Options
$6 for five 1852 U.S three cent nickles?
I recently bought a 1915D lincoln cent for $6 at Lilter.com. Got the package today and found out the seller ship me five 1852 U.S silver three cent nickles. I guess he just mixed up the address. What a lucky day! I didnt send it back. I checked ebay.com and about.com, they worth much more than $6. So ridiculous.
0
Comments
<< <i>I recently bought a 1915D lincoln cent for $6 at Lilter.com. Got the package today and found out the seller ship me five 1852 U.S silver three cent nickles. I guess he just mixed up the address. What a lucky day! I didnt send it back. I checked ebay.com and about.com, they worth much more than $6. So ridiculous. >>
The honest thing to do is send them back with an explanation.
and on your first post, too!
<< <i>congratulations, you've outed yourself.
and on your first post, too! >>
haha, I was thinking the same thing.
Impressive.
<< <i>congratulations, you've outed yourself.
and on your first post, too! >>
<< <i>I recently bought a 1915D lincoln cent for $6 at Lilter.com. Got the package today and found out the seller ship me five 1852 U.S silver three cent nickles. I guess he just mixed up the address. What a lucky day! I didnt send it back. I checked ebay.com and about.com, they worth much more than $6. So ridiculous. >>
SILVER 3 Cent NICKLES
hmmmmm
Steve
Positive BST Transactions (buyers and sellers): wondercoin, blu62vette, BAJJERFAN, privatecoin, blu62vette, AlanLastufka, privatecoin
#1 1951 Bowman Los Angeles Rams Team Set
#2 1980 Topps Los Angeles Rams Team Set
#8 (and climbing) 1972 Topps Los Angeles Rams Team Set
<< <i>Perhaps this is lame spam trying to get the Lilter .com domain in front of members?
I was thinking about that.
It's a very odd first post. Not at all PCGS related.
but, it's terrible spam.
Why would I rush to a site that might ship my 3 cent nickels (silver?) to someone who doesn't care about sending them back to the rightful owner???
bob
Anyone who wouldn't send them back is ... wow.
"Seu cabra da peste,
"Sou Mangueira......."
<< <i>
REALLY?
<< <i>congratulations, you've outed yourself... and on your first post, too! >>
Bingo. I now know all about him that I need to -- and probably a lot more than he intended or imagined.
By the way, the correct spelling is NICKELS.
<< <i>As soon as I read the OP I knew this was going to be a pile on thread. If wish people were 1 % as honest and righteous as they think they are. >>
Huh? Not sure I follow you.
The point of the OP is either:
1. Brag about a windfall that is most obviously a mistake by a seller. Thus profit at another person's loss.
or
2. Promote some website (and in an very odd manner too). Sort of like: Hey guys, buy on this website because the sellers are senile!
Taking the OP words at face value, I really do not see another option here, thus I am not sure what "piling on" there may be, or your reference to honesty and righteousness (which should be directed to the OP) regardless if his/her intent is scenario 1 or 2.
Jim
<< <i>Taking the OP words at face value >>
my first reaction is not to
probably just discovered the internet and just temporarily lost their sanity
.
.
Im just saying when its a hypothetical, almost 100% of people are honest and righteous. Oh I wish it was really that way in reality. What I am saying is why crap on the guy for being honest that he is keeping the coin ? I promise you he isnt the only one who would keep the coins ( well maybe not in this case because I dont know that they are even worth much ) but if everyone on this board was accidentally sent a gold eagle and they knew they couldnt get caught, I promise you he isnt the only one who would keep it.
Im just saying, the guy admits he is keeping it. Right or wrong, I dont see the point in 100 people posting essentially telling him they are morally superior to him, when in reality maybe they are and maybe they arent.
See http://www.doubledimes.com for a free online reference for US twenty-cent pieces
<< <i>Constantine, I dont know the guys intent eaither. Maybe he is just bragging about a dishonest windfall. I dont know. But what I do know is that if you asked 5000 people what they would do if say, they bought a 1 ounce silver eagle and recieved a one ounce gold eagle instead, lets say they know they can keep it and wont get arrested, you ask 5000 people what they would do and 4999 will say they would "do the right thing" and send it back. What I know, is that when its a hypothetical, almost everyone claims they are so honest and so righteous that they would do the right thing. Let me promise you from experience, that if those some 5000 people were actually in that situation in reality maybe and I mean MAYBE 1000 of them would "do the right thing".
Im just saying when its a hypothetical, almost 100% of people are honest and righteous. Oh I wish it was really that way in reality. What I am saying is why crap on the guy for being honest that he is keeping the coin ? I promise you he isnt the only one who would keep the coins ( well maybe not in this case because I dont know that they are even worth much ) but if everyone on this board was accidentally sent a gold eagle and they knew they couldnt get caught, I promise you he isnt the only one who would keep it.
