The problem is that you can't really lump all modern proofs together any more than you can lump all moderns together and that just as classic collectors differ so too do modern collectors. There are some great proofs and they aren't all common in high grade. In some cases there's even a wide spread between ty- pical and superb examples. Just as many collectors seek "key dates" based on mintage or grade, proof collectors can do the same.
I do hear what you are saying cladking and I do agree. But I also know for a fact (don't ask me to prove this one though) that you hear what I am saying also...
<< <i>What I shake my head at, yet don't begrudge anyone else for collecting, is the proof coin in high grade that people spend huge money for that is readily available. I am sure you hear what I am saying even though you could poke holes in some of what I am saying.
Now back to my penny jar >>
I myself have paid more than I should have for slabbed high grade Ikes and Kennedys that I have found available in a just as nice condition for just a fraction of what the slabbed coins cost me. I kick myself every time that has happened (and it happens not at all anymore). So yes, it should be buyer beware, buyer beware, buyer beware!!!!!
The term Modern Crap as a distinction of what others collect would be interpreted quite differently by those in the general numismatic community as opposed to those here on the board. Its mostly a humorous definition here. In other venues, it might be considered in poor taste.
Easy enough to test, walk up to any modern coinage dealer at a show and ask if he has any of that Modern Crap?
<< <i>The term Modern Crap as a distinction of what others collect would be interpreted quite differently by those in the general numismatic community as opposed to those here on the board. Its mostly a humorous definition here. In other venues, it might be considered in poor taste.
Easy enough to test, walk up to any modern coinage dealer at a show and ask if he has any of that Modern Crap? >>
Asking a question like that would elicit an ugly response from most dealers I believe.
There's also a lot of Classic Crap™ out there. But many moderns are at a disadvantage, as they comprise designs that are crap struck on planchets made out of crap. Thus crap is much more pervasive in the modern sphere. The term Modern Crap™, however, also carries with it a sneering dismissal of overpriced condition rarities manufactured at random by the gods of plastic, in addition to an implied elitism on the part of those who collect "superior" classic material. As someone who was never accused of NOT being an elitist, I must wholeheartedly endorse the use of this phrase.
<< <i>There's also a lot of Classic Crap™ out there. But many moderns are at a disadvantage, as they comprise designs that are crap struck on planchets made out of crap. Thus crap is much more pervasive in the modern sphere. The term Modern Crap™, however, also carries with it a sneering dismissal of overpriced condition rarities manufactured at random by the gods of plastic, in addition to an implied elitism on the part of those who collect "superior" classic material. As someone who was never accused of NOT being an elitist, I must wholeheartedly endorse the use of this phrase.
Best, Sunnywood >>
Just be careful about which person you choose to call his/hers coins crap. Many WILL take offence just as the poll on this issue shows that approximately one-third of respondents DO NOT LIKE that characterization of their collecting preference.
I collect mostly 'classic' U.S. coins, but also collect some 'modern' U.S. In addition, I also have some foreign, old and new. I may even attempt to collect a few pieces of ancient coinage. Whatever I choose to purchase, I would not want to characterize any of it as crap.
hey frankieboy, right now I collect Morgans and Barber quarters. Morgans are repeatedly called crap, and Barber coinage is repeatedly dismissed as ugly crap ("Who is that man on the obverse?" etc.) ... doesn't bother me at all !!!
<< <i>There's also a lot of Classic Crap™ out there. But many moderns are at a disadvantage, as they comprise designs that are crap struck on planchets made out of crap. Thus crap is much more pervasive in the modern sphere. The term Modern Crap™, however, also carries with it a sneering dismissal of overpriced condition rarities manufactured at random by the gods of plastic, in addition to an implied elitism on the part of those who collect "superior" classic material. As someone who was never accused of NOT being an elitist, I must wholeheartedly endorse the use of this phrase.
