<< <i>MikeInFL - 0/4? man, you need to take some accounting classses! My count is at best 5/1 and at worst 2/2/2! Go back and do a recount (Bushmaster, Sunnywood, etc.) But, your cool with me since you don't attack personally. >>
I may need to brush up on my accounting, but I believe my reading comprehension and counting skills are more than sufficient here.
You said:
Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning.
You followed that up with:
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
My contention is that of the founding members that have posted to this forum (not incuding yourself), not a single one -- 0 for 4 -- have agreed with your first assertion, and therefore the second one is incorrect.
Specifically, KryptoniteComics disagreed when he said said:
I don't know if this coin is AT or NT from the image but I can see the colors and toning pattern fairly well so if Doug feels he can see enough to give it a 100% seal of approval then I am ok with that......but that is certainly his opinion. I would also submit that their are probably others in the TCCS that would indeed agree with his assessment but I personally prefer to see a coin in hand before leverage the full weight of my opinion on a coin.
Next, Hadleydog disagreed with your assertions when he said:
Hey guys, as a fouding member of the TCCS boards let me start by saying I personally can't make the call between a good AT job and NT from a scan/image and be 100% positive................. anymore than I can accurately grade from the same format.
Thirdly, TomB disagreed with your comments when he said:
My opinion is that I would not buy this Peace dollar if raw, I would not buy this Peace dollar if certified and I am not at all convinced that the overall body of toning that this coin represents would be considered natural to me. The apparent pink, off-green, ubiquitous yellow and possible placement of blue disturb me as does the overall "feel" of the reverse image.
Lastly, bestclsr1 disagreed with you when he said:
My opinion is that I would not buy this Peace dollar if raw, I would not buy this Peace dollar if certified and I am not at all convinced that the overall body of toning that this coin represents would be considered natural to me. The apparent pink, off-green, ubiquitous yellow and possible placement of blue disturb me as does the overall "feel" of the reverse image.
By my count, not a single one agreed that this coin was [i[Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT -- that's 0 for 4.
Therefore, are you suggesting four founding members of the TCCS do NOT know the first thing about natural toning, and/or do you still stand by your statements concerning your viewpoint that your view is representative of the vast majority of the guild in this matter.?
Or shall I start the personal attacks now?
Take care...Mike
p.s. a simple "my original post was too strongly worded and I should not have misrepresented my opinion as fact or demeaned those who disagree" would shut me up immediately. Please believe me when I say that I can appreciate the passion and conviction you show, but I just think that it can be done in a more inclusive fashion and without the hubris.
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
p.s. a simple "my original post was too strongly worded and I should not have misrepresented my opinion as fact or demeaned those who disagree" would shut me up immediately. >>
Gosh, I hate it when nice people are right! Okay, so I took a few liberties with my opinions, but I don't regret my barbs slung at the Marajuana-Drag(on) Lady...is that better?
<< <i>Sure doesn't look like the Anaconda blunder-coin, that thing was concentric toned with the blue in the middle. Would like to see this one in hand first, but lean towards NT with very little premium for the color. JMHO. >>
I concur and based on the image I believe it to be NT - seeing it in hand would be very helpful in making a definative statement. But the Pink-Magenta and yellow combination is a correct NT color combination and leads me to conclude NT.
Edited to add: The toning and eye-appeal (perhaps the lack of eye-appeal) do not render this coin anywhere near a 4 figure coin. I have not been impressed with TT's images, and for that reason I seldom bid on TT coins.
I also read through this entire thread and conclude that Doug's enthusiasim seems to have irked many and consequently the thread became an argument over ego's. Doug is a founding member of TCCs, but neither he (nor I, or any other member) represent the opinions of other members. We often disagree on our opinions as to what's real and what's memorex, but we do tend to strongly agree on which toned coins are truly exceptional. This particular coin is at best a "B" toned coin, and not exceptional.
Collecting eye-appealing Proof and MS Indian Head Cents, 1858 Flying Eagle and IHC patterns and beautiful toned coins.
