Options
Do you accept the term "Modern Crap" here on the message boards? POLL
STONE
Posts: 15,275 ✭
I still get mixed feelings about this term and want to hear from everyone.
0
Comments
Russ, NCNE
But ultimately, it's their money.
[Edit to add: I wish a lot of people had disdain for what I collected, by the way. It might make acquiring stuff a lot cheaper.]
Successful BST transactions with: SilverEagles92; Ahrensdad; Smitty; GregHansen; Lablade; Mercury10c; copperflopper; whatsup; KISHU1; scrapman1077, crispy, canadanz, smallchange, robkool, Mission16, ranshdow, ibzman350, Fallguy, Collectorcoins, SurfinxHI, jwitten, Walkerguy21D, dsessom.
Russ, NCNE
Gems and turds are part of the whole and like I heard long ago-
One man's toilet bowl is another man's salad bowl.....
wait, I never heard that, I just made it up
<< <i>
Gems and turds are part of the whole and like I heard long ago-
One man's toilet bowl is another man's salad bowl.....
>>
Socrates would be proud.
[Edit to add: I wish a lot of people had disdain for what I collected, by the way. It might make acquiring stuff a lot cheaper.] >>
I believe that would considerably reduce your interest in that particular item. Don't think so? Try going out to your backyard and beginning a rock collection.
No. Don't like the term and will never use it to describe what someone may collect. To each his own and with respect to all. Modern coinage as good as classic coinage, classic as good as ancient, and so on and so forth.
And to clarify, I collect mostly classic U.S coinage: walkers, mercs, buffalos, etc. However I do have some modern and enjoy those just as much for a variety of reasons.
Check out my current listings: https://ebay.com/sch/khunt/m.html?_ipg=200&_sop=12&_rdc=1
<< <i>Cladking and other modernophiles use it all the time, so it does not bother me. Come to think of it, I rarely see the modern bashers use it. It might be like some ethnic slurs that cannot be uttered by someone outside the ethnic group but are fair game to use by those within. >>
BRILLIANT!
Questions about Ikes? Go to The IKE GROUP WEB SITE
These three series were minted as late as the 47, 45 and 38, respectively; dates which many on the Forums consider to be in the "Modern" era (i.e. 1933 forward).
Lincolns are still being produced today, but they first appeared in 1909. Lincolns are "Moderns", right?
Simply because a series is no longer in production, does that make it "Classic"? And are series still in production "Modern"? If so, then Lincolns are "Modern" US Coinage (even the $50K+ MS Red Lincolns from 1909 through the 1920's); and Frankies, Washington Quarters from 1932-1998, Peace Dollars, Ikes, Susan B. Anthony's, and maybe (depending on your definition) 1938-2003 Jeffersons are all "Classic" US Coinage.
This reply points out the obvious, namely there is no concrete definition of "Modern" nor of "Classic".
Regarding the question posed in the OP, the term "Modern Crap" does not offend me at all because some moderns are crap, just as some classics are crap. There are also moderns and classics that are drop dead gorgeous, PQ, high end, rarities. The term "Modern Crap" is used in jest and is akin the the ethnic slurs phenomena pointed out by RYK.
Russ, NCNE
Forum AdministratorPSA & PSA/DNA ForumModerator@collectors.com | p 800.325.1121 | PSAcard.com
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
1. all pre 1948 Lincolns, Jeffersons, Roosies and Washies are "Classic";
2. all post 1947 Lincolns, Jeffersons, Roosies and Washies are "Modern"; and
3. you can find both Classic and Modern Lincolns and Jeffersons (and maybe even Roosies and Washies) in change today if you look hard enough.
Further, doesn't Russ and others consider a 1964 AH CAM/DCAM Proof Kennedy a "Classic" rarity?
no one has ever bashed moderns
just the ga-ga grade moderns that are pennies on the dollar outside of the ga-ga high grade holder where the price and demand is all in the certified plastic holder
below is the crux of the matter.....................
ziggy29
Master Collector
Posts: 6952
Joined: Jul 2004
Wednesday August 16, 2006 12:15 PM (NEW!)
I don't really think it's "crap," but it generally does nothing for me. And I do confess that I personally find it hard to believe that some people will pay hundreds, thousands -- even tens of thousands -- of dollars for modern coins which are very cheap just one or two grade points lower and not all THAT much less attractive.
the people who started the word modern crap are the promoters of their own wares that they buy for a few dollars usually dip get slabbed and sell to people playing on their passions but reverse physicology
and clever marketing on the boards only to line their pockets
“One man’s junk is another man’s treasure.” Too bad that some haven’t learned that old saying.
