Options
Does this forum have an impact on the coin market?
There are several really heavy hitters in the coin market who participate and frequent this forum regularly. There are many very knowledgeable members of this forum who can usually answer even the most obscure questions that come up. There is also a lot of discussion on matters of personal taste which show where collector interest is at any one time.
I know from my own personal experience that participation in this forum has changed my views and opinions on the types of coins that I collect. There are many dealers who participate in this forum who I'm sure pay a great deal of attention to the opinions of this forum becuase it is obvious that collector interest and focus is discussed a lot here.
I'm sure that there are other factors that have a huge impact on the coin market, eg, scum sucking dealers on ebay, internet auctions, etc. Does this forum have an impact? I'd like to think so, and I hope it's a positive one.
I know from my own personal experience that participation in this forum has changed my views and opinions on the types of coins that I collect. There are many dealers who participate in this forum who I'm sure pay a great deal of attention to the opinions of this forum becuase it is obvious that collector interest and focus is discussed a lot here.
I'm sure that there are other factors that have a huge impact on the coin market, eg, scum sucking dealers on ebay, internet auctions, etc. Does this forum have an impact? I'd like to think so, and I hope it's a positive one.
0
Comments
<< <i>Does this forum have an impact? >>
I think so. When I started collecting toned Peace $ 3 years ago I'd go to a show and no one had one for sale, matter of fact most dealers told me not to even waste my time with them. Luckily I was able to grab a bunch of them at reasonable prices. Now I see alot of interest in them and see many here posting pics of them. I've also noticed more dealers paying attention to them and the prices have really skyrocketed in auctions and on Ebay.
I think Russ has made a huge impact with AH Kennedys. Who even cared about them before Russ. Now I see dealers listing AH Kennedys in their cases. I think the VAM market is starting to heat up for both the Morgans and Peace $. So much that PCGS is getting into them. Much of that has to do with this forum.
Didn't Supercoin get PCGS to attribute the 72 Ikes as well? I think this forum has a huge impact on this industry!
TPN
<< <i>Yes. It has an impact on me, and I'm part of the market, just like everyone here. >>
:
Anything that influences the buying habits of collectors, dealers, and Investors has a Influence, and this forum is no different !! So the answer is YES !!!!)
David Hall wanted the forum members to give their opinions on having PCGS designate it on the holder.
BST successful dealings with:MsMorrisine, goldman86
and it sets us apart from practitioners and consultants. Gregor
I'd like to think that this board has a positive impact on newer collectors. They can save themselves a lot of grief by reading what's being shared here.
New collectors, please educate yourself before spending money on coins; there are people who believe that using numismatic knowledge to rip the naïve is what this hobby is all about.
<< <i>I doubt it. Probably the only impact is with PCGS. I figure not even a 10th of the collecting population is on the boards. >>
It is more like less then 1% of collecting public even knows these boards exist. The are only a few thousand coin collectors on these forums and most people say that there are 10's of millions of collectors in this country.
<< <i>No I dont think so at least not for me. As for the speared Bison I think that was a done deal prior to DH asking the members how they felt. >>
You must be right since the opinions were overwhelmingly against the idea. I'm sure the reaction was not foreseen, and what was expected was some kind of excited mindless ebay-buyer-like response, which pretty much tells you what he thinks about this group. That the opinions were intelligent and well thought out must have been disconcerting, and probably brought responses like "they're just jealous" and "what do you expect from this bunch" from the discoverer. At least it gave us an opportunity to suggest he get with the program on real varieties.
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
LITTLEJOHN
------------------------------
You must be right since the opinions were overwhelmingly against the idea. I'm sure the reaction was not foreseen, and what was expected was some kind of excited mindless ebay-buyer-like response, which pretty much tells you what he thinks about this group. That the opinions were intelligent and well thought out must have been disconcerting, and probably brought responses like "they're just jealous" and "what do you expect from this bunch" from the discoverer. At least it gave us an opportunity to suggest he get with the program on real varieties.
---------------
YOU BETTER GO BACK AND LOOK AT THE opinions AGAIN,BECAUSE MOST WAS FOR IT.
------------------
HI
i was one of the player in that.
and i can tell you it was not a done deal , prior to DH asking the members .!!
littlejohn .
There might be specific cases for certain very scarce or truly rare coins that this forum might have an impact, but that's far from any sort of general market.
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
3 "DAMMIT BOYS"
4 "YOU SUCKS"
Numerous POTD (But NONE officially recognized)
Seated Halves are my specialty !
Seated Half set by date/mm COMPLETE !
Seated Half set by WB# - 289 down / 31 to go !!!!!
(1) "Smoebody smack him" from CornCobWipe !
IN MEMORY OF THE CUOF
Joe
Slabbing, eBay and registry sets are much greater factors.
However there is no single place that more numismatic information and personalities
are available at what is essentially a real time basis. To some extent this site is better
than a huge numismatic library because among us we own virtually all the books (and
written more than a few). But most importantly there is no better place to come and be
in tune with the hobby and the market.
Events here are viewed by many hobby insiders and are watched for clues about sup-
ply, demand, interests, trends, and ideas. There are nearly 17,000 people registered
to the site and most are likely coin collectors. (apparently about two thirds). Many of
these no longer visit but there are also very large numbers of lurkers.
We are like a very well attended 24/ 7 coin club. Who wouldn't be interested?
Absolutely. It's a fact. That's why dealers come here and do Damage Control when a member posts about their poor business practices.
Also I would guess at least a few hundred on here are very influential by talking to other collectors and dealers!
Russ, NCNE
HuH? Well, it was the thought that counts.
and dealers. So too are the dealers impacted by our thoughts and opinions. The collective
knowledge of this Forum is a force that indeed has an impact on the market place. Shinning forth, thru
all of the hyperbole, hype, propaganda and self serving opinions, is the truth , the facts, honesty and
opinions of merit and experience. Hale Freedonia!!
Camelot
What ziggy29 said.
- Marcus Tullius Cicero, 106-43 BC
Small impact, perhaps, but real.
K
My 1866 Philly Mint Set