@RogerB said:
There are sandblast proof 1921 and satin proof 1921,
Sandblast proof 1922 HR, and
Sandblast proof 1922 MR; then
1922 sandblast low relief.
I recall reading something like that from the 3rd Edition (2016) of "The Red Book" "A Guide Book of Peace Dollars."
FWIW, in response to the OP's 2002 original question, I have had a 1921 satin proof for a number of years that was sold to me as such. I never bothered having it sent to PCGS as at the time I acquired it PCGS apparently was not certifying them. Maybe they still aren't? In any event I grabbed a copy of the 3rd Edition of Roger's book that came out last year as evidence that such an animal does exist.
The recently revived Pawn Stars 1922 HR Proof Peace Dollar thread with its added video clip brought to mind my prior post in this legacy thread regarding the 1921 Proof Peace dollars.
Is PCGS now certifying the 1921 Satin Proof Peace Dollar? Also anyone know if the NGC Proof 61 1922 High Relief subject of the Pawn Star episode ever made it into a PCGS holder?
Read the Peace Dollar Book (Whitman LLC). Look at the photos. Then compare with your coin. [Hint: None of the coins pictured on this page (#3) is a proof or even close to it.]
@RogerB said:
Read the Peace Dollar Book (Whitman LLC). Look at the photos. Then compare with your coin. [Hint: None of the coins pictured on this page (#3) is a proof or even close to it.]
@RogerB said:
Read the Peace Dollar Book (Whitman LLC). Look at the photos. Then compare with your coin. [Hint: None of the coins pictured on this page (#3) is a proof or even close to it.]
The coin on page #1 is a perfect match for two other coins that have been graded as Proofs.
@RogerB said:
Read the Peace Dollar Book (Whitman LLC). Look at the photos. Then compare with your coin. [Hint: None of the coins pictured on this page (#3) is a proof or even close to it.]
@RogerB said:
Read the Peace Dollar Book (Whitman LLC). Look at the photos. Then compare with your coin. [Hint: None of the coins pictured on this page (#3) is a proof or even close to it.]
The coin on page #1 is a perfect match for two other coins that have been graded as Proofs.
I see multiple coins posted on page #1.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
@RogerB said:
Read the Peace Dollar Book (Whitman LLC). Look at the photos. Then compare with your coin. [Hint: None of the coins pictured on this page (#3) is a proof or even close to it.]
@RogerB said:
Read the Peace Dollar Book (Whitman LLC). Look at the photos. Then compare with your coin. [Hint: None of the coins pictured on this page (#3) is a proof or even close to it.]
The coin on page #1 is a perfect match for two other coins that have been graded as Proofs.
A cautionary comment is that all 1921 Peace dollars formerly or presently called "proof" are not. Look at the 3-coin comparison posted earlier. (Even the notable Wally Breen admitted that nicely struck 1921s were occasionally sandblasted to imitate a medal press proof. [He didn't use those exact words - he didn't seem to understand how the coins were made.... ]
@RogerB said:
A cautionary comment is that all 1921 Peace dollars formerly or presently called "proof" are not. Look at the 3-coin comparison posted earlier. (Even the notable Wally Breen admitted that nicely struck 1921s were occasionally sandblasted to imitate a medal press proof. [He didn't use those exact words - he didn't seem to understand how the coins were made.... ]
Roger, to be clear, is it your position that no 1921 Proof Peace dollars of any type were produced?
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Roger, to be clear, is it your position that no 1921 Proof Peace dollars of any type were produced?
Absolutely not, and I have never suggested that. There are satin and sandblasted 1921s made on a hydraulic medal press consistent with what are casually called "proofs." They were made to display the design and detail to Mint and Treasury officials who paid $1 for the coins if they chose to keep them.
The difficulty is the absence of agreed standard specifications for 1921 proof pieces. Absent that, my approach begins with visual examination of high point detail, and identification of those pieces most closely matching the bronze obverse casts in the Philadelphia Mint. Then divide these between satin and sandblast - satin should appear slightly sharper due to metal movement and abrasion caused by sandblasting. Next, examine edge and reeding characteristics visually and through 3D optical profiling (including heights of reeds, spacing, face-to-face deviation, etc.) Last, go back to the best detailed pieces and run full-face obv and rev optical profiles on all of them. Once the data are analyzed there will be a data set of facts plus observations to which other proposed proofs can be compared.
Objective medal press data will be specific to that physical process, and likely (given the urgency of the project) support use of different edge collars for medal press and standard toggle presses. (Anomalous data here might indicate proofs were made on more than on occasion....unlikely but cannot be ruled out without examination.)
Additionally, I've been shown sandblasted 1921s using the wrong size grit, and pieces dipped in acid, and coins with ordinary detail "certified" as proof.