“It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so.” Mark Twain Newmismatist
p.s. a simple "my original post was too strongly worded and I should not have misrepresented my opinion as fact or demeaned those who disagree" would shut me up immediately. >>
Gosh, I hate it when nice people are right! Okay, so I took a few liberties with my opinions, but I don't regret my barbs slung at the Marajuana-Drag(on) Lady...is that better? >>
A step in the right direction, at least. Thank you...Mike
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
<<I concur and based on the image I believe it to be NT - seeing it in hand would be very helpful in making a definative statement. But the Pink-Magenta and yellow combination is a correct NT color combination and leads me to conclude NT.>>
I agree with this and awlays have...it became a chest thumping issue by a self proclaimed expert representative of TCCS that his and only his opinion was final! Then for good measure, he threw the rest of your guild into the fray by proxy.
<<Stop by and see the TCCS website at Tonedcoins.org, the friendliest coin forum in cyberspace.>>
For this statement to be accurate and true, me thinks you need to corral a cowboy and teach him some of the things associated with your sig line so when he visits outside the TCCS realm he is reminded just what he represents.
BTW,I did not agree or disagree with UofA.I simply stated that i would have to see the coin in hand,and could not make a determination from the TT images.
Great coins are not cheap,and cheap coins are not great!
<< <i>BTW,I did not agree or disagree with UofA.I simply stated that i would have to see the coin in hand,and could not make a determination from the TT images. >>
Lloyd, I beg to differ - based upon Doug's posts/words, you clearly and markedly disagreed with him. Unlike you, he didn't need to see the coin in hand to be 100% certain.
<< <i>BTW,I did not agree or disagree with UofA.I simply stated that i would have to see the coin in hand,and could not make a determination from the TT images. >>
Doug wrote:
<< <i>The pictures are more than sufficient to determine NT without a doubt. >>
I would say your statement flat out disagrees with Doug. This thread took on its life because of Doug's absolute statements, suggesting that those of us who could not make an absolute NT determination from the image didn't know the first thing about toning. He stated that the vast majority of TCCS founding members would make the same determination from the image. To date, not one has made an absolute NT determination from the image. All have been knowledgeable enough to know that making such a statement would exclude them from expert status. Which of course, Doug is so self proclaimed. Basically, Doug has lost any bit of credibility with me in this thread. TomB, and the others have all responded with responsible posts on the topic.
<< <i>if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
That attitude is precisely why a lot of collectors get screwed, and buried in crap coins.
Russ, NCNE >>
That attitude is also why a lot of collectors score big time with incredibly awsome and gorgeous originally toned coins. >>
Like this one? >>
For every one mishap, there are thousands of scores! >>
No, Dizzy, that's just not the case. Please cite some examples where someone scored BECAUSE a coin was in a holder. The scores I have for holdered coins come from sellers who don't know what they have, or poor images where the color isn't shown anything like it is viewed in hand. Sure, I might be more likely to buy the coin because it's slabbed, but I rarely buy a piece when I question its color; I've passed on plenty of beautifully toned pieces because I don't think the graders got it right. Similarly, there are times when I think the graders got it right, and the seller just didn't photograph it well.
I certainly agree with Russ--the registry has caused people to look at numbers and not coins. Then, they get stuck with expensive labels and crappy coins. Period.
<< <i><<I concur and based on the image I believe it to be NT - seeing it in hand would be very helpful in making a definative statement. But the Pink-Magenta and yellow combination is a correct NT color combination and leads me to conclude NT.>>
I agree with this and awlays have...it became a chest thumping issue by a self proclaimed expert representative of TCCS that his and only his opinion was final! Then for good measure, he threw the rest of your guild into the fray by proxy.
<<Stop by and see the TCCS website at Tonedcoins.org, the friendliest coin forum in cyberspace.>>
For this statement to be accurate and true, me thinks you need to corral a cowboy and teach him some of the things associated with your sig line so when he visits outside the TCCS realm he is reminded just what he represents. >>
Woody - Our forums are quite friendly - however, neither I nor anyone else can control what or how any member expresses his opinion, just as these forums don't control or censure what you state or your opinions here. I don't think you represent the collective opinion of all Collectors Universe forum members anymore than Doug represnts the the collective opinions of TCCS members - We all have our own opinions, and we are all free to express them in a public forum. As I understand it - that's what a public forum is about - the ability to express your opinions - whether wise and informative, or inarticulate and clueless. With regard to the latter, I am of the opinion that some should exercise some thought before they push the "send button"
Collecting eye-appealing Proof and MS Indian Head Cents, 1858 Flying Eagle and IHC patterns and beautiful toned coins.
