Options
Does this 1767 8 real look okay?
Just want to be sure. Coin looks good and weight 27 g. Let me know what you think for grade too!


0
Just want to be sure. Coin looks good and weight 27 g. Let me know what you think for grade too!


Comments
Looks real to me but what is going on with all the nicks around the rim?
Is it ex-jewelry?
bob
PS: no idea of value.
Based ONLY on the pictures, my only concern is the spotting on the obverse and reverse, and whether it is etched into the coins surface, or just toning. It could be a PVC issue....it could be nothing. Can't really tell by the photo.
As for grade, I'd put it at AU-50?? Nice strong details.
I think the rim "nicks" are actually a part of the design. Kind of an scalloped reading (for lack of a better term).
The details are pretty sharp. Almost too sharp? Besides that it look pretty good to me. I should add that I once had a nice looking Pillar like yours that I sent to PCGS. It came back counterfeit. Surprised me and the dealer I bought it from. I got my money back.
I don't know how comparable they are but my 1749 FX45 looks quite a bit different in the details of your coin, in a lot of ways. It could just be that mine is a much earlier date. I'm no expert here. Here it is just for comparison:
I see just enough off that I would not buy it RAW. Do not know these well enough.
Here is my better one! This is raw and genuine.
And is a cast counterfiet.
They are not nicks. It is where the edge ornamentation comes close to the obverse or reverse. Coin looks OK.
Agree with insider. Looks good (genuine). Nice coin, would look closely at the discoloration on obverse and reverse.
I could not authenticate it from the picture, but that said, I see nothing wrong with the coin IN the picture.
Looks authentic. AU53 or so. Surface might have some contaminants.
acetone bath?
Might have to give it a bath but just wanted to make sure i wasnt missing anything blaringly obvious saying counterfeit...thanks everyone!!
While I am not an expert by any means, I have looked at a lot of these - just an interest in old coinage that likely circulated in early America - It appears authentic based on my comparison to pictures of other one's for comparison. I would definitely give it a soak in pure acetone.... Cheers, RickO
Here's a PCGS-graded piece for comparisons, from the same date and mint (courtesy of the PCGS Pop Report):