I agree with you guys! I had subscribed for 2 sets based on the 160K mintage (and I thought I over did it), but now with +260K mintage, I'm canceling my subscription especially at this price.
Not hot. Bullion value within a couple years. > @WALLE said:
ATS shows 63000
Ok I will stir the pot. A possible short strike here, I had no intention on buying these but I will watch this figure. Being the end of the year and declining sales and interest, it could happen. Maybe a diamond in the rough. Nobody knows what the ending mintage will be at this point!! I truly could care less how this plays out but we need an interesting story to end the year.
Lately the mint has been very odd. Although they finally straightened out my account and I can order now after over a month delay, they have been sending me emails about successful shipping on a 2027 reverse proof product and just today the diamond field set.
I am waiting until 8 days before the actual release date to determine whether I cancel. Probably will.
Anybody get these strange emails?
**Good news — the shipment for your #USM25315*** placed on 10/09/26 has been confirmed. Thank you for shopping with the official U.S. Mint.
Morgan and Peace Dollar Diamon wo-Coin Reverse Proof Set Enr
@Manorcourtman said:
Not hot. Bullion value within a couple years. > @WALLE said:
ATS shows 63000
Ok I will stir the pot. A possible short strike here, I had no intention on buying these but I will watch this figure. Being the end of the year and declining sales and interest, it could happen. Maybe a diamond in the rough. Nobody knows what the ending mintage will be at this point!! I truly could care less how this plays out but we need an interesting story to end the year.
Yeah. Not really a hot take, given that anything could always be "a possible short strike" if demand does not materialize. That does not make it worth taking a shot on every single thing the Mint produces, because it's either hot out of the box, or could be later if the mintage turns out to be a fraction of the maximum.
The Mint didn't bump the maximum up from 160K to 260K just to do a head fake on us and only produce 63K. They will produce to demand, up to 260K. And, the irony is that they will be lucky to sell 160K, so they should have just left the maximum mintage alone and given us something to actually want.
I have faith in aftermarket.
If you search fleabay for recent Morgan & Peace issues they trade just above spot.
Gifts that get converted back to cash.
These 2026 mintages rival 2023.
The USMINT still offers some 2023 but inflated to 2026 prices
I cancelled my sub.
My money has gone into better stuff.
The Mint has already emptied my wallet nicely with previous 2026 stuff. No regrets.
I suspect that after the fact, if I am at all interested, reduced prices can be found on other venues. Even now on fleabay, graded 69 slab sets are selling for below the $375 price of just about $15 above it.
Afraid I missed another fabulous offering, but did pick up 8 ounces of silver ( generic) today, for about the same cost as the “diamond” set. A good day was had by all, I hope.
Diplomacy is what it takes to get out of what tact would have kept you out of.
@TwoSides2aCoin said:
Afraid I missed another fabulous offering, but did pick up 8 ounces of silver ( generic) today, for about the same cost as the “diamond” set. A good day was had by all, I hope.
Yep, I had cancelled my sub for these fancy nail files and bought a 2 ounce high relief St. Gaudens coin from Intaglio Mint. $128 for a perfect and finely minted piece of silver. They do such brilliant quality work.
@TwoSides2aCoin said:
Afraid I missed another fabulous offering, but did pick up 8 ounces of silver ( generic) today, for about the same cost as the “diamond” set. A good day was had by all, I hope.
Yep, I had cancelled my sub for these fancy nail files and bought a 2 ounce high relief St. Gaudens coin from Intaglio Mint. $128 for a perfect and finely minted piece of silver. They do such brilliant quality work.
The elite Intaglio Mint, producers of such fine classic silver as "cosmic cat"? Just teasing !! 😆😆😆
Collect what catches your eye
Really...I own some weird stuff myself
I was out on this issue but decided to get 1 just to see it. I have all the other types so... Shrug... If it's not immediately awesome will return it and buy after market if prices correct.
@MsMorrisine said:
I thought those receiving discounts couldn't undercut the mint by dealer agreement
I was thinking the same 🤔
Looks like the "undercut" rule only applies to products that have been discounted.
Is it possible that this specific item was not offered to NBPP members at a discount?
@MsMorrisine said:
I thought those receiving discounts couldn't undercut the mint by dealer agreement
I was thinking the same 🤔
Looks like the "undercut" rule only applies to products that have been discounted.
Is it possible that this specific item was not offered to NBPP members at a discount?
No way. Not with that mintage. Dealers never would have ponied up.
My guess would be that either they are not enforcing that, OR everyone is agreeing that coins in slabs are not the same product, so the rule doesn't apply.
I am pretty sure that all bulk products are, by definition, discounted. If the product is "hot" and not discounted, I don't think it's made available to bulk dealers at all. The Advance Purchase program is something else entirely, given that those coins are sold at a premium, not a discount.
Comments
Why can't you believe it? Because they've never done it before? 🤣🤣🤣
I agree with you guys! I had subscribed for 2 sets based on the 160K mintage (and I thought I over did it), but now with +260K mintage, I'm canceling my subscription especially at this price.
These are DOA at the stated mintage
These are DOA at the current price.
Agree...mint fatigue is real
ATS shows 63000
Passing on this one as well.
Not hot. Bullion value within a couple years. > @WALLE said:
Ok I will stir the pot. A possible short strike here, I had no intention on buying these but I will watch this figure. Being the end of the year and declining sales and interest, it could happen. Maybe a diamond in the rough. Nobody knows what the ending mintage will be at this point!! I truly could care less how this plays out but we need an interesting story to end the year.
Here's the 2026 Retro Bucks mintages & nothing on the Diamond Finish pair:
Lately the mint has been very odd. Although they finally straightened out my account and I can order now after over a month delay, they have been sending me emails about successful shipping on a 2027 reverse proof product and just today the diamond field set.
