Seeking opinions on value range on a coin contest?
dizzyfoxx
Posts: 9,823 ✭✭✭
I have a number in mind that I feel it's worth. The closest to guess the number I have determined it at, will win a 1941-S Lincoln wheat PCGS MS66.
...based on current sales of various Gettysburgs in MS67 with or without toning, I'd
to hear some opinions of what my Getty should be valued at. Just a relative high/low range is what I'm curious to know what the forum thinks. Important to note, the coin is not for sale, I'd just like to get thoughts on it.
...Also, is it NGC Star* worthy or not worth the submission review?
Edited to add: I just found my coin in September of 1999
...based on current sales of various Gettysburgs in MS67 with or without toning, I'd
to hear some opinions of what my Getty should be valued at. Just a relative high/low range is what I'm curious to know what the forum thinks. Important to note, the coin is not for sale, I'd just like to get thoughts on it. ...Also, is it NGC Star* worthy or not worth the submission review?Edited to add: I just found my coin in September of 1999
...There's always time for coin collecting. 
0
Comments
<< <i>$1200, but only if the slab comes autographed by Bingham, Billy "White Shoes" Johnson, Early Campbell, and Kenny Stabler. >>
Would that be $1200 per autograph???
the coin is sweet, but a * ?
hm. i can see nice toning allowing for it. why not? sure.
hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
my value range for this coin would be it would sell for including the juice at a heritage signature sale
3250-3750
if it was on a major commem dealers web site that specializeed in early commems and was listed at a price where it would sell for in a couple of weeks or less time $3750
My daughter was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes at the age of 2 (2003). My son was diagnosed with Type 1 when he was 17 on December 31, 2009. We were stunned that another child of ours had been diagnosed. Please, if you don't have a favorite charity, consider giving to the JDRF (Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation)
JDRF Donation
weather it has a star on the holder or not
Thanks for the chance.
A recent example for a rough comparison
Clearly yours is much nicer than the coin sold on Heritage......but it's in an NGC holder so I don't think it would bring as much as a PCGS coin.....so
$4000
My TV Blog
value as it sits ... I'd be thinking it's worth at least 3600. based on the little I know about these
“We are only their care-takers,” he posed, “if we take good care of them, then centuries from now they may still be here … ”
Todd - BHNC #242
Looking for alot of crap.
Why not cross it to PCGS?
I guess it is worth somewhere between $2600 and $3000. This NGC coin has been around for enough years that I doubt it would cross to PCGS at the same grade. I also doubt it would get the NGC star, because by now someone would have already tried for the star, probably more than once. It is a lovely coin, and it deserves to be reholdered.
My grandchildren. The heirs to my collection! (Just not to soon I hope)
2750......
TorinoCobra71
Capped Bust Half Series
Capped Bust Half Dime Series
You said your coin is not for sale. If I were you I would reconsider, and contact some of the CU members giving your coin so much worth. You have four people saying over $4000, with a high of $5,655. How about you consign your coin to auction so we know what it is worth for real?
9000
">"http://www.cashcrate.com/5663377"
Experience the World through Numismatics...it's more than you can imagine.
It will star if resubmitted
$4,200.00...
Currently Listed: Nothing
Take Care, Dave
<< <i>Dizzy,
You said your coin is not for sale. If I were you I would reconsider, and contact some of the CU members giving your coin so much worth. You have four people saying over $4000, with a high of $5,655. How about you consign your coin to auction so we know what it is worth for real?
Tom, I've considered that
Anyhow, thanks to all who have participated in a somewhat convoluted contest. I'm not going to divulge my "final answer" yet but I will say this... based on auction prices, retail prices, and my three offers I've received on this coin, the closest members to the correct answer are ROBERTB, DickyBetz, FatMan, mommam17,colorcommem. I will also say this, I've seen quite a few high grade early commems in NGC holders with the "STAR" designation, and in IMHO, it's a no brainer that this coin should and will be in a star holder.
Auction archives of Getty's in MS67
..and Getty in MS68...which appears to be the same coin
<< <i>$2277.50 >>
I'm soooo sorry but I just can't hold it in any longer...
Bruce Scher
<< <i>I had a real nice 68 that i bought for 30k and sold for just a tick under 50k about a year or so ago thru a heritage auction..this is one of my favorite issues so i follow sales a bit..i recall 2 very nice 67 grade coins that ive seen with very nice toning as well the first sold in the summer of 03' for about 6k and then about a yr later another example sold for near 10k...both of these 67's had real nice color and were strong for the grade..im sure Gregs coin (dizzy's now) would fall on par with these 2 other 67's though if memory serves on of these coins (probably the 10k example) looked for close to a 68 and had real similar color to my 68 example..
Bruce Scher >>
Bruce, I value every single opinion and all input from each of my fellow forum members, but I must say that your input is a notch higher based on my knowledge of your knowledge on early commems.