<< <i>These were not the bullion/business strikes but the UNC's. Some people got 100 of them or more. I recall 70FS going for around $150 w/many available. One of my buddies had ordered 15 and was looking to sell for melt. I noted that they were all errors, took him to the Balto show and he sold them for $550 or so each raw. He gave me one for letting him know and I got a 70 on it. >>
To clarify, he is talking about the 2008 Rev. of 2007 Burnished Uncs. The 2015 1/10th gold eagles with the Narrow Reeding are the regular bullion issue.
TD
Numismatist. 50 year member ANA. Winner of four ANA Heath Literary Awards; three Wayte and Olga Raymond Literary Awards; Numismatist of the Year Award 2009, and Lifetime Achievement Award 2020. Winner numerous NLG Literary Awards.
Seems like the HOF gold selling in for $1100 and quickly falling into the $500 range now. I will pass. I would buy an NGC 70 ER Reverse 2008 ASW though for a $1000 if I had a choice.
<< <i>These were not the bullion/business strikes but the UNC's. Some people got 100 of them or more. I recall 70FS going for around $150 w/many available. One of my buddies had ordered 15 and was looking to sell for melt. I noted that they were all errors, took him to the Balto show and he sold them for $550 or so each raw. He gave me one for letting him know and I got a 70 on it. >>
To clarify, he is talking about the 2008 Rev. of 2007 Burnished Uncs. The 2015 1/10th gold eagles with the Narrow Reeding are the regular bullion issue.
We are discussing 1/10 eagles here, not gold kennedys Keep on topic. Again--greater fool theory in progress with these If you have any---flip them fast You will not see these stupid prices for long Soon all the fools will have purchased one at these stupid prices
Does anybody think that the interest in the 2015 American Eagle variety will increase the interest in the other American Eagle varieties, specifically the 1999-W 1/10 and 1/4 ounce errors?
Numismatist. 50 year member ANA. Winner of four ANA Heath Literary Awards; three Wayte and Olga Raymond Literary Awards; Numismatist of the Year Award 2009, and Lifetime Achievement Award 2020. Winner numerous NLG Literary Awards.
<< <i>We are discussing 1/10 eagles here, not gold kennedys Keep on topic. Again--greater fool theory in progress with these If you have any---flip them fast You will not see these stupid prices for long Soon all the fools will have purchased one at these stupid prices >>
Maybe, however Fudd's third law of opposition says:
The earlybird gets the worm and makes some decent money too!!!!
" If you push something hard enough, it will fall over. " The 1st Law of Opposition from The Firesign Theater
<< <i>Does anybody think that the interest in the 2015 American Eagle variety will increase the interest in the other American Eagle varieties, specifically the 1999-W 1/10 and 1/4 ounce errors? >>
May well be the case. I think that to some extent it depends on how the numismatic mags cover this issue - i.e., do they reference the 99's.
<< <i>Does anybody think that the interest in the 2015 American Eagle variety will increase the interest in the other American Eagle varieties, specifically the 1999-W 1/10 and 1/4 ounce errors? >>
An increase in interest will be measured by an increase in price. Not until gold sees an increase.
Only 26 have sold on ebay. Prices are however leveling as more competition enters the market. I expect them to drop a bit until the ebay flood comes and goes. My early guess of prices leveling around those of the $5 1999 W uncirc. still holds. Seems to be a shortage of 2015 $5 AGEs on ebay and among some bullion dealers. Usually the market is flooded with them right after the new year.
A collar/reeding error in the same class as a obverse die and mm error Not even in the same class Not even close It won't take six months for these to fall on thier face
Amen. I actually collect MS fractional and have NO interest in these because IMO, they just are not that significant. More power to the flippers making money though...
Love that Milled British (1830-1960) Well, just Love coins, period.
All modern hot items initially peak in the aftermarket and then the price settles down. Not unusual, happens to the best of them. What matters is where the price settles. Still too early to start sweeping the dance floor.
<< <i>Looks like prices have peaked for now and are coming down a bit. NGC MS70 ER sold for $800 yesterday and a PCGS MS70FS sold for $834 which is a substantial drop. >>
a PCGS 70FS just sold for 950 on ebay. While prices are no longer ridiculous, they currently remain quite strong.
This ebay seller has a couple of raw narrow-reed versions, including this one, which has an interesting contact mark at nearly 3 o'clock on the obverse, near the stars at the rim.
Was that mark made by contact with the reeds of another coin? I've been trying to learn how various marks are made, and I figured this was a particularly interesting one. Can you tell if the marks were made by another $5 coin with narrow reeds? Or could it have been made by another denomination gold coin altogether? How are these bullion issues handled at the mint(s)?
With a mark like that it probably wouldn't grade very well (66? 67?), but I found it remarkable in all this talk about reeding.
<< <i>This ebay seller has a couple of raw narrow-reed versions, including this one, which has an interesting contact mark at nearly 3 o'clock on the obverse, near the stars at the rim.
