Options
What 5 coins best define the history of US coinage?
MGLICKER
Posts: 7,995 ✭✭✭
No more....no less.
1792 and beyond.
You may include Patterns.
1792 and beyond.
You may include Patterns.
0
Comments
1827 bust half dollar
1892-S dime
1937 buffalo nickel
1969 quarter
If there were room I'd throw in a Morgan and a seated coin.
The 3c nickel says a lot about the country as well.
1879 flowing hair stella
1885-CC Morgan
1909-S VDB cent
1965 clad quarter
Eric
1853 Arrows half - end of free coinage of silver into US coinage.
1864 Bronze cent - first token coinage
1933 Eagle - end of gold standard.
1965 Quarter - end of precious metal in coins for circulation.
1794 Silver Dollar - The first U.S. dollar
Classic Head $5 Gold starting August 1834 - The reduction in the official ratio from 15 parts silver to 1 part gold to 16 to 1 made our gold coinage economically viable in the domestic economy and headed us toward the Gold Standard.
Morgan Dollar starting 1878 - It is symbolic battle over for "cheap money" which ultimately pushed the Democrat Party to the left with the rise of William Jennings Bryan. Before then the Democrats were the conservative party, and the Republicans were the more liberal party. The Democrats were big time racists before and after the Civil War, and Andrew Jackson and Grover Cleveland were two of the most fiscally conservative presidents ever. Bryan's "Cross of Gold" speech at the 1896 Democrat convention changed history.
Clad Coin starting 1965 - It made our fiat money economy official although it had been that way since the end of The Great Depression. I'm not saying that was a bad thing; it just made things official.
and to best define the current state....
end with the girl scout commemorative.
<< <i>1794 dollar - established the dollar as the unit of money, although they put the denomination on the edge.
1853 Arrows half - end of free coinage of silver into US coinage.
1864 Bronze cent - first token coinage
1933 Eagle - end of gold standard.
1965 Quarter - end of precious metal in coins for circulation. >>
Great list, and I dont know what I d get rid of, but the first steam coinage maybe a reeded edge half should have a place in there.
<< <i>1864 Bronze cent - first token coinage >>
Actually the Type I Silver Three Cent Piece was first coin that the government openly admitted did not have a metal content that was equal to its face value. The tiny coin was only 75% silver with the rest copper.
1794 dollar - A fledgling nation creates its sovereign. Beautiful, symbolic, confident.
1921 Peace dollar - The 1st collector-inspired design, the final portrayal of Liberty on circulating coinage, the last silver dollar, the last design of the renaissance. The beginning of the end of circulating bullion.
Ike dollar - An anachronism, bloated, with a horribly ugly depiction of a general/president. Partially mitigated by the reverse, which symbolizes American achievement. Overall, it's consistent with the government that created it
Susan B - Utterly useless with a diminished, re-tread reverse, confused - again like the government that ordered it.
Presidential dollar - Ill conceived, despised, created in astronomical numbers without a foreseeable useful purpose - again, much like the government that created it.
See Rick's list for the less-cynical version.
<< <i>1794 dollar - established the dollar as the unit of money, although they put the denomination on the edge.
1853 Arrows half - end of free coinage of silver into US coinage.
1864 Bronze cent - first token coinage
1933 Eagle - end of gold standard.
1965 Quarter - end of precious metal in coins for circulation. >>
you win.
1794 $1
1856 Flying Eagle
1933 $20
1965 25¢
<< <i>Well, not to ignore other denominations, but the dollar is our basic unit of our monetary system.
1794 dollar - A fledgling nation creates its sovereign. Beautiful, symbolic, confident.
1921 Peace dollar - The 1st collector-inspired design, the final portrayal of Liberty on circulating coinage, the last silver dollar, the last design of the renaissance. The beginning of the end of circulating bullion.
Ike dollar - An anachronism, bloated, with a horribly ugly depiction of a general/president. Partially mitigated by the reverse, which symbolizes American achievement. Overall, it's consistent with the government that created it
Susan B - Utterly useless with a diminished, re-tread reverse, confused - again like the government that ordered it.
Presidential dollar - Ill conceived, despised, created in astronomical numbers without a foreseeable useful purpose - again, much like the government that created it.
See Rick's list for the less-cynical version.
I like your cynical version. The Ike dollar was also a cross into the world of Sci Fi. An super eagle surviving on the moon without a space suit!
2) 1792 Half Disme - "some small beginning". As much as anything a propaganda device. Lots of dignitaries, especially French, were given them by Jefferson to promote identification of an economically cohesive sovereign state.
Martha's silver and the attendant amping up of already blockbuster world-class karma juice came later.
Note: MrE, Don Kagin and myself owned the Parmelee Silver Disme. Many times cooler, the best of the 3 survivors my Holy Grail, but lacking the H10c's historicity.
