<< <i>But didn't a few professional coin graders look at this coin and say it's a proof?? Also, before the coin is shipped out, isn't it looked at again and finalized by yet another grader?? A lot of money was paid for a professional grading opinion and surely the system wouldn't allow a pop 1 coin to be made and shipped out without some sort of confirmation or red flag being tripped, right?? >>
I agree, smells of bad quality control here.
It is not that life is short, but that you are dead for so very long.
Well, at least the mystery is over and resolved. Looking at the photos we can all be confident it is not a proof but rather a cleaned, mechanical error, slabbed half cent.
<< <i>But didn't a few professional coin graders look at this coin and say it's a proof?? Also, before the coin is shipped out, isn't it looked at again and finalized by yet another grader?? A lot of money was paid for a professional grading opinion and surely the system wouldn't allow a pop 1 coin to be made and shipped out without some sort of confirmation or red flag being tripped, right?? >>
Yeah that is the hope. But I'm not gonna be counting on it.
<< <i>I'd keep it the way it is for years, just as a numismatic curiosity (clearly you can't sell it like that, it would be wrong) then one day when a legit 1853 proof half cent gets certified you can be like....pssshhhtttt....whatever....I've had one of those for over a decade! You wanna see it?
Kinda like Rich's 1804 Half Dollar, WAAAAY cool, but mostly just for the cool factor. >>
Ha ha ha yes! That would be funny. If anything it would be a good conversation starter
<< <i>But didn't a few professional coin graders look at this coin and say it's a proof?? Also, before the coin is shipped out, isn't it looked at again and finalized by yet another grader?? A lot of money was paid for a professional grading opinion and surely the system wouldn't allow a pop 1 coin to be made and shipped out without some sort of confirmation or red flag being tripped, right?? >>
Yeah that is the hope. But I'm not gonna be counting on it. >>
It may be more likely that the graders look at the coins and record a grade, but make no notation of proof or business strike, and then the cert is typed up by someone else who is going at least partially by what the invoice has written on it. In this scenario it would be a clear typo.
. that is strange, in a recent discussion here about counterfeits, someone stated that the counterfeit holders were notorious for stating "cleaning" instead of "cleaned" on the holder.
but the coin shown below would negate that statement whether it is a busi/proof strike or not.
Comments
<< <i>But didn't a few professional coin graders look at this coin and say it's a proof?? Also, before the coin is shipped out, isn't it looked at again and finalized by yet another grader?? A lot of money was paid for a professional grading opinion and surely the system wouldn't allow a pop 1 coin to be made and shipped out without some sort of confirmation or red flag being tripped, right?? >>
I agree, smells of bad quality control here.
Looking at the photos we can all be confident it is not a proof but rather a cleaned, mechanical error, slabbed half cent.
<< <i>But didn't a few professional coin graders look at this coin and say it's a proof?? Also, before the coin is shipped out, isn't it looked at again and finalized by yet another grader?? A lot of money was paid for a professional grading opinion and surely the system wouldn't allow a pop 1 coin to be made and shipped out without some sort of confirmation or red flag being tripped, right?? >>
Yeah that is the hope. But I'm not gonna be counting on it.
<< <i>I'd keep it the way it is for years, just as a numismatic curiosity (clearly you can't sell it like that, it would be wrong) then one day when a legit 1853 proof half cent gets certified you can be like....pssshhhtttt....whatever....I've had one of those for over a decade! You wanna see it?
Kinda like Rich's 1804 Half Dollar, WAAAAY cool, but mostly just for the cool factor. >>
Ha ha ha yes! That would be funny. If anything it would be a good conversation starter
<< <i>
<< <i>But didn't a few professional coin graders look at this coin and say it's a proof?? Also, before the coin is shipped out, isn't it looked at again and finalized by yet another grader?? A lot of money was paid for a professional grading opinion and surely the system wouldn't allow a pop 1 coin to be made and shipped out without some sort of confirmation or red flag being tripped, right?? >>
Yeah that is the hope. But I'm not gonna be counting on it. >>
It may be more likely that the graders look at the coins and record a grade, but make no notation of proof or business strike, and then the cert is typed up by someone else who is going at least partially by what the invoice has written on it. In this scenario it would be a clear typo.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
that is strange, in a recent discussion here about counterfeits, someone stated that the counterfeit holders were notorious for stating "cleaning" instead of "cleaned" on the holder.
but the coin shown below would negate that statement whether it is a busi/proof strike or not.
edited for speeling
<< <i>