Options
Dealer has "lost" my coin! Advice requested...
Some of you may recall a thread on this coin, the coin from my avatar:


My purchase of the coin is detailed here -- there was some question if this was a proof or just a prooflike business strike:
Original Thread
In short, I gave the coin on 5/20 to my local coin dealer, whom I have no relationship with but who has been there for quite some time, and who promised to send it to NGC for grading. Understanding there was quite a backlog of coins at NGC (45 business days), it didn't come as a huge surprise last month, fully two months after handing the coin to them, when I inquired as to the status and they said it has not come back from NGC. I called them again yesterday and inquired about the coin, and this time they told me they had not ever sent it, much to my surprise. They changed their tune and said that they were waiting for enough coins to send to NGC to be graded and had in fact never sent it!?! I said that's fine, if they could just return the coin I will have it graded myself.
Today they call me back and say that they can't find the coin. They checked their entire store and even called NGC to be sure they didn't actually send it in and it was still at NGC.
They said they would continue to look, and I told them that I would contact them next week to discuss next steps, and I think they are going to try and pay me for the coin.
What advice would you give to someone in my shoes? Thanks in advance...Mike
[edit -- spelling corrected]


My purchase of the coin is detailed here -- there was some question if this was a proof or just a prooflike business strike:
Original Thread
In short, I gave the coin on 5/20 to my local coin dealer, whom I have no relationship with but who has been there for quite some time, and who promised to send it to NGC for grading. Understanding there was quite a backlog of coins at NGC (45 business days), it didn't come as a huge surprise last month, fully two months after handing the coin to them, when I inquired as to the status and they said it has not come back from NGC. I called them again yesterday and inquired about the coin, and this time they told me they had not ever sent it, much to my surprise. They changed their tune and said that they were waiting for enough coins to send to NGC to be graded and had in fact never sent it!?! I said that's fine, if they could just return the coin I will have it graded myself.
Today they call me back and say that they can't find the coin. They checked their entire store and even called NGC to be sure they didn't actually send it in and it was still at NGC.
They said they would continue to look, and I told them that I would contact them next week to discuss next steps, and I think they are going to try and pay me for the coin.
What advice would you give to someone in my shoes? Thanks in advance...Mike
[edit -- spelling corrected]
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
0
Comments
I am just curious what the coin is generally worth.
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
Second... well, hell, I dunno what to say. That sucks!
They'd better make good on the whole situation!
I hope it turns up. Maybe it will?
If it doesn't, make sure you get a good price for it, or get a lawyer.
Collector since 1976. On the CU forums here since 2001.
NoEbayAuctionsForNow
They were quite conciliatory on the telephone, having made the inference that if they couldn't track it down they would pay for it. They are not, at this point, denying having received the coin, but I expect when it comes time to discuss the value it will get very interesting...Mike
p.s. spelling is not this engineer's strong suit, LMV.
Ah yes, the value will be somewhere between the FMV for a Proof-67 DCAM and a counterfeit.
Neo...
Also, getting a lawyer is probably good advice, this could get ugly.
Edited to add:....... I just re-read what I posted........... I must be getting soft in my old age
3 "DAMMIT BOYS"
4 "YOU SUCKS"
Numerous POTD (But NONE officially recognized)
Seated Halves are my specialty !
Seated Half set by date/mm COMPLETE !
Seated Half set by WB# - 289 down / 31 to go !!!!!
(1) "Smoebody smack him" from CornCobWipe !
IN MEMORY OF THE CUOF
Give them a reasonable amount of time to find the coin. I am more concerned with the condition of the coin if it is ever found. It could have fallen beneath a file cabinet or something, and there may be a question as to its condition before and after it was lost (and then found).
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
Looking into the future, who would be the best professional opinion on the grade and value of this coin that I might solicit? Also, any recommendations concerning legal representation would be appreciated.
Thanks for all your insight guys...Mike
Russ, NCNE
Huge!
Do you have any documentation as to what you paid for the coin - as an indication of value? Did anyone else who is qualified to report, ever see the coin? If it gets to a valuation point, you will need to have some evidence of value......
If I had it my way, stupidity would be painful!
<< <i>Is there a dramatic difference in value if the coin came back from NGC as a proof rather than a business strike?
Huge! >>
If I were a cynical person I might wonder if that's what happened and the forthcoming compensation for the "lost" coin will be for a business strike. If I were a cynical person, that is.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>Is there a dramatic difference in value if the coin came back from NGC as a proof rather than a business strike?
Huge! >>
If I were a cynical person I might wonder if that's what happened and the forthcoming compensation for the "lost" coin will be for a business strike. If I were a cynical person, that is.
Russ, NCNE >>
And if I were a "cynical" person after reading this part makes me wonder. That is, if.... I was a cynical person. Hmmm, first it went to NGC then it didn't?
I guess everybody's entitled to a mistake.
