Options
Mystery 1915 Lincoln Cent in Nickel...
Can anybody here add anything useful to the text below?

From uspatterns.com:
This is a 1915 Lincoln cent struck in nickel. Pollock sites the description from Elder's 2/19 sale which is as follows:
"The mint officials thinking to invent a new cent which would not rust, like the bronze one [sic], had half a dozen samples struck off in nickel. Subsequently all these trials were rejected and destroyed, except this one."
We believe this explanation is dubious. It is more likely that this is a mint error struck from planchet strip originally intended for foreign coinage or nickel 5 cent stock which was inadvertently rolled and punched into U.S. cent planchets.
Mike Byers notes: "This fascinating piece requires further study because it weighs 50 grains and is an off-metal. A normal copper cent weighs 48 grains. The closest foreign blank which is 75% copper and 25% nickel is a 1919 El Salvador 1 Centavo, which weighs 38 grains."
From uspatterns.com:
This is a 1915 Lincoln cent struck in nickel. Pollock sites the description from Elder's 2/19 sale which is as follows:
"The mint officials thinking to invent a new cent which would not rust, like the bronze one [sic], had half a dozen samples struck off in nickel. Subsequently all these trials were rejected and destroyed, except this one."
We believe this explanation is dubious. It is more likely that this is a mint error struck from planchet strip originally intended for foreign coinage or nickel 5 cent stock which was inadvertently rolled and punched into U.S. cent planchets.
Mike Byers notes: "This fascinating piece requires further study because it weighs 50 grains and is an off-metal. A normal copper cent weighs 48 grains. The closest foreign blank which is 75% copper and 25% nickel is a 1919 El Salvador 1 Centavo, which weighs 38 grains."
Andy Lustig
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
0
Comments
Undoubtedly it's circulated (even has what's probably a test scratch done by some curious person while this coin was still in circulation). That helps disprove the Mint's explanation. If it was truly a trial piece it probably wouldn't have gotten it's way into daily commerce.
Beyond that, I'm clueless.
TD
<< <i>Just a WAG, but perhaps a normal bronze cent planchet got pickled along with some copper-nickel five cents planchets and accidentally plated?
TD >>
I had the same thought but how do you explain the heavier weight? Plating shouldn't weigh that much.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>It actually matches up pretty well to a Cuba 2 centavos planchet. These were produced in 1915, are copper-nickel, weigh 54 grains and have a diameter of 19.3mm. While the planchet is slightly wider than a cent, if a Cuban 2c blank went through the cent upset mill it would be squeezed down to a diameter that would fit into a cent collar. >>
Might account for the incredibly sharp strike. Although the missing 4 grains would be a mystery.
This sure is an odd one....