GTG: Newp Peace Dollar - will it grade?

Yonico

first, i am not planning on sending this coin in for grading.
just thought I'd get some opinions on it, will it straight-grade if sent in, and what would the grade be?

i'm aware of the rim damage at 10:00 o'clock on the reverse and the mark above "IN GOD" (reeded edged coin hit?), i still like the coin..

have fun with it!

thanks!

AUandAG

Colorful album toned slider?


bob

Flatwoods

I think the toning will cause it not to grade.

ricko

No grade...but good for album if you like tarnish....Cheers, RickO

Wabbit2313

Yes it would grade, no it is not worth doing so.

Broadstruck

I don't think the color is legit as far as having formed in a album or envelope.

It looks like it was accelerated with heat glancing at the full spectrum of rainbow colors on the obverse rims.

johnny54321

My guess is that it would it would share a similar fate to the one I posted several days ago
My Peace Dollar

Regardless, I really like it!

BryceM

AU53-55 depending on residual luster. Rub & loss of normal surface texture is visible on cheek & neck. Color is acceptable, but not attractive. Reedmark on cheek is a downer. Lots of hits & bagmarks, especially on the rims and in the left obverse field. Rim issues are +/- acceptable at this grade.

The 1923-P is one of the most numerous silver dollars ever produced in the US. Sliders like this are available by the thousands.

silverpop

95% it wouldn't grade

5% it would

so basically not worth sending in with those odds

roadrunner

I think it would grade....any anything from AU55 to MS62. Not worth sending in though for those numbers. You can cherry pick BU rolls at $40 a coin and find nicer ones.

My guess is 58 or 61. It's not like PCGS has a big downside in giving this a grade.

CoinJunkie

The toning looks bogus to me. FWIW.

lostincoins

This one is graded by PCGS and has similar rim color carry over so you might have a chance as it could be album toning. It could also have been cooked with a torch on the side? Well here is the coin.

magikbilly

Something about the rim toning from 2:00 on makes me uneasy.

Eric

lordmarcovan

Probably not worth grading, but I like how the obverse toning looks, whether or not it would pass muster at a TPG.

Would make a nice album coin, as mentioned.

Cam40

ya, rim hit, if not for the dubious color it wouldn't pass muster, imo
lostincoins coin , no chance that coin was blowtorched. its as original toning as they come there.
not super pretty sometimes but has its own characteristics.

LanceNewmanOCC

.
make sure it hasn't been cleaned and then retoned. a lot of peace dollars out there with the brown reverses and obv toning have been cleaned first and of course a lot of them haven't too.
.

Longacre

63

SeattleSlammer

For sure it will straight grade.

crypto79

I wouldn't think so.