Should some 1879 cents go on a diet ?
RogerB
Posts: 9,012 ✭✭✭✭✭
In late 1879 a contractor was supplying the Philadelphia Mint with cent planchets that were too heavy.

Benedict & Burnham Mfg. Co.
Waterbury, Conn.
November 15, 1879
A. Loudoun Snowden, Esq.,
Superintendent
United States Mint
Philadelphia
Dear Sir:
We are in receipt of your telegram of today saying that the planchets being delivered are heavy and in reply beg to say that we were aware that they averaged about 50 grains, but we thought when they were dipped and rolled, and the scale was off, they would average about 49 and as we had a leeway of 4 grains supposed they were coming about right. But we have some blanks cut and just finished, and if you will kindly work these up we will see to it that the next batch we roll shall be thinner and awaiting your further esteemed favor, we remain,
Very truly yours,
Charles Dickenson, Secretary
Comments
So, did they use the heavy planchets? The letter describing material loss in the process seems reasonable. Cheers, RickO
It appears the heavy planchets were used sometime in November.
Let's all collect 1879 cents by weight
Yes! Thenwe can trade them at a gigantic Thanksgiving Day feast held under the golden arch in St. Louis !
Actually, the weight discrepancy might be helpful in identifying counterfeits of foreign or domestic manufacture.
good info to know and to learn here. thanks roger
Assuming that the Mint was paying for them by weight, the Mint was right to complain. Fewer usable planchets per ton.
It is also likely that some of the planchets were heavier than 50 grains....Hence, an authenticator could reject a 52-grain 1879 cent as being counterfeit based on weight, yet the coin might be entirely genuine.
I collected a set of Indian Cents while I was in high school and the early years of college. One thing I noticed was that the quality of the copper that was used for the "heart of Indian Cent collection" from 1866 to 1878 was petty bad. Starting in 1879, the coins really started to look better. So I guess the bottom line is, I really liked those 1879 "fat ladies."