The Third Annual RYK/DWN Mashup...

RYK

Rosen-style...

has been posted!

Boosibri

Great stuff!

Coinosaurus

Always a great read.

bidask

Nice exchange!

Unknown

This content has been removed.

breakdown

I have very little interest in gold coins but I still find these a lot of fun to read. I think territorials would be very cool to collect but think Mr. Winter's advice is spot on.

CoinJunkie

Not my collecting area, but I found the exchange enjoyable and educational nonetheless.

keyman64

Looks like this will be an interesting read later tonight.

JJSingleton

Fun read.

GeorgeKellogg

All the mashup needs is some giblet gravy and cranberry sauce!

CoinRaritiesOnline

Good read! Makes me miss the Point /Counterpoints I had with Dave Wnuck!

kranky

Great read on a cold evening. Always enjoy reading thoughts from those who know what they are talking about.

DaveG

Nice read!

Thanks for the heads-up about a possible SF-mint book, but DW's got to get going on the update of his CC-mint book first!

RYK

<< <i>Great read on a cold evening. Always enjoy reading thoughts from those who know what they are talking about. >>


In that case, you should probably skip over whatever follows "RYK:"

lkeigwin

That was fun. I liked the banter. And learned a little along the way. Good stuff!
Lance.

ColonelJessup

Fascinating read. .

JJSingleton

<< <i>I am less enthusiastic about the 1854-D $3 >>

This from a guy who wrote an article several years back proclaiming the 54-D $3 "The King of Southern Gold". You disappoint me sir. I am in Doug's camp on this one, but I am strongly biased when it comes to that neighborhood mint in Dahlonega.

RYK

<< <i>

<< <i>I am less enthusiastic about the 1854-D $3 >>

This from a guy who wrote an article several years back proclaiming the 54-D $3 "The King of Southern Gold". You disappoint me sir. I am in Doug's camp on this one, but I am strongly biased when it comes to that neighborhood mint in Dahlonega. >>


Actually, the 61-D $5 was anointed as The King. The 54-D $3 was in the discussion. Oh, how the mighty have fallen.

ricko

Very interesting.... I really like old gold and this article taught me quite a bit. Thanks...Cheers, RickO

tradedollarnut

I thought DOG was Dirty Old Gold?

ahopewell55

Always interesting to read the thoughts of a knowledgeable collector versus those of a top of the line dealer/specialist.

JJSingleton

<< <i>

<< <i>

<< <i>I am less enthusiastic about the 1854-D $3 >>

This from a guy who wrote an article several years back proclaiming the 54-D $3 "The King of Southern Gold". You disappoint me sir. I am in Doug's camp on this one, but I am strongly biased when it comes to that neighborhood mint in Dahlonega. >>


Actually, the 61-D $5 was anointed as The King. The 54-D $3 was in the discussion. Oh, how the mighty have fallen. >>

Ahhh, finally found it. Some revisionist history at play here. I know I am older than you and losing my mind but I was quite sure who you proclaimed as King. It even appears you favored the 61-D Dollar to the 61-D $5. I guess now that you own a 61-D $5 your memory has become clouded like mine.

The King of Southern Gold, by RYK