<< <i>fully two months after handing the coin to them, when I inquired as to the status and they said it has not come back from NGC. I called them again yesterday and inquired about the coin, and this time they told me they had not ever sent it, much to my surprise. They changed their tune and said that they were waiting for enough coins to send to NGC to be graded and had in fact never sent it!? >>
billy
Yep, it's those statements from the dealer that would be the foundation for my cynicism, it I were a cynical person.
Russ, NCNE
Be sure to save your receipt for what you paid for it, along with their receipt.
If you're lucky, you could wind up even.
My posts viewed
since 8/1/6
At least you have good photos that could ID the coin if it turns up.
New collectors, please educate yourself before spending money on coins; there are people who believe that using numismatic knowledge to rip the naïve is what this hobby is all about.
Heck, he'll probably find the coin in his shop somewhere. I wish you the best.
As a side note..... A local dealer has submitted a few coins for me that I know very well.
He ALWAYS gives me a receipt with my stated insured value.
Fly-In Club
My PCGS Registry Sets
The coin had no hairlines whatsoever and only a few minute contact marks. There were what looks to my eyes like some planchet flaws in several areas, and some copper spotting I'm told is common on gold of this era. I saw no contact marks, and the coin looked like at least proof-like to my newbie eyes. I have a recepit of the original purchase, many digital pictures (and a post) to document the coin and its condition, and the receipt as decribed above from the coin dealer.
The value of this coin is where it gets interesting. I paid $340 on e-bay for it. The value for business strikes in MS goes from $250 (MS60) and $4,500 (MS67) (from PCGS price guide -- Heritage auctions seem to indicate this may be low). The value of proof-likes in high MS is between $2k and $7k (from Heritage auction records). The value of proofs is between $6,250 and $37,500 (from PCGS price guide -- Heritage auction records are between $2,800 for a PR63 and $11,000 for a PR66).
Since some of you questioned my logic...and in retrospect it is suspect. This dealer has been in buisness for years in his current location -- it is not far from where I live and I drive by it all the time. This dealer is relatively well known in the area from what I've been told, and attends the local shows. He is also an "official" PCGS dealer listed on this website. This is no fly-by-night organization. FWIW, when I bought this coin, I was just returning to the hobby not having collected since my childhood, and received advise to get it certified through a local dealer.
I'm still in need of some legal counsel and a subject matter expert to figure out more accurately the value of this coin. Advice would be appreciated. Thanks again guys...Mike
You were way too trusting for not really knowing the guy that well and leaving a coin with that potential value. With a receipt that really proves little about the coin. Kind of leaves an uncomfortable feeling in my stomach.
That being said, I do hope very much that it is truely temporarily misplaced and the situation gets resolved quickly.
<< <i>I guess I can be considered one of the cynical ones....
You were way too trusting for not really knowing the guy that well and leaving a coin with that potential value. With a receipt that really proves little about the coin. Kind of leaves an uncomfortable feeling in my stomach.
That being said, I do hope very much that it is truely temporarily misplaced and the situation gets resolved quickly. >>
I must be more cynical yet - I heard a barn door close a while ago
billy
MikeInFL:
Its the other Mike in Florida. I'd like to hear from you in a PM, as to where you left your 1889 Gold Dollar.
I can't believe this senario. I feel for you.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
As to getting more then what you paid for the coin from a dealer you don't know because you think it might be a proof....good luck. {It won't happen}.
Les
A) What grade did you think the is/was/should be?
Either way the dealer you gave it to has some splaining to do.TextText
John
PS- If I lost someone's coin I would be so embarrased I'd do anything reasonable to make it right.
John Maben
Pegasus Coin and Jewelry (Brick and Mortar)
ANA LM, PNG, APMD, FUN, Etc
800-381-2646
Misunderstandings and loose documentation at best.
I would assume you will get paid something for the receipt you DO have.
Other than that would be too tough for a 3rd party to determine anything.
Are you an ANA member? ANA members can send in their OWN NGC coins.
Take what you can get and learn.
And I'm not a lawyer, but I think it would be common sense to NOT post any retaliatory comments about the dealer ..... UNLESS.... you have a judgement in your pocket.
Just my two bits.
For what it's worth, a great many small denomination gold coins from that era have PL or semi-PL surfaces, and many that appear completely PL with cameo contrast do not get so noted on their NGC or PCGS holders, for reasons I don't know. So I'd say the odds are good you can figure this, if genuine, as an ordinary business strike of whatever grade, and base your value estimate there. Still, if it is real, it should be worth a lot more than you paid for it...
Good luck!
I know this information is "closing the barn door after the ponies have run down the road."
YJ
<< <i>"B) Knowing e-bay, what do you really think the chances that a $340 coin would grade out that high and carry such a value. It is far more likley to buy a coin for $800 on e-bay and have it be worth $200. The odds of buyinga raw coin on e-bay for $340 and have it be worth thousands are as close to zero." >>
There are just as many unknowledgeable sellers on ebay as there are buyers - opportunities to buy low and sell high exist everyday in dozens of coin categories. But I'll admit your odds are better if you are an expert in your specialty.
