Dipped and cleaned and still he grades it MS 63

cosmos66 · October 31, 2003 12:03PM

gimme a break!

kamehameha00 · October 31, 2003 12:05PM

says its an 's' but its clearly an 'o'

BillJones · October 31, 2003 12:06PM

Dipped, cleaned and it looks like it's not Mint State, and still he grades it MS-63.

Such a deal!

cosmos66 · October 31, 2003 12:07PM

And yet he has 100% positive feedback.

razorface1027 · October 31, 2003 12:17PM

I think he/she dipped it in NOXON and hand polished it.

darktone · October 31, 2003 12:25PM

I don't see whats so bad about the description? He comes right out and say's it is cleaned and dipped. Heck I routinely get coins in PCGS and NGC slabs that are cleaned and dipped in grades of 60-65. Also he must be doing something right to get 8,000 positives and only to negatives. mike

roadrunner · October 31, 2003 12:31PM

You can keep a 100% FB rating as long as you refund the money of irrate ex-customers. They are happy to get their money back and most if not all will give you POS FB to be free and clear of you.

That coin is worth XF/AU money. MS63???

roadrunner

darktone · October 31, 2003 12:38PM

<< <i>That coin is worth XF/AU money. MS63??? >>

that would be my guess of the value also as I would think most dipped and cleaned MS coins end up net grading in this area. mike

Topdollarpaid · October 31, 2003 12:52PM

Well I hope the buyer needs a 1886 - S from new orleans

he emailed me and said he would fix the pic now it shows the correct mint

darktone · October 31, 2003 12:58PM

<< <i>Well I hope the buyer needs a 1886 - S from new orleans >>

Yeah, you got that right!

mike

nwcs · October 31, 2003 1:16PM

At least they admitted it is cleaned and dipped.

JRocco · October 31, 2003 1:59PM

I bet that was a real beauty a long time ago....

Conder101 · November 1, 2003 7:14PM

kamehamehaoo - says its an 's' but its clearly an 'o'

Topdollarpaid - Well I hope the buyer needs a 1886 - S from new orleans

Darktone - << Well I hope the buyer needs a 1886 - S from new orleans >> Yeah, you got that right! mike

Odd, on my screen the coin IS an S. Poor picture but it has serifs an a diagonal down from left to right.

Tassa · November 1, 2003 7:20PM

I see an S, too. I don't see an MS63, though.

hoardmonster · November 1, 2003 8:02PM

Yep, I see an S.

razorface1027 · November 1, 2003 8:31PM

That's because they changed the pic after UNDERDOG emailed them about it. Funny thing is, I see no eBay revision...How did they do this without the ebay: date & time revision notification?

darktone · November 1, 2003 8:44PM

if the picture is supported at his web site could he change it without a revision being listed?

hoardmonster · November 2, 2003 6:50PM

<< <i>if the picture is supported at his web site could he change it without a revision being listed? >>

Exactly! He would just upload the new pic and rename it to whatever the old one was called.

Steve27 · November 2, 2003 9:14PM

I don't know what the problem is, most sellers don't say a coin has been cleaned, they just say MS63.

coinchallenged · November 3, 2003 12:08AM

Funny thing is, someone bought it. Guess there's something to be said about truth in advertising.

callawayc7 · November 3, 2003 6:52AM

I don't really see a problem either. As long as he disclosed it as cleaned and dipped, the buyer know what he's getting and will pay accordingly, regardless what the seller calls it (63 or whatever).

Dipped and cleaned and still he grades it MS 63

Comments

Leave a Comment