Options
So tell the woeful tale of the coin that you wanted to buy...
Coinstartled
Posts: 10,135 ✭✭✭✭✭
...but it got snagged by another while you were waiting for the dealer to respond to your lower offer.
0
Comments
For me so far I'm the guy that did the snagging.
Learned my lesson a long time ago. If it's a coin I really want, I'll pay up and snag it now. I've been looking for a nice 16d Mercury dime for years (maybe 4 or 5 years). I already had a 16d in VG and F but I really wanted a higher grade with great eye appeal. Finally saw a really nice PCGS 16d in AU55 come available and I bought it the day it was posted on line for the asking price (just a little over Greysheet). Not sure if others were trying to sang it a lower price but I paid up, got it, and I am very happy with it.
Most coins can be replaced. For those rare birds that can't........hold your nose and pay up.
m
Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
If I can find it I usually buy it... its one of the nice aspects to collecting hard to find toned Peace $... once you find it you dont worry about a better one coming along. It might but it might take 8 yrs for that to happen.
This is my sad tale of treachery in coins.
A guy I know called my attention to an offer on the old World Coins catalogue.
He let me order it and then told me he bought it.
We quit being buddys and then he died.
I mourned greatly.
I've only lamented about 3 or 4 coins but I ended up with other nice examples of those issues, anyway.
Sometimes, it’s better to be LUCKY than good. 🍀 🍺👍
My Full Walker Registry Set (1916-1947):
https://www.ngccoin.com/registry/competitive-sets/16292/
A few years ago, I was negotiating with a scalper on the price of a pair of tickets to an Orioles game. Seats were right behind home plate at Camden Yards. The scalper was about to say "OK" when someone else walked up, asked "what you got", and agreed to pay full ask. My daughter and I ended up down the 3rd base line.
I don’t try to burn both ends. If you like something and it’s fair price. Pay. If you share information like coins on auctions it’s fair game. Don’t let money come between friendships. Coins are nice but friends real friends are priceless.
Best place to buy !
Bronze Associate member
I have paid a higher price for a good coin... and would do so again. The only coin I have 'lost' was a CC Morgan I saw at a coin show when I first walked in.... figured 'Heck, just got here, let's look around a bit.'...Came back and it was gone....not a price issue, just slow on the snap. Cheers, RickO
If someone else is willing to pay more than I am willing to pay, that's the way it goes. I can't kick myself over that.
Years ago a well-known token and medal dealer had a Lincoln token with the Monitor on the reverse. This pieces exists with George McClellan on the obverse with the same reverse. That piece is fairly common, but the Lincoln variety is rare. I should have bought the piece on the spot, but I didn’t. When I came back an hour later, it was gone. I’ve never seen another one.
The same is true for the 1801 Jefferson Inaugural Medal that was made from die cuts by John Reich. I had the money to buy it, but someone me told it was too much and that the price would come down. It didn’t, and I missed out on the piece. I probably won’t have a chance to buy a nice example of one of those medals ever again.
There was an example that sold a year or so ago, but it was so beat up that I didn’t consider it. I know that if I buy an item that I view as an eye sore that I will never be happy with it.
_@BillJones said: "I know that if I buy an item that I view as an eye sore that I will never be happy with it." _
This is something I've learned the hard way. As a collector of varieties, I'd sometimes settle for a coin that is flawed, but decent, and priced at a bargain. Adding it to my set felt good initially, but I began realizing my collection was becoming more about quantity rather than quality. I "filled the hole," but it wasn't with a coin I was proud of, nor one that wouldn't draw your attention to it's flaws right away (especially apparent in high quality photos). So I've been working on delaying gratification and becoming more patient overall. That, and paying up for a premium coin when it presents itself. Those two changes (I hope) will ensure I'm happy with my coins for many years to come.
It's not the one that I wanted to buy........it's the one I did. The other guy didn't pull the trigger.
My local dealer showed me a PCGS OGH slabbed 1924-S Buffalo Nickel graded VF-20 that just came in. Now we all know that this date and Mint hardly ever shows a full to the tip horn due to strike, and is market graded by "overall wear". The coin had a full to the tip horn, definitley undergraded.
"There was a guy in here that was real interested in it and said he would be back". "If you want it, you better buy it".
So I did.
A couple days later I popped in to visit and the dealer said "That guy came back in looking for the coin you bought, and boy was he upset when I told him it was sold".
I usually lose due to indecision, but that time it worked out real nice.
Pete
About a 2 years ago a local dealer who I would call a friend called me to look at some early type he had bought. Purchased some really nice coins at great prices. However one was an 1805 half dime in an old pcgs holder graded EF. I told him it was an AU today and needed to be regraded. I didn't want to take advantage of him to the tune of 10000 or more dollars. The next week I went to visit him and he was very happy to tell me he sold the coin for 500 more than he offered it to me. I dumbfounded asked why he didn't regrade it like I told him to. Well needless to say the coin showed up on a major dealers sight with a gold cac sticker priced 15000 more than he offered it to me. We made an agreement after that that in the future I will take any of the great deals he gives me and split the profits.