Was that mark made by contact with the reeds of another coin? I've been trying to learn how various marks are made, and I figured this was a particularly interesting one. Can you tell if the marks were made by another $5 coin with narrow reeds? Or could it have been made by another denomination gold coin altogether? How are these bullion issues handled at the mint(s)?
With a mark like that it probably wouldn't grade very well (66? 67?), but I found it remarkable in all this talk about reeding. >>
Hard to say for sure, but that does appear to be a reeding mark from another narrow reeds coin.
Numismatist. 50 year member ANA. Winner of four ANA Heath Literary Awards; three Wayte and Olga Raymond Literary Awards; Numismatist of the Year Award 2009, and Lifetime Achievement Award 2020. Winner numerous NLG Literary Awards.
Thanks Capt. It was the kind of thing that caught my eye, but I imagine I'm probably the only potential buyer on earth who would care about such a thing.
At this point PCGS shows a population of 271 NR coins, all of them FS, and they show 1577 ATS. I guess that quantity seems kind of low for the numbers that I bet collect these... or is it? I just thought I'd put it up now and see how much the numbers grow in the coming months.
just think, if the new holders with the third side of the coin visible were not in vogue now, you wouldn't even be able to see the edge of these coins(in their holders)!! LOL!!
<< <i>just think, if the new holders with the third side of the coin visible were not in vogue now, you wouldn't even be able to see the edge of these coins(in their holders)!! LOL!! >>
Very true. Same for edge lettering on other issues of course.
<< <i>MCM dropped BIN price to 799 on PCGS ms70 FS >>
Well the price is still high because of low mintage as is now based on NGC and PCGS pops, but demand on the coin is low. So either collectors dunno/ dun care or waiting until the mint release information what cost this error or variant
Never did find out for sure if this was the result of the Mint using an old Buffalo gold collar. The Mint stonewalled it very well.
Numismatist. 50 year member ANA. Winner of four ANA Heath Literary Awards; three Wayte and Olga Raymond Literary Awards; Numismatist of the Year Award 2009, and Lifetime Achievement Award 2020. Winner numerous NLG Literary Awards.
This variety was completely hyped up by many wholesalers who made some serious cash on the deal It may be scarce, but who really cares...a reeding variety....not what I would ever call a major error Does not even come close the the 1999w, or even its silver sibling 2008 reverse 2007...as errors go
Comments
<< <i>These were not the bullion/business strikes but the UNC's. Some people got 100 of them or more. I recall 70FS going for around $150 w/many available. One of my buddies had ordered 15 and was looking to sell for melt. I noted that they were all errors, took him to the Balto show and he sold them for $550 or so each raw. He gave me one for letting him know and I got a 70 on it. >>
To clarify, he is talking about the 2008 Rev. of 2007 Burnished Uncs. The 2015 1/10th gold eagles with the Narrow Reeding are the regular bullion issue.
TD
Box of 20
I suspect they will return to the twice melt level very soon
<< <i>I suspect they will return to the twice melt level very soon >>
doubt it.
three just sold for $1500 ea.
Give Me Liberty or Give Me Debt
<< <i>
<< <i>I suspect they will return to the twice melt level very soon >>
doubt it.
three just sold for $1500 ea. >>
Wow!! Just didn't think that the $900 offer from MCM was a flipping opportunity.
<< <i>
<< <i>These were not the bullion/business strikes but the UNC's. Some people got 100 of them or more. I recall 70FS going for around $150 w/many available. One of my buddies had ordered 15 and was looking to sell for melt. I noted that they were all errors, took him to the Balto show and he sold them for $550 or so each raw. He gave me one for letting him know and I got a 70 on it. >>
To clarify, he is talking about the 2008 Rev. of 2007 Burnished Uncs. The 2015 1/10th gold eagles with the Narrow Reeding are the regular bullion issue.
TD >>
Absolutely. Sorry if I was not clear. Thanks.
<< <i>Finally my coins is shipping out, stupid me ordered 69s, but I got pcgs 70 set from GC for $900. Dunno keep it or put on eBay yet. >>
Personally, at $1500 I would flip it on Feebay in a second.
<< <i>Tulip mania >>
You were completely the opposite with the gold JFKs.
Give Me Liberty or Give Me Debt
Keep on topic.
Again--greater fool theory in progress with these
If you have any---flip them fast
You will not see these stupid prices for long
Soon all the fools will have purchased one at these stupid prices
<< <i>We are discussing 1/10 eagles here, not gold kennedys
Keep on topic.
Again--greater fool theory in progress with these
If you have any---flip them fast
You will not see these stupid prices for long
Soon all the fools will have purchased one at these stupid prices >>
Maybe, however Fudd's third law of opposition says:
The earlybird gets the worm and makes some decent money too!!!!
<< <i>I sold an NGC 70 ER on Ebay pretty quickly today for $825.
Another seller got $895 shortly before mine sold.
Looks like the demand is there for now. >>
Some one just paid crazy amount $995 for it.
<< <i>
<< <i>I sold an NGC 70 ER on Ebay pretty quickly today for $825.
Another seller got $895 shortly before mine sold.
