Morgan Dollar Grades Posted

Rampage

Several years ago, I cracked out a bunch of Morgan dollars and put them in an album. I thought it would be appealing to see an uncirculated set in an album, which it was. I have since (recently) decided to put them back in holders. Here are a few of the grades and what they were formerly graded at. I am more than happy with the results and glad to know my eyes have not failed me and I can still tell an original uncleaned coin when I see one.

1892-O was ANACS MA62, now PCGS MS63

1899-S was ANACS MS63, now PCGS MS64+

1901-S was ANACS MS62, now PCGS MS62

1902-S was PCI gold label MS64, now PCGS MS63

1883-S was ANACS MS60 Details Clean, now PCGS MS62 (it was not cleaned. ANACS screwed up)

1899-P was ANACS MS63, now PCGS MS64

1900-S was PCGS MS63, now PCGS MS63

1889-S was ANACS MS63, now PCGS MS63

1898-S was ANACS MS63, now PCGS MS62

1881-P was SCG MS66, now PCGS MS64 (I bought for 63 money)

1879-S Rev 78 was PCGS MS61, now PCGS MS62

Rampage

I should add, there were about ten others that all graded out at the same as they were previously-mostly PCGS coins.

HighRelief

Where are the pictures so we can make sure they were graded correctly?

AUandAG

Nice grades there. especially on that 1883-S





bob

Rampage

I do not have them back yet. They are enroute now.

etexmike

Nice grades on the group of Morgan dollars.





Mike

messydesk

Score!

georgiacop50

Interesting.



SCG is SEGS?

golden

Good job.

BAJJERFAN

Originally posted by: georgiacop50

Interesting.



SCG is SEGS?

SCG would be So Called Grading.

Type2

Nice Good job.

Wolf359

You had to crack these out of ANACS right?

Rampage

Originally posted by: BAJJERFAN

Originally posted by: georgiacop50
Interesting.
SCG is SEGS?

SCG would be So Called Grading.

Definitely SCG, not SEGS. It is the self slabber on eBay that sells under centsles.

Rampage

Originally posted by: Wolf359
You had to crack these out of ANACS right?

Jack, Yes. All these were cracked and put into an album for several years. It took me a long time to buy these coins, though. I searched through many coins a year finding the "nice ones".

3keepSECRETif2rDEAD

Nice Work Buddy! This lot sounds absolutely Cool and Congrats for the obvious great eye's and enough balls to crack 'em, then let 'em settle...and then submit them to the finest TPG in The Game


look forward to getting the chance to see pictures if and when you so please

oih82w8

Congrats on the "crossovers", even though they were "raw" submittals.

ricko

VERY nice results.... well done indeed on some nice Morgans... Cheers, RickO

Windycity

Well done... excellent results!!

Rampage

I will be able to post a few pictures this weekend. I have a few of the old slab inserts to show, too.

leothelyon

Originally posted by: ricko
VERY nice results.... well done indeed on some nice Morgans... Cheers, RickO

I'll pick on ole Ricko since he has thick skin........ I don't think the OP is too happy with the results having cracked out the coins years ago to store/display them in an album. I don't know if he was hoping some would tone in that time but, come on people, to have 21 coins graded and there was next to absolute 0 improvement? Do the math, the OP gained only .09524 points overall and one plus for eye appeal. This is not even 1/10th of 1 point grade increase overall for 21 coins. What's remarkable is that PCGS consistently honed in within .09524 of the overall former average grade total and how some 40-50 different graders called the same grades over the years the coins were graded.
On another note, I guess, for a more accurate assessment of the OP's grading abilities or anyone else, he should go out and find 10 certified coins in our host's holders that he believes have been cleaned, submit them raw to see how well he does. Of course, at first, this is not a too feasible thing to do, like we're all going to sit back and cheer the guy on as he stands to lose hundreds...........lol. But I am glad they all reholdered Rampage, good job!


Leo