Options
Cent Composition Change
Looks like Congress is at it again.
Press Release
Why don't they just not mint 1c and 5c for a year or more and see how it goes? Maybe even hold off on everything? There has to be plenty of these things lying around to meet the need for a couple of years.
Press Release
Why don't they just not mint 1c and 5c for a year or more and see how it goes? Maybe even hold off on everything? There has to be plenty of these things lying around to meet the need for a couple of years.
0
Comments
<< <i>Why don't they just not mint 1c and 5c for a year or more and see how it goes? >>
seriously, it is the first thought i have virtually every time i read/hear about this topic. to mint or not? why so black and white?
certainly it doesn't take minting 500 billion coins to justify all the work/effort/cost to get the designs/dies/labor, etc. to average out the cost per coin?
how the heck hard is it just to put out say 25 million per year or a bit less even?
i would say make only 1-5 million but we all know they would end up in ms70 holders selling for 299.99, so minting too low a number isn't an option if they are minting them for public use.
or just skipping years?
or is this just another one of those political spending money job protection things? i can just hear it now, "weep weep, if we stop minting 300 trillion coins, think about the job loss!" duh, sometimes losing
jobs is not a bad thing if the juice isn't worth the squeeze to keep them. ya, i said it.
makes me think of the prime example that gets analyzed a lot: if criminals stopped breaking laws, imagine all the people that would be out of work. apologies but this coin minting thing really feels just like
criminal job line imo.
heck, if the gov stopped the drug flow, who would be left to fight and what would they do with all those useful extra tax dollars? is there really anyone left out there that we haven't tried to blow up?
is it really such a bad idea to spend a bit extra on kids educations and well being? ya ya, it is the main political cliche line but it is also a very good place to spend imo.
.
<< <i>Looks like Congress is at it again.
Press Release
Why don't they just not mint 1c and 5c for a year or more and see how it goes? Maybe even hold off on everything? There has to be plenty of these things lying around to meet the need for a couple of years. >>
1) Congress at it again?
+a) Congress mandates the mint report on metals research
+b) the mint reports every 2 years
+c) 2014 is a reporting year and this is likely part of that process
2) short runs
+a) Not minting them or doing half runs would be an interesting experiment to see if they could shake some change loose.
+b) if the point is to test the waters for nickel increments, then I'm thinking even a test would never pass either half of Congress.
======================
3) The mint has already ruled out all metals for the cent. The current composition is approximately the same cost as the other alternatives: steel and aluminum
4) I'm not sure if the mint is also considering changing the physical dimensions of the coins. However, the only coins with a pressing need for alteration are the cent and nickel. All others are profitable, even and especially the dollar coin.
Lets put a Liberty head on it.
never!
<< <i>They always want to use a heavy composition, why not titanium? It can be struck very thin with very high detail then hardened. >>
FWIW: Titanium has very LOW density. You may be thinking of tungsten.
Also, both of these materials are very expensive and very difficult to work with so neither are good alternatives.
Now you're talking! I would certainly support that idea. Give my series a few more years to collect.
Lance.
Or even better- get rid of the cent, nickel, and dime and make a 1-bit coin equal to 12 1/2 cents since 2 bits equals a quarter and use that as the smallest denomination. But it would be best if we stopped minting all coins except quarters and just round everything to the nearest quarter. Transactions would be a lot easier with a single coin denomination.
But really though, do you really think that politicians will want their own removed from coins? Politicians got us into this mess and we are stuck here until common sense (I know, it does not exist in politics anymore) takes over.
<< <i>I think we should get rid of the nickel and cent and make a 1/3 dime coin. It would be equal to 3.33 cents, two would be worth 6.67 cents and three would be worth 10 cents.
Or even better- get rid of the cent, nickel, and dime and make a 1-bit coin equal to 12 1/2 cents since 2 bits equals a quarter and use that as the smallest denomination. But it would be best if we stopped minting all coins except quarters and just round everything to the nearest quarter. Transactions would be a lot easier with a single coin denomination.
But really though, do you really think that politicians will want their own removed from coins? Politicians got us into this mess and we are stuck here until common sense (I know, it does not exist in politics anymore) takes over. >>
No you're cooking with gas! Perhaps we could start a discussion about minting a 22/7-cent coin but that would just go on and on and we certainly could not count on people being rational about it.
<< <i>
<< <i>I think we should get rid of the nickel and cent and make a 1/3 dime coin. It would be equal to 3.33 cents, two would be worth 6.67 cents and three would be worth 10 cents.
Or even better- get rid of the cent, nickel, and dime and make a 1-bit coin equal to 12 1/2 cents since 2 bits equals a quarter and use that as the smallest denomination. But it would be best if we stopped minting all coins except quarters and just round everything to the nearest quarter. Transactions would be a lot easier with a single coin denomination.
But really though, do you really think that politicians will want their own removed from coins? Politicians got us into this mess and we are stuck here until common sense (I know, it does not exist in politics anymore) takes over. >>
No you're cooking with gas! Perhaps we could start a discussion about minting a 22/7-cent coin but that would just go on and on and we certainly could not count on people being rational about it. >>
close!
22/7 isn't π = 3.1415.....
and as a fraction, it is a ratio and is therefore a rational number. but the idea still flies!
if π is too greek, we could use e = 2.71828... or i to the i power = 0.207879576...
http://www.numismaticnews.net/article/news/general/mint-testifies-before-house-on-coinage-composition-changes
<< <i>The Royal Mint’s Andrew Mills demurred, saying he would have to look at the matter more closely, but he did volunteer that it would not cost less than the one cent face value, which emphasized a point made earlier in the hearing by Deputy Mint Director Richard A. Peterson in his testimony, who said no composition change could bring costs of the cent down below face value. >>
ANA 50+ year/Life Member (now "Emeritus")
Author: 3rd Edition of the SampleSlabs book, https://sampleslabs.info/
<< <i>Americans can't even speak european, they reject metric and you think they are going to copy their .10 rounding? >>
Most people would take it in stride. It's the demagogues who would have you believe otherwise.
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
<< <i>At the recent congressional hearing, both a representative of the Royal Mint and the US Mint said no matter what we changed to, it will still cost more than 1c to mint a cent...
http://www.numismaticnews.net/article/news/general/mint-testifies-before-house-on-coinage-composition-changes
<< <i>The Royal Mint’s Andrew Mills demurred, saying he would have to look at the matter more closely, but he did volunteer that it would not cost less than the one cent face value, which emphasized a point made earlier in the hearing by Deputy Mint Director Richard A. Peterson in his testimony, who said no composition change could bring costs of the cent down below face value. >>
>>
metal value for the cent is about $0.0055
Just SG&A for the cent is $0.0025
Distribution to the Fed is $0.0002
That's $0.0082 right there even before manufacture expenses and stuffing them into bags before shipment.
the mint lists cost of goods sold as $0.0156, which includes the metal value and the cost of making it into blanks, minting them, then packaging them.... but not the SG&A and Distrib. The total was $0.0183 per cent made.
It is interesting to note that $0.0183 - the $0.0055 metal value is still greater than 1 cent ($0.0128)... perhaps those questions asking if the other mints can do things cheaper would be reflective of many a mindset here, including my own, that the US government doesn't do thing on the cheap. Hmmm... I wonder. Still, with $0.0055 of the 1 cent being metal alone, one wonders what item could be fashioned for 1 cent per these days even on the order of billions of them per year... or despite them needing billions per year.
Hoard the keys.