Options
So you think because you have a top set listed here, your set is one of the best in country??
Well, with exception, I doubt it. Look, the numbers just do not add up. Considering all the coins graded by PCGS in a given series and compare that to the number of registry sets. Even for my series, the Lincoln Cent, there are rather few considering the popularity. There are too many coins simply unaccounted for. By this I mean as we watch coins got to auction, many simply do not “appear” in any set after they have been sold. How many threads have you read here of someone trying to track down a coin no one can find? Look at Lauras clients, I am sure she would say these folks do not play the registry game. Ever checked a wow coin and did a certification check and found it not registered? I know there are lots of reasons as to why it may not be but you have to ask, are we looking stupid here to some folks on the outside who have sets that dwarf the top sets here? I say yes there are many sets that if they were registered here; would take numerous number one spots.
What says you?
WS
Proud recipient of the coveted PCGS Forum "You Suck" Award Thursday July 19, 2007 11:33 PM and December 30th, 2011 at 8:50 PM.
0
Comments
Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
Soooo, I would say you are correct for most series. BUT, if you are a person that participates here and always buys the POP TOP coins...I doubt you have much to worry about because you already have the pop tops. Just sayin'. I doubt there is much out there RAW, just waiting one day to be graded and blow all of the POP TOPS away. Buy pop tops and you don't have a lot to worry about.
Not really looking for much these days but if I were, it might be a toner.
-- 1 is the only example PCGS has graded in any grade.
-- 4 of them have a total pop at PCGS (all grades combined) of just two.
-- 1 of them has a total pop at PCGS (all grades combined) of just three.
-- 4 of the six coins I own have a higher PCGS pop of 0.
So yes, I think mine IS one of the best sets in the country.
Many members on this forum that now it cannot fit in my signature. Please ask for entire list.
World Collection
British Collection
German States Collection
I personally think there too many plastic driven ego maniacs building sets because of the registry concept.
"Might" is a word that I considered pretty carefully before answering the OP's question, even though it is one that brings wildly unlimited possibilities into play -- possibilities that are both impossible to account for or to exclude. On the other hand, at some point we have to make some logic-based assumptions. For instance; no records are known to still exist about how many of these coins were originally made. Since they were made one at a time using hand presses, and since a single coin represented approximately the entire monthly wage of a highly skilled laborer at the time (the reference example I found was for a stone mason), I am assuming that no lost bag (or whatever bulk unit they originally came in) still exists.
The OP's question asks if we think our sets are "one of the best in the country"; he didn't say anything about having the #1 set, nor did he say anything about collectors elsewhere in the world. To the best of my knowledge, I have assembled the largest database of actual auction results for my series that exists. To date I have just 75 results for all 8 coins in the set. A minority of them are from Heritage or Stack's or Bowers. In doing my personal research with world coin dealers, there has been strong agreement that few of these coins appear to be in the U.S. Few of the dealers have ever handled a single example, so it seems clear that those which do exist are most likely in Europe.
Interestingly, bullion metal prices in Europe escalated sharply about a decade after my coins were minted, to the point where actual metal content of the coins was about 30% higher than their face value. Melting of them seems logical to have occurred... but to what extent? None of them? Nearly all of them? Both are possibilities, but I'm inclined to say that "none" wasn't what happened. And in the following 400+ years, how many other bullion price spikes occurred that would have encouraged more melting? The word "might" again comes into play... as in there might not be a whole lot of these coins that still exist.
Then comes the aspect of getting the coins into holders. Nearly four and one-half centuries of being around is a LOT of time for them to have been cleaned or otherwise abused to the point that no leading TPG will encapsulate them, even being as lenient as they are with such relics. For the 8 coins that are in the seven-date set, PCGS has graded a grand total of 12 examples, so I have half of the entire PCGS population for the entire series. There might be thousands of additional coins out there... or there might not be. Maybe none of them could get into a holder... or maybe they all could. It is clear that there are other coins out there. Where they are is the question, but my money is on Europe. It is also clear that higher grade examples than mine exist for every single date in the series, because I have seen catalog photos of them. Less clear, though, is whether anyone else has (or is trying to assemble) an entire collection of them. A few notes I have seen in auction lot descriptions lead me to believe they are most commonly collected as a type coin.
This is why I am sticking with "yes" as my answer to the OP's question.
Many members on this forum that now it cannot fit in my signature. Please ask for entire list.
Most serious large cent collectors disdain plastic coffins.
<< <i>Registry link here. >>
What a lovely set.
Beautiful, unique and historical.
"Inspiration exists, but it has to find you working" Pablo Picasso
<< <i>Registry link here. >>
Awesome set.
Successful Trades: Swampboy,
Eric