I’m looking to learn- What’s the grade of this ‘65 Kennedy half?

SenateSaloon · January 27, 2020 9:15PM

I want to learn more about grading. Who wants to offer an opinion about the grade of this 1965 Kennedy half dollar and tell me what stands out to lead them to that conclusion.

It’s from the 1965 SMS set. Only handled with cloth gloves. Very clean overall. Has an apparent scratch on Kennedy’s cheek, a small surface spot in the field near the “t” and “y” on the obverse, and a small dark spot on the edge of the reverse above the “e” of United.

This is from curiosity about grading, I’m not worried about value. Thanks in advance for your time and thoughts.

thisistheshow · January 27, 2020 9:30PM

I'm not a grading expert.
But I like to help.

These pics all look quite different. I might be wrong, so someone else correct me please, but you should start by making sure the pictures reflect the way the coin looks in hand. I think that would help with grading.

AUandAG · January 27, 2020 9:31PM

Can we get pics without so much light? Scratch on nose/cheek will be a limiting factor for sure. Reverse looks PL but not so sure about obverse.
bob

SenateSaloon · January 27, 2020 9:51PM

@AUandAG said:
Can we get pics without so much light? Scratch on nose/cheek will be a limiting factor for sure. Reverse looks PL but not so sure about obverse.
bob

I’m limited by my photographic skills but both sides shine like mirrors (PL) so I’m finding it very hard to take a picture. I’ve added a more recent circulated Kennedy for comparison.

TomB · January 27, 2020 10:24PM

If the mark on JFK's cheek is truly a scratch, and not a strikethrough, it would render the coin worth essentially bullion. In this case, that would be in the $2.70 range. I realize you are asking about grade and not value, but that hit is going to really limit any grade and, hence, value.

SenateSaloon · January 27, 2020 10:30PM

@TomB said:
If the mark on JFK's cheek is truly a scratch, and not a strikethrough, it would render the coin worth essentially bullion. In this case, that would be in the $2.70 range. I realize you are asking about grade and not value, but that hit is going to really limit any grade and, hence, value.

Thanks. I generally know what a strike through is, but how can one tell? For a scratch it looks mysteriously smooth. I suppose back to needing better photos. Thanks for your help.

Hemispherical · January 27, 2020 10:40PM

https://www.pcgs.com/photograde/#/Kennedy/Grades

ricko · January 28, 2020 7:15AM

The glare on the pictures makes it really tough.... I do not know much about coin photography (a classic understatement)...However, I have heard people here discuss light filters...You may want to try that to limit the glare. Cheers, RickO

291fifth · January 28, 2020 7:59AM

Grading SMS or Proof coins by photographs is extremely difficult. Yours is an SMS (Special Mint Set) coin. Coins like this really have to seen in hand.

291fifth · January 28, 2020 8:09AM

@Attumra said:
I have a few of these GEM like highly reflective Kennedys I got off eBay. I was wondering if it was possible that people dip the coins in what ever metal to cover up old scratches etc. and call it PL? Is that even possible?

NO.

cheezhed · January 28, 2020 8:25AM

67

SenateSaloon · January 28, 2020 3:24PM

Thanks for the input.

BillJones · January 28, 2020 3:56PM

@cheezhed said:
67

Really? Did you miss the deep scratch on the face?

My grade would be Uncirculated sharpness, scratched with some probable environmental damage from spots and the patch of what appears to be corrosion in first obverse photo, second photo in the hair.

DFrohman · January 28, 2020 4:59PM

I would give it an MS-72 (or possibly even the unheard of MS-73 with that luster)!
.
.

crazyhounddog · January 28, 2020 5:18PM

I’d like to help but I couldn’t render a guess with these pics. But if I was forced I would go along with @BillJones .

SenateSaloon · January 29, 2020 5:00PM

Here are some closeup photos. Not sure they’ll help with grading but here goes. Includes closeup of the scar on Kennedy’s cheek (maybe a strike through or other problem during minting- doesn’t look like a scratch but not sure) and a neat “string” on the reverse. How could that string/thread be part of the coin?

Peasantry · January 29, 2020 5:34PM

Plated?

Hemispherical · January 29, 2020 5:46PM

This looks like a strikethrough wire or string-like something.

Kind of looks like an edge/reeding hit from another coin.

IMO

SenateSaloon · January 29, 2020 6:03PM

@bombtech25 said:
Plated?

Not plated. I personally removed it from the 1965 SMS set last week. Color is off in photo due to lighting.

cladking · January 29, 2020 6:15PM

@TomB said:
If the mark on JFK's cheek is truly a scratch, and not a strikethrough, it would render the coin worth essentially bullion. In this case, that would be in the $2.70 range. I realize you are asking about grade and not value, but that hit is going to really limit any grade and, hence, value.

These are going for $4.50 each (wholesale) right now.

This specimen is hardly remarkable but it is lightly frosted and should go MS-65 with a little luck.

I think it could get a little premium from the right buyer.

thisistheshow · January 30, 2020 3:57PM

@DFrohman
I learned a lot reading through your Ike thread and the links that were there. This thread could do the same for someone else.

@DFrohman said:
I would give it an MS-72 (or possibly even the unheard of MS-73 with that luster)!
.
.

I think comments like this are unnecessary.

I’m looking to learn- What’s the grade of this ‘65 Kennedy half?

Comments

Leave a Comment

Categories