Just got these beauties back from PSA! Good grades or undergraded??

bobbyw8469

I thought these cards were a full grade undergraded. I was hoping for some second opinions....

swartz1

post some bigger scans...hard to tell...

bobbyw8469

bobbyw8469

Dust removal closed up the lettering. Also, cards look better in hand than a blown up scan...

thehallmark

Lots of very soft/worn corners and edges make the grades appropriate but the cards present really well nonetheless. Batch to be proud of for sure, classics all!

MrNearMint

Cards look real nice for the grades given. I think maybe slightly undergraded but I would still be happy with them. Maybe try sending them to bvg.

ChiSoxCardboard

<< <i>Lots of very soft/worn corners and edges make the grades appropriate but the cards present really well nonetheless. Batch to be proud of for sure, classics all! >>



Agreed...seem like technically fair grades, but (if you're selling) I'll bet you get a premium for most of those examples.

Brad

bobbyw8469

Here is another one. The 1.5 is mine. I am sorry, but comparing it to the '2' that just popped up on Ebay, I don't see the '1.5' as being the inferior card in this instance!

sportscardstop

Maybe the Robinson is a 2 instead of a 1.5, and the first Koufax is a 4 instead of a 3.5. But the other 3 look about right to me.

bobsbbcards

That's a pretty fuggly two.

orioles93

I think all the grades are pretty fair. I could see the kaline in a 5 holder though. And that Robinson is the same as my clemente rookie. I have a 1.5 clemente but it looks much better than a bunch of 3s or even some 4s i see. I guess thats just how it goes.

ClockworkAngel

The 1.5 should be in the 2 holder and the 1.5 should be in the 2 holder, but at the end of the day is the difference between a 1.5 and a 2 really translate to higher prices?

psychump

Why grade right the first time if you are going to re-sub anyway?

Giantsdude24

You selling the 54 mays psa 4.5?

bobbyw8469

Yes. It is on the bay as we speak. 99 cent opener.

Whoever said anything about cracking and resub. I detest that game and only play it if I think the grade is off by more than one full grade. I don't think any of these are off by MORE than one full grade. Some could go one grade if I play the game.

Downtown1974

Nice cards all around, but that 52 J. Robby is real nice!

Baez578

Nice cards! That Robinson grade is a but harsh

itzagoner

if they deducted a half for each wrinkle, Bobby's would be a negative 3.

bcubs

Great looking cards. I have noticed my recent submissions seem to be graded more conservatively also.

bobbyw8469

<< <i>if they deducted a half for each wrinkle, Bobby's would be a negative 3 >>



True...but how would you grade the PSA 2 that the 1.5 looks better than?!?!?

itzagoner

<< <i>

<< <i>if they deducted a half for each wrinkle, Bobby's would be a negative 3 >>



True...but how would you grade the PSA 2 that the 1.5 looks better than?!?!? >>



honestly, i could barely tell there was a baseball player beneath all that surface carf.

DetroitSquirreL

I think all grades are right on except the second Jackie (PSA 2) is OVER graded!!