Options
What do you think about this eagle?
Exbrit
Posts: 1,520 ✭✭✭✭
What do you think about this eagle? Especially between the stars across from the L in Liberty and between the stars above the L. Also beneath the wing between the D and Left wing on the reverse.
Also - GTG
Thanks

1
Comments
Really nice 64+, all coins are net graded
11.5$ Southern Dollars, The little “Big Easy” set
There is a touch of haze between stars 7-8 and under "trust" on the reverse. 63 no sticker, even if it is quite lustrous.
I do see what you are refering to, looks a little off color in those areas. Are you thinking putty or a plug? It's straight graded I presume and looks to be ok from the pics. Does it have a sticker?
The obverse spot does look rounded though.
Successful BST:here and ATS, bumanchu, wdrob, hashtag, KeeNoooo, mikej61, Yonico, Meltdown, BAJJERFAN, Excaliber, lordmarcovan, cucamongacoin, robkool, bradyc, tonedcointrader, mumu, Windycity, astrotrain, tizofthe, overdate, rwyarmch, mkman123, Timbuk3,GBurger717, airplanenut, coinkid855 ,illini420, michaeldixon, Weiss, Morpheus, Deepcoin, Collectorcoins, AUandAG, D.Schwager, blu62vette, morgan13, torinoCobra71, JWP, promethius88,
Tough crowd
11.5$ Southern Dollars, The little “Big Easy” set
I wasn't thinking putty, not sure maybe haze.
I like it for a 64. Nice Lib..
64 camp here also!
I'll wait until a few more comment and reveal the grade along with the grades two respected dealers gave after viewing only the second set of photos tomorrow.
Putty is much to do about nothing. It is easily removed, doesn’t hurt the coin and is only tragic when you need to pull it out of older holders to clean it. A modern holder like that is easily replaced.
11.5$ Southern Dollars, The little “Big Easy” set
What Crypto said. Besides, who is going to putty these areas. Based on the coloration and luster, looks like this coin took a slight dip at one point. So, just a guess, but those areas might be dip residue.
Is it also below TRUST, and below Star 7?
I think it is minor water spotting. Shouldn't affect the grade, MS-64.
Low end 64
Latin American Collection
I like it.
Lance.
Putty is much to do about nothing until you have been duped into paying a strong price for smooth looking coin in a higher than deserved grade which turns on you in a year's time. Then it's a problem for you and the grading company if the firm backs its guarantee. Sure, the stuff can be removed, but who knows what is under it? Chances are the coin will come back in a lower grade with more obvious marks.
The reverse looks like water or dip residue... The obverse, on the head... not so sure.... if not residue, it could be a problem... Otherwise, a nice gold coin.... Cheers, RickO
I personally don't care for gold.
my first thought was that it looks like there is putty on it or some kinda residue...so pass for me. pcgs doesn't guarantee those any more...you have to pay for it. they would clean it and put it in the same grade holder...speaking from experience.
Looks like a water spot. MS65
My YouTube Channel
It's got a "Cheeky" hit, but pretty clean and shiny.
64 with that plus thingy.
Pete
Hmmm...it's a nice Eagle. If the OP does not like it, please send it my way....I'll pay postage, too!
@Crypto said: "Putty is much to do about nothing. It is easily removed, doesn’t hurt the coin and is only tragic when you need to pull it out of older holders to clean it. A modern holder like that is easily replaced."
"Putty" is a fraudulent surface alteration that plagued "SOME" TPGS until it was detected and became "missed completely" or "market unacceptable." Those coins cost folks money! Some are still out there in collections and they have now turned color to a bluish haze. Sure, it didn't hurt the gold alloy, but it did turn semi-dogs and AU coins into purdy putty pieces. Too bad.
IMO, this is an example of an AU-50 gold coin with what many would consider either a "market acceptable" putty ALTERATION or not know the surface was altered.
As for the OP's coin: My personal MS-63. I'll bet it would be a "lock" 64 if not for the cheek hit; however, I'll bet it is in an MS-63+ or 64 slab. One of my teachers drummed it into my head that there was a lot of space left in the MS grades above MS-64. That lesson never caught on with me.
I didn’t say it was cool, I said it was not a big deal. Once it is dry it is easy to see not only it but the damage it covered
11.5$ Southern Dollars, The little “Big Easy” set
Looks nice, I don't know these too well but I'm going to say 65.
Collector, occasional seller
Very nice arms-length eye appeal, but some action here and there makes me think 63ish overall
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
We have two winners - PCGS MS65. The spots I believe maybe water spots, but I am not confident on it. The two respected dealers graded it off the second set of images MS63 and MS65.
It looks really nice in hand. I think I'll keep it.
The Eagle has landed. Nice keeper.
For me, too much chatter for an MS-65. I'm in the MS-64 camp.
Agreed the luster is there but too many distraction be it stains, smutzh or dings. Stand by my 64+
11.5$ Southern Dollars, The little “Big Easy” set
I'll PM my address for the giveaway. Thanks!
My YouTube Channel
More than 15 years ago, NGC graded this one MS-65. At the time I thought that was 1 point too high. Now when I look at common date eagles in the MS-65 grade this piece fits right in with them quite easily.
@BillJones That's nice!
My YouTube Channel
Thank you!
I bought that one from Stacks' over the counter in the mid 1960s. It was their "Choice Uncirculated" over just "Uncirculated." The difference in price between the two was $3. How times have changed!
Nice! It's cool that you've kept it all this time.
My YouTube Channel
64