I am waiting until 8 days before the actual release date to determine whether I cancel. Probably will.
Anybody get these strange emails?
**Good news — the shipment for your #USM25315*** placed on 10/09/26 has been confirmed. Thank you for shopping with the official U.S. Mint.
Morgan and Peace Dollar Diamon wo-Coin Reverse Proof Set Enr
$0.00**
Yeah. Not really a hot take, given that anything could always be "a possible short strike" if demand does not materialize. That does not make it worth taking a shot on every single thing the Mint produces, because it's either hot out of the box, or could be later if the mintage turns out to be a fraction of the maximum.
The Mint didn't bump the maximum up from 160K to 260K just to do a head fake on us and only produce 63K. They will produce to demand, up to 260K. And, the irony is that they will be lucky to sell 160K, so they should have just left the maximum mintage alone and given us something to actually want.
Looking forward to this set.,
I just paused my subscription. went from 10 to 5 to 1, and then thought about it & would rather save my money on this product.
Nov 6th 151am & my three subs are now cancelled, 6 days before 11-12 release.
Silver is in low $50 so I'd get about $250 in silver for just $1,150.
I really like the designs but I can't justify the $375 price point.
"Mistakes are always forgivable, if one has the courage to admit them" Bruce Lee
I really want this set and seeing them scheduled for 2027 less excited.
262,500 mintage was deflating.
I lowered it to one from 5, i'd like to have one just to keep.
Successful BST:here and ATS, bumanchu, wdrob, hashtag, KeeNoooo, mikej61, Yonico, Meltdown, BAJJERFAN, Excaliber, lordmarcovan, cucamongacoin, robkool, bradyc, tonedcointrader, mumu, Windycity, astrotrain, tizofthe, overdate, rwyarmch, mkman123, Timbuk3,GBurger717, airplanenut, coinkid855 ,illini420, michaeldixon, Weiss, Morpheus, Deepcoin, Collectorcoins, AUandAG, D.Schwager, blu62vette, morgan13, torinoCobra71, JWP, promethius88,
I have faith in aftermarket.
If you search fleabay for recent Morgan & Peace issues they trade just above spot.
Gifts that get converted back to cash.
These 2026 mintages rival 2023.
The USMINT still offers some 2023 but inflated to 2026 prices
I cancelled my sub.
My money has gone into better stuff.
The Mint has already emptied my wallet nicely with previous 2026 stuff. No regrets.
I suspect that after the fact, if I am at all interested, reduced prices can be found on other venues. Even now on fleabay, graded 69 slab sets are selling for below the $375 price of just about $15 above it.
ats 85,358 as of this morning.
"ats": 85358,
Same today
Just canceled both subscriptions. Way too many available….and I’ll just buy graded 70’s on eBay for guaranteed nice ones.
Canceled mine the other week
My cc was hit on 11-7-26 you were lucky to be able to cancel
Just for the record, I cancelled mine too. Price/mintage is way too high.
Gary TheGasMan - Retired Hank Hill
100,993 stamped out as of a couple days ago, 161,000 to go...
I was thinking the same 🤔
🇺🇸 Harlequin
harlequinnumismatic@gmail.com
Home of the Americana Collection of USA silver coins
Around 11am, pre-sale, I got an email saying my 2 sets shipped already. ???
Fine by me. Efficient anyway.
Placed the order for just 1 set. $375 for $110 worth of silver is outrageous, IMO.
"ats": 149503,
But it's not just "$375 for $110 worth of silver", it's $375 for $110 worth of rare silver.
Oh, wait a minute.
I cancelled my subscription before I even signed up for it. It's an interesting set but I'll let others fully appreciate it.
I forgot about my subscription... I guess I bought a set of these.
Collector, occasional seller
Folks can always return them. No big deal.
The court jester does not play, but gently pulls the strings…
Returns are not as liquidy split as they have been in the past as some are reporting up to six months.
Wow !
Too bad you can’t return for credit if you are a avid US mint coin buyer..
The court jester does not play, but gently pulls the strings…
Afraid I missed another fabulous offering, but did pick up 8 ounces of silver ( generic) today, for about the same cost as the “diamond” set. A good day was had by all, I hope.
Diplomacy is what it takes to get out of what tact would have kept you out of.
Yep, I had cancelled my sub for these fancy nail files and bought a 2 ounce high relief St. Gaudens coin from Intaglio Mint. $128 for a perfect and finely minted piece of silver. They do such brilliant quality work.
I think you won ! Time will tell
How many were sold today ?
The elite Intaglio Mint, producers of such fine classic silver as "cosmic cat"? Just teasing !! 😆😆😆
Collect what catches your eye
Really...I own some weird stuff myself
I was out on this issue but decided to get 1 just to see it. I have all the other types so... Shrug... If it's not immediately awesome will return it and buy after market if prices correct.
Now this is laughable.
Rick said this will be huge......he could sell anything from what I've seen.
RCTV Link
Guess so if you can sell an ms70 proof set
Looks like the "undercut" rule only applies to products that have been discounted.
Is it possible that this specific item was not offered to NBPP members at a discount?
Source: https://www.usmint.gov/content/dam/usmint/help/bulk-purchase-agreement-form-508.pdf
Market making isn't dead afterall
No way. Not with that mintage. Dealers never would have ponied up.
My guess would be that either they are not enforcing that, OR everyone is agreeing that coins in slabs are not the same product, so the rule doesn't apply.
I am pretty sure that all bulk products are, by definition, discounted. If the product is "hot" and not discounted, I don't think it's made available to bulk dealers at all. The Advance Purchase program is something else entirely, given that those coins are sold at a premium, not a discount.
Gentlemen,
https://trackthemint.com/
Cool website. Has anyone verified those #'s vs the mints ATS?