Options
An original roll of 1909-S VDB cents...
I've asked this question before but never did get a full understanding....
When dealer x says that an original BU roll of 1909-S vdb cents crossed his path does he/she mean...
A roll that would be in the same form as a roll that you would get from the bank today....wrapped in paper.
Also, is it not almost a certainty that any 1909-s vdb original BU rolls that did surface came from someone in San Francisco?
Also, how many think that there are STILL original BU rolls of 1909-S VDB cents out there? I do...probably not more than a handful, but I would bet dollars to donuts that there are old-time estates in Cali that have these locked away in a SDB.
When dealer x says that an original BU roll of 1909-S vdb cents crossed his path does he/she mean...
A roll that would be in the same form as a roll that you would get from the bank today....wrapped in paper.
Also, is it not almost a certainty that any 1909-s vdb original BU rolls that did surface came from someone in San Francisco?
Also, how many think that there are STILL original BU rolls of 1909-S VDB cents out there? I do...probably not more than a handful, but I would bet dollars to donuts that there are old-time estates in Cali that have these locked away in a SDB.


Collector of Early 20th Century U.S. Coinage.
ANA Member R-3147111
0
Comments
Is there any point in keeping the roll intact? It seems to me that there isn't a whole lot of incentive NOT to part it out piece by piece.
Why would they have to come from San Francisco. Sacramento or Los Angeles could be possibilities too.
I bet you are correct about more than one estate having a roll or more locked away.
But everyone else seems to be paying attention to gecko's fight thread.
Collector of Early 20th Century U.S. Coinage.
ANA Member R-3147111
<< <i>When dealer x says that an original BU roll of 1909-S vdb cents crossed his path does he/she mean... >>
It means he's probably BSing you.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
this scenario is a fantasy that only an overly optimistic collector would torture himself with!!!
Only a fool would store a roll of 1909-S-VDB cents in a normal paper bank wrapper. The paper is full of sulfur and the coins at best would have brown edges with red surfaces. That is probably the reason why some rather recent (1940s and '50s) Lincoln cents seem to be so scarce in the high grading numbers with full red surfaces. Many coins in collectors toned in the albums and others toned in the rolls.
Collector of Early 20th Century U.S. Coinage.
ANA Member R-3147111
<< <i>If you went to the bank in 1909 to buy some pennies, did they sell them in roll quantities and were the rolls wrapped in papper? >>
No to both questions. They sold them individually or in bags of 250. There was never, ever, ever an original roll of 09S-VDB's in existence. Any rolls would have been put together later from individual coins or broken-up 250 piece bags.
On the subject of corrosion, etc in paper rolls though, I must take exception since some of the very highest grade coins out there came from original rolls. I've picked up OBW rolls that were pristine. All it takes is proper storage.
RayP
http://macrocoins.com
<< <i>I've asked this question before but never did get a full understanding....
When dealer x says that an original BU roll of 1909-S vdb cents crossed his path does he/she mean...
A roll that would be in the same form as a roll that you would get from the bank today....wrapped in paper.
Also, is it not almost a certainty that any 1909-s vdb original BU rolls that did surface came from someone in San Francisco?
Also, how many think that there are STILL original BU rolls of 1909-S VDB cents out there? I do...probably not more than a handful, but I would bet dollars to donuts that there are old-time estates in Cali that have these locked away in a SDB.
I think there are a number of put together "original rolls" out there. But back to the preservation perspective, SDB's are a really bad place to store raw coins IMHO, especially paper rolls, due to the relatively high humidity that bank vaults are kept at in order to keep currency from drying out. Not good, especially for copper.
For more than 20 years I knew of a hoard of OBW rolls that a dealer kept in their converted bank vault at the back of their store, which used to be a bank in the 50's and 60's. Every few years I would drop by and ask to buy some, and they would not be interested in selling. Finally, they relented and decided to sell to me. They started bringing out SDB after SDB filled with OBW rolls from the 40's and 50's. But it was all junk, corroded, spotted, and with that "grungy" feel to the rolls and coins that comes from poor storage in high humidity. I was so disappointed and kicked myself for putting so much effort into the quest. So anyway, the lesson is: don't put your OBW rolls in your SDB.
RayP
http://macrocoins.com