Things that seem to come to us.
keets
Posts: 25,351 ✭✭✭✭✭
I posted a picture of a Token in another thread and the comment from another member caused me to think about something: Coins, Medals, Tokens, etc. that we seem to find simply because we begin searching for them. It is almost a discovery of fate or destiny, as though the item has been waiting in plain sight for us to come along, finally, and find it. I have had several.
Two really stick out, the first was a Proof Jefferson Nickel, 1940 Reverse of 1938. I belonged to a couple local Coin Cubs at the time and had started to assemble a high grade set of Proof Jefferson Nickels. I couldn't attend a Club meeting but there was a raw 1940 Proof Nickel in the auction, so I told a friend of mine, a local dealer, to buy the coin for me if it looked nice. I saw him a few days later and he showed me the coin. It looked pretty and when I flipped it over I had to contain myself because it was the 1938 Reverse. He sold it to me for a really low price, it went to PCGS the next day and graded PR67, a pop-8 at the time.
Around the same time, I had been looking through "Breens Encyclopedia" and noticed the 1941 and 1971 c'stamped Cleveland Commems. They interested me so I followed that up with some internet searching and added them to my list of interesting Exonumia. Unbelieveably, about two weeks later I stopped at a local coin shop and the dealer first showed me a 1941 Cleveland and a couple days later a 1971 Cleveland c'stamped coins. He had bought one from a local guy and after he sold it to me he phoned him to see if he had any others and the second one "walked in" and I was able to buy it. I waited awhile to submit those and took them to the F.U.N. Show where NGC graded the MS66 and MS63.
There have been other such instances for me but those really stand out, good timing and good fortune. We all have searched in vain for certain coins, sometimes for decades, so it's nice to hear about the other side of things. Please share a similar story if you have one. I can think of some that members have shared but it's always better when they tell the story.
Al H.

Comments
Keets.
Nice story that reminds me of my own Jefferson nickle story.
I had been looking at shops, shows and online for a raw 1957 proof nickle with two sided frosted devices. After more than ten years of searching for this coin I concluded that I would never find this coin.
A short time later I stopped by a local shop and looked at a number of OGP sets the owner had acquired. The last set I looked at was a 1957 and that set contained a nickle that has thick frost on the devices on both sides of the coin. I bought the 1957 set and remember that day as a very enjoyable day in the hobby.
Another great thread by you.😄
I was cruising eBay when a seller had 2 BIN 1953 Proof 66 cents up for sale at $38 each. I saw one was a re engraved die 401 (lapel). So I emailed him and verified it was available and he confirmed so I bought it. Now when I got it in hand it struck me as being exceptional so instead of sending it in just for attribution, I cracked it out - swabbed it in acetone, and sent it in for grading and attribution. Darn thing comes back top pop PR 68! So it just goes to show even if previously graded - you just never know.
WS
An excellent read. Thank you.
Ahhh yes, @keets I know EXACTLY what you mean. And a GREAT story, BTW. Thank You.
There are MANY coins that I feel this way about but I can narrow it down to FIVE.
1923-S NGC 64


Missed out on a freakishly struck 1923-S OGH 64 CAC in 2009 by DLRC.....I heard it through the grapevine that it was purchased and salted away into a private collection of the owner of Carter Numismatics. This one showed up a year later on Heritage. It is in an old #7 NGC slab. I bid strong. it had been off the market for 14 years, when i won it in 2010. It arrived on my birthday.
1916-S PCGS 64 CAC
Purchased from TNFC. They had won it in a Heritage auction. I only paid $400 more than their winning bid, which I felt to be fair. I woke up early @ 6:00 AM, so that I could be the first caller, when they opened and before I had to go to work to make an offer. fully struck, clean, fully original and CAC.
Saw this one after doing a random search in the wee hours after a night of drinking. The originality and freakish strike hypnotized me. thought for sure that it had already been sold. Literally called hung over the next day, just out of curiosity, and found that it was still available. Offer accepted. I thank my lucky stars every day for this piece.
Won this coin auction on my birthday. From an ancient registry set. Paid FAR less than a dull, NGC example had sold for months earlier. Super low pop at this level.
A dull, flat and abraded NGC example had sold for 11500. This example is FAR superior and sold for MUCH less. Found it on eBay while doing a random search. Tickled to death over this KEY DATE. The thumb and stem line separation on this piece is nothing short of AMAZING and surfaces are very clean.
Yes, I believe in fate and I do trust in God and luck but I believe that you create your own luck and that the harder you work, at something, the more successful you are.
As a footnote, the 1917 S obverse and the 1919 d came from the same source. My coin honey hole.
Sometimes, it’s better to be LUCKY than good. 🍀 🍺👍
My Full Walker Registry Set (1916-1947):
https://www.ngccoin.com/registry/competitive-sets/16292/
Loved your read Al
Sometime in the middle of 1990 after I got out of the Navy and had started to establish a career, I began to collect a little more, and was lucky enough to meet a dealer who helped me understand some things about coins and grading, and about building a collection and keeping things.
Anyway, after quite a bit of thought, I set my eye on finding a few Very Choice AU Standing Liberties, of which he had none at that time. As a matter of fact, I didn't see many at all, anywhere I looked. He had some Choice and Gem pieces, but those were beyond my reach. Occasionally I'd see some decent Unc's (probably 63's on today's scale), but still, too much. And the VF/EF stuff didn't trip my trigger.
He had helped me develop an eye for the difference between top quality "sliders" and true Unc's, and he told me to just keep looking and be patient, and make sure I had the money to buy one or two when the right ones presented themselves. The real Unc's were getting slabbed ... it was a new age in collecting! Actually those were some very interesting times. Too bad I didn't have the experience, time or capital to make a run at it.
Anyway, with a wife and a son, we didn't have a lot of money ... so I knew I'd have to not spend the little I had just to buy one every couple months. But I decided I would try, and if I made any money flipping anything, I'd set that aside too.
And then, almost as if they knew I was looking for them, they started to show up. Within the next few years, I think about 15 or 16 nice ones presented themselves to me that I was able to purchase. Sometime around 2004 I sent those in for grading at our host (all were raw). They all graded, and I still have 13 of those (three 55's, nine 58's and a 62), and all still a part of the set I started back then.
“We are only their care-takers,” he posed, “if we take good care of them, then centuries from now they may still be here … ”
Todd - BHNC #242
Once at a show in Seattle, Russ and I were searching tables for Kennedy halves.... about a half hour after the show opened, I noticed a dealer setting up - he was a late arrival - in a section we had passed. I zipped over there and asked about mint sets.... He pulled out some in original envelopes. I picked up an Accented Hair right away... purchased it and then went to gloat over Russ...
Cheers, RickO
beating Russ to an AH Kennedy on his home turf at the same show rates some type of award!! how long did you gloat??
Nice read
@keets
Great stories and cool thread. I really like the Proof Jefferson Nickel.