Best, Sunnywood >>
Just about everything is mostly perspective. One man sees a base metal slug where I see a high tech coinage material that wears better than just about anything ever produced relative to the cost of manufacture. One collector sees coins that are almost invariably poorly struck while another desires to find the exception. One person sees crappy designs where another sees mediocre art and someone, somewhere sees high art. One person sees increasingly lowering relief where another sees increasing per- centages of well-struck coins.
Where you may see a high grade coin manufactured by the grading companies, I see a gem. Sometimes these gems can be extremely scarce or even rare in the highest levels of preservation.
<< <i>hey frankieboy, right now I collect Morgans and Barber quarters. Morgans are repeatedly called crap, and Barber coinage is repeatedly dismissed as ugly crap ("Who is that man on the obverse?" etc.) ... doesn't bother me at all !!! >>
Called crap by who? Certainly not by me. Both Morgans and Barbers are desired by many and valued by most. I enjoy both of these series although I don't actively collect either, but do have a couple of nice specimens of each. To each his own, but certainly should not be considered crap.
I voted yes because i do accept the term but i don't use it. There are a lot of older coins that are just plain crap also. At least you know what someone is refering to when they use it. I admit that i collect it also. What i dont like is the "Modern Commemmorative Crap"........OOOOOOOOOPSS!!
<< <i>hey frankieboy, right now I collect Morgans and Barber quarters. Morgans are repeatedly called crap, and Barber coinage is repeatedly dismissed as ugly crap ("Who is that man on the obverse?" etc.) ... doesn't bother me at all !!!
Except for the fact that coin dealers can make money on it, no one would even handle MC.
Why is it that you "put your 2 cents in" but only get "a penny for your thoughts"? Where does the other penny (i.e. 50% of your money) go? Sorta like the black hole that is ever increasing pops/declining values of (MOST) MC.
-- "Why thank you DHeath, I'm glad someone appreciated that deliberately outrageous bit of sardonic humor !!" --
Anyone who is familiar with the evolution of Sunnywood's interests can see the gradual shift towards moderns. He'll be neck deep in SBAs before you know it.
I don't eccept it because I don't collect it! Modern crap is anything the TGS's overgrades and sells for moon money. When it's accurately graded, then you'll have a high quality collection. And this includes coins that have been graded MS63 or MS64. Your best coins all don't grade the same or MS67. If they do, then you're collecting slab numbers and not coins.
Leo
The more qualities observed in a coin, the more desirable that coin becomes!
Comments
than you can lump all moderns together and that just as classic collectors differ
so too do modern collectors. There are some great proofs and they aren't all
common in high grade. In some cases there's even a wide spread between ty-
pical and superb examples. Just as many collectors seek "key dates" based on
mintage or grade, proof collectors can do the same.
And the coins are pretty.
<< <i>And the coins are pretty. >>
Even Kennedies and Ike's
I do hear what you are saying cladking and I do agree. But I also know for a fact (don't ask me to prove this one though) that you hear what I am saying also...
<< <i>What I shake my head at, yet don't begrudge anyone else for collecting, is the proof coin in high grade that people spend huge money for that is readily available. I am sure you hear what I am saying even though you could poke holes in some of what I am saying.
Now back to my penny jar
Easy enough to test, walk up to any modern coinage dealer at a show and ask if he has any of that Modern Crap?
<< <i>The term Modern Crap as a distinction of what others collect would be interpreted quite differently by those in the general numismatic community as opposed to those here on the board. Its mostly a humorous definition here. In other venues, it might be considered in poor taste.
Easy enough to test, walk up to any modern coinage dealer at a show and ask if he has any of that Modern Crap? >>
Asking a question like that would elicit an ugly response from most dealers I believe.
Best,
Sunnywood
Sunnywood's Rainbow-Toned Morgans (Retired)
Sunnywood's Barber Quarters (Retired)
<< <i>There's also a lot of Classic Crap™ out there. But many moderns are at a disadvantage, as they comprise designs that are crap struck on planchets made out of crap. Thus crap is much more pervasive in the modern sphere. The term Modern Crap™, however, also carries with it a sneering dismissal of overpriced condition rarities manufactured at random by the gods of plastic, in addition to an implied elitism on the part of those who collect "superior" classic material. As someone who was never accused of NOT being an elitist, I must wholeheartedly endorse the use of this phrase.
