<< <i>s it just the rims on the '49 and the strike or are there other things you are seeing, odd color aside?
The weak strike and mushiness combined with proof-like surfaces is all wrong, unless it's a bad fake. >>
I'm not worried about the coin being genuine, I'm interested in knowing if a business strike half cent from this era could have proof-like mirror fields from a first strike, or can this only be obtained from being an actual proof?
Weepinglion - I am a collector of half cents and I have what I believe is a pretty good collection of half cents. I have an 1851 that I bought out of Eliasberg that is a very very early die state and looks Proof but is not a proof. I also own an 1853 graded ms 66 brown that is also a very very early die state and also looks proof
Sorry but your 1853 is not a Proof NFW as David Hall would say ! FYI PCGS has screwed up on many occasions grading mint state half cents as proofs. There is an 1849 Large date in the ESM collection purchased from a Goldberg auction as well as an 1851 called a proof which PCGS crossed from an NGC slab with authority from Ron Guth. PCGS has really screwed up by grading 1831 half cents as mint state when no one has ever seen an 1831 half cent remotely resembling mint state.
The best person to speak to regarding the 1853 half cent you own is Jim Mcguigan .
Thanks you guys. We weren't expecting it to come back a Proof, so it's not exactly a big loss if it isn't one. But there would still be disappointment, of course.
<< <i>Do you have the coin in a proof slab in hand, or is it just online with that designation? There is a world of difference between the two.
For what it is worth, the key diagnostic on business strike 1853 Half Cents is the tiny dot on the left lower serif of the T in CENT that is visible on your coin. I am reasonably sure that PCGS would not certify an 1853 Half Cent made with that die as a proof, no matter how well it was struck. However, if they have called it a proof and you can convince the EAC guys that they made the right call, you have a VERY valuable coin on your hands. >>
We have the coin in a proof slab in hand, yes. I'll retrieve it on monday to get a picture of the slab, and also to try to get some close up shots for diagnostics.
I do not know if the designation is assigned by PCGS or not, but there seems to be some PL early copper.
Best, Eric >>
Thanks Eric for bringing this to my attention. Very interesting, especially the comments from the owner, "When I discussed this coin with Mark Feld, he said that PL half cents are very unusual, as are large cents. Some people I have showed this coin to are of the opinion that it may be a proof, but after consulting with leading early copper dealers, I am not convinced."
I do not know if the designation is assigned by PCGS or not, but there seems to be some PL early copper.
Best, Eric >>
Thanks Eric for bringing this to my attention. Very interesting, especially the comments from the owner, "When I discussed this coin with Mark Feld, he said that PL half cents are very unusual, as are large cents. Some people I have showed this coin to are of the opinion that it may be a proof, but after consulting with leading early copper dealers, I am not convinced." >>
<< <i>We have the coin in a proof slab in hand, yes. I'll retrieve it on monday to get a picture of the slab, and also to try to get some close up shots for diagnostics. >>
Any update here??? I'm anxiously waiting some more fun reading.
It is not that life is short, but that you are dead for so very long.
<< <i>We have the coin in a proof slab in hand, yes. I'll retrieve it on monday to get a picture of the slab, and also to try to get some close up shots for diagnostics. >>
Any update here??? I'm anxiously waiting some more fun reading. >>
<< <i>I think the cool thing in this thread has been how WeepingLion (the OP) has handled this. Very well done.
Nice thread, great attitude, no ego. Just wanting to know more and get the right thing(s) done.
Kudos to you no matter how it works out >>
Thanks!
Sorry for the delay guys. I'll try my best to get a pic loaded today. I finally got a hold with someone at PCGS and explained the situation. They said they'd look into it. I asked about mechanical errors and they said that while not common, they happen fairly regularly.
Having said that, I have a minor update of sorts. I looked at my actual submission form, which I filled out online, and noticed that I actually put down 1320 as the PCGS#. For anyone who hasn't filled out a submission form online, there's a little link for the number lookup. Once you find your coin, you click on the number and it puts all the info onto the form for you. Well, for Braided Hair Half Cents, most of the PCGS #'s are for Proofs, and only a few for business strikes. I realized I scrolled down past the MS section and into the Proofs and selected the only one there for 1853: 1320.
