The Baseball HOF Registry Thread

rustywilly · March 24, 2010 10:10AM

Hello Scott-

Just came across this thread as I don't visit the forums as much as I used to. It's always nice to meet another HOF collector. Keep pluggin' away. Your collection is fantastic!

Very nice cards everyone. I never get tired of looking at these things.

Here are a few of my favs:

Thanks for letting me share.

Regards,
Mark

vbellier · March 24, 2010 9:29PM

Wow Mark, that Ruth looks better than 2. Thanks for sharing.

scotgreb · March 25, 2010 1:22AM

Mark -- those cards are tremendous -- and I love the diversity.

That's what I enjoy most about this registry set -- the freedom to include such unique cards. I don't believe I've ever seen that McPhee.

I recall an article about your collection in SMR -- can't remember many of the details but I remember being impressed and envious.

Thanks and please continue to share.

Scott

divecchia · March 27, 2010 4:00AM

Scott, nice pickups on the most recent HOF inductees...

Mark, I never get tired of looking through you collection of HOF portraits. I always see something different. The diversity of your set is simply amazing...

By the way Mark, I love the recent changes you've made to your website. By clicking on each portrait it gives a closeup of the cards and a biography of the HOF inductee and other cool info. I recommend you guys check it out...

Donato

divecchia · April 2, 2010 4:59PM

My latest pickups. All three are new type cards for me.

Enjoy...Donato

scotgreb · April 16, 2010 12:08PM

Well done Donato . . . I love the color and the 3-D effect of the Kiner.

I just upgraded my '57 Frank Robinson (from a poorly centered PSA 3). I might have overpaid a bit for this one but the centering is exceptional -- especially for this card.

divecchia · April 23, 2010 7:52AM

Scott, thanks for your kind words. I appreciate it. I really like the Kiner, too because of the off color background. Usually the background is more of an orange-red color. This one is more of a pink color.

Congrats on your upgrade of Frank Robinson, it's a nice looking card...

Donato

scotgreb · April 29, 2010 2:55AM

This is a new type card for me although not a very attractive issue IMO.

I added it essentially as an inexpensive filler until I decide on my favorite Medwick card. - Scott

divecchia · April 29, 2010 5:30PM

Scott, congrats on the new type card for your HOF set...

Donato

divecchia · May 2, 2010 12:34PM

My latest pick up for my HOF set...

A new type for me...Donato

purelyPSA · May 3, 2010 4:51AM

Donato - that's a nice one!

divecchia · May 11, 2010 7:58AM

Steve...

Thanks for the compliment on the Kelly, I appreciate it.

Here is my newest edition and a new type for the HOF set...

Donato

scotgreb · May 19, 2010 3:06AM

Just added to the HOF Registry . . .

Produced in conjunction with an early sports card and memorabilia show in Chicago held by the Chicagoland Collectors Association.

paleocards · May 25, 2010 5:11AM

Let's get this thread back on the first page...

Here are my most recent pick-ups. I feel a bit guilty using these cards to fill in the 19th century and pre-war holes in my set, but they're affordable in high-grade and are rarely graded (the Kelley, Connor, Beckley and Keefe are all Pop 1s with none higher). These six additions moved me up to #10 in the All-Time Finest list, ahead of Soloway, 707 and Marshall Fogel! My grades on 15 Shakey's Pizza HOFers recently popped (you can see the raw images one page back) and I'll share those on this thread after I get the cards in-hand and scanned.

mikeschmidt · May 25, 2010 5:14AM

This is one of my latest acquisitions:

paleocards · June 8, 2010 6:31AM

My newest addition (and first tobacco card in my collection):

divecchia · June 8, 2010 7:55AM

Marc...Love the intensity in Klein's face, nice pickup...

Paleocards...The Wallace has great looking borders and a very clean back, I'm surprised it did not grade higher. Nice addition...

Donato

scotgreb · June 16, 2010 3:48AM

I just replaced my 1968 Carew (Rookie Trophy) with one of my favorite childhood cards . . .

I'm nearly always partial to the trophy cards but this one holds great memories.

Scott

rustywilly · June 16, 2010 4:20PM

I would like to extend a very big THANK YOU to Scott (scotgreb) for my latest addition. This item was waiting for me at the post office when I returned home from a business trip. This is one of the nicest gifts I've ever received, a wonderful suprise that holds a special place in my collection.

paleocards · June 18, 2010 10:00AM

My grades came in on the 15 Shakey's Pizza HOFers I submitted back in March (you can see the images of the raw cards one page back in this thread). Very pleased overall: 2 PSA 7's, 9 PSA 8's, 2 PSA 8.5's and 2 PSA 9's. Here are the highlights:

WeekendHacker · June 18, 2010 5:16PM

Very cool thread, I just added this set to my registry. There are a few names of individuals (probably umpires) that I've never even heard of. This could get interesting.

scotgreb · July 21, 2010 10:33AM

Been chasing this one for a while . . . it's the only solo Kuhn card (his only other is a 1977 Padres Schedule card with Randy Jones).