When some use the term “Modern Crap”, it doesn’t bother me, I just chalk it up to they trying to make up for other ‘short comings’.
Tim
please, the proper term is Modernites.
My first post...updated with pics
I collect mostly moderns and I'm currently working on a US type set.
http://my.affinity.is/cancer-research?referral_code=MjI4Nzgz
<< <i>frankieboywonder states that he collects classic US coinage, including Walkers, Mercs and Buffalos.
These three series were minted as late as the 47, 45 and 38, respectively; dates which many on the Forums consider to be in the "Modern" era (i.e. 1933 forward).
Lincolns are still being produced today, but they first appeared in 1909. Lincolns are "Moderns", right?
Simply because a series is no longer in production, does that make it "Classic"? And are series still in production "Modern"? If so, then Lincolns are "Modern" US Coinage (even the $50K+ MS Red Lincolns from 1909 through the 1920's); and Frankies, Washington Quarters from 1932-1998, Peace Dollars, Ikes, Susan B. Anthony's, and maybe (depending on your definition) 1938-2003 Jeffersons are all "Classic" US Coinage.
This reply points out the obvious, namely there is no concrete definition of "Modern" nor of "Classic".
Regarding the question posed in the OP, the term "Modern Crap" does not offend me at all because some moderns are crap, just as some classics are crap. There are also moderns and classics that are drop dead gorgeous, PQ, high end, rarities. The term "Modern Crap" is used in jest and is akin the the ethnic slurs phenomena pointed out by RYK. >>
I define 'Classic' coinage, as do many others, as the non-presidential, Liberty themed, renaissance issues that were started off by Theodore Roosevelt and would include buffalos, mercs, standing quarters, walkers, peace dollars, Pratt and St. Gaudens gold coins, and could even include morgans and IHC.
no, i believe it's a derogatory term implying something that is generally not true.
Box of 20
Keep the term to modern coinage and leave it at that.
It doesn't need to be anything else or anyone else's problem what they do or don't collect.
You usually know what they are talking about when you see it written here.
-----------
etexmike
NSDR - Life Member
SSDC - Life Member
ANA - Pay As I Go Member
<< <i>Doesn't bug me. I hope it keeps the ones I like cheap. 99% of it IS crap, as are many classics. I only argue with those who suggest 100% is crap. They're stupid. >>
It was no doubt the modernites who coined the term. It was used to convey the feeling
that most classic collectors have for anything minted after 1964. When it's used this way
it is just slightly offensive because of the scatological reference but doesn't offend me, or
most other collectors, at all otherwise.
When a classic collector uses it to refer to the coins or those who deal in them and collect
them then it becomes more offensive.
Fortunately our resident golum knows other words.
(Priest) BLASPHEMY he said it again, did you hear him?
No one holds a seated half or bust quarter or bust half dime in MS state and does not look at the coin with a feeling of "classic value", yet many (myself included) can hold a 71 or 81 or 91 or 2001 (get the idea) proof set in their hands and not look at that ubber graded coin inside as something special---because there are THOUSANDS out there that are the same
Bash away guys --- at least the 3 or 4 of you who know who you are (and so do the rest of us)
i think the usage around here leans more toward a left handed compliment.
Modern Crap ™ = Nice coin
<< <i>Modern crap is a coin that a lot of people (maybe thousands) might own and do not look at as a valueable coin.
No one holds a seated half or bust quarter or bust half dime in MS state and does not look at the coin with a feeling of "classic value", yet many (myself included) can hold a 71 or 81 or 91 or 2001 (get the idea) proof set in their hands and not look at that ubber graded coin inside as something special---because there are THOUSANDS out there that are the same
Bash away guys --- at least the 3 or 4 of you who know who you are (and so do the rest of us)
The definition of value is relative to each particular collector.
For example, my daughter was born in 1971 and the proof set that I purchased at her birth means more to me than any 'dollar' value. It has its own beauty regardless of whether I have the one and only set or whether there there are millions of them (which is actually true).
Additionally, I enjoy the frosted cameo effect that many of these so-called 'common' proof sets display. And on and on.
To sum it up, that which gives you true pleasure is what is valuable, and not necessarily just the monetary aspect of an item.
But we can't bring the "sentimental" factor into this. Of course that 71 has "meaning" to you, but so does that lock of hair from my kids first haircut.
I collect modern coins, in fact one of the things I love the most is looking thru a penny jar or cracking open a new bank roll of any denomination (except Kennedies and Ike's
What I shake my head at, yet don't begrudge anyone else for collecting, is the proof coin in high grade that people spend huge money for that is readily available. I am sure you hear what I am saying even though you could poke holes in some of what I am saying.
Now back to my penny jar
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.