Options
What would happen to coin market if there was only one large TPG?
Curious if PCGS or NGC went out of business and or merged (Sherman Anti trust act anyone?) what would be impact on market? I suppose someone would try and fill to void, but interested in what others think.
Thank You
BAYOUBENGAL
CFA, LSU AND ANA
CFA, LSU AND ANA
0
Comments
If PCGS took over NGC, everything would be graded properly and if NGC took over PCGS, everything would be overgraded. Aside from that, people would keep buying and selling coins.
They’d have a lot of verk.
Not sure there would be an anti-trust action if one company in deal is privately held?
"She comes out of the sun in a silk dress,
running like a water color in the rain...."
I think ANACS or ICG would step up. There's business / customer interest in having more than one.
I would guess someone would at least try to enter and provide competition.
I think the price of slabs with serial numbers prior to that happening would skyrocket.
Probably not much would happen. Other competitors would take up the challenge if there was enough market for it. On the plus side, it might help institute a more uniform grading process.
I’d say PCGS and NGC are equally good at applying their respective grading standards. It’s just that two standards aren’t identical.
I’d say that the next form would have another fee on it
Latin American Collection
I think it would really depend on WHY they (theoretically) went out of business.
This forum would be in a major turmoil for months with almost no other topics..... The stock would go up (for the firm taking over), and business and life would continue....Such an event would be a focus of the small community known as 'coin collectors'.
Cheers, RickO
If that would happen I would hope wouldn't get to big for there own good
If entirely new entity market demand for TPG material will evolve to the new holders. If merger that entity’s holders would dominate over time. It could be like a new coach operating a lean, mean recruiting machine: all out effort get material in their holders thru grading / cross specials. Another strategy get superior pricing system expand coin facts to include graded world coins, World currency with pop data. With this one could analyze country A vs country B (low pop deals). Certainly possible for North American material. I believe CDN working on CPG pricing for Canadian material.
The market is not just slabbed US Coins - graded Currency and World another part. Also raw collector Coins,currency, and bullion another part. The market as a whole would adapt and evolve. Demand will go sideways to areas deemed undervalued (pop) or a better deal, more affordable / good profit potential to players.
My interest is graded global coins & currency especially low pop like Mexico Second Republic.
As to op question / summary - Tough, speculative to predict but Life would go on.
Initially there would be a backlog at the other TPGs as they try to absorb the business from the other. If it was sudden then the backlog would be huge. If it was in the works for some time then the market would have adjusted ahead of time so the backlog wouldn't be as great. Ultimately, Life would go on as @Cougar1978 stated!
It wouldn't change the hobby unless there was some inappropriate or unethical practices going on that contributed to the demise.
And Star coins of course would still be highly coveted material.
There is never going to be a Coin Facts equivalent for world coins, graded or not. It's far to segmented, many of the coins are too scarce and don't sell often enough (some apparently never publicly), and the existing US price structure isn't going to be replicated in any time frame which will matter to anyone reading this topic. I could see someone other than a TPG making it a hobby for a series they collect but not much more.