"I would call NGC and explain to them what happened. I would ask them to check to see if this dealer submitted an 1889 gold dollar in the last two months."
IT'LL NEVER HAPPEN. I do not believe NGC will release information to a third party about submissions without a court order, nor should they. This is confidential information. Also 1889 gold dollars are kind of like 81-S morgans. Common as dirt. Lastly, in looking at the new pics that were just added, I am 99% certain this coin is NOT a proof.
John
John Maben
Pegasus Coin and Jewelry (Brick and Mortar)
ANA LM, PNG, APMD, FUN, Etc
800-381-2646
<< <i>A) Personally, I believe it is a low grade proof MS 63 or 64 >>
>>
As opposed to a high grade mint state PF 63 or 64?
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>As opposed to a high grade mint state PF 63 or 64? >>
The first question, in my eyes, is if it is A) a business strike in MS, a prooflike business strike in MS, or C) a proof (PF). I'd say the consensus here is A) or , and after further study and IM correspondence I'm in agreement. In short, "ERT" in the Indian's headdress is not weak in my coin, and this seems to be the most telling difference between a proof and a business strike -- all examples of proof 1889's seem to have this feature, and my coin does not. This leaves A) or .
The next question is what it would grade.
The last question is what the replacement value would be.
Take care...Mike
p.s. this dealer is not listed on the NGC dealer list.
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
For future use: Anyone can submit to ANACS----any ANA member can submit to NGC----for a $49/year "Silver" membership you can submit to PCGS. I, personally, have never been comfortable giving coins to a third party to submit.
I would add to what Mark says below, the following:
1. That the dealer should pay you $100. more than the $1100. Mark suggests. Quite frankly, there should be a "pain/suffering/angst" penalty for your delay while all this has been going on. If you have a receipt for the coin over $1100., then he should pay you $100. over that.
2. If you choose to follow Mark's suggestion and give him 14 more days, I would add telling him at the same time, what you expect financially at the end of those 14 days, paid in full, or it immediately gets turned over to both the ANA (if the dealer is a member) and a lawyer.
3. I would never, under any circumstances, have any business with that dealer again. How they handled this is inexcusable.
<< <i>The dealer certainly deserves most of the blame for losing or misplacing the coin and (initially) misinforming the client about its status. However, the client was at fault for not addressing the insurance value of the coin when leaving it with the dealer.
I remember the initial thread and was/am still of the opinion that the coin is a business strike. Although there is probably no way to tell just from the images, odds greatly favor the coin's non-proof status.
If I were responsible for arriving at the fairest possible solution under the circumstances, I would:
Give the dealer another 14 days to come up with/find the coin and get it back to me in the condition it was in when he took possession of it.
Require, that if he is unable to do so, he pay fair retail market value for an MS64 (business strike) - roughly $1100.
Unfortunately, there is no way to insure that one party doesn't get a "good" deal at the expense of the other, but that is how I would handle it. >>
If the dealer is acting as an agent for NGC, I'd notify both the dealer and NGC that you'd like the coin returned within 14 days, graded or not, or be reimbursed. Your value can be determined from Coinworld's "CoinValues, and I'd guess it's for a MS-64 coin. To bad you got off to a bad start back collecting.
I bet the coin resides in a high PF holder? The dealer seen dollar signs when it was returned; and it supposely is LOST in the mail? CRAP... There is ways to find out? Contact your local POLICE; have them contact NGC to see when they received it? what they graded it? when they mailed it back? NGC will not give info; but to the POLICE they will.. NGC sends coins back from submission via Registered Mail only; the police can find out if he picked it up and SIGNED for it? Do not settle for him paying you what you paid? I would pursue this until I was blue in the face... The police can find your coin.....
If somebody has said this before, I apologize. I think I would be on the phone to NCG and inquire as to whether or not the coin ever was graded. I mean that coin doesn't get graded every day, can't be too many since the end of May. Inquire to find out if that dealer actually did submit it and then resold it. My scenerio is they got it graded, it came back back, they sold it and now are going to pay you business strike value. Nice tidy profit for a nicely time lost coin. NCG might not be to forth coming but I would try.
Comments
or
Maybe it'll be graded when you see it next on E-bay.
IT'LL NEVER HAPPEN. I do not believe NGC will release information to a third party about submissions without a court order, nor should they. This is confidential information. Also 1889 gold dollars are kind of like 81-S morgans. Common as dirt. Lastly, in looking at the new pics that were just added, I am 99% certain this coin is NOT a proof.
John
John Maben
Pegasus Coin and Jewelry (Brick and Mortar)
ANA LM, PNG, APMD, FUN, Etc
800-381-2646
<< <i>Lastly, in looking at the new pics that were just added, I am 99% certain this coin is NOT a proof. >>
John is much more confident than I am - I am only (approximately) 96.5% "certain this coin is NOT a proof".
<< <i>
<< <i>A) Personally, I believe it is a low grade proof MS 63 or 64 >>
>>
As opposed to a high grade mint state PF 63 or 64?
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>As opposed to a high grade mint state PF 63 or 64? >>
The first question, in my eyes, is if it is A) a business strike in MS,
The next question is what it would grade.
The last question is what the replacement value would be.
Take care...Mike
p.s. this dealer is not listed on the NGC dealer list.
Anyone can submit to ANACS----any ANA member can submit to NGC----for a $49/year "Silver" membership you can submit to PCGS.
I, personally, have never been comfortable giving coins to a third party to submit.
1. That the dealer should pay you $100. more than the $1100. Mark suggests. Quite frankly, there should be a "pain/suffering/angst" penalty for your delay while all this has been going on. If you have a receipt for the coin over $1100., then he should pay you $100. over that.
2. If you choose to follow Mark's suggestion and give him 14 more days, I would add telling him at the same time, what you expect financially at the end of those 14 days, paid in full, or it immediately gets turned over to both the ANA (if the dealer is a member) and a lawyer.
3. I would never, under any circumstances, have any business with that dealer again. How they handled this is inexcusable.
<< <i>The dealer certainly deserves most of the blame for losing or misplacing the coin and (initially) misinforming the client about its status. However, the client was at fault for not addressing the insurance value of the coin when leaving it with the dealer.
I remember the initial thread and was/am still of the opinion that the coin is a business strike. Although there is probably no way to tell just from the images, odds greatly favor the coin's non-proof status.
If I were responsible for arriving at the fairest possible solution under the circumstances, I would:
Give the dealer another 14 days to come up with/find the coin and get it back to me in the condition it was in when he took possession of it.
Require, that if he is unable to do so, he pay fair retail market value for an MS64 (business strike) - roughly $1100.
Unfortunately, there is no way to insure that one party doesn't get a "good" deal at the expense of the other, but that is how I would handle it. >>
Camelot
<< <i>I lost my mind and nobody seems to care.
I do.
Say, did you leave it a dealers shop without a receipt?
billy