Options
What would you grade this 1934-P 50c? (REVEALED)
cameonut2011
Posts: 11,363 ✭✭✭✭✭

PCGS MS65
2
Comments
I'll go with 66. Nice coin.
I initially thought MS65.... However, @ldhair may well be right. Cheers, RickO
I was thinking around 64, just not the booming luster you want on these common coins.
64+
If the luster pushes up from below the toning, 66. If not so much, 65. Either way I really like it.
In the 65 group, luster not showing in the photo
64
MS-63 - 64. There is a fairly big scrape on the sun on the obverse and some marks above that. There are also a couple of reed marks on MS Liberty’s belly. The luster looks good and strong, and there is no rub. It’s a nice coin and better in some ways than one I sold to a want list customer when I was a dealer.
67
I can see this as a 66. The luster is not booming, but more satiny. I like it a lot, and the surfaces appear very clean.
65
Sometimes, it’s better to be LUCKY than good. 🍀 🍺👍
My Full Walker Registry Set (1916-1947):
https://www.ngccoin.com/registry/competitive-sets/16292/
It looks like a WLH that in the older white ANACS holders would have graded MS62.
66 I can see easy
Steve
65
It looks an end of the roll coin to me.
64
I think the reverse looks okay. I kind of like the chestnut color.
I guessed 65 because the luster looks a little bit muted (more satiny) and the strike is not super-sharp, as many examples of this issue can be, but the surfaces look clean to me with little to no abrasions.
Sometimes, it’s better to be LUCKY than good. 🍀 🍺👍
My Full Walker Registry Set (1916-1947):
https://www.ngccoin.com/registry/competitive-sets/16292/
I have seen that level of toning on the other side of an end of the roll coin.
66 but minus for no eye appeal. My real grade is pass.
rainbowroosie April 1, 2003
I will guess 66. though if the photos are anywhere accurate, I would pass on this coin.
I'll go 64 or 65....
On the plus side, they tend to grade marks more on the field than anywhere else....and the fields seem quite clean.
On the minus, the strike might be a bit weak, and this is a fairly well struck date.
Where I get lost: The toning. To me, the reverse is what I'd call "enhancing" toning, and might bump up the grade. The obverse is "distracting" toning, and might hold it back.
I think Luster might be the tie breaker.
As for me: I'd probably pass. I try to avoid distracting toning. I'm buying coins, not colors.
I agree with Bill that it looks like an end of the roll toner. The last roll I bought had both coins toned like that.
I think our hosts might see that coin as code 97 Envionmental Damage, look to the reverse near the end of " Dollar" seems to be eaten in that area.
Why, oh why would you even think of dipping this coin? There are plenty of washed-out Walkers. We don't need any more.
Thanks everyone! Grade posted in the OP.
I think you are interpreting a patch of toning on the obverse to be a scrape.
The coin is ED - corroded (as on the sun) in a semi-attractive way. I hate coins that are bi-colored: whitish on one side and brownish on the other.
IMO, this coin can probably be fixed enough to get a 65 grade but it not going to be a simple job (over 40 minutes). As it is now, the coin is not for me except as a teaching coin for various problems. : )
PS Late to the party - just saw the grade. That's why I could never be a grader.