“It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so.” Mark Twain Newmismatist
<< <i><< if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
That attitude is precisely why a lot of collectors get screwed, and buried in crap coins.
Russ, NCNE >>
That attitude is also why a lot of collectors score big time with incredibly awsome and gorgeous originally toned coins. >>
You know, Dizzy, you really don't have a clue. I've handled thousands of coins that "passed muster" at PCGS and NGC and I've seen many that you couldn't pay me to own. And, it goes way beyond just toners. Dogs come in all shapes, whether they be white, toned or otherwise. There is a lot of material that has a nice grade on the label and a piece of crap in the plastic.
Collectors who think that just because a TPG has offered an opinion that a coin is all there, and thus it must be so are in for a huge shock when selling time arrives.
<< <i>BTW,I did not agree or disagree with UofA.I simply stated that i would have to see the coin in hand,and could not make a determination from the TT images. >>
Lloyd, I beg to differ - based upon Doug's posts/words, you clearly and markedly disagreed with him. Unlike you, he didn't need to see the coin in hand to be 100% certain. >>
Mark,I stand corrected.I cant agree based on that image.I do respect his opinion,even if its not the same as mine.Better?
Great coins are not cheap,and cheap coins are not great!
You know, Dizzy, you really don't have a clue. I've handled thousands of coins that "passed muster" at PCGS and NGC and I've seen many that you couldn't pay me to own. And, it goes way beyond just toners. Dogs come in all shapes, whether they be white, toned or otherwise. There is a lot of material that has a nice grade on the label and a piece of crap in the plastic
Well said....
My style is impetuous, my defense is impregnable !
<< <i>You know, Dizzy, you really don't have a clue. I've handled thousands of coins that "passed muster" at PCGS and NGC and I've seen many that you couldn't pay me to own. And, it goes way beyond just toners. Dogs come in all shapes, whether they be white, toned or otherwise. There is a lot of material that has a nice grade on the label and a piece of crap in the plastic
Well said.... >>
I think common sense and a good eye goes a long way. Some have it, some don't.
I was not going to respond but since this thread is by no means dead, I've decided to take another look.
In regards to your response Newmismatist
1.) neither I nor anyone else can control what or how any member expresses his opinion, True, but does a statement like this fit the definition of an opinion?
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely".
estimation, belief, probable, opinion...any one of these words used in the context would have been fine. The use of "absolute" is no longer an opine.
2.) just as these forums don't control or censure what you state or your opinions here True, to a point until the moderator sees fit to pull the plug.
3.)I don't think you represent the collective opinion of all Collectors Universe forum members No I do not, and would never be so brazen to do so.
4.)anymore than Doug represents the collective opinions of TCCS members
Not according to Doug: I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
I just had to reiterate these technicalities.
I’m sure you have a fine web site, I shall have to stop by one day and take a look. Pleasant response btw, nice to have met a calm poster for a change.
<< <i>You know, Dizzy, you really don't have a clue. I've handled thousands of coins that "passed muster" at PCGS and NGC and I've seen many that you couldn't pay me to own. And, it goes way beyond just toners. Dogs come in all shapes, whether they be white, toned or otherwise. There is a lot of material that has a nice grade on the label and a piece of crap in the plastic
Well said.... >>
I think common sense and a good eye goes a long way. Some have it, some don't. >>
That's absolutely nothing like the post that sparked Russ' comment:
<< <i> if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
While we love you Russ and extend open arms to you.......only a select few had the experience and paid for the privledge of being considered founding fathers of the TCCS organization. I came in toward the end of the creative process but showed an ample supply of enthusiasm and eagerness to share what I knew and learn from the collective group, so Ron and company were generous enough to allow me the oppertunity to become a FF. Some may not be very impressed with the status.....and frankly it means more in our innner circle of friends and collectors......but I am still honored none the less.
