Options
An interesting way to look at things.
gecko109
Posts: 8,231 ✭
If you buy a gold coin for $5 plus melt value (lets say it melts at $90), did you spend $95 or did you spend $5?
Somewhat similarly, if you bought a $20 bill, lets say it was from 1929, or whatever, and it cost you $30....did you spend $30, or did you spend $10?
Somewhat similarly, if you bought a $20 bill, lets say it was from 1929, or whatever, and it cost you $30....did you spend $30, or did you spend $10?
0
Comments
Example 2, I will agree with you spent 10.00 since you can still spend a 1929 20 dollar bill at the grocery store.
<< <i>You are making a great effort trying to convince us that collecting bullion is the way to go... or are you trying to convince yourself?
Actually im trying to determine if my outlook on the financials of this are way off base. As Rob pointed out, there is no guarantee that melt will remain stable a day after the purchase. However, AT THE MOMENT of purchase on a gold coin under my terms outlined above, did I spend $95 or $5?
Got to remember sooner or later the bullion bubble will burst.
You can't deposit it at a bank,,,, spend it at the grocery store or at the gas pump. Take it to a coin dealer or pawn shop and you will be paid a certain % back of spot. At that point you have SOLD something and then will have some money.
Very simple IMHO,,,,,
GrandAm
Garsmith, im curious as to what YOU feel an ounce of gold should be worth in relation to the U.S. dollar.
I was a Monkey
<< <i>
<< <i>You are making a great effort trying to convince us that collecting bullion is the way to go... or are you trying to convince yourself?
Actually im trying to determine if my outlook on the financials of this are way off base. As Rob pointed out, there is no guarantee that melt will remain stable a day after the purchase. However, AT THE MOMENT of purchase on a gold coin under my terms outlined above, did I spend $95 or $5? >>
You spent $95 on the gold and $30 on the bill. For your $30 you got at least $20 worth of guaranteed value and since you probly don't plan to spend the bill you really have spent $30 there.
<< <i>If you buy an automatic grapefruit peeler and juicer for $15 and it is worth $15 you still spent $15 >>
If you bought a 2001 $100 star note for $100....how much did you "spend"?
<< <i>
<< <i>If you buy an automatic grapefruit peeler and juicer for $15 and it is worth $15 you still spent $15 >>
If you bought a 2001 $100 star note for $100....how much did you "spend"? >>
Aaaahhhh.....$100
I know I know ....if you spend a nickel and 2 dimes for a quarter how much did you spend????
This is really a question for the Dalai Lama or Saintguru or Russ....
Thats it gecko .......this is a question for Russ.
Now you owe me a quarter for steering you in the right direction to answer this philosophical query.
with your collecting choices.
look at some of the comments! hilarious.
frankly, i am just pleased you see these coins as bullion that are in
really good shape and not as plastic coated grade labeled collector
items.
gold is good!
<< <i>lol gecko. i love your posts and how it draws out the people upset
with your collecting choices.
look at some of the comments! hilarious.
frankly, i am just pleased you see these coins as bullion that are in
really good shape and not as plastic coated grade labeled collector
items.
gold is good! >>
<< <i>Do you plan to sell? >>
Thats a good question concerning my OP about the $5 premium on the $90 melt value gold coin. If I dont plan to sell, does it matter? Consider the $100 star note "bought" at face example. Even if I did not plan to sell it, did I still "spend" $100 on it? As Jrocco said, its a bit of a philosophical subject/problem.
At first I felt lucky but then I thought it has no big value and it costs me $20 if I keep it forever. LOL so I gave it to someone else for a new $20 which I spent.
<< <i>If you buy a gold coin for $5 plus melt value (lets say it melts at $90), did you spend $95 or did you spend $5?
Somewhat similarly, if you bought a $20 bill, lets say it was from 1929, or whatever, and it cost you $30....did you spend $30, or did you spend $10? >>
You can get pills for that; I think the active ingredient is called gecko biloba.
Some collectors track both the price paid, and an estimate of current resale. To my mind, because they are separate entries, it is very clear to me that the amount paid is the amount spent. Would a person buying a MS63 Morgan for $40, record the price paid as $39 because of the $1 face value? This makes the original point seem silly when put in those terms.
For those that are obsessed with being ahead, one idea is to collect nickels and cents at face value because current melt value is way above face value, and the ban on melting will eventually be lifted.
I'm objective in a subjective world.
This might be a collector spoon and it might be a soup spoon
<< <i>What if a person is collecting world coins at the current exchange rate? Say a person trades for $100 current value in Euros at current face value. Did they spend $100 or did they spend nothing? If the person is a collector, I'd vote $100 spent.
Some collectors track both the price paid, and an estimate of current resale. To my mind, because they are separate entries, it is very clear to me that the amount paid is the amount spent. Would a person buying a MS63 Morgan for $40, record the price paid as $39 because of the $1 face value? This makes the original point seem silly when put in those terms.
For those that are obsessed with being ahead, one idea is to collect nickels and cents at face value because current melt value is way above face value, and the ban on melting will eventually be lifted. >>
How many nickels would you need to have to convince smoeone to fire up a smelter for one run?