Im just saying, the guy admits he is keeping it. Right or wrong, I dont see the point in 100 people posting essentially telling him they are morally superior to him, when in reality maybe they are and maybe they arent. >>
Fair enough and I see your point. It always goes back to one's moral conscience, because at the end of the day only two people know the truth....yourself and whoever you make yourself accountable to. Not trying to be preachy either!
Lafayette Grading Set
<< <i>I'll take the spam, eggs, spam, spam, spam, and spam. >>
Sorry, eggs are off, would you like spam instead?
Sean Reynolds
"Keep in mind that most of what passes as numismatic information is no more than tested opinion at best, and marketing blather at worst. However, I try to choose my words carefully, since I know that you guys are always watching." - Joe O'Connor
No sir, not how I was raised and not in the area I was raised in or the people I grew up with or served with, honesty is all you have. Condoning such behavior is as bad as the act itself IMO. If this is a pile on thread then it is well deserved, steeling shouldn't be tolerated and to question other who do, well that is just gravy.
<< <i>What a way to start out your first thread & post...
I am shocked also, would you deal with him? Not me!
Successful Trades: Swampboy,
Proud recipient of two "You Suck" awards
Egg, bacon and spam
Egg, bacon, sausage and spam
Spam, bacon, sausage and spam
Spam, egg, spam, spam, bacon and spam
Spam, sausage, spam, spam, spam, bacon, spam tomato and spam
Spam, spam, spam, egg and spam
Spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, spam, baked beans, spam, spam, spam and spam.
(Vikings: Spam! Spam! Spam! Spam! Lovely Spam! Lovely Spam!)
Proud recipient of two "You Suck" awards
<< <i>Constantine, I dont know the guys intent eaither. Maybe he is just bragging about a dishonest windfall. I dont know. But what I do know is that if you asked 5000 people what they would do if say, they bought a 1 ounce silver eagle and recieved a one ounce gold eagle instead, lets say they know they can keep it and wont get arrested, you ask 5000 people what they would do and 4999 will say they would "do the right thing" and send it back. What I know, is that when its a hypothetical, almost everyone claims they are so honest and so righteous that they would do the right thing. Let me promise you from experience, that if those some 5000 people were actually in that situation in reality maybe and I mean MAYBE 1000 of them would "do the right thing".
No sir, not how I was raised and not in the area I was raised in or the people I grew up with or served with, honesty is all you have. Condoning such behavior is as bad as the act itself IMO. If this is a pile on thread then it is well deserved, steeling shouldn't be tolerated and to question other who do, well that is just gravy. >>
LOL. TEXAS NATIONALS. JUST LMAO.
YOU wrote this in the BST forum
I now have $100.00 in my paypal account, what do you have that would be shipped to South Texas for this? Post here or PM me! I collect a little of everything US and dark side. I can do paypal gift to avoid fees
LOL. Isnt this THEFT ???
<< <i>Constantine, I dont know the guys intent eaither. Maybe he is just bragging about a dishonest windfall. I dont know. But what I do know is that if you asked 5000 people what they would do if say, they bought a 1 ounce silver eagle and recieved a one ounce gold eagle instead, lets say they know they can keep it and wont get arrested, you ask 5000 people what they would do and 4999 will say they would "do the right thing" and send it back. What I know, is that when its a hypothetical, almost everyone claims they are so honest and so righteous that they would do the right thing. Let me promise you from experience, that if those some 5000 people were actually in that situation in reality maybe and I mean MAYBE 1000 of them would "do the right thing".
Im just saying when its a hypothetical, almost 100% of people are honest and righteous. Oh I wish it was really that way in reality. What I am saying is why crap on the guy for being honest that he is keeping the coin ? I promise you he isnt the only one who would keep the coins ( well maybe not in this case because I dont know that they are even worth much ) but if everyone on this board was accidentally sent a gold eagle and they knew they couldnt get caught, I promise you he isnt the only one who would keep it.
Im just saying, the guy admits he is keeping it. Right or wrong, I dont see the point in 100 people posting essentially telling him they are morally superior to him, when in reality maybe they are and maybe they arent. >>
So let me get this straight.
Because not all humans are honest, there is no point in setting moral standards, and confronting them when they are posed before us?
Because we don't know what we would do as individuals if we were faced with the same moral circumstance, we should not refer to any ideal when it is brought before us for reaction?
Moral instruction is what prepares us for the individual moral decision when it occurs. People are free to make their decisions when the time arises, but it is helpful for people to know what the right decision would be.
Here's a warning parable for coin collectors...
Recipient of the coveted "You Suck" award, April 2009 for cherrypicking a 1833 CBHD LM-5, and April 2022 for a 1835 LM-12, and again in Aug 2012 for picking off a 1952 FS-902.
<< <i>Don't feed the trolls....
This. Y'all are ridiculously easy to troll. I'm almost tempted to do it myself.
<< <i>Congrats you piece of garbage! >>
lmao, that sums it up