Help me decide if I did good. 1928 peace $
Babboonbobo69
Posts: 85 ✭✭✭
Babboonbobo69
Posts: 85 ✭✭✭
Babboonbobo69
Posts: 85 ✭✭✭
Comments
Take a look at the discussion below yours at the moment.
I was looking at that discussion but those are a different type of collectible to me. I’m trying to put together as silver type set and want more whitish coins. I have purchased this PCGS graded 28 Peace and just want opinions on what members feel the grade should be to see if I did good.
No one want to give me their opinion on the grade of this Peace dollar?
Looks close to GEM, but there are hints of abrasions that might show up had the photos been taken with the coin at a slight angle. Either way, I like it! Original skin and pleasant surfaces/strike.
peacockcoins
I'm going to say it graded 63.
Pictures make it tough to give a great guess. I'll wager 62-63
Hard to tell from the photos, but I'll guess MS64.
I'd also ask you to be patient....wondering where the opinions are within 18 minutes of posting on a Friday night is kinda pushing it....
My first impression was MS63 also.
My Original Song Written to my late wife-"Plus other original music by me"
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL8A11CC8CC6093D80
https://n1m.com/bobbysmith1
Your coin has some PVC stains on both sides. My guess MS-62 (net) but looks higher.
Fine strike
PVC 
:HeadSlap; emoji needed 
Picture offers challenges.
Underneath it's likely 63.667 to 64.141592653 by @Insider2's taxonomy, but the lighting may be affecting my perception of the density of the cloudiness. Consequently my appraisal of marks positively and reflectivity negatively is suspect.
Looks MS from the pic, but I’d be concerned about the cloudy surfaces (looks like residue) on both obverse and reverse. Dipping residue perhaps from improper rinse?
Fine strike
PVC 
and I'll raise you: Clean surfaces w/ very few detracting marks. 
I'll still guess net graded.
On the other hand, the mother ship is posting the day's grades as we type, and the 23rd time may be the charm
Good question
Sorry about being impatient, I’m at work and been a busy night. It is actually in transit and was hoping it would be here today but looks like Monday with shipping being so slow.
It is straight graded and looked clean to me (other than discoloration on reverse) I like it and hope it is as nice as I expect when it arrives, if not I can always return it.
MS65 Nice
Hoard the keys.
63
Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value. Zero. Voltaire. Ebay coinbowlllc
Nice coin. 63
MS 64
58
Clearly the upper bound is π + 61, but @ColonelJessup is just rounding off. I think I missed that particular taxonomy lesson.
I'm going to guess it graded MS62 or MS63, depending on whether it looked exactly like this when graded.
I will say MS63 if more luster in hand then in picture if not 62. Here is a ms64 ms 62 to compare
Best place to buy !
Bronze Associate member
This one is ungraded
Best place to buy !
Bronze Associate member
58 or 62!
64 grade probably, but looks like it might have some gunk on it as other posters have said, which would be a problem down the road.
If that is the case (pvc residue) can it be cracked out and repaired (professionally) and re-slabbed?
Yes, I think. The photos aren't good enough to say with certainty that the smudgy areas are PVC tainted. But that would be my guess too.
I like the coin and think it would benefit from professional conservation.
Lance.
@lkeigwin said: "The photos aren't good enough to say with certainty that the smudgy areas are PVC tainted. But that would be my guess too."
You are correct. The color, pattern, and appearance are exactly what some forms of PVC look like.
AU58, but I recently was pretty sure a MS64 Morgan was a 66, so....
either a AU58 or MS60
Ok, here it is PCGS MS64 and I got a decent price on it. I’m just hoping the pvc residue mentioned (I thought it was toning) is not that bad (lighting maybe?) but we’ll see it in person soon!
Do you have return priveledges on this coin?
m
Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
If it is PVC, send it back.... Not worth messing with.... Otherwise, a nice Peace Dollar... Cheers, RickO
Ever wonder why someone would "give away" such an attractive coin? Oh. it's Christmas!
All kidding aside. Often PVC can be removed before it has etched the surface leaving an original looking coin. In cases where the surface is ruined, it's best to leave the PVC (it hides stuff like poor luster and hairlines) on the coin and get rid of it in a trade or sale. If you did get it cheap, you MAY make a tiny profit.
PS Please keep this secret! I have a little hand-held, battery-operated, fluorescent light to check the surface of coins. When a coin is shielded from the surrounding light, any rub or PVC "jumps-out" as a big change of color. "Rub" turns gray on silver and PVC often turns shades of very pale light greenish-white (you'll know it when you see it).
It may be easy to grade the coin underwater with my eyes open than from those pictures
Latin American Collection
I wish it were given to me, lol but alas that is not the case. I did get a decent deal on it and yes the seller has a nice 14 day return policy (one reason I felt ok doing the deal) I’ve been looking at other coins he has and the lighting is a little weird and makes some if his coins look off. Oh well I guess I’m going to just have to wait until Monday to see it in person. Then I can make a better decision on what to do.
Thanks everyone for your opinions and advice, this is why I joined the forum. I need to ask questions to make sure I don’t make too big of a mistake.
@Boosibri I put the pictures under macro lenses so you could see details. Sorry I was running out to funeral so could not get out the light stands. Hope you get you answer and a few laughs
Best place to buy !
Bronze Associate member
Ok after holding it in person and studying it for a little while, I have contacted the dealer and I am returning this coin. There are definitely some small surface spots that I do not see getting better. Thank you all for your advice. I am now in search of another 1928 PCGS MS64 Peace dollar.
good idea, there seems to be PVC on it.
BHNC #203
They wouldn’t have slabbed it with active pvc; if that’s what that cloudy issue is from then it’s probably already been acetoned, etc. And yeah, good idea re: return — a coin you don’t love doesn’t generally turn into one you do.
Ms63 with PVC, needs a strong dip and may come back better. I agree with insider for a 2nd time. Need to lay off the Nog
11.5$ Southern Dollars, The little “Big Easy” set
@Crypto said: "I agree with insider for a 2nd time. Need to lay off the Nog."
Surfaces look dead to my eyes but it just might be the poor images, hope it works out for you.
Be extra cautious when buying raws from ANY established dealer. Why would they not have it sent in to be graded / slabbed if it is indeed a "steal" IMHO
It’s a great looking Peace dollar. Be happy
It’s not the best pic to judge but a 64 is a good grade for this date. I like it.