For WoodenJefferson
<< <i> 4.)anymore than Doug represents the collective opinions of TCCS members
Not according to Doug: I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter. >>
The fact that Doug insinuated that he could speak for the TCCS does not make it so....I believe that was the point Ron was trying to make.
I will reiterate, the Anaconda coin was blatantly AT, and this one looks NT. I really can't imagine why people get so fired up and personal about issues like this. If you don't like toned coins, DON'T BUY THEM. It's that simple. Leave them all for me and my fellow collectors who appreciate them. Actually, we won't give you much choice; we will outbid you every time, as those of us who like beautiful toning will be willing to pay premiums for it. (I paid $23000+ for my sigline 1880-S PCGS MS68, and recently turned down a bona fide offer of $30000 for the coin.)
I trust my own competence to determine which ones to buy, and which ones to avoid. I might make a few mistakes here and there, but I bet you'll make some mistakes buying overgraded white widgets once in a while too. We all make a few mistakes ... but they are outweighed by the beauty of the sets we create. And I take the beauty contest challenge any day: put a complete set of beautifully toned coins next to a set of high-grade white coins, and I guarantee you the toned coins will win the eye appeal contest.
<<< I really can't imagine why people get so fired up and personal about issues like this. If you don't like toned coins, DON'T BUY THEM. It's that simple. >>>
Sunnywood, That is NOT what got anyone here fired up. What got a few people upset and fired up was the fact that some inexperienced nitwit claimed to the forum that he was an "expert" on toned coins, and that anyone who would not agree with his accessement was basically a fool, and also that he was some member of a "guild" and that everyone or most everyone in this guild would certainly agree with and back up his expert opinion. In addition to his false and outright laughable claims, he also acted very condescending to others that did not immediatly share his "expert" opinion.
<I really can't imagine why people get so fired up and personal about issues like this. If you don't like toned coins, DON'T BUY THEM. It's that simple. Leave them all for me and my fellow collectors who appreciate them. Actually, we won't give you much choice; we will outbid you every time, as those of us who like beautiful toning will be willing to pay premiums for it.>
<< <i><<< I really can't imagine why people get so fired up and personal about issues like this. If you don't like toned coins, DON'T BUY THEM. It's that simple. >>>
Sunnywood, That is NOT what got anyone here fired up. What got a few people upset and fired up was the fact that some inexperienced nitwit claimed to the forum that he was an "expert" on toned coins, and that anyone who would not agree with his accessement was basically a fool, and also that he was some member of a "guild" and that everyone or most everyone in this guild would certainly agree with and back up his expert opinion. In addition to his false and outright laughable claims, he also acted very condescending to others that did not immediatly share his "expert" opinion.
Sunnywood, That is NOT what got anyone here fired up. What got a few people upset and fired up was the fact that some inexperienced nitwit claimed to the forum that he was an "expert" on toned coins, and that anyone who would not agree with his accessement was basically a fool, and also that he was some member of a "guild" and that everyone or most everyone in this guild would certainly agree with and back up his expert opinion. In addition to his false and outright laughable claims, he also acted very condescending to others that did not immediatly share his "expert" opinion
My style is impetuous, my defense is impregnable !
<< <i>Every time I see that MS66 dollar above I think NGC should get rid of the * (star thing), its in the eye of the be-holder----BigE >>
NGC would never do that now -- pursuit of the coveted "star" likely channels a lot of toned coin submissions over to NGC instead of PCGS. >>
Agreed. Never fully understood the star either. Some coins you sit there and wonder why the hell it got one and others why the hell they DIDN'T get one. Might be NGC's way of telling us "hey, this is a purdy coin!".
Whether the Peace posted in the first post is AT/NT, it's still ugly to me. Hell, I love toned coins too! But if it were my money I'd stay away.
WTB: Eric Plunk cards, jersey (signed or unsigned), and autographs. Basically anything related to him
Comments
<< <i>MikeInFL - 0/4? man, you need to take some accounting classses! My count is at best 5/1 and at worst 2/2/2! Go back and do a recount (Bushmaster, Sunnywood, etc.) But, your cool with me since you don't attack personally. >>
I may need to brush up on my accounting, but I believe my reading comprehension and counting skills are more than sufficient here.