Story has it that Topps made this specially for Kuhn -- I've seen print run numbers as low as 200. At any rate, I think it's a pretty cool card.

divecchia · July 23, 2010 3:26AM

Scott...

Nice pickup on the Kuhn...

I've heard the same thing regarding it's scarcity.

Donato

scotgreb · August 12, 2010 12:20PM

My latest pickup (from the National) . . . my first and only Polar Bear

divecchia · August 12, 2010 12:58PM

Scott, nice pickup...

Love the T206 Polar Bear.

Donato

paleocards · August 21, 2010 7:41AM

Very cool Three-Finger, Scott!

Focused my National buying/submitting on cards that would improve my HOF Players set, as well as adding to my type-set diversity (Ultimate PSA Sampler registry set). I have to admit I've been inspired by the amazing number of different sets represented in Donato's collection. As a result I now have the oldest 8 in my collection (1935 Diamond Stars "Stonewall" Jackson) and oldest 9 as well (1951 Topps Blue Back Bobby Doerr). As you'll see below, I've added representatives from 1952 Bowman and 1953 Bowman Color too.

And the one I went up to Baltimore for:

I also subbed 15 HOFer 1974 Laughlin Old-Time Black Stars from a raw set I won from Steve Hart in April. I love this set and a number of these cards are arguably these players' RCs since they have no other baseball cards until the retro set boom of the last decade. Here are the five that graded highest (all are now Pop 1's with none higher):

And finally this one, which is now the only 10 from this set (247 total cards graded):

I can't describe how excited I was when I pulled this card from the PSA box on Friday afternoon at the show, it's the only 10 I've ever received from a sub. All in all, a great National!

divecchia · August 22, 2010 4:16AM

Scott...

Love the Polar Bear backs they are one of my favorites. Nice pickup on the T206 Brown...

paleocards...

Glad I could be of inspiration in building your set, but I must give credit to Mark (rustywilly) for the idea of utilizing as many sets as possible in putting the HOF set together. He was my inspiration. Great job on your National pickups. I really like Feller and the Reese is a classic. I also like the colors on the Diamond Stars Jackson. I don't have a Diamond Stars card in my set, but hope to include one at some point. Congrats on your nice range of pickups.

A BIG CONGRATS on your PSA 10 Martin Dihigo. Always a proud moment to get your first 10.

I was equally excited when I got this Dihigo back from PSA at the Nationals.

Here are a few others that I crossed over or picked up at the Nationals. All new types. Enjoy...Donato

paleocards · August 22, 2010 5:19AM

Thanks Donato. Your Dihigo is an amazing card, where did you find it raw in the first place? And I love that Anson; it looks like the National was good to you too!

Andy

divecchia · August 22, 2010 5:40AM

Andy...

Thanks for your praise on the cards.

I found the Dihigo at the Nationals at Ryan Christoff's booth who sells a lot of Cuban, Venezuelan and other Latin American cards. It was not raw, it was an SGC 40/3. I was told PSA would not grade it better than a PSA 2 because of the staining on the back. PSA is more strict on centering and staining when grading cards than SGC.

The Anson, was a crossover also. I love the image on it and it presents very well, but the pin hole gives it an automatic PSA 1.

Donato

scotgreb · September 18, 2010 8:55AM

It's been I while since I checked in but it looks like a few folks have added some nice cards.

I just upgraded my T206 Clarke Portrait (PSA 1) to this . . .

I'm generally partial to portraits but there is something about this card that I really like.

divecchia · September 18, 2010 9:05AM

Scott, nice pick up on the Clarke...

I love the colors on it and the clarity of the image...

Congrats on the upgrade...Donato

scotgreb · September 20, 2010 9:23AM

Very excited with my latest pickup . . . I've been looking for this card in a presentable low grade for a while.

I've never sent in a card for review but considering this one.

divecchia · September 20, 2010 5:27PM

Scott, that's a great looking DiMaggio...

I agree that the grade is little harsh and it is reveiw worthy.

Congrats...Donato

paleocards · September 22, 2010 1:55AM

Beautiful Clarke and JoeD cards, Scott, congrats!

BPorter26 · September 24, 2010 10:12AM

Scott, pretty Clarke. Congrats

Scarlem21 · September 28, 2010 5:27AM

Good stuff guys! I started one of these sets this week and I'm in 76th place to start.
How do you guys collect this set? Vintage cards or modern cards? Anything goes with this set!!
Check out what I have so far:
My Hall Of Fame Player Set (jb217676)

scotgreb · September 28, 2010 11:00AM

Scarlem -- Welcome and congrats on starting the set . . .

There are actually two HOF Complete Registry Sets. The set titled "Hall of Fame Complete" is for playing years cards only -- so mostly vintage cards are required for completion. It currently has 252 slots, i.e., 40 HOFers do not have playing year cards, although new "finds" are added to the set occasionally. Most are negro leaguers and pioneers. Conceptionally, I like this set more than the other, which it titled "Hall of Fame Players, Managers, Owners, Executives, Pioneers, Commissioners & Umpires" -- for that set, any graded card is eligible to fill the slot. The upside is that there is a slot for all 292 HOFers, which makes for a true "complete" set.

