What would you do...PCGS guarantee downgrade?
phantom1701
Posts: 129
Well folks, I had a 2006-W $1 PCGS PR70, but it started developing the dreaded milkspots after about 6 months in the holder. So I dropped it off at the PCGS booth at FUN for a guarantee review. As expected PCGS has come back with a downgrade to PR69 (which still seems odd given the amount of spotting). My first question is whether or not their offer of $150 is fair for a 2006-W Proof $1 in PR70. The second question is whether or not it's worth it to get the coin back and take less money?
So as the title suggests....what would you do:
In reference to submission #394XXX1, unfortunately your coin, a 2006-W $1, did downgrade. We can offer to buy back the coin for $150 or return it to you in a PR69DC holder plus $130. Please let me know what you would like us to do.
So as the title suggests....what would you do:
In reference to submission #394XXX1, unfortunately your coin, a 2006-W $1, did downgrade. We can offer to buy back the coin for $150 or return it to you in a PR69DC holder plus $130. Please let me know what you would like us to do.
0
Comments
"Because I can"
myurl The Franklin All Old Green Holder Set
<< <i>money I only like spots on animals........ >>
I guess the coin could be considered a dog now
my early American coins & currency: -- http://yankeedoodlecoins.com/
when the buyer decides he doesn't want a spotted coin...
<< <i>Well folks, I had a 2006-W $1 PCGS PR70, but it started developing the dreaded milkspots after about 6 months in the holder. So I dropped it off at the PCGS booth at FUN for a guarantee review. As expected PCGS has come back with a downgrade to PR69 (which still seems odd given the amount of spotting). My first question is whether or not their offer of $150 is fair for a 2006-W Proof $1 in PR70. The second question is whether or not it's worth it to get the coin back and take less money?
So as the title suggests....what would you do:
In reference to submission #394XXX1, unfortunately your coin, a 2006-W $1, did downgrade. We can offer to buy back the coin for $150 or return it to you in a PR69DC holder plus $130. Please let me know what you would like us to do. >>
$150 seems fair:
ebay
<< <i>Why doesn't PCGS follow their own price guide
You are not allowed to question the god of TPG's, young man.....
<< <i>
<< <i>Why doesn't PCGS follow their own price guide
You are not allowed to question the god of TPG's, young man.....
You know this first hand..... LMAO !!!
they will not get smaller
you decide
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Why doesn't PCGS follow their own price guide
You are not allowed to question the god of TPG's, young man.....
You know this first hand..... LMAO !!! >>
Take the cash + the coin. You can't buy a 69 DCAM for $20 anywhere, even a spotted one.
Ike Specialist
Finest Toned Ike I've Ever Seen, been looking since 1986
Michael Kittle Rare Coins --- 1908-S Indian Head Cent Grading Set --- No. 1 1909 Mint Set --- Kittlecoins on Facebook --- Long Beach Table 700
Where can I buy 10 ASE's at spot?
<< <i>Take the 130 dollars and list the coin on Ebay... >>
Very sound advice, I would do this.
I like the one suggestion to ask for $150 plus my coin back. It's not like they can do anything with the coin.