@RogerB said:
Read the Peace Dollar Book (Whitman LLC). Look at the photos. Then compare with your coin. [Hint: None of the coins pictured on this page (#3) is a proof or even close to it.]
I believe PCGS users can customize how many posts appear per page, so what appears as page three to you might not appear that way to someone else.
Add to the longer post, immediately above ---
Just as seen on brilliant proofs, there will be small variations between individual pieces. Some might have defects or slightly inconsistent details due to variations in planchet hardness, heat treatment (annealing), and planchet weight. The result is that in addition to the top-range pieces, some proofs could have inconsistent rims or other problems. Thus, any final "proof" specification has to accommodate less-than-ideal-but still-proof 1921s. (This is where use of edge data and 3D optical profiling can separate the guesses from the real-thing.)
Comments
Would like an update as well.
@Peace_dollar88 Here’s a Courtesy TrueView Photo Post of your 1921 Peace (VAM-1H) Peace Dollar as mentioned earlier in this thread.
She’s quite a nice looker with what appears to be Glossy Mint Luster!😁👍
Stuart
Collect 18th & 19th Century US Type Coins, Silver Dollars, $20 Gold Double Eagles and World Crowns & Talers with High Eye Appeal
"Luck is what happens when Preparation meets Opportunity"
The recently revived Pawn Stars 1922 HR Proof Peace Dollar thread with its added video clip brought to mind my prior post in this legacy thread regarding the 1921 Proof Peace dollars.
Is PCGS now certifying the 1921 Satin Proof Peace Dollar? Also anyone know if the NGC Proof 61 1922 High Relief subject of the Pawn Star episode ever made it into a PCGS holder?
A very old thread bump, but does anyone know if the Peace posted by @Jupiter88 was ever graded?
Coin Photography
Who can forget the 2023 through present proof peace dollars!
Super interesting thread, thanks for bumping it Al.
I collect world proof sets, coins featuring composers, mid-20th century U.S. proof coins, U.S. type coins, and whatever else I want.
I can.
Read the Peace Dollar Book (Whitman LLC). Look at the photos. Then compare with your coin. [Hint: None of the coins pictured on this page (#3) is a proof or even close to it.]
The coin on page #1 is a perfect match for two other coins that have been graded as Proofs.
Coin Photography
I see multiple coins posted on page #1.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
The raw coin posted by @Jupiter88
Coin Photography
A cautionary comment is that all 1921 Peace dollars formerly or presently called "proof" are not. Look at the 3-coin comparison posted earlier. (Even the notable Wally Breen admitted that nicely struck 1921s were occasionally sandblasted to imitate a medal press proof. [He didn't use those exact words - he didn't seem to understand how the coins were made.... ]
Roger, to be clear, is it your position that no 1921 Proof Peace dollars of any type were produced?
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Absolutely not, and I have never suggested that. There are satin and sandblasted 1921s made on a hydraulic medal press consistent with what are casually called "proofs." They were made to display the design and detail to Mint and Treasury officials who paid $1 for the coins if they chose to keep them.
The difficulty is the absence of agreed standard specifications for 1921 proof pieces. Absent that, my approach begins with visual examination of high point detail, and identification of those pieces most closely matching the bronze obverse casts in the Philadelphia Mint. Then divide these between satin and sandblast - satin should appear slightly sharper due to metal movement and abrasion caused by sandblasting. Next, examine edge and reeding characteristics visually and through 3D optical profiling (including heights of reeds, spacing, face-to-face deviation, etc.) Last, go back to the best detailed pieces and run full-face obv and rev optical profiles on all of them. Once the data are analyzed there will be a data set of facts plus observations to which other proposed proofs can be compared.
Objective medal press data will be specific to that physical process, and likely (given the urgency of the project) support use of different edge collars for medal press and standard toggle presses. (Anomalous data here might indicate proofs were made on more than on occasion....unlikely but cannot be ruled out without examination.)
Additionally, I've been shown sandblasted 1921s using the wrong size grit, and pieces dipped in acid, and coins with ordinary detail "certified" as proof.
I believe PCGS users can customize how many posts appear per page, so what appears as page three to you might not appear that way to someone else.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
TomB. Thanks! Was not aware of that.
Add to the longer post, immediately above ---
Just as seen on brilliant proofs, there will be small variations between individual pieces. Some might have defects or slightly inconsistent details due to variations in planchet hardness, heat treatment (annealing), and planchet weight. The result is that in addition to the top-range pieces, some proofs could have inconsistent rims or other problems. Thus, any final "proof" specification has to accommodate less-than-ideal-but still-proof 1921s. (This is where use of edge data and 3D optical profiling can separate the guesses from the real-thing.)