Options
Can anyone tell me why I have such a hard time finding an 1805 Half-Cent in an ANACS/NGC/PCGS holder
keets
Posts: 25,351 ✭✭✭✭✭
I've looked for quite a while probably the better part of 2004 off and on, can't seem to find anything. There are always 1804's and the earlier dates pop up with seeming regularity. Heck, I just perused eBay quick and found an 1809/6 and an 1811, two tougher dates but they aren't the Bust Type I'm stuck on. So tell me copper guys, what's so special about an 1805 that there aren't many in holders and all the raw coins are cleaned-crap-planchet-well-worn-dogs??
Al H.
Al H.
0
Comments
We'll use our hands and hearts and if we must we'll use our heads.
But seriously, one of the things working against you is that the early copper people aren't all that big on slabs. Have you seen any raw?
New collectors, please educate yourself before spending money on coins; there are people who believe that using numismatic knowledge to rip the naïve is what this hobby is all about.
that was good for a laugh!!! as i explained, most of what i see raw at shows and on eBay have either been cleaned or are in a grade lower than i'd like. that's about XF-AU. keep in mind that i don't search religiously like i do for some stuff but whenever i do it's the same result, nothing.
do you remember that one i found back at the P.A.N. Show in 2003?? i do, and i remember what you said when i asked you what you thought of it-----"Early copper in a Gold PCI holder, that sounds safe!!!" i opted to pass!! what a pal.
al h.
Thier is a local guy here who moved down from Pa. He has been coming into the local shop each week selling off a few coppers to pay for his living expenses. At one time, he must have accumulated a tremendous amount of Half cents and large cents. Of the hundreds that he has brought in, I can only remeber seeing a single 05 Half cent in the group? and it was lower grade like Fine , If I recall?
jim
"Seu cabra da peste,
"Sou Mangueira......."
al h.
Second the survival rate of high grade coins was low. An AU 1805 C-1 would be just below the condition census, and an AU 1805 C-4 would be tied for either CC2 or CC3. An XF C-4 would just miss the bottom of the CC. So yes in the condition you are looking for most of them probably are tied up in EAC hands.
1805 in Canada
Well the auction is on the Canada eBay, but the item is in Washington. hmmm.
Nice Cohen 1 and Cohen 4 varieties are generally available from the major copper sellers. XF/AU specimens go for around $1K.
An 1805 Cohen 2 variety is a Rarity 5 and a very tough coin to find nice and are seldom seen for sale. A coin graded Good generally goes for $5K or more.
The Cohen 3 variety is a Rarity 4 and is plagued by corrosion. A coin grade Fine will set one back $6K and up.
When I was collecting half cents by die variety I upgraded my set to the best coins that I could find for the most part. The only pieces that were off the table were the ones that cost many thousands of dollars, and I did not run into that many of those. Here’s a list of the grades for the four varieties of 1805 half cents that I ultimately had and some selling prices as best as I could remember them. The grades were according to EAC standards:
C-1, Medium 5, stemless, EF-40 sharpness, got a Body Bag from NGC for artificial toning, which was a load of bull. Sold raw to a dealer for $375.00 (Gray Sheet “bid” was $180 at the time.)
C-2, Small 5, stems, the rare one (about 20 examples known in all grades) – Ground salvage, Good-4 sharpness, porous, sold for $1,100 to a specialist copper dealer more than a decade ago.
C-3, Small 5, stems, the less rare one – Fine-12 with a great look for the variety - sold about a decade ago to two dealers who bought it as a “joint venture” for $1,600. Today this would be worth $6,000
C-4, Large 5, stems, not quite as common as C-1. EF-40 sharpness, with a small natural planchet fleck (lamination) on the cheek. Sold for $350 about a decade ago.
As you can see there were no “homeruns” here Keets. This date is tough. (BTW you had a chance to buy the C-1 from me a couple of FUN shows ago, but passed.)
As for the other coins you mentioned, the 1809 over 6 half cent (really a blundered die, not an overdate) is the most common 1809 half cent variety IMO. AND 1809 along with 1804 are among the most common half cent dates.
The 1811 is scarce, but low grade porous examples always seem to be around. These coins have a hard time finding permanent loving homes because of high prices and ugly coins that usually fail to "grow" on you.
You don’t find a lot of early copper in slabs because the graders at PCGS and NGC are either too strict or in some cases very poorly educated about how to grade copper. If they were as tough on gold and silver coins as they are on copper, there would be very few of those in slabs too.
Charlie