You said:
Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT. Anyone who stated otherwise does NOT know the first thing about natural toning.
You followed that up with:
I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
My contention is that of the founding members that have posted to this forum (not incuding yourself), not a single one -- 0 for 4 -- have agreed with your first assertion, and therefore the second one is incorrect.
Specifically, KryptoniteComics disagreed when he said said:
I don't know if this coin is AT or NT from the image but I can see the colors and toning pattern fairly well so if Doug feels he can see enough to give it a 100% seal of approval then I am ok with that......but that is certainly his opinion. I would also submit that their are probably others in the TCCS that would indeed agree with his assessment but I personally prefer to see a coin in hand before leverage the full weight of my opinion on a coin.
Next, Hadleydog disagreed with your assertions when he said:
Hey guys, as a fouding member of the TCCS boards let me start by saying I personally can't make the call between a good AT job and NT from a scan/image and be 100% positive................. anymore than I can accurately grade from the same format.
Thirdly, TomB disagreed with your comments when he said:
My opinion is that I would not buy this Peace dollar if raw, I would not buy this Peace dollar if certified and I am not at all convinced that the overall body of toning that this coin represents would be considered natural to me. The apparent pink, off-green, ubiquitous yellow and possible placement of blue disturb me as does the overall "feel" of the reverse image.
Lastly, bestclsr1 disagreed with you when he said:
My opinion is that I would not buy this Peace dollar if raw, I would not buy this Peace dollar if certified and I am not at all convinced that the overall body of toning that this coin represents would be considered natural to me. The apparent pink, off-green, ubiquitous yellow and possible placement of blue disturb me as does the overall "feel" of the reverse image.
By my count, not a single one agreed that this coin was [i[Inarguably and absolutely 100% NT -- that's 0 for 4.
Therefore, are you suggesting four founding members of the TCCS do NOT know the first thing about natural toning, and/or do you still stand by your statements concerning your viewpoint that your view is representative of the vast majority of the guild in this matter.?
Or shall I start the personal attacks now?
Take care...Mike
p.s. a simple "my original post was too strongly worded and I should not have misrepresented my opinion as fact or demeaned those who disagree" would shut me up immediately.
<< <i>Or shall I start the personal attacks now?
Take care...Mike
p.s. a simple "my original post was too strongly worded and I should not have misrepresented my opinion as fact or demeaned those who disagree" would shut me up immediately.
Gosh, I hate it when nice people are right!
<< <i>Sure doesn't look like the Anaconda blunder-coin, that thing was concentric toned with the blue in the middle.
Would like to see this one in hand first, but lean towards NT with very little premium for the color. JMHO. >>
I concur and based on the image I believe it to be NT - seeing it in hand would be very helpful in making a definative statement. But the Pink-Magenta and yellow combination is a correct NT color combination and leads me to conclude NT.
Edited to add: The toning and eye-appeal (perhaps the lack of eye-appeal) do not render this coin anywhere near a 4 figure coin. I have not been impressed with TT's images, and for that reason I seldom bid on TT coins.
I also read through this entire thread and conclude that Doug's enthusiasim seems to have irked many and consequently the thread became an argument over ego's. Doug is a founding member of TCCs, but neither he (nor I, or any other member) represent the opinions of other members. We often disagree on our opinions as to what's real and what's memorex, but we do tend to strongly agree on which toned coins are truly exceptional. This particular coin is at best a "B" toned coin, and not exceptional.
“It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so.” Mark Twain
Newmismatist
<< <i>
<< <i>Or shall I start the personal attacks now?
Take care...Mike
p.s. a simple "my original post was too strongly worded and I should not have misrepresented my opinion as fact or demeaned those who disagree" would shut me up immediately.
Gosh, I hate it when nice people are right!
A step in the right direction, at least.
I agree with this and awlays have...it became a chest thumping issue by a self proclaimed expert representative of TCCS that his and only his opinion was final! Then for good measure, he threw the rest of your guild into the fray by proxy.