As for the actual topic of this post - in my experience, when something seems odd or suspicious, it usually is. I hope the resolution is good in this case and that the 'lesson' learned here is not an expensive one.
<< <i>A) What grade did you think the is/was/should be?
A) Personally, I believe it is a low grade proof MS 63 or 64 best case, and about the same grade prooflike, worst case. I've looked at virtually every picture of proof and proof-like pics I could find online, and the strike most closely resembles a proof. Here's one that is a spitting image, strike wise: Heritage PR 63 CAM. I'm anything but an authority -- thus my request for a subject matter expert.
Take care...Mike
next time you get a full receipt from the dealer with the grade, method of manufacture and valuation of the coin from the dealer and when he will specifically send the coin into the grading service with the submission form number on your receipt which means it is already written up on the form and going in this day or the next and if such a valuable rip coin then pay THE DEALER TO DO THIS NOW FOR YOU AND ONLY SEND THE COIN INTO NGC ON THIS FORM AND REQUEST THAT THE COIN BE SENT DIRECTLY BACK TO YOU if you do not get all of this you walk out of the shop with your coin
and join the pcgs collectors club for a measily 99 dollars and send the coin in yourself if it is such a rip as being a cheap a$$ gets you into trouble like this
maybe a happy ending to the story and you get your coin back
if you get it back then send the coin in yourself to pcgs reread as per the above!!
myself based on just this photo of this coin and all the diagonastics of a proof vs biz strike aqs there are like 12 diagonistics many sifferent combos too.....as such for these specific 1889 one dollar proof gold coins and some are confusing
and i would need to see the coin in hand sight seen to tell you for sure
but based on the photos and compairing the diagonastics my opinion would be this is a biz strike coin based on the proof diagonastics and you definately had a great photo to do this from!!
Per Breen: "Proofs have ERT weak, date low, like some Uncs. Many melted as unsold. Uncs. are plentiful, saved as last of their kind. Dates higher or lower, normally slanting downward to r...Counterfeits are common."
Per Bass III catalog: Lot 79: "The attribution of this piece as beinfg a Proof is tentative...On the headband, ERT is missing, a key that bears further study as we go to press."
Per Bass IV catalog: Lot 113: "ERT in Liberty are weak, characteristic of both Proofs and circulation strikes."
It sounds like the experts even have trouble telling a proof from a business strike.
RYK, Thanks for digging those up for me. I'd say the jury is still out -- IIRC most folks were split between MS and PR when I posted the coin the first time.
I'm continuing to hope this is just a case of a misplaced coin, but I'm preparing myself for the worst case.
Take care...Mike
Here are a few of them:
For the complete photos, including much higher resolution copies, please look here: Gold Dollar Pics
Take care...Mike
<< <i>A) Personally, I believe it is a low grade proof MS 63 or 64 >>
I remember the initial thread and was/am still of the opinion that the coin is a business strike. Although there is probably no way to tell just from the images, odds greatly favor the coin's non-proof status.
If I were responsible for arriving at the fairest possible solution under the circumstances, I would:
Give the dealer another 14 days to come up with/find the coin and get it back to me in the condition it was in when he took possession of it.
Require, that if he is unable to do so, he pay fair retail market value for an MS64 (business strike) - roughly $1100.
Unfortunately, there is no way to insure that one party doesn't get a "good" deal at the expense of the other, but that is how I would handle it.
You are not without recourse. While using a lawyer to resolve this may not be feasible, even if one would take the case..... you have Small Claims Court. Most people assume small claims court is for nickel-dime fueds, and kind of used to be. But limits allowed have been raised, and I think in some states claims up to $10000 may be used. In Nebraska, I think it is $5000, but not sure what it is in FL.
This route could be in your favor. First, you present your own case to the judge. Kind of like a people's court.... You have many reference pictures of your coin; you have many reference pictures of documented uncirculated coins and proof-like coins as well as their documented values; you have documentation of how the dealer failed to properly document and safeguard your trusted submission to him. The judge weighs the evidence and then makes the decision. I think sometimes the standard of evidence-proof may tend to be relaxed.... especially if the judge smells a rat..... and I certainly think this would weigh heavily in your favor. You could have a good chance of recouping not only your initial amount, but something closer to the true value of a proof-like based on the above mentioned documentation.
And the decision carries the weight of the law.... just as if you had gone the route of a lawyer.
So what I myself would probably do.... give the dealer a week or so, in case the coin truely has been misplaced. If not found, present him with a claim for the value of a proof-like coin. If he will not make good on it..... proceed with the Small Claims Court lawsuit.
Whether this was truely an accidental loss, or a more calculated manuever..... you should not have to take a loss due to the dealers actions or inactions.
If so, I think he has violated the terms of his NGC dealer membership and you may have recourse.
and they're cold.
I don't want nobody to shoot me in the foxhole."
Mary
Best Franklin Website