Edited to remove a bunch of blank lines below name and a couple of typos.
The 'top-tier' TPGs have added value to the hobby, but having blind faith in them will get you screwed, if not now, for sure later.
10-4,
My Instagram picturesErik
My registry sets
10-4,
My Instagram picturesErik
My registry sets