Options
Raw 1874 Proof Trade Dollar: NT or AT?
TennesseeDave
Posts: 4,931 ✭✭✭✭✭
Seller had it listed as a business strike,but it's definately a proof.I have never owned any 19th century proofs so I am not familiar with the natural toning that can occur.I had to take the picture at this angle to capture the colors.What's your opinion?




Trade $'s
0
Comments
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
-Paul
Lance.
On another note, what's the giveaway that it's a proof? I see the strong strike and all but what else tells you it's a proof? (not saying you're wrong)
<< <i>I would say that it's AT.
On another note, what's the giveaway that it's a proof? I see the strong strike and all but what else tells you it's a proof? (not saying you're wrong) >>
Most 1874 proofs have broad rims and a reverse peripheral die crack. The business strike all have a flat breast. At least I've never seen an 1874 with a full breast.
<< <i>I would say that it's AT.
On another note, what's the giveaway that it's a proof? I see the strong strike and all but what else tells you it's a proof? (not saying you're wrong) >>
I did some research by looking at several 1874 Proof Trade $'s on heritage.All have a die scratch in the dentils on the reverse just right of the word OF and the ribbon that contains the E-Pluribus-Unum has the same strike weakness as the Graded ones on Heritage.I'm assuming all 700 were struck by the same set of dies.
<< <i>The white balance must be off in at least one set of images - which is it? >>
The pictures posted now look like the coin does in hand.I deleted the 2 pictures that were off.The camera I use is a point and shoot that I don't know how to adjust the white balance.
<< <i>Seeing the updated second image, I believe that the coin is AT. >>
It seems that the general opinion of the forum is that the color is Questionable. Therefore I will ask this question. If it were your coin would you give it a quick dip in something like 50% E-zest and 50% acetone to remove the toning?I will likely see what Pcgs says 1st and then proceed from there.
<< <i>I have a 1874 trade dollar, I want to know how much of a coin turn there should be. Mine seems to have, at most a 10degree difference. I think its a fake because of this and the fact that it only weights 24 grams. CAN YOU HELP? >>
Post a pic!
<< <i>I have a 1874 trade dollar, I want to know how much of a coin turn there should be. Mine seems to have, at most a 10degree difference. I think its a fake because of this and the fact that it only weights 24 grams. CAN YOU HELP? >>
If it only weighs 24 grams,(unless it is worn down to poor 1) there's a 99% chance it is a fake.
Russ, NCNE