So in a way, the mechanical error was mine. But it makes you wonder, is that less of an error on PCGS's part? Or did they make the same mistake I did, not realizing the rarity of the Proof. But looking at it another way, imagine you're the grader. You get the submission, look up the #, and grade it as such. Soooo, I'm not sure if that bodes better or worse for the coin!
Here are some quick pics I took. I took them at work, so they're not as close up as I'd like. I tried to get a different angle of light on it than the PCGS pics.
I'm still trying to figure out uploading a pic, let's see if this works...
So, if this 1853 "Proof" were placed in an auction, what would you do? What should the auction company do? What if it sold for $200,000 as the only PR example known? Is the label the sold determinant of the status of the coin?
I would hope that the owner would return the coin to PCGS as a "Mechanical" error.
<< <i>Yes, it is a whizzed business strike. He listed it on the form with the PR number and PCGS missed it. >>
It doesn't look whizzed to me and it doesn't look fake like you said in a previous post.
I have long admired the strike of the 1853 business strike. The denticles are more detailed than many proofs (see the 1850 posted in this thread) and stars and liberty are bold. The Rims are bold and square. It is certainly easy to mistake this coin for a proof and we shouldn't be hard on the op. As Bochiman pointed out he has handled it well, which is unusual around here.
I wonder whey no proofs were made in 1853? A small number were made in each of the nearby years. Do we know who owns the single known 1852 proof? Why isn't it in the price guide? do we have good mint records? Is it possible that proofs were made in 1852 but they weren't sufficiently better than the MS coins and they were all released as MS coins?
<< <i>So, if this 1853 "Proof" were placed in an auction, what would you do? What should the auction company do? What if it sold for $200,000 as the only PR example known? Is the label the sold determinant of the status of the coin?
I would hope that the owner would return the coin to PCGS as a "Mechanical" error. >>
Well, without trying to turn this into an ethics issue, I think that no matter what I did with it any auction company would want to verify it's authenticity as well. I'm just speculating though, that's probably not their job. But with the potential impact of this coin, if I was working there I'd want to know all I could. Just like what I'm doing.
I'm still awaiting a reply from PCGS, so we'll see what they say.
i don't get this coin grade at all. first, i don't see why it's considered cleaned. second, XF details? really? third...Proof? this seems totally messed up to me. i don't collect copper...so some please educate me on this.
<< <i>i don't get this coin grade at all. first, i don't see why it's considered cleaned. second, XF details? really? third...Proof? this seems totally messed up to me. i don't collect copper...so some please educate me on this. >>
The coin definitly looks whizzed but I think they were overly harsh with the technical grade of XF, I would call it AU. (just my opinion)
<< <i>I can't comment on what the grader was thinking, but from the images, the coin is NOT a Proof striking. Put me in the typo camp. >>
I would concur. If not for the OP mentioning it, proof striking would never have occurred to me. Now that 1854 proof looks far more detailed and much more square in all the details. The coins aren't very comparable imo. The cleaned surfaces on the 1853 can make it resemble "proof like" surfaces. You see that a lot.
I'd keep it the way it is for years, just as a numismatic curiosity (clearly you can't sell it like that, it would be wrong) then one day when a legit 1853 proof half cent gets certified you can be like....pssshhhtttt....whatever....I've had one of those for over a decade! You wanna see it?
Kinda like Rich's 1804 Half Dollar, WAAAAY cool, but mostly just for the cool factor.
I just looked at this again - I kept seeing the other pics posted when I'd peek. That coin has a lot of moved metal (!) and is whizzed (not so perfectly) IMHO as already pointed out. Particularly the upper right hand Reverse. It would never occur to me to think Proof either. The color is worrisome of course.
Edit - I must be going senile - I commented on his coin already!
But didn't a few professional coin graders look at this coin and say it's a proof?? Also, before the coin is shipped out, isn't it looked at again and finalized by yet another grader?? A lot of money was paid for a professional grading opinion and surely the system wouldn't allow a pop 1 coin to be made and shipped out without some sort of confirmation or red flag being tripped, right??