<<Stop by and see the TCCS website at Tonedcoins.org, the friendliest coin forum in cyberspace.>>
For this statement to be accurate and true, me thinks you need to corral a cowboy and teach him some of the things associated with your sig line so when he visits outside the TCCS realm he is reminded just what he represents.
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
<< <i>NT or AT? >>
I have no idea, nor do I care. I find it a bit ugly.
"Cool-ugly" rather than "Plain-Old-Ugly", to be sure- it is interesting- but not my cup of tea.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
<< <i>
<< <i>if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
That attitude is precisely why a lot of collectors get screwed, and buried in crap coins.
Russ, NCNE >>
That attitude is also why a lot of collectors score big time with incredibly awsome and gorgeous originally toned coins.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
That attitude is precisely why a lot of collectors get screwed, and buried in crap coins.
Russ, NCNE >>
That attitude is also why a lot of collectors score big time with incredibly awsome and gorgeous originally toned coins.
Like this one?
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
That attitude is precisely why a lot of collectors get screwed, and buried in crap coins.
Russ, NCNE >>
That attitude is also why a lot of collectors score big time with incredibly awsome and gorgeous originally toned coins.
Like this one?
For every one mishap, there are thousands of scores!
In the real world, for every one score, there many, many passes. Admittedly, things might be different in Color Coin Fantasy Land.
<< <i>Color Coin Fantasy Land >>
Needs a TM
Color Coin Fantasy Land™
<< <i>BTW,I did not agree or disagree with UofA.I simply stated that i would have to see the coin in hand,and could not make a determination from the TT images.
Lloyd, I beg to differ - based upon Doug's posts/words, you clearly and markedly disagreed with him. Unlike you, he didn't need to see the coin in hand to be 100% certain.
<< <i>BTW,I did not agree or disagree with UofA.I simply stated that i would have to see the coin in hand,and could not make a determination from the TT images.
Doug wrote:
<< <i>The pictures are more than sufficient to determine NT without a doubt. >>
I would say your statement flat out disagrees with Doug. This thread took on its life because of Doug's absolute statements, suggesting that those of us who could not make an absolute NT determination from the image didn't know the first thing about toning. He stated that the vast majority of TCCS founding members would make the same determination from the image. To date, not one has made an absolute NT determination from the image. All have been knowledgeable enough to know that making such a statement would exclude them from expert status. Which of course, Doug is so self proclaimed. Basically, Doug has lost any bit of credibility with me in this thread. TomB, and the others have all responded with responsible posts on the topic.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
That attitude is precisely why a lot of collectors get screwed, and buried in crap coins.
Russ, NCNE >>
That attitude is also why a lot of collectors score big time with incredibly awsome and gorgeous originally toned coins.
Like this one?
For every one mishap, there are thousands of scores!
No, Dizzy, that's just not the case. Please cite some examples where someone scored BECAUSE a coin was in a holder. The scores I have for holdered coins come from sellers who don't know what they have, or poor images where the color isn't shown anything like it is viewed in hand. Sure, I might be more likely to buy the coin because it's slabbed, but I rarely buy a piece when I question its color; I've passed on plenty of beautifully toned pieces because I don't think the graders got it right. Similarly, there are times when I think the graders got it right, and the seller just didn't photograph it well.
I certainly agree with Russ--the registry has caused people to look at numbers and not coins. Then, they get stuck with expensive labels and crappy coins. Period.
<< <i>For every one mishap, there are thousands of scores!
MR. Expert, Jr., so happy to see your continued support with respect to this issue. You, sir, are no "cut-and runner!"
respectfully,
just another wannabe
<< <i><<I concur and based on the image I believe it to be NT - seeing it in hand would be very helpful in making a definative statement. But the Pink-Magenta and yellow combination is a correct NT color combination and leads me to conclude NT.>>
I agree with this and awlays have...it became a chest thumping issue by a self proclaimed expert representative of TCCS that his and only his opinion was final! Then for good measure, he threw the rest of your guild into the fray by proxy.
