Options
Another your grade vs guess the assigned grade thread - 1920 Mercury dime
KollectorKing
Posts: 4,820 ✭✭✭✭✭


1
Comments
MS65FB maybe better
Very nice strike the only thing holding it back is the marks on the Obv. if on the holder then an easy higher grade
Oh, for shame. I looked at the reverse first. With the stuff on the face, I'd say MS63FB. Without that stuff, could have easily been 66 or 67.
61 and I’m being generous.
rainbowroosie April 1, 2003
My grade 62
Slab grade 63
I'm seeing
MS 63 for the hits on the face
It's my understanding that full bands can't have a hit across them and it seems to have one.
64 FB?
64 fb
I should be embarrassed working at a major TPGS that graded this coin higher than MS-63. Too many hits and big PVC stain right in front of the face, NOT FB due to large hit that crosses them.
Also, consider the value of the coin in high grades. I don't see any rub on it so I hope it is in an MS-62 slab as that is my guess.
I can see this getting into an MS-63FB holder. The marks on the obverse and small ticks on the reverse hold it to the lower MS grades. The hit on the lower center band does cross to the upper, but barely, so I don't think it would preclude it from getting FB as it does not interrupt the split. The only thing I can see that may DQ it from getting FB is the left side of the central bands at the edge of the Fasces, it looks like it might be weak, but it could just be a lighting anomaly.
62-63fb
mine is 62fb
tpg is 63fb
63/62 No FB.... Cheers, RickO
63 FB.I don't think the hit on the bands is deep enough.
64fb
I have taken enough photos to know that light angles can mark scratches look much bigger than they are. The coin had the makings of an MS-67 or even a 68 given the superb strike, but the small, sharp marks precluded that.
I think they really hit the coin for the chin. MS63FB .