NEWP! GOLD CAC!! RATTLER INDIAN (VALUE ANYONE??)

Vbowling299

Appears to go darker in a few spots in the pics, but in actuality its just my poor photography skills! appears red
Just thought to share a Beautiful NEWP
Let me know your thoughts!

Justacommeman

VERY cool! Congrat's.................MJ

illini420

Not bad!!!

Kove

Very nice. PCGS was tough on that coin 25 years ago.

lcoopie

better if you bought it without the sticker

coinlieutenant

Cool little coin...

DorkGirl

Jcarney

<< <i>better if you bought it without the sticker >>



Bought what? You mean the coin? Who cares about the coin, it's a GOLD STICKER!!!!!

TPRC

Definitely looks undergraded from the pic.

etexmike

Looks like a very nice pickup. Great little Indian.


Mike

Vbowling299

Anyone have an opinion on the value of such an item??

BillJones

There are two prices, one with the sticker and one without it.

Without the sticker, I'm assuming that coin is probably under graded and is really an MS-64 or 64+ R&B. Under those conditions I'd say $75 to $80 retail.

With the gold all bets are off because of speculators. To me it would be really maxed out at $100, but if a "true believer" paid $150 to $175, I would not be surprised.

AuroraBorealis

Very nice Injun... A big congrats...

AB

mrearlygold

mkman123

sticker collectors will overpay I bet.

SeattleSlammer

I mostly agree with Bill but think that true believers will pay quite a bit more. From the pics that coin looks like it could be a 65+ ..... and in my experience it seems that CAC won't gold bean a coin unless it looks BADLY undergraded, not just BARELY undergraded. I could easily see that coin with the gold bean at 250++ based upon bean envy alone.

renomedphys

Send it to Rick Snow and get a Photoseal. He won't automatically sticker CAC'd coins (like JA will for EERC sticker coins) but I'd say in that grade your chances are pretty good.

Then the sticker collectors will be all over it.

IMHO, the coin is probably only worth MS64+ money, which in RB, ain't that much. Maybe, just maybe $200.

Yes, better to max out the stickers.

johnny9434

it looks pretty good from here.

Timbuk3

Nice score !!!

VanHalen

Nice piece. I'd say $150 value.

coinbuf

<< <i>Anyone have an opinion on the value of such an item?? >>



Its a very nice coin and the holder will add some value as will the gold sticker. But to be perfectly honest it looks no better than a 64 or 64+ from these pics. I say that because the feathers dont look to be fully struck out and that should limit the grade to 64, that opinion could change with a better obv pic thats not tilted. Now as to value all bets are off in an auction format like ebay, because of the gold sticker and old holder I could easily see this hitting $150.

Vbowling299

Thanks for all the opinions everyone, its very much appreciated!
Vbowling299

lordmarcovan

With "gold" and "Indian" in the title, I was expecting a Pratt quarter-eagle, for some reason. My eye totally skipped over the "CAC" part.


It was not an unpleasant surprise to see copper instead of gold, though. 'Tis indeed a beautiful newp you have there.