Looks like the demand is there for now. >>
Some one just paid crazy amount $995 for it. >>
Just noticed that - $995 for an NGC 70ER.
Looks like I sold too early. Thought that $825 was a good price to get but sold early - AGAIN! UGH!!!!!!!
I wonder where these will top out. Just nuts right now.
<< <i>Does anybody think that the interest in the 2015 American Eagle variety will increase the interest in the other American Eagle varieties, specifically the 1999-W 1/10 and 1/4 ounce errors? >>
May well be the case. I think that to some extent it depends on how the numismatic mags cover this issue - i.e., do they reference the 99's.
<< <i>Does anybody think that the interest in the 2015 American Eagle variety will increase the interest in the other American Eagle varieties, specifically the 1999-W 1/10 and 1/4 ounce errors? >>
An increase in interest will be measured by an increase in price. Not until gold sees an increase.
Give Me Liberty or Give Me Debt
<< <i>Saturation point probably reached >>
Only 26 have sold on ebay. Prices are however leveling as more competition enters the market. I expect them to drop a bit until the ebay flood comes and goes. My early guess of prices leveling around those of the $5 1999 W uncirc. still holds. Seems to be a shortage of 2015 $5 AGEs on ebay and among some bullion dealers. Usually the market is flooded with them right after the new year.
Give Me Liberty or Give Me Debt
These will fall a lot harder
<< <i>These aren't even in the same class as the 1999 w unc
These will fall a lot harder >>
Get back with me in six months.
Give Me Liberty or Give Me Debt
Not even in the same class
Not even close
It won't take six months for these to fall on thier face
Well, just Love coins, period.
<< <i>Amen. I actually collect MS fractional and have NO interest in these because IMO, they just are not that significant. >>
then you'll never have all of the key coins of the series.
Give Me Liberty or Give Me Debt
NGC MS70 ER sold for $800 yesterday and a PCGS MS70FS sold for $834 which is a substantial drop.
<< <i>The party's over >>
A tenth ounce bullion gold for 7X spot sounds pretty strong to me. Party on.
Give Me Liberty or Give Me Debt
Well, just Love coins, period.
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
If you had them, hope you sold.
<< <i>Looks like prices have peaked for now and are coming down a bit. NGC MS70 ER sold for $800 yesterday and a PCGS MS70FS sold for $834 which is a substantial drop. >>
a PCGS 70FS just sold for 950 on ebay. While prices are no longer ridiculous, they currently remain quite strong.
Give Me Liberty or Give Me Debt
<< <i>It looks like prices have settled out at approx. $850 for PCGS MS70 FS. $800 for NGC MS70 ER though less of these have sold recently. >>
7X melt! I guess the party is over.
Give Me Liberty or Give Me Debt
Sell em now........
Was that mark made by contact with the reeds of another coin? I've been trying to learn how various marks are made, and I figured this was a particularly interesting one. Can you tell if the marks were made by another $5 coin with narrow reeds? Or could it have been made by another denomination gold coin altogether? How are these bullion issues handled at the mint(s)?
With a mark like that it probably wouldn't grade very well (66? 67?), but I found it remarkable in all this talk about reeding.
<< <i>This ebay seller has a couple of raw narrow-reed versions, including this one, which has an interesting contact mark at nearly 3 o'clock on the obverse, near the stars at the rim.
Was that mark made by contact with the reeds of another coin? I've been trying to learn how various marks are made, and I figured this was a particularly interesting one. Can you tell if the marks were made by another $5 coin with narrow reeds? Or could it have been made by another denomination gold coin altogether? How are these bullion issues handled at the mint(s)?
With a mark like that it probably wouldn't grade very well (66? 67?), but I found it remarkable in all this talk about reeding. >>
Hard to say for sure, but that does appear to be a reeding mark from another narrow reeds coin.
At this point PCGS shows a population of 271 NR coins, all of them FS, and they show 1577 ATS. I guess that quantity seems kind of low for the numbers that I bet collect these... or is it? I just thought I'd put it up now and see how much the numbers grow in the coming months.
<< <i>just think, if the new holders with the third side of the coin visible were not in vogue now, you wouldn't even be able to see the edge of these coins(in their holders)!! LOL!! >>
Very true. Same for edge lettering on other issues of course.
<< <i>MCM dropped BIN price to 799 on PCGS ms70 FS >>
Well the price is still high because of low mintage as is now based on NGC and PCGS pops, but demand on the coin is low. So either collectors dunno/ dun care or waiting until the mint release information what cost this error or variant
<< <i>The pop reports for MS70 PCGS FS 5$ AGE are almost identical for narrow and wide reeds...... Why pay a premium for narrow? >>
Good question. I think those who buy at the current high prices are in for a severe hit to their wallets in the coming months/years.
Approx 600 for pcgs 70 FS on d bay
It's a race to the bottom
It may be scarce, but who really cares...a reeding variety....not what I would ever call a major error
Does not even come close the the 1999w, or even its silver sibling 2008 reverse 2007...as errors go