<< <i>But didn't a few professional coin graders look at this coin and say it's a proof?? Also, before the coin is shipped out, isn't it looked at again and finalized by yet another grader?? A lot of money was paid for a professional grading opinion and surely the system wouldn't allow a pop 1 coin to be made and shipped out without some sort of confirmation or red flag being tripped, right?? >>
Those are just opinions, with an error(s) mixed in I think. Nothing is infallible. But I am more interested in what qualities form own opinion that it is a Proof, if you think it is a Proof?
Comments
s it just the rims on the '49 and the strike or are there other things you are seeing, odd color aside?
The weak strike and mushiness combined with proof-like surfaces is all wrong, unless it's a bad fake.
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
<< <i>s it just the rims on the '49 and the strike or are there other things you are seeing, odd color aside?
The weak strike and mushiness combined with proof-like surfaces is all wrong, unless it's a bad fake. >>
Thanks.
Best,
Eric
<< <i>s it just the rims on the '49 and the strike or are there other things you are seeing, odd color aside?
The weak strike and mushiness combined with proof-like surfaces is all wrong, unless it's a bad fake. >>
I'm not worried about the coin being genuine, I'm interested in knowing if a business strike half cent from this era could have proof-like mirror fields from a first strike, or can this only be obtained from being an actual proof?
Hi,
I just read about a 1855 1/2 C NCG MS65 BN PL... and a Prooflike 1793 S-5 (R4) Wreath Large Cent with Large Date and Liberty...
I do not know if the designation is assigned by PCGS or not, but there seems to be some PL early copper.
Best,
Eric
Interesting thread nonetheless. While I'm seeing an MS struck piece as well,
I'm crossing my fingers in anticipation that it is a PF
Weepinglion - I am a collector of half cents and I have what I believe is a pretty good collection of half cents. I have an 1851 that I bought out of Eliasberg that is a very very early die state and looks Proof but is not a proof. I also own an 1853 graded ms 66 brown that is also a very very early die state and also looks proof
Sorry but your 1853 is not a Proof NFW as David Hall would say ! FYI PCGS has screwed up on many occasions grading mint state half cents as proofs. There is an 1849 Large date in the ESM collection purchased from a Goldberg auction as well as an 1851 called a proof which PCGS crossed from an NGC slab with authority from Ron Guth. PCGS has really screwed up by grading 1831 half cents as mint state when no one has ever seen an 1831 half cent remotely resembling mint state.
The best person to speak to regarding the 1853 half cent you own is Jim Mcguigan .
Stewart Blay
<< <i>The best person to speak to regarding the 1853 half cent you own is Jim Mcguigan .
Stewart Blay >>
I forwarded the link to this thread to Jim the other day - so he is aware of it.
<< <i>Do you have the coin in a proof slab in hand, or is it just online with that designation? There is a world of difference between the two.
For what it is worth, the key diagnostic on business strike 1853 Half Cents is the tiny dot on the left lower serif of the T in CENT that is visible on your coin. I am reasonably sure that PCGS would not certify an 1853 Half Cent made with that die as a proof, no matter how well it was struck. However, if they have called it a proof and you can convince the EAC guys that they made the right call, you have a VERY valuable coin on your hands. >>
We have the coin in a proof slab in hand, yes. I'll retrieve it on monday to get a picture of the slab, and also to try to get some close up shots for diagnostics.
Whether true or not, it's still exciting.
Good luck!!
My Early Large Cents
<< <i>I wish PCGS would chime in on this. >>
I would assume if an error occurred, they would contact the submitter directly. I would not expect PCGS to discuss grading opinions here.
Free Trial
<< <i><<I'm interested in knowing if a business strike half cent from this era could have proof-like mirror fields>> - g048406
Hi,
I just read about a 1855 1/2 C NCG MS65 BN PL... and a Prooflike 1793 S-5 (R4) Wreath Large Cent with Large Date and Liberty...
I do not know if the designation is assigned by PCGS or not, but there seems to be some PL early copper.
