Which of these do you like more, within the $550-575 pricerange? (AU Pillar dollar vs. CAM 3cN)
lordmarcovan
Posts: 45,441 ✭✭✭✭✭
Here. Let's try this. Had some technical difficulties in trying to post a poll for the first time with this new setup.
(*EDIT: and I also made a typo which went unnoticed for 24 hours and described the 3cN as a DCAM. It is merely a CAM.)
Which of these two do you like more? I realize opinions will differ, and some will be biased towards one category or the other. That's OK. This makes no pretension at being a "scientific" poll in any way.
1761-Mo 8R, PCGS AU50
For sale at $550. Could be mine in an even swap. I might even be able to squeeze the $25 price difference out of the other party, but not much more than that. He paid more for it. Besides, he did very well by me in our previous swap.
1888 3cN, PCGS PR65 CAM
My coin. Purchased from Pinnacle Rarities for $575. I like the other, but I'm perfectly content to keep this one.
Thing is, I can't have both of 'em, much as I would like to. It's gotta be one or the other.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.






















Comments
Keep the three cN. If you have to consult about a trade you really don't want to part with the coin that you already own.
I thought this one was going to be the updated post with pictures.
"A dog breaks your heart only one time and that is when they pass on". Unknown
Technical difficulties with pix and poll. Stand by.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
...
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
3CN
INYNWHWeTrust-TexasNationals,ajaan,blu62vette
coinJP, Outhaul ,illini420,MICHAELDIXON, Fade to Black,epcjimi1,19Lyds,SNMAN,JerseyJoe, bigjpst, DMWJR , lordmarcovan, Weiss,Mfriday4962,UtahCoin,Downtown1974,pitboss,RichieURich,Bullsitter,JDsCoins,toyz4geo,jshaulis, mustanggt, SNMAN, MWallace, ms71, lordmarcovan,JWP,dantheman984,olah_in_MA,USMC_6115
Wow... tough decision LordM..... That being said, if forced, I choose the 1761 Pillar coin.... I am a sucker for big old coins... Cheers, RickO
I agree, tough choice.
So good to see that you're back for the time being.
"If I say something in the woods and my wife isn't there to hear it.....am I still wrong?"
My Washington Quarter Registry set...in progress
In my opinion, the 8 reales is much cooler and in keeping with the anything goes philosophy of your collection.
Which one do you like more? Your opinion and only your opinion is the one that counts.. I like the big old pillar dollar, just because l like big old pillar dollars. You can pick up an 1888 three cent nickel anytime. I do not know how many 1761 pillar dollars are on the market, most likely though not too many. If you are not date specific you could wait for a better deal. JMO.
Bob
That's a nice wholesome Pillar dollar if the truview pics are close. The 3 center is not so nice as 3 centers go in my opinion. Use the PCGS priceguide in your negotiations! You should be able to do better than $25!
I vote for the Pillar Dollar!
I like the look of the pillar Dollar!
Wow, that pillar dollar is nice. If I was spending those dollars, I would go for age, look, history, size of the pillar dollar over the trickle.
I really like them both and it was a hard choice. But I went with that beautiful 3c proof.
I am not much into "Dark Side" coins...nor proofs...but between the two...buy American!
BST transactions: dbldie55, jayPem, 78saen, UltraHighRelief, nibanny, liefgold, FallGuy, lkeigwin, mbogoman, Sandman70gt, keets, joeykoins, ianrussell (@GC), EagleEye, ThePennyLady, GRANDAM, Ilikecolor, Gluggo, okiedude, Voyageur, LJenkins11, fastfreddie, ms70, pursuitofliberty, ZoidMeister,Coin Finder, GotTheBug, edwardjulio, Coinnmore, Nickpatton, Namvet69,...
I am all about condition and the fact that it is a regular U.S. issue. I like the date, too. 3CN!
Sometimes, it’s better to be LUCKY than good. 🍀 🍺👍
My Full Walker Registry Set (1916-1947):
https://www.ngccoin.com/registry/competitive-sets/16292/
The 3CN is sweet, but I'd take that Pillar Dollar hands down!
My YouTube Channel
I can't help but think of the first coin pictured in the Redbook (maybe not the first) and as a kid learning it was the basis of our dollar and the dollar sign!
At 11-12 years old, I never thought I'd someday own one
Tough call but I like the eye appeal of the 3 Cent piece.
The 3CN has very nice eye appeal imo. It's just a CAM though...not a DCAM as posted. And they've done nothing but decline in value for the past 27 years. I doubt that is going to change as there are just too many of these proofs for the relatively few gem type/gem proof collectors (over 50,000 minted). While I love gem American type coins, I'd lean towards the Pillar dollar, if only because it might have a better long term future. One could say the Pillar dollar has North America or world wide appeal....not quite so for proof 3CN. A Pillar $ dated in the 1700's is probably easier to understand by the general and uninformed public. In late May 1989 PCGS PR65 3CN's were going for $1875.
