Options
2019 s Silver Eagle Enhanced Reverse Proof - Post your guess for ebay prices 11/14
engmtic
Posts: 139 ✭✭✭
The 1995 W has similar mintage and it looks like the value is 2k plus... So even if you factor in silver eagle fatigue due to the mints
constant churning of new issues, I think it should still be around 1k... What do you guys think? Any reason this would not do that well?
I know there are a bunch of threads on this coin but this is price specific...
0
Comments
I will try to get one out of the gate...though likely will not succeed....If not successful, I will wait until the flipping fever dies down.....Cheers, RickO
Looks like current auctions sold are in the $500 range
You giving something away ? 😁
bragging rights
trying to use crowd wisdom to see if i should lock in one of these offers to pre sell to or take the risk and hold on to it
$65.95
You win
there will be a race to the bottom - starting at 500 and will land around 300. always happens.
The 1995 W has come down, granted, but still commands 2k I think, so why should this one only be worth less than 25% of that? Just curious as to your reasoning.. Is it because many of the 1995 w are stuck in the gold sets while these will be flipped more so more supply?
many raw presales for $900 and NGC 70s for $3500 have already sold
I wouldn't sell one at $500 or even $700.
What if you had two?
The desperate ones sell now, then the real price will be established over time. Look at the prices for this coin after 10 years.
2008 w silver eagle reverse 2007
That had 47,000 coins released, and it is where this one is starting out already. 30,000 is much less. This coin is also selling 30,000 not due to low demand, but due to low supply. The 70 coins will be over $1500 so dealers will pay to get those.
Good basis for comparison. I'm not so knowledgeable but there might be a difference (aside from mintage) in that the 2019 - s issue is an official part of the series as opposed to a variety. I assume (might be totally wrong here) completionists will need this issue but not necessarily want/need a variety/error.
“...who need it for their registry set NOW, who won't wait 6 months or 10 years.”
This.
Driving factor for many of the early sales, IMO... and those who have to have a complete collection NOW.
Additionally, with the registry and with all the ties, getting that certificate number in before others will solidify their placement on the registry by the time entered.
With offers to buy at $500 ( and I consider that a good offer) I know these guys ( on the dealer network) know more than me so they see the price going well over $500. With that said we ain't got coins yet.
The 95W used to be valued at a lot higher than it is now. It was the King for years.. I remember seeing them for 5K. Well, now that this new coin is going to be out in the world, the 95W prices have dropped. the 95W was only available in the 4 coin gold set for 1995 as I recall. So you had to pony up for the whole (5 coin) set to get it. Very speedy, thus the lower mintage.. Many sets were broken up, so the original unbroken set will still be a good one. This coin, I'm not sure about long term. It may be the first of many with similar mintages. It will be a flippers dream sort term. So good luck to all who try.
As a long time US mint subscriber, I will offer this advice.. Set up an account and go buy something cheap before the sale date. Make sure all your address and phone numbers and credit cards are spot on they way they want them. This will increase the speed at check out. The less time going through the screens the more likely you are to get one of these coins in the bag and order placed..
The court jester does not play, but gently pulls the strings…
I sold a 95W for $400 and thought the guy was nuts ( it was a free coin).
TMI
When I look at all the S and W coins in proof and "specimen", etc. out this year I think this one becomes a member of the whole clan. I agree with the 500 level however & hope as a COLLECTOR, non-flipper to get a single example.
Well, just Love coins, period.
This PCGS 70 already "sold" for $1900: https://ebay.com/itm/2019-S-PCGS-SILVER-EAGLE-ENHANCED-REVERSE-PROOF-PF70-FIRST-STRIKE-PR70/202817965047?hash=item2f38e48bf7:g:ZYkAAOSwSeVdxYTz
Prices trending downwards on ebay.. about 400-450 now for sold listings.
And a TON of available listings! I dont remember **ever **this many "pre sales" 3 days before
This is very sobering.
Between a friend and I we will try to get three, likely to keep only one. For me, a fast 300% profit is a better bet than waiting long term to see what happens.
Prices dropping until many presales go unfilled then prices rise to get live coins. Amounts are a variable. IMO
or artificial price manipulation - it pays for dealers to sell some low to set the new price level low so they can buy low. Or weak hands.
If 70s turn out to be a high percentage of submissions do you think the price will be much lower?
From NEW USM Press Release -
"The 2019 American Eagle Once Ounce Silver Enhanced Reverse Proof Coin WILL NOT be available at the Mint’s sales centers in Washington, D.C.; Philadelphia; and Denver."
The presales on ebay are absolutely insane, almost 1 sold every 2-3 minutes last hour or so.
All the guesses here are FAR too conservative IMO. I think this 750+ easy tomorrow
presales are always less. and 90% of the sellers are <50 feedback. The few established sellers >500 feedback that I noticed went for 500-600.
When it sells out in 4-5 minutes tomorrow as it surely will, prices will spike nicely. Just my fun guess/prediction. We'll see...almost there now
5.....hours and counting until showtime.
I'm buying some Depends, I refuse to take a chance having to leave my computer for ANYTHING!!!
I think 70s will end up netting 1500 and 69s maybe 700. Worth the grading cost.
976 sets and counting, have been sold on ebay as of 1:20 EST.
Isn't there a ebucks promo ending today? Surprised so many listings are under bullion.
Why? Aren't the return rules different for items under bullion than under just coins (non-bullion)?
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
I'm surprised at the latest auction related closing prices. All the way up to over $700+ These are not BIN'S.
Ebay seller that had his delivered this morning just sold for $800 after listing.
He probably could have got $999.99