3) 1848 CAL $2 1/2 - California Gold Rush and greatly increased international trading power
4) 1878-CC S$1 - Mega-mintages
5) 1933 $20 - "Taps" for the gold standard
6) 1964 Kennedy 50c - Likewise for silver
Change for a buck ? dollar twenty four and half cents.
Diplomacy is what it takes to get out of what tact would have kept you out of.
it's just not possible to cover in 5 coins. A shot if I had to narrow my collection down and keep only 5 coins to try it:
Any flowing hair coin from the 1700's
Any draped bust coin from 180X
Any capped bust coin from 1807-1838
Any seated liberty coin from 1838-1865
Any coronet liberty gold coin from 1849-1865, or a 1907 indian eagle or 1907 saint double eagle
I'd probably try to vary the denominations, favoring larger coins, and would not bother with anything after 1865, with the two exceptions noted.
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
1794 $1
1795 Eagle
1907 HR Saint
1907 Rolled Edge Eagle
the 1794 Dollar captures the American revolution. I would choose a cent from this era because the common man probably dealt more in cents but the dollar as a currency conquered the world and must be used.
A gold $5 to represent the civil war era here? I don't know the series or era well enough. This era is like America's version of the dark ages.
3 cent silver Nickel IMO captures the wild west like no other coin. Morgan dollar is debatable here but has that feel like it only circulated during bank heist. A 3 cent nickel for a beer in a saloon just screams Wild West to me.
Peace dollar coming out of the American industrial revolution and into the world stage as a nation.
1964 Kennedy half dollar. Some people are picking the clad quarter here, but same reason.I think you celebrate the last of something not the first of the next thing. The HOF QB is honored at his last game, not his rookie replacement. The Kennedy being the last 90% piece. The clad quarter is the first clad piece but there was still 40% silver being used so not exactly a full departure yet. Either one is the right pick here.
<< <i>Just five coins is very tough to define "the history of US coinage" because you'll invariably omit several important sectors, >>
Baley, limiting the choices to 5 (6 for Jessup who favors the new math), forces the mind to think a bit more cohesively.
One could offer up a complete type set, but what fun would that be?
Some seem to have picked their favorite coins, or a group of really expensive coins, or numismatic "firsts", also good choices, thread could have legs if more folks posted pictures, good job twosides for making the effort
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
I wouldn't wanna try listing specific dates. For general types? Hmm...
Morgan dollar, Saint Gaudens $20, steel cent... I dunno.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
1853 Arrows half - end of free coinage of silver into US coinage.
1864 Bronze cent - first token coinage
1933 Eagle - end of gold standard.
1965 Quarter - end of precious metal in coins for circulation.
That pretty much sums it up right there. The U. S. has been travelling down the debasement path for quite some time it appears. Before too long we'll have nickels made of steel to add to the list.
1857 Flying Eagle Cent
1964 Kennedy Half Dollar
1982 Zinc Lincoln Cent
1986 American Silver Eagle
I knew it would happen.
Morgan dollars
St. Gaudens double eagles
Kennedy half
silver 3¢ pieces
<< <i>
<< <i>Just five coins is very tough to define "the history of US coinage" because you'll invariably omit several important sectors, >>
Baley, limiting the choices to 5 (6 for Jessup who favors the new math), forces the mind to think a bit more cohesively.
One could offer up a complete type set, but what fun would that be? >>
This question is exquisitely cruel in that even six (maybe even seven!) are too few. Is the OP an alt for Procrustes?
S-1 anyone? 1909 VDB MPL? 1965 25c, 1795 $10, 1794 $1 ???
"Complete" US design set at 76 coins still omits many major subtypes and composition changes
About 100 coins should do it proper
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
<< <i>This question is exquisitely cruel in that even six (maybe even seven!) are too few. Is the OP an alt for Procrustes? >>
Actually on the 1948-55 Bakelite Pez forum, I go by Glicker the Impaler.
Damn it Jessup. You are now officially granted the privilege of listing as many coins as you desire on your master list of US coinage!
Get it right son, as we are counting on you.
Coins carry symbols of tribal unity and trust, and guarantee a straight count for all, so thus trustworthiness too. The first presidential portrait coin. Lincoln, as much as anyone, a unifying Father of our Tribe.
The first circulating coin to tell a story. And the story told in a blink. The Renaissance esthetic that created this was a paradigm shift from the bland impersonality of all that came before.
An icon. This is the national numismatic meme.
To the history of US coin collecting, Lincolns are tops at market penetration. Irrelevant to the history of coinage itself, but that surely seeped into my weighting. Ask any kid . .
Notwithstanding all that, if a quasi-quantum shift in functionality is to be considered, and it should, the 1856 FE 1c must be, at the least, 12th on any list of 5. . .
The "master list" . . .