<<Stop by and see the TCCS website at Tonedcoins.org, the friendliest coin forum in cyberspace.>>
For this statement to be accurate and true, me thinks you need to corral a cowboy and teach him some of the things associated with your sig line so when he visits outside the TCCS realm he is reminded just what he represents. >>
Woody - Our forums are quite friendly - however, neither I nor anyone else can control what or how any member expresses his opinion, just as these forums don't control or censure what you state or your opinions here. I don't think you represent the collective opinion of all Collectors Universe forum members anymore than Doug represnts the the collective opinions of TCCS members - We all have our own opinions, and we are all free to express them in a public forum. As I understand it - that's what a public forum is about - the ability to express your opinions - whether wise and informative, or inarticulate and clueless. With regard to the latter, I am of the opinion that some should exercise some thought before they push the "send button"
“It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so.” Mark Twain
Newmismatist
<< <i><< if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
That attitude is precisely why a lot of collectors get screwed, and buried in crap coins.
Russ, NCNE >>
That attitude is also why a lot of collectors score big time with incredibly awsome and gorgeous originally toned coins. >>
You know, Dizzy, you really don't have a clue. I've handled thousands of coins that "passed muster" at PCGS and NGC and I've seen many that you couldn't pay me to own. And, it goes way beyond just toners. Dogs come in all shapes, whether they be white, toned or otherwise. There is a lot of material that has a nice grade on the label and a piece of crap in the plastic.
Collectors who think that just because a TPG has offered an opinion that a coin is all there, and thus it must be so are in for a huge shock when selling time arrives.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>BTW,I did not agree or disagree with UofA.I simply stated that i would have to see the coin in hand,and could not make a determination from the TT images.
Lloyd, I beg to differ - based upon Doug's posts/words, you clearly and markedly disagreed with him. Unlike you, he didn't need to see the coin in hand to be 100% certain.
Mark,I stand corrected.I cant agree based on that image.I do respect his opinion,even if its not the same as mine.Better?
Well said....
<< <i>You know, Dizzy, you really don't have a clue. I've handled thousands of coins that "passed muster" at PCGS and NGC and I've seen many that you couldn't pay me to own. And, it goes way beyond just toners. Dogs come in all shapes, whether they be white, toned or otherwise. There is a lot of material that has a nice grade on the label and a piece of crap in the plastic
Well said.... >>
I think common sense and a good eye goes a long way. Some have it, some don't.
In regards to your response Newmismatist
1.) neither I nor anyone else can control what or how any member expresses his opinion,
True, but does a statement like this fit the definition of an opinion?
I am an expert in the field and this one is a no brainer NT...others with similar experience and expertise will agree with me "inarguably and absolutely".
estimation, belief, probable, opinion...any one of these words used in the context would have been fine. The use of "absolute" is no longer an opine.
2.) just as these forums don't control or censure what you state or your opinions here
True, to a point until the moderator sees fit to pull the plug.
3.)I don't think you represent the collective opinion of all Collectors Universe forum members
No I do not, and would never be so brazen to do so.
4.)anymore than Doug represents the collective opinions of TCCS members
Not according to Doug: I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
I just had to reiterate these technicalities.
I’m sure you have a fine web site, I shall have to stop by one day and take a look. Pleasant response btw, nice to have met a calm poster for a change.
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
I'm member number 9.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>You know, Dizzy, you really don't have a clue. I've handled thousands of coins that "passed muster" at PCGS and NGC and I've seen many that you couldn't pay me to own. And, it goes way beyond just toners. Dogs come in all shapes, whether they be white, toned or otherwise. There is a lot of material that has a nice grade on the label and a piece of crap in the plastic
Well said.... >>
I think common sense and a good eye goes a long way. Some have it, some don't. >>
That's absolutely nothing like the post that sparked Russ' comment:
<< <i> if it's in a TPG slab, it has passed the proverbial mustard... or is it muster. >>
<< <i>BTW, what exactly is a "founding member"? I guess I must be since:
I'm member number 9.
Russ, NCNE >>
While we love you Russ and extend open arms to you.......only a select few had the experience and paid for the privledge of being considered founding fathers of the TCCS organization. I came in toward the end of the creative process but showed an ample supply of enthusiasm and eagerness to share what I knew and learn from the collective group, so Ron and company were generous enough to allow me the oppertunity to become a FF. Some may not be very impressed with the status.....and frankly it means more in our innner circle of friends and collectors......but I am still honored none the less.