I focus primarily on the playing years set but recently have started adding cards of the 40 other players toward completion of the other. Ultimately, I'd like to have a playing years card of all that are possible and fill in the remainder with modern cards. The downside of this is that a there are several HOFers that have relatively few and expensive playing years cards.

Good luck and please keep us posted on your progress.

Scott

paleocards · October 1, 2010 11:26AM

Scarlem,

Welcome to HOFer collecting and this thread. Nice start on the HOF player set and I appreciate you taking the time and making the effort to provide scans of all your cards. I've been working on this set for over four years and I'm now #6. I've tried to collect the 1950s-present players during their playing years, but the pre-war, 19th century and negro leaguers are too tough, scarce and expensive for my budget in high grade so these players are mostly represented by 1950 Callahan, 1961 Golden Press, 1960 & '61 Fleer and 1974 Laughlin (for many of the Negro Leaguers).

However, Scott , Donato and other contributors to this thread have inspired me to go after the old-timers during their playing years so I'll likely be starting the "real" HOFer set after the new year.

Good luck and I look forward to your contributions!

Scarlem21 · October 4, 2010 3:55AM

Thanks guys! (You all can call me Jeff!)

I have about 15 nice vintage playing career cards coming my way that will fill some hole in this set. I'll keep you posted! I also really like the 1974 Laughlin Black Star cards. I would love to pick up a nice raw set if anyone has one for sale.

Scarlem21 · October 13, 2010 4:42AM

My hall of fame players set is up to #63! Still have a bunch more on the way. If interested, click on the link to check out my sets I'm currently working on.

My Sets

divecchia · October 13, 2010 8:26AM

Hi Jeff...

Thanks for sharing your sets and showing them off with scans. I love when the sets include scans as it gives us a chance to see pictures of some cards that we may have never seen before. I also like how diverse your sets are, including hockey and basketball. I guess that way you never get bored as you will always have something different to search for.

You have a good start on your HOF set, keep up the good work...

Donato

scotgreb · October 23, 2010 12:28PM

Tom Yawkey is one of the 40 HOFers without a playing years card (unless you count the 1959 Fleer Ted Williams #42 which PSA does not allow).

I just added this one to my "Complete" Set -- I think these 2003 SPs are beautiful cards . . .

divecchia · October 25, 2010 3:43AM

Hi Scott,

I'm not a huge fan of the newer cards, but that Yawkey card is a real beauty...

Do you know why PSA will not include the Ted Williams card with Tom Yawkey pictured on the front in the HOF set? Is it because Yawkey is not named on the front of the card?

Donato

scotgreb · October 25, 2010 9:56AM

Do you know why PSA will not include the Ted Williams card with Tom Yawkey pictured on the front in the HOF set? Is it because Yawkey is not named on the front of the card?

Donato, I asked the registry folks a while back and following is their response;

"The 1959 Fleer Ted Williams #42 is a Ted Williams card. We do realize that Yawkey is pictured on the card but the card is actually a Ted Williams card. This card is already in use in the Ted Williams slot in the HOF Complete set and has been for a while. A card cannot be used for 2 different slots in the same set"

I'm not sure I agree but didn't press it -- Note that Yawkey's name is on the back.

bxb · October 25, 2010 9:47PM

The same thing happened to me with another card, A fatima team card.

The PSA software only allows a given team card to be entered for one player, whichever one gets requested first, even if that team card has several hall of famers. Likewise with any card that has more than one person, such as the Yawkey card. Why they can't change this software limitation with 21st century technology remains a mystery to me (and to them too, apparently). My guess is that the issue never got past the front lines to the technical staff.

Furthermore, although the folks I corresponded with at PSA were very nice during several email to and fros, they seem to have no interest in fixing this glitch.

Scarlem21 · October 29, 2010 12:41AM

Added a bunch of cards to my set (up to #49). Anybody else make some nice additions?

My Hall Of Fame Player Set (jb217676)

NickM · October 30, 2010 6:32AM

I've argued for inclusion of the Yawkey as well. To the extent that the software doesn't allow the same card to be used in multiple slots, that cries out for a software update. There are quite a few cards featuring multiple HOFers together, and in many of those cases it's no more one player's card than the other's ('35 Goudey, Double Play, Mecca Double Folders, Exhibits 4-in-1, combo cards, NL & AL Leaders, etc.).

Nick

bxb · November 3, 2010 11:08PM

Finally got my Tinker - to finish the big three:

Scarlem21 · November 29, 2010 6:07AM

Picked up a bunch of cards and moved into the 40th spot!

My Hall Of Fame Player Set (jb217676)

divecchia · November 29, 2010 7:02PM

Jeff...

Great job moving up in the rankings, keep it up...

Larry, I really like your three amigos Tinker, Evers and Chance...

Donato

The Baseball HOF Registry Thread

Comments

Categories