Best,
Eric >>
Thanks Eric for bringing this to my attention. Very interesting, especially the comments from the owner, "When I discussed this coin with Mark Feld, he said that PL half cents are very unusual, as are large cents. Some people I have showed this coin to are of the opinion that it may be a proof, but after consulting with leading early copper dealers, I am not convinced."
<< <i>
<< <i><<I'm interested in knowing if a business strike half cent from this era could have proof-like mirror fields>> - g048406
Hi,
I just read about a 1855 1/2 C NCG MS65 BN PL... and a Prooflike 1793 S-5 (R4) Wreath Large Cent with Large Date and Liberty...
I do not know if the designation is assigned by PCGS or not, but there seems to be some PL early copper.
Best,
Eric >>
Thanks Eric for bringing this to my attention. Very interesting, especially the comments from the owner, "When I discussed this coin with Mark Feld, he said that PL half cents are very unusual, as are large cents. Some people I have showed this coin to are of the opinion that it may be a proof, but after consulting with leading early copper dealers, I am not convinced." >>
You are very welcome
Have a great holiday/Sunday!
Eric
<< <i>We have the coin in a proof slab in hand, yes. I'll retrieve it on monday to get a picture of the slab, and also to try to get some close up shots for diagnostics. >>
Any update here??? I'm anxiously waiting some more fun reading.
<< <i>
<< <i>We have the coin in a proof slab in hand, yes. I'll retrieve it on monday to get a picture of the slab, and also to try to get some close up shots for diagnostics. >>
Any update here??? I'm anxiously waiting some more fun reading. >>
My Early Large Cents
Very well done.
Nice thread, great attitude, no ego. Just wanting to know more and get the right thing(s) done.
Kudos to you no matter how it works out
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
<< <i>Any update here??? I'm anxiously waiting some more fun reading. >>
I'm looking foward to hearing the results of this more than I am seeing the next episode of Walking Dead.
My Early Large Cents
<< <i>This thread is starting to remind me of the movie "No country for old men" very interesting story with a very unfulfilling ending! >>
You should try discussing 1895 Morgans
Actually it was as fulfilling as a Thanksgiving Turkey...for almost all.
Eric
<< <i>
<< <i>This thread is starting to remind me of the movie "No country for old men" very interesting story with a very unfulfilling ending! >>
You should try discussing 1895 Morgans
Actually it was as fulfilling as a Thanksgiving Turkey...for almost all.
Eric >>
You are satisfied without knowing if it was intentionally slabbed as a proof and why? Its a very excting story, but we need the rest of it.
My Early Large Cents
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>This thread is starting to remind me of the movie "No country for old men" very interesting story with a very unfulfilling ending! >>
You should try discussing 1895 Morgans
Actually it was as fulfilling as a Thanksgiving Turkey...for almost all.
Eric >>
You are satisfied without knowing if it was intentionally slabbed as a proof and why? Its a very excting story, but we need the rest of it. >>
I was speaking of the '95 from threads past. I don't believe this is a Proof.
Eric
<< <i>I think the cool thing in this thread has been how WeepingLion (the OP) has handled this.
Very well done.
Nice thread, great attitude, no ego. Just wanting to know more and get the right thing(s) done.
Kudos to you no matter how it works out
Thanks!
Sorry for the delay guys. I'll try my best to get a pic loaded today. I finally got a hold with someone at PCGS and explained the situation. They said they'd look into it. I asked about mechanical errors and they said that while not common, they happen fairly regularly.
Having said that, I have a minor update of sorts. I looked at my actual submission form, which I filled out online, and noticed that I actually put down 1320 as the PCGS#. For anyone who hasn't filled out a submission form online, there's a little link for the number lookup. Once you find your coin, you click on the number and it puts all the info onto the form for you. Well, for Braided Hair Half Cents, most of the PCGS #'s are for Proofs, and only a few for business strikes. I realized I scrolled down past the MS section and into the Proofs and selected the only one there for 1853: 1320.