For WoodenJefferson
<< <i>
4.)anymore than Doug represents the collective opinions of TCCS members
Not according to Doug: I would wager that almost every TCCS founding member would agree with my assessment. So, it is not just one person - I believe I represent the vast majority of the guild in this matter.
>>
The fact that Doug insinuated that he could speak for the TCCS does not make it so....I believe that was the point Ron was trying to make.
I trust my own competence to determine which ones to buy, and which ones to avoid. I might make a few mistakes here and there, but I bet you'll make some mistakes buying overgraded white widgets once in a while too. We all make a few mistakes ... but they are outweighed by the beauty of the sets we create. And I take the beauty contest challenge any day: put a complete set of beautifully toned coins next to a set of high-grade white coins, and I guarantee you the toned coins will win the eye appeal contest.
Best,
Sunnywood
Sunnywood's Rainbow-Toned Morgans (Retired)
Sunnywood's Barber Quarters (Retired)
Sunnywood, That is NOT what got anyone here fired up. What got a few people upset and fired up was the fact that some inexperienced nitwit claimed to the forum that he was an "expert" on toned coins, and that anyone who would not agree with his accessement was basically a fool, and also that he was some member of a "guild" and that everyone or most everyone in this guild would certainly agree with and back up his expert opinion. In addition to his false and outright laughable claims, he also acted very condescending to others that did not immediatly share his "expert" opinion.
You get it now??
Well said!
<< <i><<< I really can't imagine why people get so fired up and personal about issues like this. If you don't like toned coins, DON'T BUY THEM. It's that simple. >>>
Sunnywood, That is NOT what got anyone here fired up. What got a few people upset and fired up was the fact that some inexperienced nitwit claimed to the forum that he was an "expert" on toned coins, and that anyone who would not agree with his accessement was basically a fool, and also that he was some member of a "guild" and that everyone or most everyone in this guild would certainly agree with and back up his expert opinion. In addition to his false and outright laughable claims, he also acted very condescending to others that did not immediatly share his "expert" opinion.
You get it now?? >>
Well said
<< <i>Well said
Well said
The keyword here is "expert". Many others here I'm guessing are novices. ...Just guessing of course.
<< <i>
<< <i>Well said
Well said
I had to hurry mine Mike so my post would follow right behind dizzy's
(Stoke it up) Doug
<< <i><he also acted very condescending to others that did not immediatly share his "expert" opinion. >
The keyword here is "expert". Many others here I'm guessing are novices. ...Just guessing of course.
I missed something...
-D
-Aristotle
Dum loquimur fugerit invida aetas. Carpe diem quam minimum credula postero.
-Horace
<< <i>Every time I see that MS66 dollar above I think NGC should get rid of the * (star thing), its in the eye of the be-holder----BigE >>
Good point.
<< <i>Every time I see that MS66 dollar above I think NGC should get rid of the * (star thing), its in the eye of the be-holder----BigE >>
NGC would never do that now -- pursuit of the coveted "star" likely channels a lot of toned coin submissions over to NGC instead of PCGS.
<< <i>
<< <i>Every time I see that MS66 dollar above I think NGC should get rid of the * (star thing), its in the eye of the be-holder----BigE >>
NGC would never do that now -- pursuit of the coveted "star" likely channels a lot of toned coin submissions over to NGC instead of PCGS. >>
Agreed. Never fully understood the star either. Some coins you sit there and wonder why the hell it got one and others why the hell they DIDN'T get one. Might be NGC's way of telling us "hey, this is a purdy coin!".
Whether the Peace posted in the first post is AT/NT, it's still ugly to me. Hell, I love toned coins too! But if it were my money I'd stay away.
Positive BST: WhiteThunder (x2), Ajaan, onefasttalon, mirabela, Wizard1, cucamongacoin, mccardguy1
Negative BST: NONE!
And people wonder why someone would stoop to doctoring coins!
<< <i> paid $23000+ for my sigline 1880-S PCGS MS68, and recently turned down a bona fide offer of $30000 for the coin.)
And people wonder why someone would stoop to doctoring coins! >>
An authorized PCGS dealer, and a contributor to the Red Book.