Can anyone explain to me how this is not staged?
CalifornianKing
Posts: 1,259 ✭✭✭✭
This video claims that this 1917 quarter is worth $1000? 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OrqXUDDHiFo&t=153s
Because the price guide only lists $1000 at MS64/65 and that ain't it. I would be surprised if it graded as a MS coin at all.
Thoughts?
2
Comments
at around 3:04 it seems to have a lot of luster but from the video it is tough to know one way or the other. i watched this one a couple weeks ago and for sure isn't the standard interaction for the show. also, if a professional from pcgs, ngc, anacs, icg, segs etc says an item is unc, ( i don't recall if he actually says that) then odds are pretty high it is. i also bet from a T.V. that is a rather lovely coin with some possible light rainbow toning obv/rev.
your question, how it is not staged. this has been discussed at length here and it is a tv show, obviously there is some scripting and editing. to just film people off the street in such an environment simply cannot work. i've been in too many shops and at too many shows to know that much. collectables/lack of knowledge/money/emotions is a total recipe for disaster and is a train only but the most seasoned and patient dealers can keep from going off the rails.
It's pawn stars...it's ALL staged.
All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.
Well, all of these reality shows are staged, of course, but it looks like a pretty nice coin from the video.
Our own @ThePennyLady, Charmy, went on this same show and sold something non-coin related. Maybe she'll stop by and share her experience.
It does look like a great coin. It just doesn't seem like a $1000 coin. And I am not sure about you, but if I thought a coin was a $1000 coin, i would not set it down on the velvet because it may cause minor hairlines, or use my bare hands, I would use gloves.
Yea. Well I guess I'm extra careful. And idk why he overpaid for it. Coin shops/pawn shops pay less than retail... I guess he just overpaid and got burned again.
Yes I was on Pawn Stars a few years ago and some of the show is staged. For instance, the tidbits of knowledge that the Pawn Star guy imparts during the episode is researched and fed to them by the producers, and the people walking around in the background are actually extras since they clear out the store whenever they do filming.
However, the actual negotiations between me and the Pawn Star personality (in my case it was Corey) was real including the sale of my item, which was a WWII aerial bomber camera with original film inside.
Here's the clip to my episode: https://youtu.be/uRst1TqM8Qw
The Penny Lady®
I'm trying to think of a time when I remember a professional using gloves, and I can't come up with one. If you know how to hold a coin, you're more likely to cause damage by dropping it because you don't have a good a grip with gloves than you are to do any damage directly with your fingers. When I was last at the Smithsonian they asked me to wear gloves when I was handling large gold bars (which don't have small edges the way coins do) and that was fine (used latex), but otherwise, I only handle coins with my bare hands. If you don't slide a coin on velvet, you aren't going to damage it.
The stars who make out on this show in terms of profits are the core group like Rick, at tens of thousands per episode. An MS66 FH is under $1K on GS, so not sure how the pricing by the NGC guy is accurate unless it was an old episode. And no pawn shop pays that kind of money for a raw coin like this.
It's Reality T.V. Get a grip. I have a good friend who lives in Taos, New Mexico who was on a show like that. She was picked-up by a limo at the airport in New York. The first thing the driver did was to hand her a list of the questions she would be asked on the show.......WITH THE ANSWERS!!!!!! She had a great time. The whole thing was FAKE! It was the Jerry Springer Show.
Show Biz.
The guy selling the coin has also been on other episodes
From what I read in the comments, his "grandad" died at least 6 times so far.
Unfortunately, the video has been removed from YouTube.
When I click on the link, the video is still there.
It's also on my website towards the bottom of this page:
https://thepennylady.com/the-penny-lady-story/
The Penny Lady®
Video unavailable
This video contains content from A+E Networks, who has blocked it in your country on copyright grounds.
perhaps you can still see it because it is your account.
vpn time
https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/comment/11091544#Comment_11091544
ha. was fun to see the pic of charmy and corey!
tanks
what do you mean by this?
I thought that video was going to de-bunk these experts. It only verified the fact that they are, indeed experts.
I guess it's always possible to mess up an appraisal. I've seen counterfeit and doctored coins in third party holders.
As far as having no idea what they're talking about, i didn't see that at all......
Some of their experts are real experts....I sold a rare certified counterfeit Colonial note on ebay to one of their experts, stupidly I did a no reserve auction which is guaranteed to be a low result for the seller.
People who believe most of the stuff on reality TV also believe there will be an Oak Island treasure, and those guys in Alaska will strike it rich..... Of course it is staged... Cheers, RickO
.
Perhaps this will help - here's a link to the original thread about my episode on Pawn Stars:
https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/comment/10500531#Comment_10500531
The Penny Lady®
Didn't know that. Yep. I'd like her take on it too.
Pete
MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
Edited to add that I didn't see the above reply.
DUH
Pete