So in a way, the mechanical error was mine. But it makes you wonder, is that less of an error on PCGS's part? Or did they make the same mistake I did, not realizing the rarity of the Proof. But looking at it another way, imagine you're the grader. You get the submission, look up the #, and grade it as such. Soooo, I'm not sure if that bodes better or worse for the coin!
You should have put #1227.
R.I.P. Bear
I say, PCGS error.
Would it be unethical to just put the coin up for sale as-is (in PCGS PF slab)?
Real
Fake
On the 1853 "Proof", I agree that it looks like a whizzed circulation strike, nowhere close to a Proof - strike wise.
I'm still trying to figure out uploading a pic, let's see if this works...
Pic1
pic2
pic3
Edit: Pics didn't post, so I linkified them
I would hope that the owner would return the coin to PCGS as a "Mechanical" error.
<< <i>I would hope that the owner would return the coin to PCGS as a "Mechanical" error. >>
So in your opinion the OP's coin is indefinitely not a proof?
<< <i>Yes, it is a whizzed business strike. He listed it on the form with the PR number and PCGS missed it. >>
It doesn't look whizzed to me and it doesn't look fake like you said in a previous post.
I have long admired the strike of the 1853 business strike. The denticles are more detailed than many proofs (see the 1850 posted in this thread) and stars and liberty are bold. The Rims are bold and square. It is certainly easy to mistake this coin for a proof and we shouldn't be hard on the op. As Bochiman pointed out he has handled it well, which is unusual around here.
I wonder whey no proofs were made in 1853? A small number were made in each of the nearby years. Do we know who owns the single known 1852 proof? Why isn't it in the price guide? do we have good mint records? Is it possible that proofs were made in 1852 but they weren't sufficiently better than the MS coins and they were all released as MS coins?
--Jerry
I said the 1849 was fake, not the 1853. The 1853 is real, just not original (whizzed) and not Proof.
I agree that the OP handled it well and I do thank him for posting. I'd like to know when it goes back to PCGS.
<< <i>So, if this 1853 "Proof" were placed in an auction, what would you do? What should the auction company do? What if it sold for $200,000 as the only PR example known? Is the label the sold determinant of the status of the coin?
I would hope that the owner would return the coin to PCGS as a "Mechanical" error. >>
Well, without trying to turn this into an ethics issue, I think that no matter what I did with it any auction company would want to verify it's authenticity as well. I'm just speculating though, that's probably not their job. But with the potential impact
of this coin, if I was working there I'd want to know all I could. Just like what I'm doing.
I'm still awaiting a reply from PCGS, so we'll see what they say.
Again, thanks for all the responses.
Whizzed
<< <i>i don't get this coin grade at all. first, i don't see why it's considered cleaned. second, XF details? really? third...Proof? this seems totally messed up to me. i don't collect copper...so some please educate me on this. >>
The coin definitly looks whizzed but I think they were overly harsh with the technical grade of XF, I would call it AU. (just my opinion)
<< <i>I can't comment on what the grader was thinking, but from the images, the coin is
NOT a Proof striking. Put me in the typo camp. >>
I would concur. If not for the OP mentioning it, proof striking would never have occurred to me.
Now that 1854 proof looks far more detailed and much more square in all the details. The coins aren't very comparable imo.
The cleaned surfaces on the 1853 can make it resemble "proof like" surfaces. You see that a lot.
Kinda like Rich's 1804 Half Dollar, WAAAAY cool, but mostly just for the cool factor.
Edit - I must be going senile - I commented on his coin already!
Best,
Eric
Michael Kittle Rare Coins --- 1908-S Indian Head Cent Grading Set --- No. 1 1909 Mint Set --- Kittlecoins on Facebook --- Long Beach Table 700
<< <i>But didn't a few professional coin graders look at this coin and say it's a proof?? Also, before the coin is shipped out, isn't it looked at again and finalized by yet another grader?? A lot of money was paid for a professional grading opinion and surely the system wouldn't allow a pop 1 coin to be made and shipped out without some sort of confirmation or red flag being tripped, right?? >>
Those are just opinions, with an error(s) mixed in I think. Nothing is infallible.
But I am more interested in what qualities form own opinion that it is a Proof, if you think it is a Proof?
Eric