Guess the grades (gold) .... Grades revealed 1st post

lunytune2

These are my new purchases in a big (to me ) trade and cash. Won't be in hand for awhile because the dealer is sending them strait to Pcgs for me. Guess the current grade , and what our host will grade them.

Coin 1





Coin 2





Original grades

grip

EX 45.Shoot me

jdimmick

Au-50

Au-53

coinkat

nice coins

45 on the first

50 on the second shot at 53

TopographicOceans

AU53 and XF45

mannie gray

53

45



at PCGS

50

45

mirabela

55, 53

Great coins, especially the first.

golden

Originally posted by: mannie gray
53
45

at PCGS
50
45

jcping

50, 45

DollarAfterDollar

53
45

CharlotteDude

I say the '42-D I will grade 53. The '45-D will grade 50. I like them both!

'dude

jonruns

Great coins!!! I'm guessing both are 50s...

superpsychmd

55 and 50 in that order

COINS MAKE CENTS

Both au50

MCADSPEC

42-D 55 45-D 45

TPRC

53
50

TheDukeK

40
45

Boosibri

55 and 50 to 50 and 45

HoledandCreative

Pair of 40s.

lunytune2

Here are the Ngc grades in the first post ... Pcgs grades to follow in about a month !

ricko

I got here too late to GTG since now the NGC grades are posted.... I did guess the first one,

but thought the second was lower....Be sure to let us know the new grades...Cheers, RickO

jcping

I am not sure our host would grade that high on either of the two keep them in NGC holders.

mirabela

I want all the people who called these XF's to sell me their branch mint gold ...

CharlotteDude

I second Mirabela's comment. Although I think the AU-55 designation is a bit generous for the '45-D, perhaps NGC and CAC believe it looked better in hand than via an image. And even with just the provided image, I think the 42-D will easily land in a P-53 holder.

'dude

steveben

i could not grade them by the photos. i would have guessed 45 on both.



i like the 42-D a lot!



nice coins

lunytune2

Originally posted by: mirabela
I want all the people who called these XF's to sell me their branch mint gold ...

coinkat

Question for those of you that graded the 1842D higher than the 1845D-

Why?

mirabela

Question for those of you that graded the 1842D higher than the 1845D-

Why?

I was one who did. The pics showed me comparable detail in each case, but I believed I saw more luster in the 'skin' on the 42-D, and a bit more abrasion on the 45-D.

lunytune2

Coins not in hand and I marked cross at current grade . The 45-D crossed to Au55 . The 42-D is coming back in an ngc holder

coinkat

Thanks for posting the results- looks as if both NCG and PCGS graded the 1845-D higher