PCGS pops for Proof 3c nickels is over 22,000......1666 for Pillar dollars. A 13X factor. For your 1761 variety there's only a lone MS specimen at MS61. So figure an AU Pillar dollar is on the order of a superb gem proof 3c nickel. After looking at the numbers, I'd definitely go with the Pillar $. The only thing I don't know is how many Pillars were minted/how many actually survive. You can figure 20,000-40,000 proof 3c nickels remaining. Toss in another 10K for MS specimens. While CAM's in grades of 65 or higher seem to represent 20-50% of slabbed pieces, I'm not sure that even over the long term how the CAMs will hold up. DCAMs are quite scarce though....most of them probably dipped to get there. I "like" the 1888 better for looks and grade. For long term appreciation or "less depreciation," I prefer the Pillar $. USA bust silver dollars have slowly marched higher over the past 75 years. Would Pillar dollars be any different? For another comparison, 14,000+ slabbed US bust dollars vs 1666 PCGS Pillar dollars.
I'll always choose the older coin made for circulation over the newer coin made for collectors.
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
I voted: 1761-Mo MM Mexico 8-reales, Calico-888, PCGS AU50 (for sale @ $550)
Proof 3cN's are really rather available, and you should be able to find another suitable one in the future. Prices on 3cN's don't really accelerate until to you get to rare dates or uber grades. Pillar dollars are available as well, but most are sea-salvaged or otherwise impaired. Unimpaired Pillar dollars get really pricey in PCGS uncirculated grades!
Pillar DOllar
TOUGH one. Liquidity says 3c but my preference would be the 8R.
Even today, the Pillar dollar is pictured early in the Redbook as the lead in for the book's introduction and early American coinage. I remember it as a kid too.
Big coins sell better than esoteric ones.
For me an easy choice. The three cent piece has eye appeal for days and is in a solid collectible grade with no excuses. The 8 reales, though a nice coin for the grade, is a harder sell and is priced $150 over guide to boot. But, what matters in the end is which one you prefer.
RIP Mom- 1932-2012
Tough call for me.
On one hand, I really, REALLY, want a pillar dollar.
On the other, I collect 3CN business strikes, and want one proof as a companion.
But, for ME, I went with the pillar dollar since I want my proof from a "proof only" year, just so it's different than the rest of the set.
That's a distinction that probably doesn't make or break the 3CN for you.....so I'm no help at all.
Not only is the Pillar dollar older, rarer and larger, 1761 is a historic date because that is when the issues around the Revolutionary War started as the British began conducting random searches of property under the writs of assistance.
Going for the 3C ... it's just better looking.
But talk about apples and oranges!
No question. If it were me, I'd take the pillar dollar.
mbogoman
https://pcgs.com/setregistry/collectors-showcase/classic-issues-colonials-through-1964/zambezi-collection-trade-dollars/7345Asesabi Lutho
One way to look at it - how easy would it be to replace those coins? The AU pillar can be obtained in that range relatively easily. Can the 3cN?
The 3cN.
"A dog breaks your heart only one time and that is when they pass on". Unknown
Where have you been LM, or have I just missed your posts?
I like the ones made in 'MERICA!
Pillar dollar all day. 3cN are in such a downward spiral pretty soon they will be selling for less than face value
The cameo proof has some nice toning.
The pillar is a very nice coin too, and with cool history, which judging by other coins you have posted, I expect you like the pillar better.
But my preference is that cameo 3c.
Bst transactions with: dimeman, oih82w8, mercurydimeguy, dunerlaw, Lakesammman, 2ltdjorn, MattTheRiley, dpvilla, drddm, CommemKing, Relaxn, Yorkshireman, Cucamongacoin, jtlee321, greencopper, coin22lover, coinfolio, lindedad, spummybum, Leeroybrown, flackthat, BryceM, Surfinxhi, VanHalen, astrorat, robkool, Wingsrule, PennyGuy, al410, Ilikecolor, Southcounty, Namvet69, Commemdude, oreville, Leebone, Rob41281, clarkbar04, cactusjack55, Collectorcoins, sniocsu, coin finder
Flip for em. Winner of toss gets both.
CORRECTION: The 3cN is a CAM, not a DCAM.
I had a Freudian slip (wishful thinking, apparently) when I typed "DCAM". Duh.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
@roadrunner (and others) - thank you. I appreciate the detailed analysis.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
Two people expressed an interest in the PIllar dollar if I should happen to pass on it. I told them and its seller ("thebigeng") that either of them may have a shot at it, since they're likely to be cash buyers. If the weekend passes and neither one takes it, I told TBE I'd probably go for the swap, even-Steven. So it's all good either way. And I'm happy to inadvertently advertise the Pillar dollar for Mark/TBE, since he's a good guy and I came out smelling like a rose in our last swap. Win-win.
I just wanted some good analysis, like we got here (despite my typos and fumbling with the poll). Thanks again.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
Update: the deal went down. The Pillar dollar is mine now. The proof 3cN has gone to live with another forum member I will kind of miss the pastel loveliness it exhibited in hand, but the Pillar dollar is also nicer in hand than in the pictures.
Both parties have expressed satisfaction with the swap.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
I would have waited for a different pillar dollar
Both nice, if this is about collecting, then I like the 8 reale for sure. All there for a 50.
Best, SH
Id stick with the Pillar Dollar, although I'm not too excited about the scratches in the field on the obverse. I'm not a fan of the toning on the 3cn.
How can you go wrong with a nice example of a 200+ year old coin?
I think a great swap for both of you. I lean towards the Pillar (as you know
) but sounds like a win-win kind of trade.
I have never been a big Nickel Three Cent Piece collector. Once I got the one I needed for the type, I was done. The Pillar Dollar is more historic and interesting to me.
Having said that I already have a 1761 Pillar Dollar, so I would not need two.