Best,
Sunnywood >>
Just be careful about which person you choose to call his/hers coins crap. Many WILL take offence just as the poll on this issue shows that approximately one-third of respondents DO NOT LIKE that characterization of their collecting preference.
I don't mind the term, and I don't collect modern US coins. To each his/her own.
I collect mostly 'classic' U.S. coins, but also collect some 'modern' U.S. In addition, I also have some foreign, old and new. I may even attempt to collect a few pieces of ancient coinage. Whatever I choose to purchase, I would not want to characterize any of it as crap.
Best,
Sunnywood
Sunnywood's Rainbow-Toned Morgans (Retired)
Sunnywood's Barber Quarters (Retired)
<< <i>There's also a lot of Classic Crap™ out there. But many moderns are at a disadvantage, as they comprise designs that are crap struck on planchets made out of crap. Thus crap is much more pervasive in the modern sphere. The term Modern Crap™, however, also carries with it a sneering dismissal of overpriced condition rarities manufactured at random by the gods of plastic, in addition to an implied elitism on the part of those who collect "superior" classic material. As someone who was never accused of NOT being an elitist, I must wholeheartedly endorse the use of this phrase.
Best,
Sunnywood >>
Just about everything is mostly perspective. One man sees a base metal slug where
I see a high tech coinage material that wears better than just about anything ever
produced relative to the cost of manufacture. One collector sees coins that are almost
invariably poorly struck while another desires to find the exception. One person sees
crappy designs where another sees mediocre art and someone, somewhere sees high
art. One person sees increasingly lowering relief where another sees increasing per-
centages of well-struck coins.
Where you may see a high grade coin manufactured by the grading companies, I see
a gem. Sometimes these gems can be extremely scarce or even rare in the highest
levels of preservation.
<< <i>hey frankieboy, right now I collect Morgans and Barber quarters. Morgans are repeatedly called crap, and Barber coinage is repeatedly dismissed as ugly crap ("Who is that man on the obverse?" etc.) ... doesn't bother me at all !!! >>
Called crap by who? Certainly not by me. Both Morgans and Barbers are desired by many and valued by most. I enjoy both of these series although I don't actively collect either, but do have a couple of nice specimens of each. To each his own, but certainly should not be considered crap.
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
Best,
Sunnywood
Sunnywood's Rainbow-Toned Morgans (Retired)
Sunnywood's Barber Quarters (Retired)
I admit that i collect it also. What i dont like is the "Modern Commemmorative Crap"........OOOOOOOOOPSS!!
<< <i>hey frankieboy, right now I collect Morgans and Barber quarters. Morgans are repeatedly called crap, and Barber coinage is repeatedly dismissed as ugly crap ("Who is that man on the obverse?" etc.) ... doesn't bother me at all !!!
>>
I dunno, that doesn't look like ugly crap to me
My posts viewed
since 8/1/6
Anyone who thinks that is ugly crap can sell it to me.
The name is LEE!
Why is it that you "put your 2 cents in" but only get "a penny for your thoughts"?
NO! And I don't collect it either.
<< <i>Do you accept the term "Modern Crap" here on the message boards? >>
NO
a mix of country and rap !
Anyone who is familiar with the evolution of Sunnywood's interests can see the gradual shift towards moderns. He'll be neck deep in SBAs before you know it.
<< <i>Except for the fact that coin dealers can make money on it, no one would even handle MC.
>>
Except for the fact that coin dealers can make money on it, no one would even handle classics either.
I don't see your point.
<< <i>The fact is that a lot of moderns are crap. Say, for example, Frankies.
Russ, NCNE >>
Or IKEs.
Leo
The more qualities observed in a coin, the more desirable that coin becomes!
My Jefferson Nickel Collection